Logo
Home Register Members User Control Panel Search Frequently Asked Questions
Penny Arcade Forums > On-Topic Forums > Games and Technology » Dragon Age: Origins: [Please post in new thread]
Reply
 
Thread Tools
 
Catastrophe_XXVI's Avatar
 
Location: Send lawyers, guns and money.

Catastrophe_XXVI is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 11:41 AM
Robman wrote: View Post
Mike99TA wrote: View Post
surrealitycheck wrote: View Post
quote:
Because you're still thinking of items in terms of "end-game". This isn't WoW, this isn't Diablo, stop trying to think the game revolves around items. When factoring in skills and attributes, the best items in the game aren't even that much better than middle level items. You could go into the final battle as a dual wielding rogue or warrior with 2 grey iron daggers and still be pretty effective. It's not like a white level 1 dagger in WoW compared to Tier 2738423894 dagger of explosive dragon combustion.
You're not thinking of the purpose of loot properly.

One of the primary jobs of loot in a game like this is as reward/motivation. The monsters scale with your level, so the stat gains from levelling up are accounted for. The only thing that changes your relative power is gear. The problem with giving people the best loot with 90% of the game left to go is that it can make a lot of quests seem unrewarded and fairly dull. When you go to the Brecilian forest, you are meant to be excited by the offer of an ironbark breastplate or bow - this is meant to be a carrot. If you know you have better, it utterly fails at this task.
Why do you assume I'm not thinking of loot properly? I think it's you who isn't thinking of loot properly. Maybe I'm just from an older generation but all the games I used to love playing, loot didn't matter nearly as much as people think it does now. I prefer games where the loot means less. I'd rather the reward just be a continuing storyline and interesting dialog.

Sort of like a good fantasy book - most of the time you read novels like DragonLance, etc, there is almost no mention of various magical weapons and armor. The heroes almost always are just in standard non-magical gear because they don't need to be in more than that. To me the gear is just an aside and I'm glad that it sort of feels that way in Dragon Age, because I hate the feeling of "if I can't find the right gear I can't be effective", which is why games like WoW suck so bad.
You know there's a point in-between your shitty fantasy books and WoW, where there's a compelling story and bosses drop interesting and unique loot. It's not like this game is balanced at all around some difficulty level, as seen by the drastic changes observed when you bring in more mages.

Yes, but you could have said it a little nicer... The reason they don't talk about every characters weapons etc is because it would be boring and usless information coupled with the fact that it's about them and not about you. I don't care what leather boots they have but I care about what leather boots I have.
  Reply With Quote | #1926
Mike99TA's Avatar
 
Location: Greenville, SC

Mike99TA is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 11:42 AM
Robman wrote: View Post
Mike99TA wrote: View Post
surrealitycheck wrote: View Post
quote:
Because you're still thinking of items in terms of "end-game". This isn't WoW, this isn't Diablo, stop trying to think the game revolves around items. When factoring in skills and attributes, the best items in the game aren't even that much better than middle level items. You could go into the final battle as a dual wielding rogue or warrior with 2 grey iron daggers and still be pretty effective. It's not like a white level 1 dagger in WoW compared to Tier 2738423894 dagger of explosive dragon combustion.
You're not thinking of the purpose of loot properly.

One of the primary jobs of loot in a game like this is as reward/motivation. The monsters scale with your level, so the stat gains from levelling up are accounted for. The only thing that changes your relative power is gear. The problem with giving people the best loot with 90% of the game left to go is that it can make a lot of quests seem unrewarded and fairly dull. When you go to the Brecilian forest, you are meant to be excited by the offer of an ironbark breastplate or bow - this is meant to be a carrot. If you know you have better, it utterly fails at this task.
Why do you assume I'm not thinking of loot properly? I think it's you who isn't thinking of loot properly. Maybe I'm just from an older generation but all the games I used to love playing, loot didn't matter nearly as much as people think it does now. I prefer games where the loot means less. I'd rather the reward just be a continuing storyline and interesting dialog.

