Our new Indie Games subforum is now open for business in G&T. Go and check it out, you might land a code for a free game. If you're developing an indie game and want to post about it,
follow these directions. If you don't, he'll break your legs! Hahaha! Seriously though.
Our rules have been updated and given
their own forum. Go and look at them! They are nice, and there may be new ones that you didn't know about! Hooray for rules! Hooray for The System! Hooray for Conforming!
[Phalla] of Lovecraft: West Victory!
Posts
God, I was the worst defender ever in the Newham game. Worst. Ever.
Why would I even go near those if I was really a cultist?
So, do you remember the order in which the roles get played out every night?
What I mean is, if we kill the doctor ourselves will it happen before the zombies get the kill?
If we assume the zombies have some working brains left (haha), why would we waste our vote on RU as well?
And I don't remember the kill order.
Elendil, what goes first? zombie or vote?
*edit: oh wait, I understand, you want to be sure that Dr West gets killed.
Because if the zombies kill the doctor then they satisfy their win condition and the village loses.
According to the OP, revenants are the last to act.
Quid was not the Illuminati Necromancer, he was a Cultist of the Church of Starry Wisdom.
I believe !Aldo is trying to obscure the truth by only revealing a portion of it.
Why do I think this?
Aldo's suspicions of me are most likely to get me killed no matter what at this point, but I'm not about to let him get away with it.
I believe that a portion of what he says is true, I believe Quid did in fact target me and I did, in fact, resist his attack? Why? Because I am the gravedigger's son, and I am immune to poison, the Cult of Starry Wisdom's weapon of choice. Of course, it's a pretty natural reaction to think I might have been something else and Aldo, as a cultist, has just as much reason to fear Dr. West as the village does. The difference is, if Quid was the Illuminati Necromancer and he had targeted me, I assure you, I would have died.
So the question is, if Quid WASN'T the illuminati necromancer, why would Aldo know all this?
Folks, I think the answer is pretty obvious.
Obviously, it's now my word versus his, but whether I'm Dr. West or the gravedigger's son, there's no reason for the Revenants not to kill me now, so I don't really have anything to gain by coming out like this except to expose Aldo as the vile cultist he is.
Godspeed village.
If one of Plutonium's bad guys had attacked this supposed doctor, the doctor wouldn't have waisted his revolver on them because he knows he is immune to poison and disease. Meaning, that if Quid was the necromancer, he would have died when tried to attack romantic undead had RU actually been the doctor.
Your story doesn't add up.
Thanks for trying gundam, but the Revenants would probably have killed me just to be safe anyways.
The OP says the gravedigger's son can choose to protect themselves from either poison or disease, not that they are immune from poison.
So, have you been protecting yourself from poison this whole time or did you just get lucky when Quid attacked you?
Also, if Quid really is the Illuminati Necromancer, wouldn't his weapons of choice be the same of that of the cultists? I am not sure about this, but it sounds logical, doesn't it?
To be sure: Elendil, if the zombies kill Dr West, does that mean the village looses the game?
As for the village losing if the revenants win, Elendil clarified before that it's possible for both the village and the revenants to win together. I'm gonna go find it and edit it in.
Found it:
Nice try cultist, But the Illuminati Necromancer's role PM says nothing about poison or disease. That's a mighty big overlook on Elendil's part if that were true. What, do you expect whoever the Necromancer is to PM Elendil and go "I kill so and so with poison?" Unlikely.
I'm taking you down with me you evil son of a bitch.
I don't know how the Illuminati Necromancer's attacks work, Mae. :? All I know is that Quid told me he was suspicious of you because he tried killing you and it didn't work.
Then you're either his pawn or a fellow cultist. If he was the necromancer, I'd be dead.
I think exhuming a recent kill would be beneficial in this case, since all three vocal people died at the same time.
He didn't post at all for 4 days. He didn't get killed for inactivity. All of the few posts that he has made have had little to no substance, both in quantity or quality. He showed up last night when I said I was suspicious of him, and his one post was to ask for a summary of gundam's thoughts on Fuzzy. This seems more like trying to bolster support for that theory to avoid detection than a genuine interest.
Putting another day between the accusations might add some well needed data.
1) Why did Quid decide to trust you?
2) Why did you decide to trust Quid when he claimed to be the Necromancer?
3) If Quid was the necromancer, why would he risk his alleged mouthpiece (yourself) starting a bandwagon on Saburbia when he could just kill Sab himself?
