|
 11-07-2009, 10:41 PM
 |
Artreus wrote:

Rent wrote:

|
I'm kind of split on this one
On one hand this is really cool
On the other it's basically a subforum injoke that makes no goddamn sense and is unfunny to people outside of the subforum
Now, a lot of posters here give D and D reported posts shit for basically being glorified injokes, and that's totally fair; it's warranted as a matter of fact. I'll be the first to vote down a D and D reported post for being an injoke because, even though I post there, I expect that standard to be held; awesome posts must be awesome regardless of context unless the context is easily explained (like, two sentences explained)
Now if we hold D and D to that standard, which I utterly agree with, we must hold all subfora to this standard.
Therefore, I am giving this post a one star, not because it isn't awesome, because it is, but because of a combination of lack of context, subforum in-joke that isn't funny regardless of context to out-of-subforumers, lack of context in the OP, and context not easily explainable (as SabreMau brought everyone up to speed, that was a good paragraph or two of context)
No offense meant guys
|
I never, ever would have guessed you are from D&D.
|
This post is as funny, or funnier than the reported awesome post.
Although, I say that from the perspective of someone not "in". |
|
|
Last edited by Luthz; 11-07-2009 at 10:42 PM.
Reason
| #27
|
|
|