Sort of like a good fantasy book - most of the time you read novels like DragonLance, etc, there is almost no mention of various magical weapons and armor. The heroes almost always are just in standard non-magical gear because they don't need to be in more than that. To me the gear is just an aside and I'm glad that it sort of feels that way in Dragon Age, because I hate the feeling of "if I can't find the right gear I can't be effective", which is why games like WoW suck so bad.
You know there's a point in-between your shitty fantasy books and WoW, where there's a compelling story and bosses drop interesting and unique loot. It's not like this game is balanced at all around some difficulty level, as seen by the drastic changes observed when you bring in more mages.
Shitty fantasy books? Books r 4 dum pplz. reeding iz 4 luzerz. videeoh gaymz r d important fakturz here.

Do people not play games for a story anymore? All you care about is loot and looking super uber epic in purplez at the end of the game? Ugh.
  Reply With Quote | #1927
ALWAYS ANGRY
Fiaryn's Avatar
 
Location: ALL THE TIME

Fiaryn is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 11:43 AM
I love Strawman arguments.

I put them all over my cereal in the morning I love it I love it

False dichotomies too. This just in: Story and varied loot compatible and non-mutually exclusive! Jesus this is like suggesting that complaining about the controls in a game means you don't care about graphics at all. Which is to say it's a retarded argument.
__________________
Corianan, Genasi Barbarian
Spoiler:

Last edited by Fiaryn; 11-20-2009 at 11:45 AM.
Reply With Quote | #1928
Rampant
durandal4532's Avatar
 
Location: The candles burn out for you; I am free.

durandal4532 is online now

Old 11-20-2009, 11:44 AM
Robman wrote: View Post
You know there's a point in-between your shitty fantasy books and WoW, where there's a compelling story and bosses drop interesting and unique loot. It's not like this game is balanced at all around some difficulty level, as seen by the drastic changes observed when you bring in more mages.
I suppose I would never turn down them putting in as much new art as they possibly can, including interesting loot. Particularly unique looking stuff would be fun, maybe give out one interesting looking item per unique enemy.

I just don't actually run into it making my experience less fun. I think the rune system makes up for that. For instance, my nice dagger that was cheap, deals a lot of damage, and has become magical because I can put 3 runes on it. Now it paralyzes frequently, and deals +10 elemental damage.

Now Dragon Age Journeys had loot that really did make me notice and become annoyed. I don't think I ever changed my gear after the first time I bought something.
__________________
Reply With Quote | #1929
Mike99TA's Avatar
 
Location: Greenville, SC

Mike99TA is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 11:46 AM
durandal4532 wrote: View Post
Robman wrote: View Post
You know there's a point in-between your shitty fantasy books and WoW, where there's a compelling story and bosses drop interesting and unique loot. It's not like this game is balanced at all around some difficulty level, as seen by the drastic changes observed when you bring in more mages.
I suppose I would never turn down them putting in as much new art as they possibly can, including interesting loot. Particularly unique looking stuff would be fun, maybe give out one interesting looking item per unique enemy.

I just don't actually run into it making my experience less fun. I think the rune system makes up for that. For instance, my nice dagger that was cheap, deals a lot of damage, and has become magical because I can put 3 runes on it. Now it paralyzes frequently, and deals +10 elemental damage.

Now Dragon Age Journeys had loot that really did make me notice and become annoyed. I don't think I ever changed my gear after the first time I bought something.
In regards to part of your statement (specifically the different 'looks'), that is mainly what I care about, and then mostly just during cutscenes where it is easily visible. I think there are quite a large number of different looks for armor in this game (not as many for weapons but the armor is more noticeable anyway). I also much prefer to stare at armor that looks like armor, not some swirling black vortex of doom from the abyss. I was actually quite blown away with the art direction of the armor and weapons in the game, hearing people bitch about it is just...odd.

To me, interesting and unique means names and looks, not magical abilities. I'd rather go from Heavy Plate Armor (Grey Iron) to Heavy Plate Armor (Veridium) if it looks cooler/different than go from heavy plate armor to Super adamantium armor of destruction that looks basically the same with just a tiny little tweak in looks.
 

