Cake vs. Pie [Phalla] - Game Over! Mafia Wins! Cake gets secondary victory!

daniant

Vs.

A plethora of delicious treats sit before you. But which will you choose, Cake or Pie?

This is a Faction Main Phalla for 50 people. Standard rules apply: no sharing of host-provided PMs via screenshots and direct quotation. No anonymous contact is allowed. No “death posts” that reveal any information, no multiple “death posts”.

If any players create proboards, please send a link for it to the host.

Every day a player must make at least two posts to evade Inactivus. Vote in red, retract in lime.

Vote close will be at 8 PM PST.

Warning: conversions and other unsavory mechanics are possible!

Sign up in lime, clarifications in orange.

Player List:
1. kime- Apple Spice Cake
2. stever777- Pumpkin Pie
3. Mr. Blarney- Lemon Meringue Pie
4. The Anonymous- Carrot Cake (Pie)
5. romanqwerty- Fruitcake
6. Darian- Cookie
7. Kias- Baklava
8. Teucrian- Chess Pie
9. Alt_Raven- Apple Pie
10. Lucedes
11. mascara305- Cupcake
12. jimtopia- Empanada
13. SeGaTai- Red Velvet Cake
14. Celebrim- Bread Pudding
15. Shorn Scrotum Man
16. CaptainPlanet82
17. Thetheroo- Pecan Pie
18. Monkeyfeet- Birthday Cake
19. Over The Moon- Berry Tarts
20. 3clipse- Pumpkin Bars
21. Capfalcon- Doughnut
22. Heffling- Genoise Cake
23. Sir Fabulous- Cherry Pie
24. Gandalf_the_Crazed- Coconut Custard Pie
25. Dragon6860- Lemon Bar
26. Dunadan019- Pavlova
27. Ringo Ronrab- Tiramisu
28. oldmanken- Ice Cream
29. Extermatott
30. Void Slayer- Pound Cake
31. Nodgarb- Eclair
32. PsychoLarry1- German Chocolate Cake
33. wildwood- Petit Fours
34. Unsalted- Creme Brule
35. Raiden333
36. thatguy00- Angel Food Cake
37. Wildcat- Mince Pie
38. Mordroth
39. The Cow King
40. towndrunk34
41. pezzy- Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
42. Stew_Stick
43. Yourbadgegaveitaway jackisreal- Quiche
44. Bedlam- Banana Cream Pie
45. Savant- Key Lime Pie

Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4
Day 5
Day 6
Day 7
Day 8

Clarifications

Spoiler:

Order of actions?

What happens in the case of a tie vote?

1. Vote, then all other actions simultaneously.

2. In the case of a tie, both players die, as does the tie creator.

The Anonymous

PANCAKE MONSTER HUNGERS.

TEAM PANCAKE, ARISE!

kime

daniant wrote: »

CAKE VS. PIE
is up!

I will be so sad if kime doesn't come back to play it.

I can't very well deny you, now can I?

CAKE

stever777

Never played this before. Not really sure how it goes but it seems so popular. Total newb. Can I get in?

MrBlarney

stever777, we welcome all players. You'll catch on quick, there's loads of us to help you out.

I !sign up.

The Anonymous

FEAR NOT, PANCAKE MONSTER ALWAYS WELCOMES FRESH MEAT.

AT LEAST, WHEN IT JOINS IN BOLD LIME.

stever777

MrBlarney wrote: »

stever777, we welcome all players. You'll catch on quick, there's loads of us to help you out.

I !sign up.

Hmm. Should I trust you in a game like this?

MrBlarney

stever777 wrote: »

MrBlarney wrote: »

stever777, we welcome all players. You'll catch on quick, there's loads of us to help you out.

Hmm. Should I trust you in a game like this?

Of course. Besides, there are plenty of other players who will call me out on it if I'm not being trustworthy.

stever777

I'm scared! Saw this game being played on a tour in Israel last year.

kime

stever777 wrote: »

I'm scared! Saw this game being played on a tour in Israel last year.

Sign up.

