The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
How much money would it cost to build a PC that could run WoW at 60 FPS with everything on high, max shadow quality, 4x multisampling, etc. at a 1680x1050 resolution? This is assuming that you already have a monitor/speakers/whatever else.
I'm mostly just asking out of curiosity. A friend brought it up and I really don't know anything about computers beyond browsing the internet. I don't have anywhere near the spare cash for this sort of thing, but I feel like I need to know now.
It depends, your biggest sinks are going to be CPU and GPU. Wow is notoriously CPU intensive to the point where a CPU at 2.0GHz quad core is less desirable than a 3.33 GHz dual core.
A good CPU and a good GPU can run up to about $700. $1200 isn't a bad price range, including needing a monitor that goes up that high.
bowen on
not a doctor, not a lawyer, examples I use may not be fully researched so don't take out of context plz, don't @ me
My Core2Duo 3.33 Ghz CPU, 4GB ram, and Nvidia GTX 260 run WoW at 1920x1280 @ 60fps easily.
It's 18 months old, so should be able to find all that stuff cheap.
I'm guessing you don't even need a computer anywhere near that good to pull ~60, especially at the lower resolution he's talking about. WoW is a pretty easy program to run.
The multisamping is what usually kills it. The core2duo @ 3.33 is pretty much the recommended one for wow. For a good multisample and high framerate, you're looking at a $300 video card.
It also seems a lot of parts sellers have picked up on wow and the 3.33GHz duos as they're usually the most expensive ones.
bowen on
not a doctor, not a lawyer, examples I use may not be fully researched so don't take out of context plz, don't @ me
The multisamping is what usually kills it. The core2duo @ 3.33 is pretty much the recommended one for wow. For a good multisample and high framerate, you're looking at a $300 video card.
It also seems a lot of parts sellers have picked up on wow and the 3.33GHz duos as they're usually the most expensive ones.
Really easy to overclock a slower Core2Duo to push beyond 3.33 though. Although the cost of getting a cpu cooler upgrade might not justify just getting the 3.33 in the first place.
Does it really matter that much? Even with a maxed out, top of the line PC, you are going to get server lag that will kill your FPS.
Server lag doesn't equate directly to Frames per Second, although the net effect (the game not responding or acting "jumpy") might appear to be the same. However, FPS is locally limited (and could be caused by being CPU-, I/O-, or GPU-bound processes, or some combination). Server lag is performance problems anywhere from the back of your computer all the way up to, and including, the server the game's running on. The cause, cost, and ability to mitigate FPS and lag problems differ rather significantly.
However, you are correct in that there is a point of diminishing returns that is usually reached well before you get into the $Texas top-of-the line gaming computers, and that many MMOs do no benefit from expensive hardware (not having software written to take full advantage of it). Overspending in one area will not overcome bottlenecks in other areas. You want a balanced approach to your computer build.
However, the Computer Build Thread, although it's long, does have a good OP that is relatively up to date, and the thread is chock-full of bleeding edge vs. bang-for-the-buck discussions. We're really just covering an already well-tread path here in H/A. Let the gearheads in Moe's help you.
darkgrue on
0
Madpandasuburbs west of chicagoRegistered Userregular
edited March 2010
Can people actually run WoW at 60fps with Shadows on anything but low?
I am running a q6600@3.0ghz with a GTX 280 and turning shadows up just kills it.
Yeah, I have a computer that is quite a bit less powerful than that which handles shadows fine.
Core 2 Duo E6750 (overclocked to 2.93GHz from 2.66GHz)
8800GT, 512MB VRAM
4GB RAM
Windows 7 x64
2048x1152 resolution
All settings at ultra, with multisampling turned down to 2x due to massive resolution. 60 FPS in non-taxing environments, 20 FPS in more taxing environments (Dalaran, for example).
The hardware is almost 3 years old, and was purchased for $1100. You could probably do much better at less than half the cost now.
It depends, your biggest sinks are going to be CPU and GPU. Wow is notoriously CPU intensive to the point where a CPU at 2.0GHz quad core is less desirable than a 3.33 GHz dual core.
A good CPU and a good GPU can run up to about $700. $1200 isn't a bad price range, including needing a monitor that goes up that high.
To play WoW? Yes it is. OP shouldn't spend more than 300 and it'll run it flawlessly.
Honestly if you're a professional WoW player the best bang for your buck is just going to be buying an expensive internet connection with a big fat pipe so you get 0 lag, and then maybe SSD drives for fast loading of zones.
Eveything else, you can just go cheap on and it'll run it flawlessly.
It depends, your biggest sinks are going to be CPU and GPU. Wow is notoriously CPU intensive to the point where a CPU at 2.0GHz quad core is less desirable than a 3.33 GHz dual core.
A good CPU and a good GPU can run up to about $700. $1200 isn't a bad price range, including needing a monitor that goes up that high.
To play WoW? Yes it is. OP shouldn't spend more than 300 and it'll run it flawlessly.
Yeah because a core2duo and a mobo itself didn't just eat up that $300.
