Our new Indie Games subforum is now open for business in G&T. Go and check it out, you might land a code for a free game. If you're developing an indie game and want to post about it, follow these directions. If you don't, he'll break your legs! Hahaha! Seriously though.
Our rules have been updated and given their own forum. Go and look at them! They are nice, and there may be new ones that you didn't know about! Hooray for rules! Hooray for The System! Hooray for Conforming!

Capsule One: March 2009

sanstodosanstodo Registered User regular
Alright, I finally got some time and finished an edit of Capsule One. I think it will give you more context for Capsule Two (sorry for the weird order, Capsule Two was giving me headaches).

I hope you enjoy it!
Spoiler:

sanstodo on
The headquarters for my writing:
hummusandkimchi.blogspot.com

http://us.battle.net/d3/en/profile/FriedRice-1814/hero/11834264

Posts

  • MuncieMuncie Registered User
    The first three sentences do absolutely nothing for me.

    The sentence that kept me reading was: He wonders when she is going to leave him.

    The biggest problem is you're starting a story with a person waking up and doing a morning routine, and not a particularly interesting one. When you start a story with a character waking up they don't exist anywhere outside of where your story starts. It immediately cripples your ability to make the character seem alive and real.

    Here is one of my favorite openings:
    Many years later, as he faced the firing squad, Colonel Aureliano Buendia was to remember that distant afternoon when his father took him to discover ice.

    Why does this sentence work so well?

    1. It establishes that there is already a history and now you're in the middle of it. There was all this stuff going on before the story started.
    2. It establishes a character, we know something about him, he is a Colonel, he is facing death, and it is making him think of more idyllic times.
    3. It establishes conflict, right off the bat. We don't know much about the Colonel but now we have an emotional attachment to him, he is in peril, and we are worried for him.

    Dream sequences feel like a cheat. Later they can be used for thematic purposes but opening up with one is not going to make the reader more likely to trust you. The first thing you've done to them is present an illusion and then rip it away.

    I don't like extremely logical, lucid dream sequences. Dreams are nonsense (except in myth where they can play other roles, like foreshadowing or cementing themes). When people wake up and then tell their bored-to-tears significant other about their dreams they are interpreting the nonsense into a narrative. Be careful with dreams in fiction. In this place I don't feel it adds anything to the story. Perhaps with the complete story it would. That's up to you. Hang a note on it though: "What does this achieve? Is it believable or is is a trope?"

    The mundanity of "getting ready for work" sequences eventually caused you to fall into "he did this, he did that, he jerked off in the shower" kind of stage direction. None of this shit is important, and secondly, I am sick as hell of reading about dudes jerking off in the shower. American Beauty already put the point on that particular bit of symbolism. Write it at the top of a piece of paper: "WHY DID MAN CHARACTER JERK OFF IN THE SHOWER?" and see what kind of answers you come up with. Why is it essential to your story?

    This goes for all of it. Why is not wiping the fog from the mirror significant?

    I see that you are trying to show your character as some kind of ultra-loser. Fine, but there are more finesse ways to go about it.

    Ultimately though, this isn't a story. You're writing is fine when you're not dicking around with insignificant things for half a paragraph but I have no idea how good of a storyteller you are. Write the story then worry about it 400 words at a time.

    Competent writers can be shitty storytellers. Don't assume if you have the first part the second just comes naturally.

  • RazielRaziel Registered User
    Muncie's on point here. 500 words describing waking up - something that everyone does on a daily basis - isn't cutting it for me. More tension, please.

    Read the mad blog-rantings of a manic hack writer here.

    Thank you, Rubacava!
  • sanstodosanstodo Registered User regular
    Btw, that is one of my favorite opening lines as well. I read started reading "One Hundred Years of Solitude" after I dropped off my friends for a seven hour long pre-marriage Catholic couples counseling session and had to wait for them to finish. I didn't stop reading until they were banging on the driver's side window.

    I will never be that good a writer :) Then again, I don't feel bad because pretty much no one is (with a few exceptions).

    Your criticism is well-taken and I will revise. A few thoughts, though:

    Re not wiping the fog off the mirror: He's shaving. Have you ever tried to shave with a fogged mirror, especially when you're new at it? It's a terrible idea. This is part of the characterization, perhaps sloppily done, of his laziness and assocation/disassociation with his body (cognizant of its faults and how it used to be, ignorant of how it feels and how to maintain it). Regardless, I'll go through each action and consider its necessity.

    I'm finding that it's difficult to explain the idea of Capsules (or the flow of it) by posting the capsules separately. It's probably not the right format for these boards (as I am discovering from the comments on each one) since the narrative isn't really found in any of the capsules themselves but in the sum total of the moments they describe, like the way our memories and dreams are relatively incoherent as parts but can be coherent when pasted all together. There are references in here to later capsules (ones that occur chronologically before and after this one) that are only noticeable upon deep reading or re-reading.

    I can't expect that kind of commitment from people on a forum board. I'll try posting a more "traditional" form of fiction once I can figure out how to smoothly integrate footnotes into a post......

    The headquarters for my writing:
    hummusandkimchi.blogspot.com

    http://us.battle.net/d3/en/profile/FriedRice-1814/hero/11834264
Sign In or Register to comment.