This is why you should forget what you think you know about my how I generally post.
Also facetious you weren't that bad, but you did make it easy for the mafia to pour suspicion on you and others, i wouldn't say you endangered the game prior to the last day though. Well done WH, i think. Also that mafia did pretty well to be honest. I think this was a hard game for them.
1. There's a super passive-aggressive response to taya's post (http://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/comment/19872551#Comment_19872551) in the PM chain. My only excuse is that I was frustrated from the game not going so well at that point, and that I am really stressed out from bar exam studying. I apologize!
2. The conversation feature is a great way to coordinate with multiple people, but you have to be really careful. When lonelyahava was added to the conversation between WH and me, she accidentally kinda sorta confirmed that I was a special of some kind. I didn't think WH noticed (and you can tell that he still had his doubts about me on the day he came forward to the village), so I didn't say anything and I don't think it affected the game at all. It's just something future game hosts should keep in mind.
1. There's a super passive-aggressive response to taya's post (http://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/comment/19872551#Comment_19872551) in the PM chain. My only excuse is that I was frustrated from the game not going so well at that point, and that I am really stressed out from bar exam studying. I apologize!
I was really frustrated because I wanted to network with a seer. A vig without a seer is just a regular villager with a knife, and that's dangerous. Plus, at that point I wasn't sure Wandering Hero was even telling the truth.
I actually tried to drop a hint or two that I was Will Scarlet early in the game but it was too subtle and nobody picked up on it.
2. The conversation feature is a great way to coordinate with multiple people, but you have to be really careful. When lonelyahava was added to the conversation between WH and me, she accidentally kinda sorta confirmed that I was a special of some kind. I didn't think WH noticed (and you can tell that he still had his doubts about me on the day he came forward to the village), so I didn't say anything and I don't think it affected the game at all. It's just something future game hosts should keep in mind.
Yeah, this new "add to conversation" feature might require an additional rule to be added to the start of phallas to prevent you from being able to confirm something was said by someone simply by just adding them to the convo.
Well done, village! I thought we had this game after the first couple days, but then you turned it around.
I didn't do so hot finding specials this game. I was convinced I had found the vigs after Mr.B's death, especially with Roman's posts when he was getting voted out, but clearly I was wrong.
It seems like I did pretty well staying off the mafia radar. I didn't see any Virgil=Robin Hood? posts
I just needed to do a tiny bit better staying off of the village radar.
1. There's a super passive-aggressive response to taya's post (http://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/comment/19872551#Comment_19872551) in the PM chain. My only excuse is that I was frustrated from the game not going so well at that point, and that I am really stressed out from bar exam studying. I apologize!
I was really frustrated because I wanted to network with a seer. A vig without a seer is just a regular villager with a knife, and that's dangerous. Plus, at that point I wasn't sure Wandering Hero was even telling the truth.
I actually tried to drop a hint or two that I was Will Scarlet early in the game but it was too subtle and nobody picked up on it.
Hey, I understand! We were both frustrated, though for different reasons.
I'll make you a deal. Next time I'm the seer I will target you first.
Interesting read there. Playing vanillager is always weird, somewhere between not overly caring to just going over the top in posting is what I shoot for :P
I was honestly gone a good majority of the time, which I guess helped me avoid suspicion early on, but really didn't help me the later it got. Oh well.
3DS: 2981-5304-3227
0
Options
BaidolI will hold him offEscape while you canRegistered Userregular
I take pride in being the player to roleplay the longest.
I'm a bit peeved that I died the day before things got interesting, particularly because The Anonymous didn't change the kill orders in time. I'm still really surprised they thought I was a special, when I was talking that much. Putting a vote on a guy who no one else suspects because I think they're mafia is pretty much all I did in the last SE++ phalla.
(It got me killed there too because I kept guessing right while the village followed the same bad leads)
My friend is working on a roguelike game you can play if you want to. (It has free demo)
I apologize to everyone in the village for my antics, I thought they would be helpful at first. And once I started I could not help myself. I actually managed to talk vigil out of viging me, don't know if that was such a good idea given what happened later...
Also thank you for running the game lonelyahava!
