[Phalla] Game Over! Way to go killer p.50 The Unfortunate Voyage of the Harbinger

KetBra

I think it was Egos that I was talking to before that was telling me that when he's mafia he'll later on in the game go into "detective villager mode" to try to seem helpful and villager-y.

Egos

1)haha I find Akimbo suspicious but because of how certain people have reacted and because certain people have jumped on his wagon, I don't feel very comfortable jumping on him.

2)I found you suspicious before, you can look it up on Phyphor's box or I can point it out to you (look at for reasons mentioned yesterday (that is a big part even though it doesn't get a lot of screen time ). The debate is between you and Malkor. The fact that you are on Malkor makes me have some reservations about going after him. When it is more he is shady as hell and there is some actual stuff on you.

Egos

KetBra wrote: »

I think it was Egos that I was talking to before that was telling me that when he's mafia he'll later on in the game go into "detective villager mode" to try to seem helpful and villager-y.

No I was saying when I'm villager I get into detective villager mode and I'm more enthusiastic x(

Bedlam

Gaslight wrote: »

KetBra is alive. Reading narrations is not that hard, people, at least if you wait a few minutes to make sure Munkus covers everybody in the bloodbaths that have been happening.

I think the list SNT posted a couple pages back is accurate:

1. Pierce Benedict, Harbinger Captain - Skull Man
4. Dr. Ian Forbes, Doctor, Head of the Medbay - sportzboytjw
5. Dr. Curtis Henshaw, Doctor, Head of Research and Development - KetBra
8. Simon Krieger, Lab Assistant - DumpShock
12. Albert 'Ace' McKinney, Marine - REG Rysk
15. Bob Rickman, Repairman, Home Issues - Void Slayer JackIsReal
18. Larry Curtis, Marketing Manager - The Anonymous romanqwerty
21. Dr. Calvin Underton, Gravity Engineer - Cythraul
23. Razer, Band Member - Egos
30. Buster Chambers, Shopkeeper/Provisions Officer - Citizen
32. Jerome Jones, Co-Pilot - Cayrus Nullzone
35. Dr. Sarah Longfellow, Psychiatrist - Bedlam
36. Dr. Riki Oz, Xenobiologist Researcher - I needed a name to post.
37. Dr. Juan Nestor, Geologist - SLyM
38. Billy Sheldon, Accountant - Mr. Mojo Risin
40. Wally Walters, Information Technology Guru - Smoove Operator
41. Dr. Blaire Doolittle, Artificial Intelligence Researcher - 38thDoe
42. Jack Rollins, Repairman, Computer/Electronics - Infidel
44. Peter Rogers, Police/Guard Force - Gaslight
46. Roland Burroughs, Harbinger General Manager - Spoit
47. Brittany "Babs" Harrow, General Manager's Secretary - Alegis
48. Lester/Debra *last name open*, Crewperson's Spouse - AkimboLegs
49. John/Susana *last name open*, Crewperson's Spouse - Shiny New Toys

Juxtaposing it with this list:

140 posts by Infidel
79 posts by Bedlam
71 posts by Spoit
71 posts by Skull Man
69 posts by Egos
62 posts by AkimboLegs
59 posts by Gaslight
42 posts by Phyphor
36 posts by SLyM
33 posts by Cythraul
29 posts by I needed a name to post.
25 posts by Nullzone
22 posts by REG Rysk
21 posts by 38thDoe
21 posts by Alegis
20 posts by DumpShock
17 posts by sportzboytjw
17 posts by romanqwerty
17 posts by Malkor
15 posts by Shiny New Toys
15 posts by Smoove Operator
15 posts by KetBra
13 posts by Mr. Mojo Risin
11 posts by jackisreal
8 posts by Citizen

Pretty sure SNT missed some names then (or I did) because I got Malkor as being still alive.

Gaslight

Egos wrote: »

1)haha I find Akimbo suspicious but because of how certain people have reacted and because certain people have jumped on his wagon, I don't feel very comfortable jumping on him.