Oh wait, you're talking about a fucking celeron chip from best buy preloaded with shitware. Sorry. The minute you start going for those lower chips, you'll notice a huge decrease in performance in wow.
It'll still run, but not at that resolution, with that frame-rate, with everything cranked up. Now if you do pay $300 for a pc, you'll likely get great frame-rates in dalaran, but anywhere else you'll be pissed you didn't spend the extra money.
Comparing computers is like comparing restaurants. Generally you don't compare McDonalds to Gordon Ramsay's restaurant. But you also don't compare McDonalds to a steakhouse either.
Also upgrading your pc every other year is probably the stupidest idea ever.
As it stands, the hugest performance sink in wow still is the CPU, god only knows why. The next is the GPU, all the rest of the stuff will only improve loading issues, any broadband connection will cover the "lag" issue and will be limited by your providor.
Having a broadband connection rated at 10 megs trying to pump 1 meg (if that) through it is a tad overkill as well.
bowen on
not a doctor, not a lawyer, examples I use may not be fully researched so don't take out of context plz, don't @ me
This is less a suggestion and more perspective, but my bottom of the line early 2006 macbook ran WoW well enough to play, and ran me about $900. Spending three hundred dollars more than this four years later for a desktop to run the same game seems... Excessive? This, and I helped a buddy build a computer in late '09 for $700 that I have seen run Borderlands and Company of Heroes flawlessly. So while I am surely no rocket doctor and don't know the market or the specs, if WoW is your highest aspiration I am really skeptical that figures over maybe $600 have too much merit.
I don't understand. Are you asking me to read the OP before offering him advice?
Yeah, $600 is foolishly low and I am foolish. $1200, though, I am still unconvinced of, especially given that all he'd be buying is the tower.
In any event, it's true that we have a specially purposed computer build thread full of specially purposed computer builders for this very special purpose.
Installing WoW on a SSD might be a significant performance increase. Not on the gameplay, but on all the loading. This would include model loading (players popping into existence faster), zoning and loading after crashes / dc's.
Wether it's worth your money is debatable, but it's the best way to up that part of the game. (I don't play anymore, but I remember (re)loading being quite tedious).
I did a quick google and found some evidence that the effect is at least nontrivial.
No but it probably wouldn't hurt to reread my last sentence in the 2nd post. Focusing specifically on the word right after the comma.
Edit: As long as he had no qualms with having to upgrade possibly every expansion he could probably get away with $600 on a tower PC with those settings.
My original price assumption was guessing he probably didn't want to be doing that. Because it's pretty stupid to do.
bowen on
not a doctor, not a lawyer, examples I use may not be fully researched so don't take out of context plz, don't @ me
0
ceresWhen the last moon is cast over the last star of morningAnd the future has past without even a last desperate warningRegistered User, ModeratorMod Emeritus
edited March 2010
Yeah, my netbook can RUN WoW. With all the settings turned down. And the framerate is STILL terrible. And if I want to do anything more than stand there, just forget it.
But that really doesn't answer the question, which is complicated slightly by what you intend to do once you've loaded the game. If you want 60fps at max settings while standing still in East Jabib, Outlands, your equipment will be a lot cheaper than if you're trying to get 60fps at the same settings while fighting a raid boss in Icecrown Citadel with 24 other people all spamming area effects while the boss is doing his screen-filling, monitor-killing, once-a-minute raid-wide bitch-slap of doom.
This thread is actually kind of relevant to me, because I do raid and I can't tell you how many times I've been killed trying to something delicate because I'm only getting 5-10 fps, so we're thinking it's time I upgraded my motherboard/CPU. I just upgraded to a Radeon HD 5700 series card from an ancient nvidia, and I've got a CPU sitting in the closet waiting for next month's purchase of a compatible motherboard. My hard drives aren't changing, so without those, or sound cards or anything like that, processor, motherboard, graphics card, and memory are probably going to add up to about $7-800.
I'm going a little overboard so I don't have to replace anything for a number of years (and also because I beat my computer to death even when I don't have a game up), but I'd say you can probably get the kind of game experience you're asking about for about $200 less than that if you don't mind upgrading again soon.
edit: Sander called it, but my husband now runs WoW from a SSD and he can't say enough about the difference in loading times.
ceres on
And it seems like all is dying, and would leave the world to mourn
Posts
A good CPU and a good GPU can run up to about $700. $1200 isn't a bad price range, including needing a monitor that goes up that high.
Bowen's advice is sound, the Build Thread will give you ideas on templates and components that will meet your needs and budget.
It's 18 months old, so should be able to find all that stuff cheap.
PSN: Beltaine-77 | Steam: beltane77 | Battle.net BadHaggis#1433
I'm guessing you don't even need a computer anywhere near that good to pull ~60, especially at the lower resolution he's talking about. WoW is a pretty easy program to run.
It also seems a lot of parts sellers have picked up on wow and the 3.33GHz duos as they're usually the most expensive ones.
Really easy to overclock a slower Core2Duo to push beyond 3.33 though. Although the cost of getting a cpu cooler upgrade might not justify just getting the 3.33 in the first place.
