Our new Indie Games subforum is now open for business in G&T. Go and check it out, you might land a code for a free game. If you're developing an indie game and want to post about it, follow these directions. If you don't, he'll break your legs! Hahaha! Seriously though.
Our rules have been updated and given their own forum. Go and look at them! They are nice, and there may be new ones that you didn't know about! Hooray for rules! Hooray for The System! Hooray for Conforming!
Sherlock - Not now! I'm in shock. Look, I've got a blanket.
Benedict Cumberbatch (Small Island, Starter For Ten) and Martin Freeman (The Office, Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy) star in Sherlock, a thrilling, fast-paced update of Arthur Conan Doyle's classic detective, set in present-day London, for BBC One.
Sherlock is co-created by the hugely talented partnership of Steven Moffat (Doctor Who, Coupling) and Mark Gatiss (The League Of Gentlemen, Crooked House, Doctor Who) and produced by Sue Vertue (Coupling, The Cup).
The three, 90-minute films, written by Steven Moffat, Mark Gatiss and Steve Thompson (Whipping It Up, Mutual Friends) are directed by Paul McGuigan (Lucky Number Slevin, Gangster No. 1, The Acid House) and Euros Lyn (Doctor Who, Torchwood).
In this unique adaptation, the iconic details from Conan Doyle's original books remain. They live at the same address, are only interested in the bizarre and, somewhere out there, Moriarty is waiting for them.
Sherlock also stars Rupert Graves (God On Trial, Midnight Man) as Detective Inspector Lestrade, Scotland Yard's finest, largely because Sherlock allows him to take credit for his deductions, and Una Stubbs (EastEnders, The Catherine Tate Show) as Mrs Hudson, their long-suffering housekeeper.
Steven Moffat says: "Everything that matters about Holmes and Watson is the same. Conan Doyle's stories were never about frock coats and gas light – they're about brilliant detection, dreadful villains and blood curdling crimes and frankly, to hell with the crinoline.
"Mark and I have been talking about this project for years, on long train rides to Cardiff for Doctor Who. Quite honestly, we'd still be talking about it if Sue Vertue, of Hartswood Films, hadn't sat us down for lunch and got us to work."
Mark Gatiss says: "The fact that Steven, myself and millions of others are still addicted to Conan Doyle's brilliant stories is testament to their indestructibility.
"They're as vital, lurid, thrilling and wonderful as they ever were. It's a dream come true to be making a new TV series and, in Benedict and Martin, we have the perfect Holmes and Watson for our time."
Sherlock was commissioned by Jay Hunt, Controller of BBC One, and Ben Stephenson, Controller of BBC Drama Commissioning.
Sherlock is executive produced by Beryl Vertue, Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat. The BBC executive producer is Bethan Jones.
Sherlock is a Hartswood Films production for BBC Wales, co-produced with Masterpiece. Rebecca Eaton is the executive producer for Masterpiece.
Sherlock is simulcast on the BBC HD channel – the BBC's High Definition channel, available through Freesat 108, Freeview 50, Sky 143 and Virgin 108.
So, this starts tonight at 9pm on BBC1. Anyone else watching?
Rhesus PositiveDamn these electric sex pants!Registered Userregular
edited July 2010
The first episode, definitely - I've just started reading the originals from the beginning after finishing The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes a few months back. It'll be interesting seeing how the methods of deduction are translated to an era of CSI teams.
facetiousa wit so dryit shits sandRegistered Userregular
edited July 2010
This is like.
The perfect thing. At least for me.
Thank you, world!
I seriously can't get over this. I like Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman both a lot. And Sherlock Holmes. And Stephen Moffat. And BBC adaptations of books I already love.
"I am not young enough to know everything." - Oscar Wilde
To imply that those currently at the top - the Warren Buffets and Roman Abramoviches of this world - are the very best, the ne plus ultra of humanity, is a kind of hate speech toward the species. Dignity demands that we refute it.
The first twenty minutes were pretty good. It's a retelling of "A Study in Scarlet", but I like how this guy plays Sherlock. I'd watch more, but my signal crapped out.
Also...
Spoiler:
"Harry is short for Harriet."