2)I found you suspicious before, you can look it up on Phyphor's box or I can point it out to you (look at for reasons mentioned yesterday (that is a big part even though it doesn't get a lot of screen time ). The debate is between you and Malkor. The fact that you are on Malkor makes me have some reservations about going after him. When it is more he is shady as hell and there is some actual stuff on you.

What are the reasons mentioned yesterday? I assume you're talking about Akimbo going after me for being on the SeGa wagon. I answered that then. At the time I voted for SeGa, there was a logjam of people in the nighborhood of 2-4 votes each, none of which I thought were very good leads. The SeGa vote didn't have much to go on either but it seemed at least as good as the justification for anybody else at the time, and the wagon on Anialos (which ended up being second place that day) didn't pick up steam until later.

As I said at the time though, I can understand why people would look at me since I was on the SeGa wagon, and since that's what Akimbo said he was largely basing his vote on I didn't hold it against him. But apparently not getting pissy at Akimbo and knee-jerk voting against him in return makes me somehow more suspicious?

Egos

Gaslight wrote: »

What are the reasons mentioned yesterday?

spoilered for length

Spoiler:

Egos wrote: »

I'm going to go with Gaslight for the time being. It's not the strongest argument, but he wasn't a fan of the Anialos vote when they were a few votes on it, as seen here. Or he didn't see much there , which is kinda understandable. But he jumped on when it was in full swing here, which you could argue was an attempt to have a better vote record (if you want to argue innocence ) . You could argue the pure he is trying to get information angle, depending on how strong you think that is.

Alternatives I think daniant is good for aforementioned reasons. Also Dumpshock, there was one post of his that stood out to me. It was this one, it struck me as really odd. Mainly because it is sort of the mentality a mafioso has when there is a network head. That is, I'm sure many of you have been in this position, you are aware the network head has info and is likely sitting on it and puts out a false target for the village to follow and wants to see how many people are geese and how many are independent thinkers (etc.). To narrow things down. Now I believe at the time , this was Infidel's first day. So it seems a bit odd. And also he made is vote (which wasn't on the A wagon; it was on figgy). If he were mafia, I would think he would use different phrasing? I'm not quiet sure what to make of this. If he is a player that just wants to survive or what. I'd have to read Figgy's analysis a bit more in-detail.

Smoove Operator

So who are the remaining people who were on the SeGa wagon?

Also, I'm with Egos on the Malkor shadiness (specifically, the " in cahoots" comment from awhile back that got swept under the rug).

Gaslight

Feh. I answered the stuff about my vote record. If you want to go after me for that, fine. It's mistaken, but at least it's legitimate and understandable. The other stuff I have heard advanced as a reason to vote for me though...I "act odd" (can't really respond to that)...I typed the wrong name (horrors!)...and given the choice between two people who are supposedly suspicious, I chose not to pick a personal vendetta over my best judgment...that's all frankly bullshit.

Egos

Gaslight wrote: »

Feh. I answered the stuff about my vote record. If you want to go after me for that, fine. It's mistaken, but at least it's legitimate and understandable. The other stuff I have heard advanced as a reason to vote for me though...I "act odd" (can't really respond to that)...I typed the wrong name (horrors!)...and given the choice between two people who are supposedly suspicious, I chose not to pick a personal vendetta over my best judgment...that's all frankly bullshit.

I don't think I've mentioned any of that, the odd part might have been implied? As for the last part it's admittedly conspiracy theory (e.g. mafia knows one person is innocent and says something in order to make one look good)- conspiracy theory and nothing more. I even say as much. It's not the foundation for the vote. It's just an aside. As said

Egos wrote: »

There is always the possibility Gas is a bigger man ,etc. etc. but there are other things that make him suspect.

I may go back onto Malkor... Gaslight's presence unfortunately didn't help.