He's a shy overambitious dog-catcher on the wrong side of the law. She's an orphaned psychic mercenary with the power to bend men's minds. They fight crime!
In hindsight we probably should've left Infidel alone for another day or two. He hadn't really done anything at the point when we killed him, so it was probably a lame thing to do.
He would have died anyway to Blarney's revenge kill too
Blarney with a revenge kill just means he'll put me as the order for all time day 1.
Nice job as network head WH. But I don't know why you believed we'd kill you. Our need to kill specials at that moment was dire, so you were very safe for a while. The only real mistake you made was revealing your seering results too early in the day, which limited the pool of candidates for the seer. Then when I was obviously bogus, you could have just said I was obviously bogus and left it at that. It's not like I was going to actually convince people long term. Instead, you revealed potentially critical information about Robin Hood.
Most importantly, you did a great job of ferreting out the remainder of the mafia without a seer. Much props for that. I did a really bad job of covering for them while I was still alive so its partly my fault. But I don't understand why Locus suspected me, other than I made some comments about his avatar.
Also, it kinda defeats the purpose if someone knows they're a miller. Usually it's just a really unpleasant surprise when you die, from what I've seen.
My friend is working on a roguelike game you can play if you want to. (It has free demo)
WH, why did you think I was village? I mean you were right and all, was I seered or?
I didn't. I thought the last two mafia were you and KingMole. Since I had already been in contact with KingMole, Void Slayer, and Facetious I knew Void and Facet were village, Matev was confirmed, KingMole was mafia.
When it was revealed that only one mafia was left, KingMole trumped my suspicions on you.
It seems like I did pretty well staying off the mafia radar. I didn't see any Virgil=Robin Hood? posts I just needed to do a tiny bit better staying off of the village radar.
If you, or anyone else, would like more practice with that, sign up for the newbie mini, complete with helpful mentoring!
Spoit on
0
Options
facetiousa wit so dryit shits sandRegistered Userregular
But yeah, way to go Locus! I don't know why I thought Taya was the vig getting the kills. Other than, you know. I'm dumb.
"I am not young enough to know everything." - Oscar Wilde
In hindsight we probably should've left Infidel alone for another day or two. He hadn't really done anything at the point when we killed him, so it was probably a lame thing to do.
He would have died anyway to Blarney's revenge kill too
Blarney with a revenge kill just means he'll put me as the order for all time day 1.
It is not surprising.
Actually, his original pick was Peccavi. And that was to be his standing order until end of time.
And then he changed it to you on the night he got killed.
There was a bit of a NOOOOOOOOOO moment on this end.
Blarney with a revenge kill just means he'll put me as the order for all time day 1.
It is not surprising.
As lonelyahava says, I actually had my order on Peccavi on Day 1, switching over to you towards the end of Day 2. I thought you were up to no good with your low posting...
It seems like I did pretty well staying off the mafia radar. I didn't see any Virgil=Robin Hood? posts I just needed to do a tiny bit better staying off of the village radar.
If you, or anyone else, would like more practice with that, sign up for the newbie mini, complete with helpful mentoring!
Your helpful mentors includes a dude who's cool with personal attacks.
I'd prefer to not risk dealing with more of that, especially since I'm pretty content with most of my unpopular thoughts on the game.
Posts
Argh! I purposefully did not vote that day so the mafia wouldn't suspect me of being a special.
Also my seer target before I died was Nirya, so I was 3/5 in picking out badguys!
In other news, well-done village, and well-done Wandering Hero! I picked a good person to form a network of two with.
And thanks to lonelyahava! It was a fun game and, as expected, the narrations were top notch.
Also facetious you weren't that bad, but you did make it easy for the mafia to pour suspicion on you and others, i wouldn't say you endangered the game prior to the last day though. Well done WH, i think. Also that mafia did pretty well to be honest. I think this was a hard game for them.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sdfBh3bkGdHrm8plOSneRlZ1vZ9uHjkm9qIk6Pd6sS4/edit?hl=en_US
Two things about the PMs:
1. There's a super passive-aggressive response to taya's post (http://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/comment/19872551#Comment_19872551) in the PM chain. My only excuse is that I was frustrated from the game not going so well at that point, and that I am really stressed out from bar exam studying. I apologize!