Last edited by Mike99TA; 11-20-2009 at 11:51 AM.
Reply With Quote | #1930
Travis hello?
Rainfall's Avatar
 
Location: Garden of Madness

Rainfall is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 11:51 AM
But a lot of bosses do drop unique and interesting loot. Just not the main story bosses. You have to go out of your way to find equipment.

After all, Mage treaty spoilers
Spoiler:


Random high-end loot spoilers.
Spoiler:


There's other weapons that aren't in that list and are dropped from dudes in-game. Sure, it would be better if all the stuff that's 75+ gold dropped from bosses instead of being merchant crap, like the Rose's Thorn, Veshialle, Spellward, Knight-Commander's Armor, the spell-resist armor that Ruck has, etc... but Bioware wanted to take a different step with their loot in DA, making money something that's actually worthwhile (my Human Noble gave money away like water and didn't ask for rewards, and ended up with significantly less money than my Dalish Elf, who refused to help Shem for free. It made a difference when I was buying stuff for the endgame and allowed me to purchase a full extra level on my Elf via elfroots.)

Hopefully Bioware will realize that some of their bosses need to drop more compelling gear, but some of the best gear in the core game IS dropped from bosses. Oh, and there needs to be more belts and amulets.
__________________
Ask me about Space Dragons! | #criticalfailures on SlashNET
Jeanne D'Orien | Perra m'Donaar | Keylet
Reply With Quote | #1931
Team Old World
The_Scarab's Avatar
 
Location: UK

The_Scarab is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 11:54 AM
Bring Shale to Orzammar guys. You get a whole load of new conversations around the topic of 'what the fuck is that thing?'
  Reply With Quote | #1932
The Megapode!
chrono_traveller's Avatar
 
Location: Maryland

chrono_traveller is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 11:55 AM
Robman wrote: View Post
Mike99TA wrote: View Post
Sort of like a good fantasy book - most of the time you read novels like DragonLance, etc, there is almost no mention of various magical weapons and armor. The heroes almost always are just in standard non-magical gear because they don't need to be in more than that. To me the gear is just an aside and I'm glad that it sort of feels that way in Dragon Age, because I hate the feeling of "if I can't find the right gear I can't be effective", which is why games like WoW suck so bad.
You know there's a point in-between your shitty fantasy books and WoW, where there's a compelling story and bosses drop interesting and unique loot. It's not like this game is balanced at all around some difficulty level, as seen by the drastic changes observed when you bring in more mages.
I'm not going to argue that there isn't a middle ground, but I really like how DA did the loot. I think the fantasy book analogy works pretty well here. The progression of the character should be tied to the character (stats/abilities) more than to the loot they get. You don't see Frodo chucking Sting away when he finds a better sword in Smaug's loot. You don't see Arya chucking Needle after any number of battles she's in.

I'd rather see what happens in DA, where you get a good/notable weapon and it stays with you for a long time. I find this more appealing.
__________________
Terry Pratchett wrote:
The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it.
Neil Gaiman wrote:
George R. R. Martin is not your bitch.
Reply With Quote | #1933
ALWAYS ANGRY
Fiaryn's Avatar
 
Location: ALL THE TIME

Fiaryn is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 11:58 AM
By the way guys does anyone have a damn clue where the longbow Far Song is found? I've done just about everything but I've still yet to find it. The PRIMA guide indicates it's easily the best bow.

I'm beginning to suspect I gotta pickpocket somebody for it.
__________________
Corianan, Genasi Barbarian
Spoiler:
Reply With Quote | #1934
Slice Gods are watching
Decomposey's Avatar
 
Location: Slice Gods are mean

Decomposey is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 11:58 AM
Robman wrote: View Post
There's a big risk in taking on the big High Dragon

What is the reward? Some shitty armor? A sidegrade axe from something that dropped from a normal boss earlier? Yay!
I killed that dragon. I had no idea what it was going to drop. I would have been happy if whatever came out of the corpse would simply cover the cost of the potions I used up beating it. I didn't care that much what it dropped, I had my reward already. I killed a goddamn dragon! I was proud of my accomplishment, and that's all I needed.

