The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
MustangArbiter of Unpopular OpinionsRegistered Userregular
edited May 2010
I say: It's good!
Your stop motion video is very good, though I must admit a light dissapointment in it not being anymore than just "Oh hey cool". A little story about a lost rubicks cube could've been really cute.
yeah the video seems to trade entirely on one thing
edit: that is, the cube thing is neat, but I don't think it can carry the entire video without something else. Maybe a narrative like Mustang suggested.
yeah for the first minute I was fine with the "this is coo"l.. then it started to get redundant and the lack of a storyline or something caused me to lose interest.
also the hand around the bluejay barely looks like a hand. I thought it was sticks or just abstract shapes at first.
Hey, I liked Rubik's Music Video quite a bit -- it made about as much sense as anything by Daft Punk.
But I'm with Ken in that I expected a conclusion.
The narrative seemed to be that the people going about their business in the background and the scrambled, turning cube in the foreground were related. The ending I expected was for the cube to be solved with an iconic image of human achievement in the background. You kind of hit on this with the city skyline, but given this was also your first image and the cube remain scrambled, I didn't feel it was conclusive.
Then again, maybe you're trying to get across the point that we go through our lives day by day, turning and turning and turning without anything ever getting better.
And that bums me out, dude. Which reminds me, I should stop reading these forums and get back to my day job. Ugh.
Yeah, for the video, I was really trying to not make it cheesy or corny. I feel like it's incredibly difficult for stop motion not to be cheesy or to look like something obviously amateur, that's why I didn't really add in a story or anything.
Posts
Your stop motion video is very good, though I must admit a light dissapointment in it not being anymore than just "Oh hey cool". A little story about a lost rubicks cube could've been really cute.
edit: that is, the cube thing is neat, but I don't think it can carry the entire video without something else. Maybe a narrative like Mustang suggested.
also the hand around the bluejay barely looks like a hand. I thought it was sticks or just abstract shapes at first.
But I'm with Ken in that I expected a conclusion.
The narrative seemed to be that the people going about their business in the background and the scrambled, turning cube in the foreground were related. The ending I expected was for the cube to be solved with an iconic image of human achievement in the background. You kind of hit on this with the city skyline, but given this was also your first image and the cube remain scrambled, I didn't feel it was conclusive.
Then again, maybe you're trying to get across the point that we go through our lives day by day, turning and turning and turning without anything ever getting better.
And that bums me out, dude. Which reminds me, I should stop reading these forums and get back to my day job. Ugh.
Yeah, for the video, I was really trying to not make it cheesy or corny. I feel like it's incredibly difficult for stop motion not to be cheesy or to look like something obviously amateur, that's why I didn't really add in a story or anything.