Our new Indie Games subforum is now open for business in G&T. Go and check it out, you might land a code for a free game. If you're developing an indie game and want to post about it, follow these directions. If you don't, he'll break your legs! Hahaha! Seriously though.
Our rules have been updated and given their own forum. Go and look at them! They are nice, and there may be new ones that you didn't know about! Hooray for rules! Hooray for The System! Hooray for Conforming!

Girlfriend pregnant, wants adoption... I don't

245

Posts

  • LieberkuhnLieberkuhn __BANNED USERS
    Perpetual wrote: »
    I think it's the girl's choice, ultimately. Even the whole "well, how about the father keeps the baby after it's born" thing doesn't make sense. The girl will be carrying it for 9 months, not the guy.

    I don't think it's right for the OP to pressure her like this. She's probably going through a lot already.

    The girl may not want the baby, but she does want to give birth to it. Thus the father has every right to keep it if she doesn't want it.

    While you eat, let's have a conversation about the nature of consent.
  • MimMim Registered User regular
    Archgarth wrote: »
    Xaquin wrote: »
    Perpetual wrote: »
    I think it's the girl's choice, ultimately. Even the whole "well, how about the father keeps the baby after it's born" thing doesn't make sense. The girl will be carrying it for 9 months, not the guy.

    that doesn't make him 'not the father'

    Bingo. A woman's right to choose whether or not to carry a baby to term is hers and hers alone. Once that baby is born, however, the choices regarding that baby belong to two people unless one decides to give up their right to make those choices.

    Limed for mother fuckin' truth. Yes, during the time she is pregnant the choice of having the baby VS not having the baby is hers and hers alone because she is the one carrying it. However, she has decided to carry this child to term. What happens with the child then falls on both biological parents.

    A, what, year ago we had a thread where an awesome dude's wife cheated on him with some guy. She ended up pregnant but had no idea who was the father of the child and she decided to bring the baby to term and then put it up for adoption. The guy had the choice of signing off on the adoption (she cannot give the baby up unless you sign those papers) or keeping the kid himself. He signed off on the papers because once that kid was born he HAD THE CHOICE.

    OP, if you want this kid and you have the backing of your family (and it seems that you do) then by all means do so because you want the child. Do not have ANY misgivings that this will keep your relationship with the mother intact or that she will come around to wanting your child. This could very well destroy your relationship and you have to be prepared for that. But if you are not keeping this kid because you think it'll keep you two together, and you are truly attached to this child (and I think it was Esh who said that you already being attached to this kid is dangerous and that is NOT true. It is a beautiful thing and some guys don't even feel that attachment till the kid is born. You having it now is not unnatural) and willing to deal with the sacrifices that comes along with it, then do it.

    And most people do not know how the sacrifices will effect them even if they do plan on having the kid. Its just something you learn as you go. However you should know that partying and other illicit activities are pretty much out.

    TL;DR - If you want this kid with good intentions (no delusions of what it could do for your relationship with the mother and prepared to give up a lot for said child) then do it. If you're not prepared then assist in helping her find adoptive parents for the baby. But you do have rights and you should not allow yourself to get screwed out of them.

  • TrillianTrillian Registered User
    There is a huge demand adoption when it comes to babies, I mean people go to Guatemala, China and all over the place to get one.

    One girl I know who was adopted as a crack-addicted infant is now finishing up her medical residency. Another is growing up as a very privelaged child with two show horses.
    There is hope.


    They cast a shadow like a sundial in the morning light. It was half past 10.
  • EshEsh Portland, OR__BANNED USERS regular
    Shall we also think of the repercussions psychologically if the OP somehow ends up with the child?

    "Where's mommy?"

    "Oh, she didn't want you."

    On top of diapers, tack on years of psychiatrist bills.

    Just because you messed up doesn't mean you need to be a father. There are soooo many loving families who want a healthy baby but can't have one. Stop thinking about yourself and start thinking about others (the mom, the child, etc...)

    "At first he thought it might be a natural occurrence - maybe a rabbit. But upon closer inspection, it was clear a knife had been used. And rabbits don't carry knives."
  • DruhimDruhim Usagi's cuddlefish Registered User, ClubPA regular
    While I question the maturity and preparedness of Nitsua when it comes to raising a child as a single father, what you just said makes no sense Esh.