I really don't understand why the lack of uber gear is that much of a problem for some of you. You don't need it to win, so it's not like it's crippling you. I mean, we aren't friggen mules here, we shouldn't NEED carrots to encourage us to keep going.

Hell, I'd happily trade every named and unique weapon in the game for a decent looking mage hat, and consider myself on the winning end of the bargain.
  Reply With Quote | #1935
The Megapode!
chrono_traveller's Avatar
 
Location: Maryland

chrono_traveller is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 11:58 AM
The_Scarab wrote: View Post
Bring Shale to Orzammar guys. You get a whole load of new conversations around the topic of 'what the fuck is that thing?'
Shale disapproves (-5)
__________________
Terry Pratchett wrote:
The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it.
Neil Gaiman wrote:
George R. R. Martin is not your bitch.
Reply With Quote | #1936
Travis hello?
Rainfall's Avatar
 
Location: Garden of Madness

Rainfall is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:00 PM
Also regarding loot: I don't want to have to strip my armor off every five hours to replace it with the new set I bought/found. I want to be able to get high-class armor that I can stay in. It feel satisfying to stick with the same stuff rather than having your character get larger shoulderpads after every treaty.

Not having a continuous progression of better and better loot allows for that, and I like it. I would also love more variation on the light/medium/heavy armor, like being able to pick up leather armor similar to Isabela's, so hopefully they'll put that into DLC rather than just more f*cking massive plate.

But I'm pretty happy with how loot worked out in DA. Every treaty provides a few useful items to use, but it doesn't overwhelm you or force you to keep upgrading each and every character, and by the end you have good armor and weapons for every party member(seriously, every party member should have unique items and top-tier armor. Accessories, well... your main party might have decent rings, and your main character will be badass.)
__________________
Ask me about Space Dragons! | #criticalfailures on SlashNET
Jeanne D'Orien | Perra m'Donaar | Keylet
Reply With Quote | #1937
 
Catastrophe_XXVI's Avatar
 
Location: Send lawyers, guns and money.

Catastrophe_XXVI is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:03 PM
chrono_traveller wrote: View Post
Robman wrote: View Post
Mike99TA wrote: View Post
Sort of like a good fantasy book - most of the time you read novels like DragonLance, etc, there is almost no mention of various magical weapons and armor. The heroes almost always are just in standard non-magical gear because they don't need to be in more than that. To me the gear is just an aside and I'm glad that it sort of feels that way in Dragon Age, because I hate the feeling of "if I can't find the right gear I can't be effective", which is why games like WoW suck so bad.
You know there's a point in-between your shitty fantasy books and WoW, where there's a compelling story and bosses drop interesting and unique loot. It's not like this game is balanced at all around some difficulty level, as seen by the drastic changes observed when you bring in more mages.
I'm not going to argue that there isn't a middle ground, but I really like how DA did the loot. I think the fantasy book analogy works pretty well here. The progression of the character should be tied to the character (stats/abilities) more than to the loot they get. You don't see Frodo chucking Sting away when he finds a better sword in Smaug's loot. You don't see Arya chucking Needle after any number of battles she's in.

I'd rather see what happens in DA, where you get a good/notable weapon and it stays with you for a long time. I find this more appealing.

It would be just like that if the staff you get for helping out one of the kings in orizmar was any good... It means a lot that he's giving this to you for helping him become king but since i had better from a merchant I pawned that shit.

Also, we're only bitching about the loot because it's one of the few things that is lacking. If this game didn't have everything else going for it this 8th thread or what ever number we're on wouldn't exist. We all love DA.
  Reply With Quote | #1938
Storyteller
Taramoor's Avatar
 

Taramoor is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:03 PM
Rainfall wrote: View Post
But a lot of bosses do drop unique and interesting loot. Just not the main story bosses. You have to go out of your way to find equipment.