"...A sister! There's always something!"
that was kinda cool, and i liked the acting and the music
some of the stuff felt a bit above me though, like i was lagging behind holmes and he was having to tell me shit, which i suppose is the intended effect but it meant there's no satisfying "oh what if it's XYZ". i have to confess i've never read a sherlock holmes book- did he always pull that "oh, your trouser leg is 5 millimeters shorter on the left side, indicating your dick is rotting off from the leprosy caught from the lady over there who is bluh bluh bluh" logic from mid air?
Rhesus PositiveDamn these electric sex pants!Registered Userregular
edited July 2010
That was probably the best thing I've seen on TV this year. It might be because it's just finished, but that was amazing.
Spoiler:
Martin Freeman's performance was an amazingly low-key complement to Sherlock. What made it for me was his reply when Holmes snapped at him to use his imagination for his dying words: "I don't have to." I got chills.
The art direction was brilliant, with the thoughts and text messages being presented very cleverly - it reminded me a bit of Night Watch, especially with the brief shot from behind the text when Holmes was looking at the body.
I loved all the nods to the originals - the case being a "three patch problem", and the curious case of Watson being shot in different places depending on which book you read.
I was completely taken in with the bait and switch with Mycroft - I should have known better to have assumed that Steven Moffat would have had such a typical introduction to the series nemesis
Edit: Yeah, Nuzak, Holmes does that a lot - in The Hound of the Baskervilles, he comes up with three or four paragraphs' worth of information from a walking stick.
Reasonably enjoyable, but a few things annoyed me regarding Holmes' deductions:
Spoiler:
- I immediately guessed a taxi driver, before disregarding it for being too obvious (lots of taxi driver rapists and murderers).
Also surely after the first couple of suicides people knew they were going to die, yet look like a suicide. Take the 'bullet' then at least the police will treat it like a murder.
Really really liked it. Sunday night is going to be enjoyable for the next fortnight anyway.
Anarchy Rules:
Spoiler:
Good to see you would take one for humanity. Unlike you, I would probably go for the pill. The option of potential survival will always be a nicer option than a bullet through the face, even if it was to ultimately expose a murderer.
The sound of eight hooves reaches his ears, comes from the heavenly light, two wolves howls fills his heart with fear, and he sees two ravens fly. Down from the sky a warlord rides, like fire his one eye glows, and just before the preacher dies he knows his god is false.
Reasonably enjoyable, but a few things annoyed me regarding Holmes' deductions:
Spoiler:
- I immediately guessed a taxi driver, before disregarding it for being too obvious (lots of taxi driver rapists and murderers).
Also surely after the first couple of suicides people knew they were going to die, yet look like a suicide. Take the 'bullet' then at least the police will treat it like a murder.
Spoiler:
That's assuming that the victims had read enough about the previous suicides to know that it was a pattern. I doubt the first few were reported in any depth if they were just seen as suicides.
Cumberbatch was superb, as was Freeman. There were times Sherlock seemed to be unusually slow - how did he not work out it was taxi drivers? - but overall the deduction (especially the thought process represented on screen) was superb.
"I'm not a psychopath, I'm a high-functioning sociopath, I know you've read the file" - brilliant.
The Princess Bride ending was a little difficult to take seriously, and Mark Gatiss is very difficult to take seriously, but overall this is showing a lot of promise.
Cumberbatch was superb, as was Freeman. There were times Sherlock seemed to be unusually slow - how did he not work out it was taxi drivers? - but overall
The Princess Bride ending was a little difficult to take seriously, and Mark Gatiss is very difficult to take seriously, but overall this is showing a lot of promise.
Spoiler:
I thought it was done very well, as it wasn't really about the choice - it was just a McGuffin to show how Holmes' mind works. I like that it wasn't revealed which one was the correct one, as I did initially think that it would be resolved with some antidote trick or something.
The Princess Bride ending was a little difficult to take seriously, and Mark Gatiss is very difficult to take seriously, but overall this is showing a lot of promise.
Spoiler:
I thought it was done very well, as it wasn't really about the choice - it was just a McGuffin to show how Holmes' mind works. I like that it wasn't revealed which one was the correct one, as I did initially think that it would be resolved with some antidote trick or something.