    I mean, you're saying the kid's going to be traumatized being raised by a single father and not knowing his mother but perfectly fine with being abandoned by both parents and put up for adoption? very curious logic there

    I'm not speaking against adoption, just saying Esh isn't making any sense there. My opinion is that adoption probably is the best option, but that's because I doubt Netsua has the maturity and wisdom to be a good single father based largely on the lack of wisdom he's demonstrated so far in this whole episode.

    belruelotterav-1.jpg
  • EshEsh Portland, OR__BANNED USERS regular
    Druhim wrote: »
    While I question the maturity and preparedness of Nitsua when it comes to raising a child as a single father, what you just said makes no sense Esh.

    I mean, you're saying the kid's going to be traumatized being raised by a single father and not knowing his mother but perfectly fine with being abandoned by both parents and put up for adoption? very curious logic there

    I'm not speaking against adoption, just saying Esh isn't making any sense there. My opinion is that adoption probably is the best option, but that's because I doubt Netsua has the maturity and wisdom to be a good single father based largely on the lack of wisdom he's demonstrated so far in this whole episode.

    It makes plenty of sense. A child can understand being put up for adoption because of unknown circumstances (hell, do some kids even know they're adopted?), but if there's just one parent and the other one isn't dead and just wants nothing to do with the child, then that child is going most likely develop some serious issues. Are you following me here?

    Basically, since the child has never had the opportunity to actually know either of his birth parents, it's much less traumatizing.

    "At first he thought it might be a natural occurrence - maybe a rabbit. But upon closer inspection, it was clear a knife had been used. And rabbits don't carry knives."
  • MimMim Registered User regular
    Esh wrote: »
    Shall we also think of the repercussions psychologically if the OP somehow ends up with the child?

    "Where's mommy?"

    "Oh, she didn't want you."

    On top of diapers, tack on years of psychiatrist bills.

    Just because you messed up doesn't mean you need to be a father. There are soooo many loving families who want a healthy baby but can't have one. Stop thinking about yourself and start thinking about others (the mom, the child, etc...)

    Yes, because children raised by single mothers ALWAYS need psychiatry and face psychological damage because they're raised by one parent.

  • DruhimDruhim Usagi's cuddlefish Registered User, ClubPA regular
    Mim wrote: »
    Esh wrote: »
    Shall we also think of the repercussions psychologically if the OP somehow ends up with the child?

    "Where's mommy?"

    "Oh, she didn't want you."

    On top of diapers, tack on years of psychiatrist bills.

    Just because you messed up doesn't mean you need to be a father. There are soooo many loving families who want a healthy baby but can't have one. Stop thinking about yourself and start thinking about others (the mom, the child, etc...)

    Yes, because children raised by single mothers ALWAYS need psychiatry and face psychological damage because they're raised by one parent.

    No, no, esh knows best. About everything.

    belruelotterav-1.jpg
  • EshEsh Portland, OR__BANNED USERS regular
    Mim wrote: »
    Esh wrote: »
    Shall we also think of the repercussions psychologically if the OP somehow ends up with the child?

    "Where's mommy?"

    "Oh, she didn't want you."

    On top of diapers, tack on years of psychiatrist bills.

    Just because you messed up doesn't mean you need to be a father. There are soooo many loving families who want a healthy baby but can't have one. Stop thinking about yourself and start thinking about others (the mom, the child, etc...)

    Yes, because children raised by single mothers ALWAYS need psychiatry and face psychological damage because they're raised by one parent.

    I'm saying it's much more likely. And Druhim, don't be a silly goose. It's not needed or appreciated.

    "At first he thought it might be a natural occurrence - maybe a rabbit. But upon closer inspection, it was clear a knife had been used. And rabbits don't carry knives."
  • RebeccaRebecca Registered User
    Esh wrote: »
    This woman obviously does not want to raise a child with you. Get over that ever happening.

    Unless she wants your help during the pregnancy, you need to just stay away. You sound like you're somehow already becoming attached to the unborn child and that's not a good thing. My suggestion would be to support her in the pregnancy (financially, emotionally, whatever she asks for) and then leave it well enough alone. This will help to minimize your "emotional distress".

    I'm going with Esh (not in total agreement with the rest of his posts :) but he's dead on here) , psyck0,Chop Logic, Archgarth and Perpetual on this one. If I were in her shoes I would want an abortion, I know I could not handle the biological and psychological turmoil that goes along with carrying an unwanted pregnancy to term. I think you would be a constant reminder of a stupid mistake. I also can't understand having sex without protection and a back up plan, that goes for both parties involved. I don't mean to be cruel but it shows a serious lack of responsible decision making skills. Raising a child requires those skills to be a good parent.

    It sounds like she's made the best decision for herself, though don't be surprised if she struggles with the decision the entire pregnancy.

    I wish you the best of luck, if you are serious on raising the baby yourself I'd seek out a financial planner, a strong support group for single dads, perhaps a lawyer to make sure you get the child, and figure out who will be willing to watch the child when you are at work/school.