After all, Mage treaty spoilers
Spoiler:


Random high-end loot spoilers.
Spoiler:


There's other weapons that aren't in that list and are dropped from dudes in-game. Sure, it would be better if all the stuff that's 75+ gold dropped from bosses instead of being merchant crap, like the Rose's Thorn, Veshialle, Spellward, Knight-Commander's Armor, the spell-resist armor that Ruck has, etc... but Bioware wanted to take a different step with their loot in DA, making money something that's actually worthwhile (my Human Noble gave money away like water and didn't ask for rewards, and ended up with significantly less money than my Dalish Elf, who refused to help Shem for free. It made a difference when I was buying stuff for the endgame and allowed me to purchase a full extra level on my Elf via elfroots.)

Hopefully Bioware will realize that some of their bosses need to drop more compelling gear, but some of the best gear in the core game IS dropped from bosses. Oh, and there needs to be more belts and amulets.
That makes sense to a point, spiders and golems and random creatures not having advanced metal plate, etc. But then why the hell are there Lyrium potions on every Deepstalker corpse from here to Orlais? Also, the locked chests should have fixed, decent loot rather than health poultices that can be manufactured en masse by anyone with an elfroot garden.

Other great items that drop from boss-like characters:

Forgemaster's Hammer and the Spear-Thrower bow both drop from the Forgemaster in the Dead Trenches. Those are freaking awesome. Corruption, one of the best helms for the end boss fight (+75 Spirit Resistance), is dropped by one of the Darkspawn Generals in the final battle. Aodh, a damn good Axe in my opinion, is dropped by the head thief in the back alleys of Denerim sidequest.
__________________
Xbox Gamertag: Bricobrosse
SSB:Brawl Code: 1032 0894 4020
Reply With Quote | #1939
Hot dog!
Rami's Avatar
 

Rami is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:05 PM
Someone tell me how to unlock the caged in stone secret in Orzimmar. All I can find is a pressure plate that doesn't seem to do anything.
__________________
Goomba wrote: View Post
You don't play with Rami so you don't really understand.

Like, making him feel a little bit better would literally be like making Hitler feel a lot better.
Reply With Quote | #1940
ALWAYS ANGRY
Fiaryn's Avatar
 
Location: ALL THE TIME

Fiaryn is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:06 PM
Rami wrote: View Post
Someone tell me how to unlock the caged in stone secret in Orzimmar. All I can find is a pressure plate that doesn't seem to do anything.
Spoiler:
__________________
Corianan, Genasi Barbarian
Spoiler:
Reply With Quote | #1941
Storyteller
Taramoor's Avatar
 

Taramoor is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:07 PM
Fiaryn wrote: View Post
By the way guys does anyone have a damn clue where the longbow Far Song is found? I've done just about everything but I've still yet to find it. The PRIMA guide indicates it's easily the best bow.

I'm beginning to suspect I gotta pickpocket somebody for it.
Redcliffe spoilers

Spoiler:


Yeah.
__________________
Xbox Gamertag: Bricobrosse
SSB:Brawl Code: 1032 0894 4020
Reply With Quote | #1942
ALWAYS ANGRY
Fiaryn's Avatar
 
Location: ALL THE TIME

Fiaryn is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:08 PM
Taramoor wrote: View Post
Fiaryn wrote: View Post
By the way guys does anyone have a damn clue where the longbow Far Song is found? I've done just about everything but I've still yet to find it. The PRIMA guide indicates it's easily the best bow.

I'm beginning to suspect I gotta pickpocket somebody for it.
Redcliffe spoilers

Spoiler:


Yeah.
Goddamn it :<
__________________
Corianan, Genasi Barbarian
Spoiler:
Reply With Quote | #1943
Team Old World
The_Scarab's Avatar
 
Location: UK

The_Scarab is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:10 PM
Fiaryn wrote: View Post
Rami wrote: View Post
Someone tell me how to unlock the caged in stone secret in Orzimmar. All I can find is a pressure plate that doesn't seem to do anything.
Spoiler:
Also, bring some potions. Shit happens.
  Reply With Quote | #1944
 
korodullin's Avatar
 
Location: SC

korodullin is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:12 PM
Fiaryn wrote: View Post
Taramoor wrote: View Post
Fiaryn wrote: View Post
By the way guys does anyone have a damn clue where the longbow Far Song is found? I've done just about everything but I've still yet to find it. The PRIMA guide indicates it's easily the best bow.

