Also, if we get a network head (which I'm surprised we don't have since we seem to have a vig), that person can secretly reveal that they were the mason. Unless the mafia also try it, that confirms someone, and if they do try it, then we have a 1 in 2 shot of getting a mafia.
Edit: Although I guess we could do this publicly and either get a network head or catch a mafia.
Well I suppose the mason could come out now. Don't think the mafia-mafia would be dumb enough to risk pretending to be it since the real mason would also come forward.
[Edit] I guess we're all stating the obvious at the same time, eh? :P
And by that I mean he should come forward, specials should wait for most of the day, and then if no one else comes forward, the mason will be pretty confirmed and they can contact him.
the conceit of the game is that it is a village of mafia people who are beset by villagers. The "mafia" kills are with every day objects, while our vig is like a mafia hit.
That's a pretty lame interpretation of the VI. The whole point is that it's anti village by needing to be voted off, and the disruption they cause to do so. Though the "VI" a couple games ago was even less of one
0
Options
sportzboytjwsqueeeeeezzeeeesome more tax breaks outRegistered Userregular
That's a pretty lame interpretation of the VI. The whole point is that it's anti village by needing to be voted off, and the disruption they cause to do so. Though the "VI" a couple games ago was even less of one
So don't think of it as VI, think of it as "freedom chaser" or something if that helps... not a bad role, sort of interesting at least.
Walkerdog on MTGO
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
Awww, ok fine. I guess I get to be network head for realsies this time.
I'm Baidol's mason.
Just to be safe - I don't think specials should contact MrT yet. He may still be a "bad guy", playing a gambit to grab a few specials before the real mason pair has a chance to come out to the thread.
0
Options
tzeentchlingDoctor of RocksOaklandRegistered Userregular
So there's a vig, a serial killer, and two "mafia" kills. That's a healthy amount of deaths/turn.
Awww, ok fine. I guess I get to be network head for realsies this time.
I'm Baidol's mason.
Tell me again the logic of believing you? Ie why would mafia not claim this? Just that if multiple people claimed it, the vigs/mafia hits would go after them?
Awww, ok fine. I guess I get to be network head for realsies this time.
I'm Baidol's mason.
Just to be safe - I don't think specials should contact MrT yet. He may still be a "bad guy", playing a gambit to grab a few specials before the real mason pair has a chance to come out to the thread.
Yeah, this was said by Langly earlier and I agree. Please just make sure I get guarded tonight
Awww, ok fine. I guess I get to be network head for realsies this time.
I'm Baidol's mason.
Tell me again the logic of believing you? Ie why would mafia not claim this? Just that if multiple people claimed it, the vigs/mafia hits would go after them?
Yeah basically there's no reason for a villager to make a mason claim if they aren't the mason, so if there's a counter claim, ONE of them has to be evil
Also, if there's multiple mason claims, there's likey no reason to keep the real mason alive, as mason's powers are supposed to just be knowing someone else is not evil. /glares at the BoI mini/
0
Options
tzeentchlingDoctor of RocksOaklandRegistered Userregular
I suppose that makes sense.
0
Options
tzeentchlingDoctor of RocksOaklandRegistered Userregular
And because this is day 2 and Langly isn't dead yet, Langly.
Bedlam
Makes no sense to vote MrT out now. If someone comes forward to challenge, ok, then we pick our poison, but as of now it's PURE FOLLY.
I think he's still just grudging me, and not actually trying to get me voted out.
Anybody can come forward and say that they are a mason partner after the fact. Your reveal means absolutly nothing since we cant trust you to be telling the truth. Anybody who reveals to you or assumes you are the network head is a damn fool.
Bedlam
Makes no sense to vote MrT out now. If someone comes forward to challenge, ok, then we pick our poison, but as of now it's PURE FOLLY.
I think he's still just grudging me, and not actually trying to get me voted out.
Anybody can come forward and say that they are a mason partner after the fact. Your reveal means absolutly nothing since we cant trust you to be telling the truth. Anybody who reveals to you or assumes you are the network head is a damn fool.
Except that if he is lying the real mason should come forward.
Bedlam
Makes no sense to vote MrT out now. If someone comes forward to challenge, ok, then we pick our poison, but as of now it's PURE FOLLY.
I think he's still just grudging me, and not actually trying to get me voted out.
Anybody can come forward and say that they are a mason partner after the fact. Your reveal means absolutly nothing since we cant trust you to be telling the truth. Anybody who reveals to you or assumes you are the network head is a damn fool.
I don't think people should necessarily reveal to him yet, nor do I necessarily consider him de facto network head at this point. But there is no good reason at all to vote him out right now either.
Posts
Edit: Although I guess we could do this publicly and either get a network head or catch a mafia.
[Edit] I guess we're all stating the obvious at the same time, eh? :P
Confusion will be my epitaph
He's confirmed by default and can network.
I'm Baidol's mason.
Your fear of me is impressive, but it will not save you
OOOOooOOOOOOOoooo
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
You may want to revise that enthusiasm...
Although we did get 1 traditional mafia, so for day 1 that's pretty good.
Confusion will be my epitaph
That is less fantastic.
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
Unknown at this point. At least by me. Sounds like a VI-type role where they needed to be killed at night.
the conceit of the game is that it is a village of mafia people who are beset by villagers. The "mafia" kills are with every day objects, while our vig is like a mafia hit.
So don't think of it as VI, think of it as "freedom chaser" or something if that helps... not a bad role, sort of interesting at least.
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
Just to be safe - I don't think specials should contact MrT yet. He may still be a "bad guy", playing a gambit to grab a few specials before the real mason pair has a chance to come out to the thread.
Tell me again the logic of believing you? Ie why would mafia not claim this? Just that if multiple people claimed it, the vigs/mafia hits would go after them?
Yeah, this was said by Langly earlier and I agree. Please just make sure I get guarded tonight
MrT is very likely the real mason, but yes, specials should wait until later to reveal.
If he dies good then I'll double trust Baidol. Till then hes a lying liar mclyingpants.
Makes no sense to vote MrT out now. If someone comes forward to challenge, ok, then we pick our poison, but as of now it's PURE FOLLY.
I agree with this. Bedlam, what's the matter wit'chu?
Henri Emmanuel Gratien St Pierre in Where No Man Has Gone Before
Lord Augustus Cumberbatch in Eclipse Phase
I think he's still just grudging me, and not actually trying to get me voted out.
Finally a legitimate grudge.
Took long enough.
oOoOoOoOoOoOo
I don't know if I should give the black-name vig a high five or grudge them as well.
I be hatin'
Except that if he is lying the real mason should come forward.
So.
Yeah, voting him out is a bad idea.
I don't think people should necessarily reveal to him yet, nor do I necessarily consider him de facto network head at this point. But there is no good reason at all to vote him out right now either.