  • KistraKistra Registered User
    I'm surprised no one has asked this but... Are you sure the baby is yours? It generally takes 5 weeks after conception for a urine pregnancy test to come back positive. It sounds like you found out about her being pregnant sooner than 5 weeks after meeting her if I understand your post correctly.

    Also, consider asking her to defer the decision to give the baby up for adoption till after it is born. Once she has held the baby and looked into its eyes the chances that she will still want to give it up diminish tremendously. I know it sounds like a sneaky move but at least consider it.

    That is completely false! Think about it, most women take pregnancy tests when they miss their period. Most women have periods 4 weeks apart and are fertile right in the middle of between their periods. That makes it a 2 week wait until the tests will reliably come up positive.

    To the OP: you do not have any right to ask this girl to raise the baby with you. She wants to give birth to it, so you can decide to raise it but you do not have a right to ask her to be involved. Would you be willing to let her sign away her parental rights? You wouldn't be able to collect child support from her that way, but she might feel more comfortable that way.

    Animal Crossing: City Folk Lissa in Filmore 3179-9580-0076
  • MimMim Registered User regular
    Rebecca wrote: »
    Esh wrote: »
    This woman obviously does not want to raise a child with you. Get over that ever happening.

    Unless she wants your help during the pregnancy, you need to just stay away. You sound like you're somehow already becoming attached to the unborn child and that's not a good thing. My suggestion would be to support her in the pregnancy (financially, emotionally, whatever she asks for) and then leave it well enough alone. This will help to minimize your "emotional distress".

    I'm going with Esh (not in total agreement with the rest of his posts :) but he's dead on here) , psyck0,Chop Logic, Archgarth and Perpetual on this one. If I were in her shoes I would want an abortion, I know I could not handle the biological and psychological turmoil that goes along with carrying an unwanted pregnancy to term. I think you would be a constant reminder of a stupid mistake. I also can't understand having sex without protection and a back up plan, that goes for both parties involved. I don't mean to be cruel but it shows a serious lack of responsible decision making skills. Raising a child requires those skills to be a good parent.

    It sounds like she's made the best decision for herself, though don't be surprised if she struggles with the decision the entire pregnancy.

    I wish you the best of luck, if you are serious on raising the baby yourself I'd seek out a financial planner, a strong support group for single dads, perhaps a lawyer to make sure you get the child, and figure out who will be willing to watch the child when you are at work/school.


    Wait, so if we're to go with Esh's logic here then give the girl whatever she wants, but if you want this kid "fuck you"? It shouldn't work like that. If he wants the baby, he can do those things but if she gives up the kid its the adopted parents' obligation to support her financially or whatever she asks for.

  • EshEsh Portland, OR__BANNED USERS regular
    Mim wrote: »
    Rebecca wrote: »
    Esh wrote: »
    This woman obviously does not want to raise a child with you. Get over that ever happening.

    Unless she wants your help during the pregnancy, you need to just stay away. You sound like you're somehow already becoming attached to the unborn child and that's not a good thing. My suggestion would be to support her in the pregnancy (financially, emotionally, whatever she asks for) and then leave it well enough alone. This will help to minimize your "emotional distress".

    I'm going with Esh (not in total agreement with the rest of his posts :) but he's dead on here) , psyck0,Chop Logic, Archgarth and Perpetual on this one. If I were in her shoes I would want an abortion, I know I could not handle the biological and psychological turmoil that goes along with carrying an unwanted pregnancy to term. I think you would be a constant reminder of a stupid mistake. I also can't understand having sex without protection and a back up plan, that goes for both parties involved. I don't mean to be cruel but it shows a serious lack of responsible decision making skills. Raising a child requires those skills to be a good parent.

    It sounds like she's made the best decision for herself, though don't be surprised if she struggles with the decision the entire pregnancy.

    I wish you the best of luck, if you are serious on raising the baby yourself I'd seek out a financial planner, a strong support group for single dads, perhaps a lawyer to make sure you get the child, and figure out who will be willing to watch the child when you are at work/school.


    Wait, so if we're to go with Esh's logic here then give the girl whatever she wants, but if you want this kid "fuck you"? It shouldn't work like that. If he wants the baby, he can do those things but if she gives up the kid its the adopted parents' obligation to support her financially or whatever she asks for.

    OP is nothing but an accidental sperm donor and needs to remember that. The girl actually has to carry and birth the child. So yes, give her what she wants.