PSN: Beltaine-77 | Steam: beltane77 | Battle.net BadHaggis#1433
Server lag doesn't equate directly to Frames per Second, although the net effect (the game not responding or acting "jumpy") might appear to be the same. However, FPS is locally limited (and could be caused by being CPU-, I/O-, or GPU-bound processes, or some combination). Server lag is performance problems anywhere from the back of your computer all the way up to, and including, the server the game's running on. The cause, cost, and ability to mitigate FPS and lag problems differ rather significantly.
However, you are correct in that there is a point of diminishing returns that is usually reached well before you get into the $Texas top-of-the line gaming computers, and that many MMOs do no benefit from expensive hardware (not having software written to take full advantage of it). Overspending in one area will not overcome bottlenecks in other areas. You want a balanced approach to your computer build.
However, the Computer Build Thread, although it's long, does have a good OP that is relatively up to date, and the thread is chock-full of bleeding edge vs. bang-for-the-buck discussions. We're really just covering an already well-tread path here in H/A. Let the gearheads in Moe's help you.
I am running a q6600@3.0ghz with a GTX 280 and turning shadows up just kills it.
Steam/PSN/XBL/Minecraft / LoL / - Benevicious | WoW - Duckwood - Rajhek
I only have a ATI HD4650
Core 2 Duo E6750 (overclocked to 2.93GHz from 2.66GHz)
8800GT, 512MB VRAM
4GB RAM
Windows 7 x64
2048x1152 resolution
All settings at ultra, with multisampling turned down to 2x due to massive resolution. 60 FPS in non-taxing environments, 20 FPS in more taxing environments (Dalaran, for example).
The hardware is almost 3 years old, and was purchased for $1100. You could probably do much better at less than half the cost now.
To play WoW? Yes it is. OP shouldn't spend more than 300 and it'll run it flawlessly.
Eveything else, you can just go cheap on and it'll run it flawlessly.
Yeah because a core2duo and a mobo itself didn't just eat up that $300.
Oh wait, you're talking about a fucking celeron chip from best buy preloaded with shitware. Sorry. The minute you start going for those lower chips, you'll notice a huge decrease in performance in wow.
It'll still run, but not at that resolution, with that frame-rate, with everything cranked up. Now if you do pay $300 for a pc, you'll likely get great frame-rates in dalaran, but anywhere else you'll be pissed you didn't spend the extra money.
Comparing computers is like comparing restaurants. Generally you don't compare McDonalds to Gordon Ramsay's restaurant. But you also don't compare McDonalds to a steakhouse either.
Also upgrading your pc every other year is probably the stupidest idea ever.
As it stands, the hugest performance sink in wow still is the CPU, god only knows why. The next is the GPU, all the rest of the stuff will only improve loading issues, any broadband connection will cover the "lag" issue and will be limited by your providor.
Having a broadband connection rated at 10 megs trying to pump 1 meg (if that) through it is a tad overkill as well.
He's not looking to run "well enough to play."
Yeah I could probably find him any off the shelf pc that can do that for $200.
Also the engine has changed considerably in 4 years. Low can run on roasted turkey sub and high settings pretty much requires top of the line.
Yeah, $600 is foolishly low and I am foolish. $1200, though, I am still unconvinced of, especially given that all he'd be buying is the tower.
In any event, it's true that we have a specially purposed computer build thread full of specially purposed computer builders for this very special purpose.
Wether it's worth your money is debatable, but it's the best way to up that part of the game. (I don't play anymore, but I remember (re)loading being quite tedious).
I did a quick google and found some evidence that the effect is at least nontrivial.
Edit: As long as he had no qualms with having to upgrade possibly every expansion he could probably get away with $600 on a tower PC with those settings.
My original price assumption was guessing he probably didn't want to be doing that. Because it's pretty stupid to do.
But that really doesn't answer the question, which is complicated slightly by what you intend to do once you've loaded the game. If you want 60fps at max settings while standing still in East Jabib, Outlands, your equipment will be a lot cheaper than if you're trying to get 60fps at the same settings while fighting a raid boss in Icecrown Citadel with 24 other people all spamming area effects while the boss is doing his screen-filling, monitor-killing, once-a-minute raid-wide bitch-slap of doom.
This thread is actually kind of relevant to me, because I do raid and I can't tell you how many times I've been killed trying to something delicate because I'm only getting 5-10 fps, so we're thinking it's time I upgraded my motherboard/CPU. I just upgraded to a Radeon HD 5700 series card from an ancient nvidia, and I've got a CPU sitting in the closet waiting for next month's purchase of a compatible motherboard. My hard drives aren't changing, so without those, or sound cards or anything like that, processor, motherboard, graphics card, and memory are probably going to add up to about $7-800.
I'm going a little overboard so I don't have to replace anything for a number of years (and also because I beat my computer to death even when I don't have a game up), but I'd say you can probably get the kind of game experience you're asking about for about $200 less than that if you don't mind upgrading again soon.
edit: Sander called it, but my husband now runs WoW from a SSD and he can't say enough about the difference in loading times.
Um I called it. Edit that