2. The conversation feature is a great way to coordinate with multiple people, but you have to be really careful. When lonelyahava was added to the conversation between WH and me, she accidentally kinda sorta confirmed that I was a special of some kind. I didn't think WH noticed (and you can tell that he still had his doubts about me on the day he came forward to the village), so I didn't say anything and I don't think it affected the game at all. It's just something future game hosts should keep in mind.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1nSVWqG0Y4LRnd-rnvjEMK7JyaqTaELjFmxX0IJjPDXI/edit?hl=en_US
I actually tried to drop a hint or two that I was Will Scarlet early in the game but it was too subtle and nobody picked up on it.
Yeah, this new "add to conversation" feature might require an additional rule to be added to the start of phallas to prevent you from being able to confirm something was said by someone simply by just adding them to the convo.
I didn't do so hot finding specials this game. I was convinced I had found the vigs after Mr.B's death, especially with Roman's posts when he was getting voted out, but clearly I was wrong.
Then I voted for INANTP and INANTP died by vigilante.
I just needed to do a tiny bit better staying off of the village radar.
Hey, I understand! We were both frustrated, though for different reasons.
I'll make you a deal. Next time I'm the seer I will target you first.
Was it brass phalla? Was I that devious?
Little John played an important role...maybe not. Pro work facetious.
Thanks for running it ahava, good game!
Time to read me some proboards!
Confusion will be my epitaph
Me, yes and yes. It was your day 1 roleblock that got me killed in that game.
I had fun with my little gambit there, but Taya earned herself a grudge vote for not contacting me and therefore messing up the whole plan. grrrr (:P)
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Confusion will be my epitaph
3DS: 2981-5304-3227
It was you being an SK that made me look legit.
Grudge kill accepted sir.
(It got me killed there too because I kept guessing right while the village followed the same bad leads)
Also thank you for running the game lonelyahava!
Blarney with a revenge kill just means he'll put me as the order for all time day 1.
It is not surprising.
Nice job as network head WH. But I don't know why you believed we'd kill you. Our need to kill specials at that moment was dire, so you were very safe for a while. The only real mistake you made was revealing your seering results too early in the day, which limited the pool of candidates for the seer. Then when I was obviously bogus, you could have just said I was obviously bogus and left it at that. It's not like I was going to actually convince people long term. Instead, you revealed potentially critical information about Robin Hood.
Most importantly, you did a great job of ferreting out the remainder of the mafia without a seer. Much props for that. I did a really bad job of covering for them while I was still alive so its partly my fault. But I don't understand why Locus suspected me, other than I made some comments about his avatar.
And I would've been grudged forever. Still, it was worth a shot.
I also like that the last PM between us before he died was "Alright, I am going to contact Kime"
Not the first time those have been the last words of players.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Confusion will be my epitaph
True story:
I woke up early the morning after I died, saw kime's posts claiming to be a mafia, saw that I had died, and didn't bother to keep reading.
It was only two days later that I went back to the thread and saw that kime hadn't screwed me over.
I didn't. I thought the last two mafia were you and KingMole. Since I had already been in contact with KingMole, Void Slayer, and Facetious I knew Void and Facet were village, Matev was confirmed, KingMole was mafia.
When it was revealed that only one mafia was left, KingMole trumped my suspicions on you.
Steam: Chagrin LoL: Bonhomie
Actually, his original pick was Peccavi. And that was to be his standing order until end of time.
And then he changed it to you on the night he got killed.
There was a bit of a NOOOOOOOOOO moment on this end.
And then I giggled.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
As lonelyahava says, I actually had my order on Peccavi on Day 1, switching over to you towards the end of Day 2. I thought you were up to no good with your low posting...
You didn't even let me get around to posting a list! That was gonna be day 3 whether anyone called me out or not.
Your helpful mentors includes a dude who's cool with personal attacks.
I'd prefer to not risk dealing with more of that, especially since I'm pretty content with most of my unpopular thoughts on the game.
To dismiss it or avoid engaging in debate instead of facing it is Letting the Terrorists Win, or something.