    "At first he thought it might be a natural occurrence - maybe a rabbit. But upon closer inspection, it was clear a knife had been used. And rabbits don't carry knives."
  • DruhimDruhim Usagi's cuddlefish Registered User, ClubPA regular
    It should be obvious, but just to be clear Esh is in no position to be making assertions about what rights the OP has regarding the infant.

    belruelotterav-1.jpg
  • widowsonwidowson Registered User
    Dis wrote: »
    1) How old are you two?
    2) Talk to parents on both sides and them to help with the child?
    3) Be responsible and take care of the child yourself.

    Abortion > Adoption

    You have no idea how bad the child might end up.

    o_O

    That is disturbingly cynical and makes the Pro choice = Culture of Death argument stronger.

    The child might wind up just fine; adopted by a loving home which beats the hell out of being summarily executed for comming into existance at an inconvenient moment and the possibility they *may* have problems. You could make that argument to abort any pregnancy because you have no idea how bad *any* child in *any* situation might end up.

    Adoption > Abortion.

    As for the OP, the fact that your girlfriend is choosing the hard right over the easy wrong is admirable and should be supported.

    I was raised by a single, overwhealmed parent for most of my childhood and a sane, stable, loving home with adoptive parents would have been better. I'd let her place the child for adoption because, with how picky most agencies are, you've got a high chance the adoptive parents are good people.

    I've got a kid and with a spouse it's still hard, very hard, some days. It's gonna hurt, but think; would you want to raise the child as a single parent because it's best for the kid or because it's best for your feelings of guilt?

    Personally, I have more respect for a couple/parent who admits they can't handle it and gives the child up for adoption instead of stubbornly keeping the child, and raising him/her badly, because they're too proud to admit they can't do it or too wrapped up in soothing their selfish guilt.

    Not saying that's you or all single parents, though some fall into this category. Just something to consider.

    -I owe nothing to Women's Lib.

    Margaret Thatcher
  • EshEsh Portland, OR__BANNED USERS regular
    Druhim wrote: »
    It should be obvious, but just to be clear Esh is in no position to be making assertions about what rights the OP has regarding the infant.

    Legal rights if she decides to give birth. He has those. It doesn't make him any less of a silly goose though for doing what he's trying to do.

    Also, stop derailing the thread with personal attacks. Another one and I'm going to hit the report button. Hugs.

    "At first he thought it might be a natural occurrence - maybe a rabbit. But upon closer inspection, it was clear a knife had been used. And rabbits don't carry knives."
  • DruhimDruhim Usagi's cuddlefish Registered User, ClubPA regular
    It's not a personal attack when I'm merely stating that your advice is blatantly wrong or irrelevant. If you're talking about abortion, then you're giving the OP advice he's not seeking as he's made it clear she's planning to bring it to term. She originally wanted to raise the baby with him and now is considering adoption. So why do you keep bringing up his rights in a situation that doesn't currently have any bearing on his situation? We're talking about adoption vs him possibly getting custody and raising the child himself.

    belruelotterav-1.jpg
  • EshEsh Portland, OR__BANNED USERS regular
    Druhim wrote: »
    It's not a personal attack when I'm merely stating that your advice is blatantly wrong or irrelevant. If you're talking about abortion, then you're giving the OP advice he's not seeking as he's made it clear she's planning to bring it to term. She originally wanted to raise the baby with him and now is considering adoption. So why do you keep bringing up his rights in a situation that doesn't currently have any bearing on his situation? We're talking about adoption vs him possibly getting custody and raising the child himself.

    I haven't mentioned abortion once. I think you're very confused.

    I'm asserting that the OP should let her give it up for adoption and go on his merry way.

    "At first he thought it might be a natural occurrence - maybe a rabbit. But upon closer inspection, it was clear a knife had been used. And rabbits don't carry knives."
  • DruhimDruhim Usagi's cuddlefish Registered User, ClubPA regular
    You claimed he didn't have any rights, that he's just a donor. When I pointed out this is wrong, you implied he only has rights if she carries it to term, so if you weren't talking about abortion then I can't even tell what your point is any more. Anyone else able to make any sense of Esh?

    belruelotterav-1.jpg
  • SmokeStacksSmokeStacks License Number 137596Registered User regular
    Esh you need to shut up. Your "advice" is consistently terrible.



    It looks to me like you're going to have to choose between maintaining a relationship with this woman or raising your child, because she doesn't seem interested.

    Know that there is a lot of information and support available for single fathers, and although raising a child will be the most difficult thing you will ever do, it will also be the most rewarding. That said, there are also many avenues available to you to be able to keep in touch or keep track of your child's progress should you decide to give him or her up. But, if you decide to raise your child on your own, understand that you may not end up being a single parent forever. For all you know you could meet the love of your life a week, month, year, or whatever after your kid is born.

