Our new Indie Games subforum is now open for business in G&T. Go and check it out, you might land a code for a free game. If you're developing an indie game and want to post about it,
follow these directions. If you don't, he'll break your legs! Hahaha! Seriously though.
Our rules have been updated and given
their own forum. Go and look at them! They are nice, and there may be new ones that you didn't know about! Hooray for rules! Hooray for The System! Hooray for Conforming!
[Phalla] Game Over! Way to go killer p.50 The Unfortunate Voyage of the Harbinger
Posts
So I would assume that at least 1 in 5 are mafia. Or 10 for this game.
corvidae supports Langly's post and says he is "trustworthy" but corv was mafia, so Langly is probably mafia. But based on this logic, it was a setup and Langly is not mafia.
Oh Phalla.
I have to admit that I am suspicious of Egos based on his quoted day 1 post. You can say it is circumstantial possibly, and that may be true. My gut tells me things. It told me:
AkimboLegs
Egos
Alegis
godmode (because he is the last remaining Marine, and I just assumed 1/4 was evil to be safe; this is based solely on Maths I made up)
McKinney eyed Gordon warily as he chomped on the nasty bit of MRE he'd scrounged up, "I don't like losing troops, especially not that way. You were with him, but lived? Why didn't you chase that fool and put him down."
lol you jerk you actually made me go check >_>
I figured somebody would look askance at me ever since SeGa turned out to be village. It's true, I was one of the early votes on him day 2. I want to point out, though, that at the time there were still a bunch of people log-jammed at about 2-4 votes each. I didn't particularly like any of those votes at the time, and then SeGa made his post which I and several other people thought was odd. It wasn't much to go on, but it seemed like more than there was for anybody else. It did make me a little uncomfortable how fast the wagon for SeGa picked up. But it wasn't like there was some other definite wagon going at the time that I countered by voting for SeGa; it ended up being SeGa versus Anialos at the end of that day, but Anialos only had a couple votes at the time - his wagon didn't pick up momentum really until later on, when Infidel settled on him (after voting for SeGa himself and then changing his mind).
As for seeming odd...well, there's not a whole lot one can say in response to that.
Maximus: He was inactive all game, so we can't exactly examine his behaviour to establish any sort of pattern or possible given orders, but we can take a look at who was talking about him. For example, when Assuran chose him as a target on Day 1, what was the reaction? When he died and was revealed as mafia that night, what were people saying?
Day 1: Assuran calls his kill on Maximus [10:04 PM]. Egos comments on Assuran's kill and suggests he change it, because Maximus will likely die to inactivity anyway [10:24 PM]. Egos clarifies [10:43 PM].
Day 2: We've already been over this, but Skull Man then had an interesting reaction to Maximus's death. He begins by suggesting it wasn't a kill and was just an inactivity death, despite very clear narrative indication of the contrary: [1:34 AM] [1:57 AM] [11:33 AM] [12:14 PM] [12:19 PM] [12:52 PM] [12:58 PM] etc.
Aaand, that's pretty much it. Nothing very telling, but there it is. NEXT!
corvidae: He has more to go on than Maximus, but he was not especially active. Let's review his posts.
Day 1: He votes for Egos at [8:00 AM]. Malkor responds by at [8:22 AM] by voting for corvidae. Egos questions corvidae about his vote, and he claims a grudge at [7:38 PM].
Day 2: At [2:36 PM], he votes for citizen. Amid SeGaTai nonsense, posts RP at [7:30 PM] Post at [7:58 PM]. At [9:18 PM], says he'll follow Langly and hops on Seg wagon.