Spoiler:
Yeah, it's more that it was undermined (for me anyway) by the reflex reference to TPB than anything wrong with the scene. If it wasn't for that, it'd be fine, and that's hardly the fault of the program.
It was fantastic. I liked the way the train of thought was illustrated for us when Sherlock wasn't thinking aloud.
Spoiler:
part of me was expecting the case to go on more than one episode. Is this going to be a new adventure every week with underlying bigger plot? Not that I'm opposed to that of course. sometimes you can only take so much suspense.
How many episodes of this are there? I'm hoping it'll cure my Doctor Who cravings for a while.
I liked it a lot. I thought it was going to be a weekly type of thing, but 3 feature length movies is just as good. I haven't read any of the books, but this makes me want to.
Holmes left me in the dust when
Spoiler:
he broke down the Watson's past and the cell phone.
Guessed that Gatiss was Mycroft just before the reveal, and was immensely pleased that Gatiss hadn't cast himself as Moriarty, as he would have been completely wrong for the part.
Freeman and Cumberbatch (made up name, surely) were great, and the whole thing bounced along merrily with few, if any, slow passages.
Bogart's English. That's a weird name. And made up I think.
His mum is Wanda Ventham. I used to fancy her. How odd.
Neal Stephenson wrote:
It was, of course, nothing more than sexism, the especially virulent type espoused by male techies who sincerely believe that they are too smart to be sexists.
I liked it a lot. I thought it was going to be a weekly type of thing, but 3 feature length movies is just as good. I haven't read any of the books, but this makes me want to.
Holmes left me in the dust when
Spoiler:
he broke down the Watson's past and the cell phone.
Sherlock Holmes was all panicky after the cabby was shot, worried that he wouldn't got the answer to the puzzle. Why didn't he just take the pill to a mass spectrometer or something. Hell, take both of them, to make sure the cabby wasn't cheating by, I don't know, taking the antidote in advance. This way he would get his answer.
Also, if the cabby had held a gun to my head, I would have picked the pill too. I would have done it differently, though. His superpower is to predict my thought process in choosing the bottle, and, on basis of that, either hand me the poison or the not-poison. If you accept that he truly is a genius, and that he has a better than 50% chance of survival, we can limit his chances of survival by making the choice truly random. Toss a coin. Heads and I take the one handed to me. Tails and I take the other one.
If everyone did that, he would be lucky to survive more than two attempts.
Sherlock Holmes was all panicky after the cabby was shot, worried that he wouldn't got the answer to the puzzle. Why didn't he just take the pill to a mass spectrometer or something. Hell, take both of them, to make sure the cabby wasn't cheating by, I don't know, taking the antidote in advance. This way he would get his answer.
Also, if the cabby had held a gun to my head, I would have picked the pill too. I would have done it differently, though. His superpower is to predict my thought process in choosing the bottle, and, on basis of that, either hand me the poison or the not-poison. If you accept that he truly is a genius, and that he has a better than 50% chance of survival, we can limit his chances of survival by making the choice truly random. Toss a coin. Heads and I take the one handed to me. Tails and I take the other one.
If everyone did that, he would be lucky to survive more than two attempts.
That's assuming the game is actually as presented. Given his success rate, that's unlikely.
Also, according to my brother, the breaking down Watson's past and phone is lifted almost entirely wholesale from the first Conan Doyle Holmes story (except there, it was referring to a pocket-watch, not a cellphone).
Just got finished watching it. I didnt know if i would like it much, never having been drawn to sherlock, but this was all kinds of awesome. Its witty, smart, and has good writing. Cant wait for more.
Mike Danger"Diane..."a place both wonderful and strangeRegistered Userregular
edited July 2010
I loved
Spoiler:
just about everything. I had a hard time buying that Holmes was actually going to take the pill, as I was so sure it was leading up to a moment where he was going to be all "I may be a sociopath, but I'm not crazy" or something.
Mycroft coming in at the end there, however, was hilarious. I totally didn't see it coming, to the point where when "Mummy" came up I was all "wait, Moriarty and Holmes are brothers in this?"
I loved the nod to Watson's love for the ladies with him constantly trying to pick up Mycroft's PA there. Definitely looking forward to next week.