    A (if everything works out) lifetime relationship with a son or daughter would mean more to me than a relationship with a woman that may or may not last, but you can't eliminate the chance that she will change her mind someday (which is difficult to impossible if you both pursue adoption).

    I think you should raise your child, on your own if need be, and I think that every day you'll look back and be glad that you did.

  • EshEsh Portland, OR__BANNED USERS regular
    Druhim wrote: »
    You claimed he didn't have any rights, that he's just a donor. When I pointed out this is wrong, you implied he only has rights if she carries it to term, so if you weren't talking about abortion then I can't even tell what your point is any more. Anyone else able to make any sense of Esh?

    Yes, he does only have rights if she carries it to term, which she is. Thus, he has rights, but if he wants to be a decent person, he needs to let it go.

    "At first he thought it might be a natural occurrence - maybe a rabbit. But upon closer inspection, it was clear a knife had been used. And rabbits don't carry knives."
  • VisionOfClarityVisionOfClarity Registered User
    A (if everything works out) lifetime relationship with a son or daughter would mean more to me than a relationship with a woman that may or may not last, but you can't eliminate the chance that she will change her mind someday (which is difficult to impossible if you both pursue adoption).

    It's not difficult to impossible at all if they go for the more logical choice of an open adoption. Where a family who can afford to and is able to raise the child will and the OP and his gf will still be able to have a relationship with the child.

  • NitsuaNitsua Newport News, VARegistered User regular
    Rent wrote: »
    Nitsua wrote: »

    1)In what way can I present to her actual plans that could work for going to school, working, and raising a kid together that would be plausible and not add more than the expected load upon her. Basically I want ideas from those that have done this and how hard/rewarding it was to do so.

    1) How old are you two

    2) You can't, really. Also, I don't really...I mean...let's assume you're both 22. I mean, the sheer ludicrous amount of time that raising a kid would consume would be enormous. Not to mention going to school in the meantime? Yeah, we're talking like < 4 hours of sleep/night for new parents, and that's highballing it. A full courseload on top of that? Plus, money issues (unless you guys are suitably well off/getting help from the 'rents, a new kid is gonna be a huge money burden, esp in this economy)

    Just not really seeing a whole lot of positives for raising a kid here based on your situation (besides the whole "it's the responsible thing to do" one, which is a biggie tbh)

    I gotta ask (please don't interpret this as dickish, because I'm really not trying to be): Do you really, truly, want to raise a kid, or is something you feel obligated to do/want to raise out of a sense of duty/interest in the mother?


    In that same vein, is it really the inability in raising a kid that's the issue here (for you), or is it the perceived/implied loss of the relationship with your gf that is bringing these issues to the forefront?

    Okay, I'm 29 (my profile states this), she's 22. As for the whole school thing, I work full-time at a pretty good job (Canon) and could afford an apartment on my own, even with her there. I don't wish to keep the kid because I feel I have to... I REALLY want to be a father, always have. A little hard to explain really, but it is something I've always wanted to do. This is why I ask for help with ways of being able to let go if I have to. I will try and give her alternatives to giving it up, but otherwise I will support her fully. I don't wish to lose her either.


    edit: Oh, and thanks to everyone who has responded. Sorry for taking a bit to get back to this. So many things going on right now and I went to chat with my best friend on this as well.

  • RebeccaRebecca Registered User
    Mim wrote: »
    Rebecca wrote: »
    Esh wrote: »
    This woman obviously does not want to raise a child with you. Get over that ever happening.

    Unless she wants your help during the pregnancy, you need to just stay away. You sound like you're somehow already becoming attached to the unborn child and that's not a good thing. My suggestion would be to support her in the pregnancy (financially, emotionally, whatever she asks for) and then leave it well enough alone. This will help to minimize your "emotional distress".

    I'm going with Esh (not in total agreement with the rest of his posts :) but he's dead on here) , psyck0,Chop Logic, Archgarth and Perpetual on this one. If I were in her shoes I would want an abortion, I know I could not handle the biological and psychological turmoil that goes along with carrying an unwanted pregnancy to term. I think you would be a constant reminder of a stupid mistake. I also can't understand having sex without protection and a back up plan, that goes for both parties involved. I don't mean to be cruel but it shows a serious lack of responsible decision making skills. Raising a child requires those skills to be a good parent.

    It sounds like she's made the best decision for herself, though don't be surprised if she struggles with the decision the entire pregnancy.