I'm beginning to suspect I gotta pickpocket somebody for it.
Redcliffe spoilers

Spoiler:


Yeah.
Goddamn it :<
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/GuideDangIt
__________________
Reply With Quote | #1945
Travis hello?
Rainfall's Avatar
 
Location: Garden of Madness

Rainfall is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:14 PM
Taramoor wrote: View Post
Fiaryn wrote: View Post
By the way guys does anyone have a damn clue where the longbow Far Song is found? I've done just about everything but I've still yet to find it. The PRIMA guide indicates it's easily the best bow.

I'm beginning to suspect I gotta pickpocket somebody for it.
Redcliffe spoilers

Spoiler:


Yeah.
Oh snap.
Spoiler:


My only problem with locked chests, as Taramoor pointed out, was that they fed off of random drop tables. They should at the very least have gold in them rather than elfroot.

And wild animals should have crafting materials, not potions or poultices. It gives you much more reason to head off on long trips with flasks and distillation agents to make potions out of the things you find. Like if Deep Stalkers had lyrium dust on their corpses, that would make sense because they live underground with lyrium.

etc.

But locked chests and chests in general really need to have their loot tables fixed, crates/barrels need to not exist because fuck checking them, and then I'd be pretty much 100% satisfied with DA's loot.

Although there's still some locked chests with cool things in them!
__________________
Ask me about Space Dragons! | #criticalfailures on SlashNET
Jeanne D'Orien | Perra m'Donaar | Keylet
Reply With Quote | #1946
 
Pellaeon's Avatar
 

Pellaeon is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:15 PM
Taramoor wrote: View Post
Rainfall wrote: View Post
But a lot of bosses do drop unique and interesting loot. Just not the main story bosses. You have to go out of your way to find equipment.

After all, Mage treaty spoilers
Spoiler:


Random high-end loot spoilers.
Spoiler:


There's other weapons that aren't in that list and are dropped from dudes in-game. Sure, it would be better if all the stuff that's 75+ gold dropped from bosses instead of being merchant crap, like the Rose's Thorn, Veshialle, Spellward, Knight-Commander's Armor, the spell-resist armor that Ruck has, etc... but Bioware wanted to take a different step with their loot in DA, making money something that's actually worthwhile (my Human Noble gave money away like water and didn't ask for rewards, and ended up with significantly less money than my Dalish Elf, who refused to help Shem for free. It made a difference when I was buying stuff for the endgame and allowed me to purchase a full extra level on my Elf via elfroots.)

Hopefully Bioware will realize that some of their bosses need to drop more compelling gear, but some of the best gear in the core game IS dropped from bosses. Oh, and there needs to be more belts and amulets.
That makes sense to a point, spiders and golems and random creatures not having advanced metal plate, etc. But then why the hell are there Lyrium potions on every Deepstalker corpse from here to Orlais? Also, the locked chests should have fixed, decent loot rather than health poultices that can be manufactured en masse by anyone with an elfroot garden.

Other great items that drop from boss-like characters:

Forgemaster's Hammer and the Spear-Thrower bow both drop from the Forgemaster in the Dead Trenches. Those are freaking awesome. Corruption, one of the best helms for the end boss fight (+75 Spirit Resistance), is dropped by one of the Darkspawn Generals in the final battle. Aodh, a damn good Axe in my opinion, is dropped by the head thief in the back alleys of Denerim sidequest.
I liked finding things like silver vases, silk carpets and other such flavor loot in chests, except of course the part where it took up inventory space. Some small amount of cash would have been nice as well. Not sure why they locked up the mushrooms though.
  Reply With Quote | #1947
Begin
Fatal3RR0R's Avatar
 
Location: the operation!

Fatal3RR0R is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:16 PM
korodullin wrote: View Post
Fiaryn wrote: View Post
Taramoor wrote: View Post
Fiaryn wrote: View Post
By the way guys does anyone have a damn clue where the longbow Far Song is found? I've done just about everything but I've still yet to find it. The PRIMA guide indicates it's easily the best bow.