Egos

Egos wrote: »

Gaslight wrote: »

Feh. I answered the stuff about my vote record. If you want to go after me for that, fine. It's mistaken, but at least it's legitimate and understandable. The other stuff I have heard advanced as a reason to vote for me though...I "act odd" (can't really respond to that)...I typed the wrong name (horrors!)...and given the choice between two people who are supposedly suspicious,I chose not to pick a personal vendetta over my best judgment...that's all frankly bullshit.

I don't think I've mentioned any of that, the odd part might have been implied? As for the last part it's admittedly conspiracy theory (e.g. mafia knows one person is innocent and says something in order to make one look good)- conspiracy theory and nothing more. I even say as much. It's not the foundation for the vote. It's just an aside. As said

Egos wrote: »

There is always the possibility Gas is a bigger man ,etc. etc. but there are other things that make him suspect.

I may go back onto Malkor... Gaslight's presence unfortunately didn't help.

bleh I bolded one extra thing on accident, fixed it.

jackisreal

Bob Rickman is still pretty in the dark but thinks that the way Gaslight disregarded the Anialos vote on page 19 could be a sign of his inner evil

Gaslight

Egos wrote: »

Gaslight wrote: »

Feh. I answered the stuff about my vote record. If you want to go after me for that, fine. It's mistaken, but at least it's legitimate and understandable. The other stuff I have heard advanced as a reason to vote for me though...I "act odd" (can't really respond to that)...I typed the wrong name (horrors!)...and given the choice between two people who are supposedly suspicious, I chose not to pick a personal vendetta over my best judgment...that's all frankly bullshit.

I don't think I've mentioned any of that, the odd part might have been implied? As for the last part it's admittedly conspiracy theory (e.g. mafia knows one person is innocent and says something in order to make one look good)- conspiracy theory and nothing more. I even say as much. It's not the foundation for the vote. It's just an aside. As said

Egos wrote: »

There is always the possibility Gas is a bigger man ,etc. etc. but there are other things that make him suspect.

I may go back onto Malkor... Gaslight's presence unfortunately didn't help.

The acting odd and name typo weren't you, no, that was akimbo's secondary justification for voting for me earlier and what nullzone said respectively, although I should say nullzone backed off.

Nullzone

Yeah, my entire foundation for voting Gaslight was based on the fingerpointing at Assuran. Without that, the rest was too circumstantial to be comfortable in my mind

KetBra

So, this is the conversation I was talking about before. It turns out I was wrong about what Egos said (he actually said the opposite, I just misremembered)

<Egos> I get into enthusiastic detective mode as a villager (usually if I'm not busy)
<Egos> as mafia I'm too concerned about not screwing things up for my team ...too careful
<Egos> so my posts are usually not as crazy and I'm not putting theories out

whoops.jpg

Infidel

!Malkor

!!!

Smoove Operator

Does the post min go up today? The wife and I are headed to friends house. Just to be safe...

Smoove Operator

...I'll make this 2 posts, since it will likely be my last for the night. As above, Malkor is my best shot tonight.

Egos

hm I'm rather glad you changed your mind Infidel, I was about to go "fuck it I'll go with the guy with 17 posts over 59"

Malkor

jackisreal

Wait what why are we voting for Malkor

Infidel

For suspicious absence from the living player list another player created!

Shiny New Toys

I'm probably going to regret posting this but if I don't do it now I will miss the vote close.

I have spent all day playing sport in 40 degree heat and then all night drinking, so I may not be at my most cohesive. I haven't read all the post uptil now, I still have 2 pages to read- but I feel that is a job better done sober.

So to avoid inactivus the curse of the village I vote Malkor

Munkus Beaver

Four post minimum will start Tomorrow. I will remind you again in tonight's narration.

Basically, there are so few of you left that it will start to be a dust town if nobody posts. And more data conversation is always at the core of a game like this.

EDIT: And can I say I'm surprised that you guys have an idea for what a Munkus Phalla is since this is only the second I've run?