    I wish you the best of luck, if you are serious on raising the baby yourself I'd seek out a financial planner, a strong support group for single dads, perhaps a lawyer to make sure you get the child, and figure out who will be willing to watch the child when you are at work/school.


    Wait, so if we're to go with Esh's logic here then give the girl whatever she wants, but if you want this kid "fuck you"? It shouldn't work like that. If he wants the baby, he can do those things but if she gives up the kid its the adopted parents' obligation to support her financially or whatever she asks for.

    Eh, not quite what I was thinking, its yes give her support as best as you are able but if you want this kid, get a lawyer to make sure you can. He wanted to raise the baby with her. And so far it sounds like she doesn't, that's when the fuck you comes in to play.

    I left "My suggestion would be to support her in the pregnancy (financially, emotionally, whatever she asks for) and then leave it well enough alone. This will help to minimize your "emotional distress". Because I think it is a good suggestion, I put in the "I wish the best of luck "sentence because I think he may want to raise the baby on his own and professionals will help come up with a reasonable plan.

  • SmokeStacksSmokeStacks License Number 137596Registered User regular
    A (if everything works out) lifetime relationship with a son or daughter would mean more to me than a relationship with a woman that may or may not last, but you can't eliminate the chance that she will change her mind someday (which is difficult to impossible if you both pursue adoption).

    It's not difficult to impossible at all if they go for the more logical choice of an open adoption. Where a family who can afford to and is able to raise the child will and the OP and his gf will still be able to have a relationship with the child.

    That's true, but visiting your child and raising your child are two different things. I would hate to be in a biological parent's shoes when it was time to say goodbye and go home.

    edit: Nitsua posted while I was writing this.

    Bottom line - Please try to leave yourself options. The way you feel now might not be the way you feel a year from now, or ten years from now. That said, good luck with whatever route you decide to take.

  • EshEsh Portland, OR__BANNED USERS regular
    Nitsua wrote: »
    Rent wrote: »
    Nitsua wrote: »

    1)In what way can I present to her actual plans that could work for going to school, working, and raising a kid together that would be plausible and not add more than the expected load upon her. Basically I want ideas from those that have done this and how hard/rewarding it was to do so.

    1) How old are you two

    2) You can't, really. Also, I don't really...I mean...let's assume you're both 22. I mean, the sheer ludicrous amount of time that raising a kid would consume would be enormous. Not to mention going to school in the meantime? Yeah, we're talking like < 4 hours of sleep/night for new parents, and that's highballing it. A full courseload on top of that? Plus, money issues (unless you guys are suitably well off/getting help from the 'rents, a new kid is gonna be a huge money burden, esp in this economy)

    Just not really seeing a whole lot of positives for raising a kid here based on your situation (besides the whole "it's the responsible thing to do" one, which is a biggie tbh)

    I gotta ask (please don't interpret this as dickish, because I'm really not trying to be): Do you really, truly, want to raise a kid, or is something you feel obligated to do/want to raise out of a sense of duty/interest in the mother?


    In that same vein, is it really the inability in raising a kid that's the issue here (for you), or is it the perceived/implied loss of the relationship with your gf that is bringing these issues to the forefront?

    Okay, I'm 29 (my profile states this), she's 22. As for the whole school thing, I work full-time at a pretty good job (Canon) and could afford an apartment on my own, even with her there. I don't wish to keep the kid because I feel I have to... I REALLY want to be a father, always have. A little hard to explain really, but it is something I've always wanted to do. This is why I ask for help with ways of being able to let go if I have to. I will try and give her alternatives to giving it up, but otherwise I will support her fully. I don't wish to lose her either.


    edit: Oh, and thanks to everyone who has responded. Sorry for taking a bit to get back to this. So many things going on right now and I went to chat with my best friend on this as well.

    Smartest thing I've seen in the thread so far. Good on you for realizing this.

    "At first he thought it might be a natural occurrence - maybe a rabbit. But upon closer inspection, it was clear a knife had been used. And rabbits don't carry knives."
  • NitsuaNitsua Newport News, VARegistered User regular
    Would it be feasible for you to pick up, say, 75% of the work until she finishes school instead of what was originally planned?

    Yes, this is indeed something I was thinking of. She is the type of person that does not like others doing things for them, but I could indeed afford to take care of her and the child while she goes through the last two semesters she has left. My best friend (a mother of three) also would love to help as well as my mother and a TON of her friends. it isn't like we don't have support.

  • DruhimDruhim Usagi's cuddlefish Registered User, ClubPA regular
    Ok, you're considerably older than I thought and it appears in a stable situation to be able to actually support the kiddo so I apologize for suggesting you might not be ready for this earlier. Best of luck to you in finding a way to make this work.

    belruelotterav-1.jpg
  • JokermanJokerman Lord Paramount of the Neckbeards Registered User regular
    Nitsua, can you not raise the child by yourself or is that not an option?