Posts
The perfect thing. At least for me.
Thank you, world!
I seriously can't get over this. I like Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman both a lot. And Sherlock Holmes. And Stephen Moffat. And BBC adaptations of books I already love.
Steam: Chagrin LoL: Bonhomie
Come on...
Sherlock fan.
It is a simple calculation, after that.
Also...
"...A sister! There's always something!"
EDIT: Oh, it's on iPlayer live!
some of the stuff felt a bit above me though, like i was lagging behind holmes and he was having to tell me shit, which i suppose is the intended effect but it meant there's no satisfying "oh what if it's XYZ". i have to confess i've never read a sherlock holmes book- did he always pull that "oh, your trouser leg is 5 millimeters shorter on the left side, indicating your dick is rotting off from the leprosy caught from the lady over there who is bluh bluh bluh" logic from mid air?
The art direction was brilliant, with the thoughts and text messages being presented very cleverly - it reminded me a bit of Night Watch, especially with the brief shot from behind the text when Holmes was looking at the body.
I loved all the nods to the originals - the case being a "three patch problem", and the curious case of Watson being shot in different places depending on which book you read.
I was completely taken in with the bait and switch with Mycroft - I should have known better to have assumed that Steven Moffat would have had such a typical introduction to the series nemesis
Edit: Yeah, Nuzak, Holmes does that a lot - in The Hound of the Baskervilles, he comes up with three or four paragraphs' worth of information from a walking stick.
For some reason, I think the showdown with the serial killer went on a little too long for a Sherlock Holmes adaptation.
All in all, a pretty solid start. Will all episodes be 90 minutes long, or will they be more condensed like most of the stories?
Also surely after the first couple of suicides people knew they were going to die, yet look like a suicide. Take the 'bullet' then at least the police will treat it like a murder.
Anarchy Rules:
"I'm not a psychopath, I'm a high-functioning sociopath, I know you've read the file" - brilliant.
The Princess Bride ending was a little difficult to take seriously, and Mark Gatiss is very difficult to take seriously, but overall this is showing a lot of promise.
How many episodes of this are there? I'm hoping it'll cure my Doctor Who cravings for a while.
then my internet died
Fuck sky
I liked it a lot. I thought it was going to be a weekly type of thing, but 3 feature length movies is just as good. I haven't read any of the books, but this makes me want to.
Holmes left me in the dust when
Freeman and Cumberbatch (made up name, surely) were great, and the whole thing bounced along merrily with few, if any, slow passages.
It is England.
Steam: Chagrin LoL: Bonhomie
Bogart's English. That's a weird name. And made up I think.
His mum is Wanda Ventham. I used to fancy her. How odd.
I dunno, Michael Caine's real name is Maurice Micklewhite. I'd say he toned it down.
Yep. David Tennant's real name is David McDonald. He claimed to have gotten his new name from Smash Hits!
Fairly sure the American one does as well - or maybe it's just the Writers' Guild, as I remember David X Cohen mentioning it in a Futurama commentary.
Hi5!
You can't have the same name as another member. Which is frankly retarded.
Also, if the cabby had held a gun to my head, I would have picked the pill too. I would have done it differently, though. His superpower is to predict my thought process in choosing the bottle, and, on basis of that, either hand me the poison or the not-poison. If you accept that he truly is a genius, and that he has a better than 50% chance of survival, we can limit his chances of survival by making the choice truly random. Toss a coin. Heads and I take the one handed to me. Tails and I take the other one.
If everyone did that, he would be lucky to survive more than two attempts.
Also, according to my brother, the breaking down Watson's past and phone is lifted almost entirely wholesale from the first Conan Doyle Holmes story (except there, it was referring to a pocket-watch, not a cellphone).
Mycroft coming in at the end there, however, was hilarious. I totally didn't see it coming, to the point where when "Mummy" came up I was all "wait, Moriarty and Holmes are brothers in this?"
I loved the nod to Watson's love for the ladies with him constantly trying to pick up Mycroft's PA there. Definitely looking forward to next week.
Not only is that a pretty good pun, it's making me want to watch this even more.
Steam: Chagrin LoL: Bonhomie