Day 3: At [4:27 AM] complains about 4 post minimum, but says he'll post with no BS. Stresses that narration is fluff, "Munkus even said so." Placeholder on Mojo. Says he's drunk at [4:31 AM] and votes Shabooty. Changes at [4:43 AM] to Anialos. Comes back at [2:57 PM] with some RP and points to my analysis post. At [3:13 PM] remarks that Infidel is rambling. Infidel was attacking Langly and supporters. At [4:48 PM] comments about guard fluff. Junk post at [7:56 PM] Edited post at [8:50 PM] that was supposed to be a PM. At [8:52 PM], Egos quotes what corvidae originally wrote: are/were you and egos talking? He says, "no." Edit timestamp on corv's post matches the timestamp on Egos' reply. Could be a legitimate response by Egos. [10:17 PM] makes a junk post. Then he dies that night to the SK.
So, a bit more to go on. I think his little PM/post slip-up could yield fruit. It's interesting that no one really called attention to it, but it's very possible that is how the SK found his target, quietly. Who was he sending the PM to? Who was he networking with in PMs? If it was another mafia, why not just use the proboards? I'm also a bit suspicious of his "drunk" votes early in the morning. I'm not saying he wasn't actually drunk, but I am saying it's odd one of those votes was for his fellow mafioso. Were the others as well? Would that be too easy?
Edit: And note there was a link between corvidae and Egos on two occasions: one a slip up.
I'd do the same summary for Anialos, but he has many, many more posts. I might later. We'll see.
as to the stuff about me, I don't have anything to add to what I said before. I was reading too deep into the narrative
Egos
I like this reasoning. Shabooty. Egos sounds good too though. I support the gift of vacuum for both of them.
So the situation could be that corv was soft networking with someone, and was trying to figure out who egos had been talking to, for whatever reason. He could, yes, have been trying to soft network and act like he wasn't in contact with egos, even though they were mafia buddies.
He could have actually been meaning to post to the proboard and accidentally posted it here, which would be hilarious.
Anyway, the day one post he made is odd, but I'm not sure it's enough to hang him. Especially when we know that there are mafia on the late sega wagon. There's at least one more on it, I'm sure.
follow Infidel even if he jumps off a cliff
the only way I would have it
my return is complete
Day 1: Asks why corvidae votes him at [1:24 PM]. Posts at [1:55 PM]. Votes [4:33 PM] and says "baddies rarely vote each other on day 1. At [5:00 PM], defends his reasoning of corv vote based on previous phalla. Provides links at [5:06 PM]. Reiterates at [5:10 PM]. Seems to be working hard to provide a concrete reason for that vote. Post at [5:12 PM]. [8:22 PM] replies to corv's clarification of vote against him. More defense. Youtube vid at [8:30 PM]. Post at [9:51 PM]. Youtube vid at [9:54 PM]. Votes Nirya at [10:21 PM]. [10:24 PM] posts about Assuran's kill target. [10:43 PM] posts clarification.
Day 2: [12:09 AM] junk post. [12:17 PM] post Youtube vid. [1:42 AM] discusses narration with Skull Man--what Maximus's death was attributed to. Does not mislead. [3:16 AM] posts Youtube vid. At [6:03 PM] replies to Bedlam who suspects him: I would be smarter than that. [6:21 PM] responds again about it, also says Skull Man is probably not mafia, because his network would have "stopped him" from posting as he did. [6:25 PM] agrees Personface vote is dumb. At [6:26 PM] replies to Gaslight's question about his Skull Man defense. Says again he thinks Skull Man is not mafia. At [6:59 PM], agrees with Alegis that Anialos is suspicious... but doesn't vote. Junk post at [7:02 PM]. Lengthy post at [7:20 PM] about SNT, votes Anialos, and says he could be swayed to vote SNT. Was only the 2nd vote on Anialos, late day, and with a wagon already elsewhere. Also seems like too much justification so late in the game for a vote that will clearly go nowhere anyway. [7:55 PM] responds to Gaslight about the Anialos vote. Responds to corvidae about Gaslight confusing Assuran/Alegis at [8:01 PM]. Disagrees with SeGaTai bandwagon at [8:08 PM]. [9:47 PM] post.