  • UsagiUsagi Got catz in my zone Ca-catz in my zoneRegistered User regular
    Well, it looks like the alternative to giving up your child for adoption is to be a single father. Are you prepared to do that? Because what the tone of your posts says to me Nitsua, is that you want to be a family not necessarily just a father.

    She's young, and your relationship with her hasn't gone on for very long, so to try and pin her down with your expectations of familial bliss really isn't fair to either of you.

    twit | make stuff | GW2: Arithmetock.3459 | a list of wishes | a post of wishes | svpply
  • EshEsh Portland, OR__BANNED USERS regular
    "At first he thought it might be a natural occurrence - maybe a rabbit. But upon closer inspection, it was clear a knife had been used. And rabbits don't carry knives."
  • NitsuaNitsua Newport News, VARegistered User regular
    I'm surprised no one has asked this but... Are you sure the baby is yours? It generally takes 5 weeks after conception for a urine pregnancy test to come back positive. It sounds like you found out about her being pregnant sooner than 5 weeks after meeting her if I understand your post correctly.

    Also, consider asking her to defer the decision to give the baby up for adoption till after it is born. Once she has held the baby and looked into its eyes the chances that she will still want to give it up diminish tremendously. I know it sounds like a sneaky move but at least consider it.

    yes, I am quite certain this child is mine. Haven't done a paternity test, but she was on her period when I met her. She hadn't been with anyone for at least five months or so before hand.

    As for the others asking (I really should read more before answering as I am, oh well) - this is not my first relationship... more like my tenth and my third sex partner. I will get to more questions as I see them.

    As far as I can see it, her biggest worry is that she wouldn't be able to handle school and taking care of the baby. She already fears she won't be as good as a mother as her own was and she wasn't doing well in school before I came around. She feels I will be a great father though (MANY people keep telling me this) and has no doubts about my support, love for her, or anything like that. We have discussed me raising it on my own, but (with us being together still) it would be like she didn't really give it up anyhow.

  • NitsuaNitsua Newport News, VARegistered User regular
    Esh wrote: »
    Kinda sounds like you want to use the baby to trap the girl. Classy.

    EDIT: You have to realize a baby is a joint decision. You're being incredibly selfish and probably very naive about this. You're potentially completely fucking up her life plans.


    NOT ON MY LIFE!

    I don't wish to trap her... I am prepared to raise the child completely on my own if I must, but I really don't wish to (my friends wouldn't let me be alone anyhow though).

    We get along extremely well and it was really the way I handled the news and was there for her and supported her when we found out that really calmed her down at first - that and how supportive her entire social network has been. There has literally been more offers to help watch the child when it is born than there are days in the month we would need such a thing.

  • MimMim Registered User regular
    Esh wrote: »
    Druhim wrote: »
    It should be obvious, but just to be clear Esh is in no position to be making assertions about what rights the OP has regarding the infant.

    Legal rights if she decides to give birth. He has those. It doesn't make him any less of a silly goose though for doing what he's trying to do.

    Also, stop derailing the thread with personal attacks. Another one and I'm going to hit the report button. Hugs.

    Bolded for "That's what we're talking about". She is planning to give birth to this child. They aren't in the abortion vs adoption. This is adoption vs keeping the kid. He wants the kid, she want to give it up for adoption. Therefore if he wants the kid, he should be able to have the kid.

    We're saying he can do this, it's hard as fuck, yes but he can do it. He has legal rights and he wants to exercise those rights. If this was abortion this would be completely different, but because this child is coming into the world and he wants to be there for all the milestones, then he should be able to.

    Hell, to even come to an even ground, OP have you ever considered open adoptions?

    Edit: See Nitsua chimed in. Dude, you can totally do this if you choose to. And I also saw someone brought in the open adoption argument before I did.

    Anyways, keep your options open but if you're willing to raise this kid on your own, then do it. You're at a decent enough age to take care of the kid, you have the means, you seem to have the support.

  • NitsuaNitsua Newport News, VARegistered User regular
    Druhim wrote: »
    That's irrelevant if he found out she's pregnant a week after they first had sex.

    it sounds like they had sex around valentine's day, became a couple on march 12, and then a week after that they found out she's pregnant

    I met her on OKCupid on Valentine's Day, we met up at my place for Rock Band the Sunday after (February 21st) We had sex on the 25th of February... was fairly unexpected really. The day I believe she conceived was around March 12th and we found out she was pregnant the Thursday after that.