Malkor

Everyone's voting for me because I looked into the game too hard a few times. I asked weird things like, "maybe the infection is a seering" and "maybe infidel is in cahoots with Anialos" and most recently "Figgy is dead, he suspected Egos, I suspect him!"

So. Pretty much I am bad at Phalla.

Malkor

Also, if I die and Egos is bad you have to erect me the forum equivalent of a statue proclaiming that I was right.

If I'm wrong, then my bad Egos and you should erect a forum statue saying that Figgy doesn't know what the hell he's talking about.

Infidel

Being wrong doesn't mean you don't know what you're doing.

Malkor

The point is.

statues

Also I was scared to post again because I thought maybe I was dead already but refused to comprehend it.

Egos

Malkor wrote: »

Figgy is dead, he suspected Egos, I suspect him!"
.

"Langly is dead, he didn't suspect Egos" at least not for the same reasons others were blabbing on about and didn't mention any suspicions

38thDoe

Malkor wrote: »

Everyone's voting for me because I looked into the game too hard a few times.

If you look too hard into the game it looks back into you.

38thDoe

Bedlam wrote: »

Juxtaposing it with this list:

140 posts by Infidel
79 posts by Bedlam
71 posts by Spoit
71 posts by Skull Man
69 posts by Egos
62 posts by AkimboLegs
59 posts by Gaslight
42 posts by Phyphor
36 posts by SLyM
33 posts by Cythraul
29 posts by I needed a name to post.
25 posts by Nullzone
22 posts by REG Rysk
21 posts by 38thDoe
21 posts by Alegis
20 posts by DumpShock
17 posts by sportzboytjw
17 posts by romanqwerty
17 posts by Malkor
15 posts by Shiny New Toys
15 posts by Smoove Operator
15 posts by KetBra
13 posts by Mr. Mojo Risin
11 posts by jackisreal
8 posts by Citizen

Pretty sure SNT missed some names then (or I did) because I got Malkor as being still alive.

2posts a night *5 nights looks like a lot of people below the minimum.
Jackisreal came in one day late? Or two?
Citizen has been in the entire time I think? I don't have time to check right now.

I'm kind of suspicious of people skirting the line anyways, and coincidentally Malkor is in this group as well.

Egos

jack came in at the end of day 1 as a replacement for void slayer.

Bedlam

Freaking nullzone come in at like day 3 or 4 and he is posting more than the rest.

And he converses like hes been here the whole time!

I needed a name to post.

hey guys now that my work week is over i can come home and communicate over something other than dywitter, how's everyone doing

KetBra

Awww I miss the "Posted from my DyPad 7" signoffs already

KetBra

Infidel wrote: »

For suspicious absence from the living player list another player created!

Wait, which list is this?

Egos

Malkor wrote: »

Also, if I die and Egos is bad you have to erect me the forum equivalent of a statue proclaiming that I was right.

If I'm wrong, then my bad Egos and you should erect a forum statue saying that Figgy doesn't know what the hell he's talking about.

You know , I have to say it's kinda funny that if you're right you get to be a "good" statue. But if you're wrong then Figgy gets the blame. I mean I understand Figgy was killed by the mafia and it's looking like you are getting voted out. Still rather amusing.

DumpShock

Hmmmm... I'm going to stick with Infidel and to be honest I see a lot of my last games playstyle in Malkor

REG Rysk

Vote switching?

While I admit I had already concurred that Akimbo is likely not mafia (for the same mentioned reasons as Egos) I don't get the Infidel vote, then vote change. Not sure I feel like sheeping on the main wagon everybody else will be on, so Gaslight

Malkor

Welp.

This isn't an epic reveal it's a regular one. I'm just your everyday, average ordinary villager.

I'm looking over the thread, and it looks like I am actually maybe, kinda-slightly sorta wrong about Egos possibly. He was one of the first people to vote for Analios apparently.

Skull Man

Infidel

!Gaslight

For real this time.

KetBra

Uhhh gaslight I guess?