4) You contradict yourself a lot here. You say Quid thinks RU is Dr. West because Quid failed to kill him last night, but Quid died last night. How would you know Quid thinks that then? Also, you state Quid left hints to the revenant(s) that RU was West. If he did that, why would he then attack him the same night and risk getting killed rather than giving the revenant(s) a chance to do it first? Or if he was willing to use you to bandwagon Saburbia, why not have you bandwagon RU?
5) Quid had his "Head torn off", which sounds a hell of a lot like a revenant attack. If Quid's attack on RU went before the revenants, then if RU was West his counterattack would have killed Quid before the revenants could. If the revenants got first dibs, then Quid never got an attack off on RU and so you couldn't deduce anything about him in the first place.
It's quite possible you're right about Romantic Undead being Dr. West. However, it seems very likely that you are a cultist, so I !vote for Aldo.
I am incredibly curious to know his role.
Either way we eliminate a suspect.
1) I don't know
2) I didn't trust him completely
3) He would have to wait another day to kill someone again and he didn't want to risk that. He considered Dr. West to be a bigger threat than the cultists at that point.
4) Quid could kill on odd night and guard at even nights. He could not kill someone every night. I was willing to try and bandwagon Sab because I was suspicious of him as well and considered this a good time to get him killed to see if I was right.
I am not sure if Quid was really the Illuminati Necromancer or a cultist, all I know is that he tried to convince me that he ran into people he couldn't kill and that the chances were that one of them was Dr. West.
This, mostly.
I'm 100% comfortable with !voting for Aldo. I did before, when he started the bandwagon on Saburbia. I felt his reasoning was skewed then, and I feel the same now. His excuse for starting that(Sab bandwagon) is just too convenient.
Hopefully Aldo will stay in the lead. If he turns up innocent and RU makes it through the night he'll have to go next.
It's past midnight here and I want to go to bed, I was hoping more people would post between now and an hour ago, but it seems like everyone is either network'd or inactive. It's kinda sad how slow these phallas get after night 1. It's just not my idea of fun and it's kinda pissing me off right now. My phalla will be brutal for inactives, I don't think I would care about screwing teams over, if you sign up for a phalla, it should mean you can be posting in the thread at least a few times per day.
If RU turns up as the gravedigger's son, then the bad guys will probably know exactly who Dr West is, but they won't be able to kill him without doing what I did earlier tonight. I'm not sure if they want to run this risk. There's a big chance Dr West will win this phalla, unless the zombies are paying attention to the kills and who killed who and who might have been killed as well. It's really up in the air right now.
Anyway, I'm off for the night, I understand it if you're going to kill me, I'm about the last active poster anyway, so it's a miracle I survived this long.
If Aldo is innocent, then he's just screwed the village out of the gravedigger's son.
But due to his connection with Quid, it's more likely he's a cultist.
Either way, he's doing the village no favors and I believe him to be our strongest lead right now. I really don't see how we can go wrong with voting Aldo out.
So the true question of this is for Elendil. Is the Illuminati Necromancer's attack, like his identity, indistinguishable from the cultists'?
I'm not making a move until this question is answered.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GlUsiKfeDfo&eurl=http://areasofmyexpertise.blogspot.com/
http://www.ugo.com/movies/babylon-ad-video-gallery/?cur=vin-diesel-dungeons-and-dragons&morepics=1
I am torn about who to vote to be dug up so I guess I am going with !exhume Satan Himself
Yes, I would prefer to avoid picking your staking target.
So to those of you who think I'm Dr. West, care to explain why? Aldo's theory has been shot to hell and back, proving that he's lying out of his ass, or, at the very least, Quid could not have been the Necromancer.
Remember: Aldo called for the revenants to kill me. Although I'm not an as prime target for them as the REAL Dr. West would be, it's still in their interest to kill me, since by having 2 exhumations a day, you guys have a better shot at uncovering Revenants. With me dead, the zombies have upped their chances.
If I was really concerned with staying alive, why would I come out as the gravedigger's son rather than just try and pin some equally far fetched ideas about Aldo?
In fact, I think that it would be hilarious if Aldo himself turned out to be Dr. West, though I have no proof of that besides a sense of Irony.
Either way, Aldo is not on the village's side, or at the very least, he's been played for a total patsy, to which I should give kudos to Quid.