Our new Indie Games subforum is now open for business in G&T. Go and check it out, you might land a code for a free game. If you're developing an indie game and want to post about it, follow these directions. If you don't, he'll break your legs! Hahaha! Seriously though.
Our rules have been updated and given their own forum. Go and look at them! They are nice, and there may be new ones that you didn't know about! Hooray for rules! Hooray for The System! Hooray for Conforming!

Dark Ages [short story, 2679 words]

ScudoScudo Registered User regular
Hey guys, I hope it isn't considered terrible etiquette to post a story if you aren't an active WB poster. I've always wanted to post here, but truth be told, I've avoided this place because seeing all of your stories reminds me of how terribly unproductive I've been. This is like the first piece of creative writing I've finished in two years, and I'd love to get some more eyes on it. It's about a family on New Years Eve.
Spoiler:

Posts

  • SlortexSlortex In my chairRegistered User regular
    That was beautiful. I wish I was more experienced at critiquing things, so I could give you some real advice, but you'll have to settle for knowing that I loved it. You've got a great voice and the pacing is perfect. Every time I thought you were about to dwell on a point just a little too long, you switched gears and made me want to keep reading. The whole thing reminds me of an episode of The Wonder Years or Brady Bunch or... hell, my own relationship with my brother. You've really captured the family dynamic here.

    I like the ambiguity you give about the mom. Makes me wonder more about the structure and make-up of the family without feeling out of place or forced.

    Great work.

  • ScudoScudo Registered User regular
    Thanks! I really appreciate the feedback. Glad you liked it, it means a lot.

  • CaptPocoCaptPoco Registered User
    The last image, of a mom's pee running down the gutter of the street, is pretty grotesque. Not exactly heartwarming... but on the whole I thought it was an above-average work. The "fight" between the boy and his dad ended in a way that seems very real... I wouldn't be surprised if it was drawn from actual life. I took an intro to Creative Writing class a few years ago and this blows anything we read in that class out of the water.

  • VanityPantsVanityPants Registered User regular
    While there's nothing wrong with the prose of dialogue of this story, I couldn't help but finish reading this story feeling like nothing had really happened. It's a very short sort of look into a family's life, but there's not really anything compelling or interesting there. There's a lack of any real action (even in the sense of internal character action).

    The fight between the father and son was interesting, but I was let down that nothing really came from it. Pieces that focus on character, theme, or emotion are all okay and good, but I still believe you need to have some element of CHANGE to have a complete story arc, and so I end up feeling more like I'm reading a journal entry of some kind instead of a fully realized short story.

    I do agree with CaptPoco that the image of the mother's pee running down the gutter seemed entirely out of place with the rest of the story. It was crass, and while I don't mind that, it didn't seem to fit the tone of the rest of the story at all.

    Ultimately I think you really just need to find a way to interject some form of energy or change in here to make it compelling and memorable.

  • MagellMagell Registered User regular
    Maybe I read a different story than the other two people, but this didn't really work for me. You have the beginnings of an interesting story with the confrontation between the son and the father, but it feels muddled by the setting of Y2K, which doesn't really do anything for anything.

    There is too much description of the what's going on in the computer when nothing happens there and it's too described for a short story and loses some of the effect of what you're going for.

    As I read it the son feels like the person in the wrong, but that's not how the story plays out. He maybe right, but he should listen to his father, because he has a rationale behind his request even if the son knows it's wrong.

    The ending of the story also feels wrong. You don't need the story about the Mom. Because her not being there doesn't really play into anything. Just have the father apologize to the son.

  • ScudoScudo Registered User regular
    Thanks for the feedback. With the mom, I was trying to hint that this is the family's first New Year's Eve without her, and the dad's overreaction about Y2K stems from wanting to protect them in her absence. The son was definitely in the wrong, but what I'm hoping to get with the final exchange is the dad admitting that he overreacted, and the son (with his mom fresh on his mind) finally understanding where he's coming from.

    I think I deliberately went kind of gross with that last image to keep it from being schmalzy, but it doesn't look like it's hitting the right note at all, so I'll try to go back and rethink it. I think maybe that can tie into VanityPants' suggestion about creating more energy -- I need to make it more clear that the change happening is the son coming to understand his father's perspective.

Sign In or Register to comment.