Day 3: Youtube vid at [2:44 AM]. [2:44] again, responds to Alegis's post about Egos's suspicious posts being a "recurring silly joke." [2:46] post. Votes for Anialos at [2:57 PM]. I think the 4th vote for Anialos that day, but remember corvidae voted for him earlier. [3:23 PM] about SeG wagon. [3:36 PM] Youtube vid. [3:44 PM] comments about previous phalla SK. Speculation about mafia unblockable kill at [4:57 PM]. Post at [5:04 PM]. [8:03 PM] posts about Ketbra's "busy" post. [8:52 PM] responds to corvidae's edited mistake PM. [10:09 PM] posts joke forum.
Day 4: [11:29 PM] posts Youtube vid. [12:03 AM] joke post. [1:47 AM] Youtube vid.
Now, the excessive Youtube video posting. Is this normal for him? This phalla will soon have a 4 post minimum, and it makes sense to establish a reason to post often... like being the one who posts random videos all game. What about times when he was especially active and then times when known mafia were as well? Do they match up?
Figgy I liked you in the steam thread and now I like you even more in the phalla thread
Magic box, I love you so much. Seriously Phyphor, this thing is amazing and it allowed me to read just Infidel's posts which gave me these two:
These are the only two conclusions I could find regarding what it would mean if Anialos was mafia.
So daniant for now.
The PhalLounge :: Chat board for Phalla discussion and Secret Santas :: PhallAX 2013
Critical Failures IRC! :: #CriticalFailures and #mafia on irc.slashnet.org
Infidel's suspicions came from day one's throwaway vote onto Anialos. That's what led him to Anialos and Daniant on day one/two and resulted in us hitting mafia. His conclusion was that if Anialos was mafia, then we need to look at daniant for trying to create a good voting record starting on day one.
correct me if I am wrong here infidel
His total of 7 posts isn't really helping him, either. Most of those are garbage, and his first vote was "Oh I forgot this was going on!"
Daniant is a lady.
Edit: Beaten.
All ladies.
Ladies :winky:
if nothing else, you mentioning it is likely to get some previously quiet mafiosos tripping over themselves to post to dissuade guild
which should be pretty obvious!
Incident Report #A546FB98
Date: Day 4 since the terrorist attack
Time:
Offending Citizens: All the men
Incident Type: S69
Description of Incident:
Sexual misconduct. Its been three days without sex and alot of the men are getting restless. They keep pointing out that certain people alive are, in fact, women.
Filed by:
Clark Wayne
Officer 542020
These crack me up
Anyways, Shabooty's vote here broke the tie on Anialos and Segatai.
Shady posts during the critical moments and the target I feel strongest about.
!Shabooty
The PhalLounge :: Chat board for Phalla discussion and Secret Santas :: PhallAX 2013
Critical Failures IRC! :: #CriticalFailures and #mafia on irc.slashnet.org
The lead on Anialos was posted by Egos and I pretty much endorsed it. I found and pointed out the day 1 connection which would implicate daniant if Anialos turned up mafia.
The PhalLounge :: Chat board for Phalla discussion and Secret Santas :: PhallAX 2013
Critical Failures IRC! :: #CriticalFailures and #mafia on irc.slashnet.org
hmm Vell you could bring them by thee medbay for some fun..Owever They vould ave to submit to the truth before hand.
da-ni-ant
Coincidence? :lol:
The PhalLounge :: Chat board for Phalla discussion and Secret Santas :: PhallAX 2013
Critical Failures IRC! :: #CriticalFailures and #mafia on irc.slashnet.org
(Dammit.)
The PhalLounge :: Chat board for Phalla discussion and Secret Santas :: PhallAX 2013
Critical Failures IRC! :: #CriticalFailures and #mafia on irc.slashnet.org
Perhaps.
Alright, don't buy into the idea of Shabooty being a mistaken Corv drunkvote or whatever, but he gets my vote for the general lack of activity, voting late on the SeGa wagon on day 2 (and putting responsibility for it on somebody else), and voting late on the Anialos wagon when it was long since a foregone conclusion on day 3.
I am also pretty certain we have at least a couple of mafia and likely the SK too among the other people who have largely been keeping their heads down all game.