Rule #1: Always trust kime

stever777

Hehe! OK Kime! Darian says he has to hide when he's online when playing. Do I have to do that?

kime

stever777 wrote: »

Hehe! OK Kime! Darian says he has to hide when he's online when playing. Do I have to do that?

It's advisable to set your status to Invisible, because in the past people have used that, but it's not necessary.

stever777

done

romanqwerty

kIME!

Darian

stever, a few of things I feel I should mention:

1. You should put your sign-up in bold lime, as the PANCAKE MONSTER kindly pointed out.
2. Editing posts is a no-no, and in particular editing a vote post will result in that vote not counting.
3. kime is always evil, so you would be a fool to trust him.

stever777

Darian wrote: »

stever, a few of things I feel I should mention:

1. You should put your sign-up in bold lime, as the PANCAKE MONSTER kindly pointed out.
2. Editing posts is a no-no, and in particular editing a vote post will result in that vote not counting.
3. kime is always evil, so you would be a fool to trust him.

1. done
2. OK
3. :o

kime

Evil? Me? pfft, just misunderstood.

stever777

kime wrote: »

Evil? Me? pfft, just misunderstood.

Aren't we all...

Darian

Really, though, we can avoid any controversy by reading this scientific study.

Abstract:

I love cake. Cake is wonderful. But it is too easy to get caught up in the idea of cake. When you compare the data, it is clear that pie is a better choice.

stever777

Darian wrote: »

stever, a few of things I feel I should mention:

1. You should put your sign-up in bold lime, as the PANCAKE MONSTER kindly pointed out.
2. Editing posts is a no-no, and in particular editing a vote post will result in that vote not counting.
3. kime is always evil, so you would be a fool to trust him.

You know I always trust you Darian. You taught me to host CitOW.

Kias

Darian wrote: »

Really, though, we can avoid any controversy by reading this scientific study.

Abstract:

I love cake. Cake is wonderful. But it is too easy to get caught up in the idea of cake. When you compare the data, it is clear that pie is a better choice.

You are both wise and link-savvy.

Sign up for PIE!

Teucrian

Kias wrote: »

Darian wrote: »

Really, though, we can avoid any controversy by reading this scientific study.

Abstract:

I love cake. Cake is wonderful. But it is too easy to get caught up in the idea of cake. When you compare the data, it is clear that pie is a better choice.

You are both wise and link-savvy.

Counter argument:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CmOkXV-S1zQ

Sign up

Alt_Raven

As the Waffles fall from the sky!

kime

Order of actions?

What happens in the case of a tie vote?

Lucedes

!Cheesecake.

mascara305

Pineapple upside down cake!!!

jimtopia

Mmm Cheesecake

SeGaTai

I stand with pie

Celebrim

!Sign up. Enjoyed watching the last one.

Shorn Scrotum Man

!Signup

Been a while, feel like doing these again!

CaptainPlanet82

For the good of all of us, except the ones who are dead.

Thetheroo

I'm down

Monkeyfeet

I got an incredible urge to play a phalla after watching the D&D episode of Community. So I'm here

Over The Moon

Boysenberry Pie for the Pie God

3clipse

MUST DEVOUR ALL PASTRY

Capfalcon

Is day one-ing the host an acceptable choice of actions?

Heffling

!Cake is a lie!

Sir Fabulous

Kime. You are like a father to me. Why, I remember that time I spent 30 minutes writing up a post about why people who were bandwagoning you were just utterly confused by your awesome glory (or something like that). But I feel this is where we must part.

You may bring as much Cake as you want, and I shall lead the legions of Pie. There is no going back on this now. Truly, the apocalypse has come.

Also Stevers, Invisible Mode is for people who have something to hide... mafioso.

Gandalf_the_Crazed

!I prefer cobbler, to be honest.

Dragon6860

Signin up!

daniant

kime wrote: »

Order of actions?

What happens in the case of a tie vote?

1. Vote, then all other actions simultaneously.

2. In the case of a tie, both players die, as does the tie creator.