I'm beginning to suspect I gotta pickpocket somebody for it.
Redcliffe spoilers

Spoiler:


Yeah.
Goddamn it :<
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/GuideDangIt
There goes the rest of my free time between classes.
__________________
Reply With Quote | #1948
The Megapode!
chrono_traveller's Avatar
 
Location: Maryland

chrono_traveller is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:16 PM
Catastrophe_XXVI wrote: View Post
chrono_traveller wrote: View Post
Robman wrote: View Post
Mike99TA wrote: View Post
Sort of like a good fantasy book - most of the time you read novels like DragonLance, etc, there is almost no mention of various magical weapons and armor. The heroes almost always are just in standard non-magical gear because they don't need to be in more than that. To me the gear is just an aside and I'm glad that it sort of feels that way in Dragon Age, because I hate the feeling of "if I can't find the right gear I can't be effective", which is why games like WoW suck so bad.
You know there's a point in-between your shitty fantasy books and WoW, where there's a compelling story and bosses drop interesting and unique loot. It's not like this game is balanced at all around some difficulty level, as seen by the drastic changes observed when you bring in more mages.
I'm not going to argue that there isn't a middle ground, but I really like how DA did the loot. I think the fantasy book analogy works pretty well here. The progression of the character should be tied to the character (stats/abilities) more than to the loot they get. You don't see Frodo chucking Sting away when he finds a better sword in Smaug's loot. You don't see Arya chucking Needle after any number of battles she's in.

I'd rather see what happens in DA, where you get a good/notable weapon and it stays with you for a long time. I find this more appealing.

It would be just like that if the staff you get for helping out one of the kings in orizmar was any good... It means a lot that he's giving this to you for helping him become king but since i had better from a merchant I pawned that shit.

Also, we're only bitching about the loot because it's one of the few things that is lacking. If this game didn't have everything else going for it this 8th thread or what ever number we're on wouldn't exist. We all love DA.
It must not have meant much to you if you just vendored it. And did you really expect to get a powerful mage staff from a dwarf?

Look, I'm not arguing that my way of thinking is right and yours is wrong. But merely voicing my opinion that not every quest needs to have an upgrade just because you did it after another. I find it lends a bit more realism to the world that you don't have the linear loot progression that, say a Final Fantasy game has.

Is it a perfect system? Of course not. But do I want some (slight spoiler) Spoiler:
to have some random well crafted sword for no particular reason? No. Which is what I believe some are arguing.
__________________
Terry Pratchett wrote:
The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it.
Neil Gaiman wrote:
George R. R. Martin is not your bitch.
Reply With Quote | #1949
Storyteller
Taramoor's Avatar
 

Taramoor is offline

Old 11-20-2009, 12:18 PM
korodullin wrote: View Post
Fiaryn wrote: View Post
Taramoor wrote: View Post
Fiaryn wrote: View Post
By the way guys does anyone have a damn clue where the longbow Far Song is found? I've done just about everything but I've still yet to find it. The PRIMA guide indicates it's easily the best bow.

I'm beginning to suspect I gotta pickpocket somebody for it.
Redcliffe spoilers

Spoiler:


Yeah.
Goddamn it :<
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/GuideDangIt
Mage's Eye (chest in Haven), Falon'din's Reach (from a chest in the Brecilian Fortress), and Spear Thrower (from the dead trenches Forgemaster), and WolfKiller (Ironbark quest reward) are damn good f*cking bows. I only got Far Song because I wasn't paying attention going through Redcliffe. It happens. Same reason I missed Bow of the Golden Sun was because it just didn't work out.
__________________
Xbox Gamertag: Bricobrosse
SSB:Brawl Code: 1032 0894 4020
Reply With Quote | #1950
Reply

Penny Arcade Forums > On-Topic Forums > Games and Technology » Dragon Age: Origins: [Please post in new thread]

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 09:48 AM.



Powered by vBulletin® | Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.