The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
My mother is trying to get my help with a short notice Christmas gift for my father.
Apparently he was fan of Doctor Who when he was younger, and I remember people being really enthusiastic about David Tennant's recent run as the character, so I thought that would be a good suggestion. But I've never seen Doctor Who, and I have no idea how many seasons/series that encompasses, or where would be a good place to begin, or whatever.
Could any fans of the show point me in the right direction? Is Series 2 where we want to start? Is there a box set that has them all? BBCAmericaShop.com lists each individual DVD for about $90 apiece, which seems absurd, but Amazon has them for like $40-something. I have no idea how this works.
Thanks in advance!
Mitten on
0
Posts
admanbunionize your workplaceSeattle, WARegistered Userregular
edited December 2010
I would start with Series 1 and if he likes the modern look of the show, keep going. Tennant is a popular favorite, but he's by no means universal (I can't stand him) and a lot of people enjoyed the first new doctor just as much.
I dunno why they're that expensive on BBC America, but just get them from Amazon.
Just an alternative thought here -- would he enjoy a NetFlix subscription? Series 1 through 4 I believe are available on Netflix Instant (which is where I'm working through them now). Whether he ended up liking them or not, for the cost of a couple of seasons he could get a whole bunch of movies/tv shows (not the same as owning, obviously, but not everyone will rewatch them anyway).
As to the actual question, I agree with admanb -- start with Series 1. There's definitely nothing so special about David Tennant that you should start with Series 2 instead of 1. The doctor in series 1 is perfectly enjoyable (I think I like him a bit better actually).
twmjr on
0
admanbunionize your workplaceSeattle, WARegistered Userregular
edited December 2010
Netflix also has a selection of the older Doctor Who series on watch instantly.
I'll consider NetFlix, but I don't have any personal experience with it, and both my parents are pretty adverse to using computers for anything other than work. Also it's not something that comes in a box, which is a semi-important consideration.
Edit: Plus, my parents are people who procrastinate a lot. I can see how it would be a good idea, but unless it's something that can sit on a shelf for a long time until they they're in the mood for it, it would probably go to waste.
I second the netflix suggestion, it has seasons 1-4 on instant view, as well as torchwood(one of the spin off shows). If you have an internet connection and a way to watch over the television that is.
This would also let you grab the hour long specials via the mail order dvd option.
*edit* There are devices that let you stream things like hulu and netflix directly to the tv.
If he likes the older Doctor Who, there are a few really great stories you could pick up from the classic series, as well: Genesis of the Daleks, Robots of Death, and City of Death are all great, and star the most recognizable 'classic' Doctor Tom Baker.
I am in the 'couldn't stand David Tennant' group as well, so I would agree with all of the people saying you should start with series 1 if you are going with the current series. Plus, Rose and Captain Jack both debuted in series 1 and they show up throughout the Tennant years as well, so it makes it a bit easier to follow when they come back later on.
My mother is trying to get my help with a short notice Christmas gift for my father.
Apparently he was fan of Doctor Who when he was younger, and I remember people being really enthusiastic about David Tennant's recent run as the character, so I thought that would be a good suggestion. But I've never seen Doctor Who, and I have no idea how many seasons/series that encompasses, or where would be a good place to begin, or whatever.
Could any fans of the show point me in the right direction? Is Series 2 where we want to start? Is there a box set that has them all? BBCAmericaShop.com lists each individual DVD for about $90 apiece, which seems absurd, but Amazon has them for like $40-something. I have no idea how this works.
Thanks in advance!
The DVDs are mad expensive, I waited until there was a huge sale on TV DVDs at Barnes and Noble to buy them.
There was recently a box set of Tennant's entire run (Series 2-4 plus the specials), but I think it was only in the UK and is now sold out.
Series 1 is Christopher Eccleston as the Ninth Doctor, and ends with him regenerating into David Tennant (the Tenth Doctor). Series 2-4 is Tennant, plus another boxset of the specials that were aired in the off-year between Series 4 and 5. Series 5 with Matt Smith as the Eleventh Doctor was just released.
The two best places to start for the new show are either Series 1 or Series 5, as neither of them requires a really big understanding of what came before (although Series 1 is a little better than 5 if you're starting COMPLETELY fresh, as 5 refers back to characters/villains from Series 3 and 4).
From what it sounds like here, you should probably get him Series 1 and 2.
Note that the Series numbers mentioned above are all about the more recent Doctor Who and not the older shows. There is a great wiki on Doctor Who which should tell you all you need.
PS. Also make sure to get some for DVD's for yourself.
(Damn - I'm so looking forward to the Christmas special.)
Posts
I dunno why they're that expensive on BBC America, but just get them from Amazon.
As to the actual question, I agree with admanb -- start with Series 1. There's definitely nothing so special about David Tennant that you should start with Series 2 instead of 1. The doctor in series 1 is perfectly enjoyable (I think I like him a bit better actually).
Edit: Plus, my parents are people who procrastinate a lot. I can see how it would be a good idea, but unless it's something that can sit on a shelf for a long time until they they're in the mood for it, it would probably go to waste.
Thanks, though.
This would also let you grab the hour long specials via the mail order dvd option.
*edit* There are devices that let you stream things like hulu and netflix directly to the tv.
I am in the 'couldn't stand David Tennant' group as well, so I would agree with all of the people saying you should start with series 1 if you are going with the current series. Plus, Rose and Captain Jack both debuted in series 1 and they show up throughout the Tennant years as well, so it makes it a bit easier to follow when they come back later on.
Classic stuff might be good as well, but I thought he might like something more recent.
You have made me cry
Not enough lime in the world. I used to sit next to his neice. She looks like him.
For paintings in progress, check out canvas and paints
"The power of the weirdness compels me."
The DVDs are mad expensive, I waited until there was a huge sale on TV DVDs at Barnes and Noble to buy them.
There was recently a box set of Tennant's entire run (Series 2-4 plus the specials), but I think it was only in the UK and is now sold out.
Series 1 is Christopher Eccleston as the Ninth Doctor, and ends with him regenerating into David Tennant (the Tenth Doctor). Series 2-4 is Tennant, plus another boxset of the specials that were aired in the off-year between Series 4 and 5. Series 5 with Matt Smith as the Eleventh Doctor was just released.
The two best places to start for the new show are either Series 1 or Series 5, as neither of them requires a really big understanding of what came before (although Series 1 is a little better than 5 if you're starting COMPLETELY fresh, as 5 refers back to characters/villains from Series 3 and 4).
From what it sounds like here, you should probably get him Series 1 and 2.
PS. Also make sure to get some for DVD's for yourself.
(Damn - I'm so looking forward to the Christmas special.)
For paintings in progress, check out canvas and paints
"The power of the weirdness compels me."
Wasn't the worst experience. Gotta say the latest Doctor is pretty great, but I had some wiki and original series to supplement gaps in my knowledge.
Why I fear the ocean.