Location: It's a Class 5 Whitebeard! Hold on to something!
|
 09-20-2008, 07:39 PM
 |
Frosteey wrote:

redx wrote:

Frosteey wrote:

redx wrote:

|
Garbage might be a little strong, but there isn't any aspect of it that couldn't be improved.
aside from the costumes.
|
It could be Card Captor Sakura. And everything would be fixed.
I'd be curious to know your reasoning for labeling it terrible.
|
Me? I haven't technically watched cardcaptors. I might have seen one episode of it.
CCS's art and animiation aren't really all that hot. The fights are fairly uninspired and repetive. The cut a lot of corners like mixing in stock animation with the costume of the week. Even in CCS, that's not something they added to gain time in Cardcaptors or anything. Pretty sure they frequently re-used animation from the episode before.
uhh... I don't remember being horribly impressed by the music. The characters and plot are like clamp trying to do a children's magic girl manga, for crying out loud. Right down to major villains being close friends and all that. A lot of the inter-character stuff is fairly odd, and not all that much is particularly compelling. Tomoyo? wtf?
It could be better, in a lot of ways. I didn't label it terrible, but there isn't really anything about it that is outstanding. No real reason for someone to push themselves to watch it, if they have something against the target demographic or genre.
|
Aside from disagreeing with your points, I guess it's mostly a matter of your three categories for quality boiling down to 'Terrible', 'Not terrible, but...', and 'Pinnacle of animation'.
I imagine your breakdown of something like Azumanga Daioh would be...
"Its art and animiation aren't really all that hot. The fights are fairly uninspired and repetive.
uhh... I don't remember being horribly impressed by the music. A lot of the inter-character stuff is fairly odd, and not all that much is particularly compelling. Kaorin? wtf?
It could be better, in a lot of ways. I didn't label it terrible, but there isn't really anything about it that is outstanding. No real reason for someone to push themselves to watch it, if they have something against the target demographic or genre."
---
The outstanding part is its being cute and innocent and adorable. The main characters do that on their own, but it really comes through in the relationships (aside from the jackass Yukito).
|
No seriously, what are you doing here Frosteey.
There is nothing redeemable about Card Captors, and right now I am very tempted to say that you have bad taste but I won't commit yet because I think this is all just a clever ruse on your part. |
__________________
|
| #2277
|
|
|