  • NitsuaNitsua Newport News, VARegistered User regular
    Aegis wrote: »
    That the mother does not want to raise the child does not somehow remove the father's rights from the picture. This isn't the case of an abortion where the child isn't even born yet (at least, according to the OP's note that she wants to give it up for adoption).

    Whether or not it's a wise decision for himself in this situation to raise it on his own is a completely different question and I'd honestly suggest speaking it over with one's parents or the like to see if you could reasonably support such a child in your current situation. It seems that she's already decided that raising it with the OP is not really being considered as an option and I don't know, given the shortness of the relationship, whether it's a possibility that she could change her mind.

    It is not that she can't she herself raising a child with me... we even talked about children and everything mere days before finding out she was pregnant. We just assumed it would be a good number of years before this would happen. Yeah, we didn't actually work on making sure that would be the case, but we were already talking long term in a lot of ways. The major thing is that she doesn't believe that she can take care of a child, work more hours, and go to school as she needs to. I'm looking for more ideas on how I can present to her that it can indeed work and especially any way that I can take pressure off of her in the process. I intend to be a VERY hands on father and I'm with her every step of the way during the pregnancy.

  • NitsuaNitsua Newport News, VARegistered User regular
    widowson wrote: »
    Dis wrote: »
    1) How old are you two?
    2) Talk to parents on both sides and them to help with the child?
    3) Be responsible and take care of the child yourself.

    Abortion > Adoption

    You have no idea how bad the child might end up.

    o_O

    That is disturbingly cynical and makes the Pro choice = Culture of Death argument stronger.

    The child might wind up just fine; adopted by a loving home which beats the hell out of being summarily executed for comming into existance at an inconvenient moment and the possibility they *may* have problems. You could make that argument to abort any pregnancy because you have no idea how bad *any* child in *any* situation might end up.

    Adoption > Abortion.

    As for the OP, the fact that your girlfriend is choosing the hard right over the easy wrong is admirable and should be supported.

    I was raised by a single, overwhealmed parent for most of my childhood and a sane, stable, loving home with adoptive parents would have been better. I'd let her place the child for adoption because, with how picky most agencies are, you've got a high chance the adoptive parents are good people.

    I've got a kid and with a spouse it's still hard, very hard, some days. It's gonna hurt, but think; would you want to raise the child as a single parent because it's best for the kid or because it's best for your feelings of guilt?

    Personally, I have more respect for a couple/parent who admits they can't handle it and gives the child up for adoption instead of stubbornly keeping the child, and raising him/her badly, because they're too proud to admit they can't do it or too wrapped up in soothing their selfish guilt.

    Not saying that's you or all single parents, though some fall into this category. Just something to consider.

    If we keep it, it would not be out of any feelings of guilt or any of that. Both of us wanted families... just not so soon in her case. If we keep the child it will be because we want to have a family and raise the child, not for any other reason. If guilt was coming into play at all I would rather put up the child for I would not raise a kid in those circumstances.

  • UsagiUsagi Got catz in my zone Ca-catz in my zoneRegistered User regular
    Listen Nitsua, maybe your girlfriend really isn't ready to be a mother at 22, which is perfectly reasonable. You're each at very different stages in your lives, she's still in school and struggling to balance studying, a job, and dating you - she has every right to feel overwhelmed by the possibility for adding a child into the mix.

    And no offense, but you've been dating her for just over two months, you have no idea if you two have a strong relationship yet.

    twit | make stuff | GW2: Arithmetock.3459 | a list of wishes | a post of wishes | svpply
  • EshEsh Portland, OR__BANNED USERS regular
    The fact of the matter is, if she doesn't feel ready, then she doesn't feel ready. Especially at 22. Give her some breathing space and just let it go for a while. Maybe she'll change her mind. Not likely, but you bothering her about it is not going to help, and is only going to lead to resentment.

    "At first he thought it might be a natural occurrence - maybe a rabbit. But upon closer inspection, it was clear a knife had been used. And rabbits don't carry knives."
  • RebeccaRebecca Registered User
    Ok..wait..you knew her for less than a month (met feb 14th, found out she was pregnant on March 12th) and you were already talking about children and everything?! Please tell me I am mistaken here.

    At 22 I was just starting to enjoy the experience of living on my own. Having a kid with a guy I just met was the absolute farthest thing on my mind. If she doesn't believe that she can take care of a child, work more hours, and go to school as she needs to. SHE'S RIGHT.

    I have to say, you are creeping me out. The fact that she's said no, and that you keep trying to work her into a yes is frightening.

Sign In or Register to comment.