Bedlam
Makes no sense to vote MrT out now. If someone comes forward to challenge, ok, then we pick our poison, but as of now it's PURE FOLLY.
I think he's still just grudging me, and not actually trying to get me voted out.
Anybody can come forward and say that they are a mason partner after the fact. Your reveal means absolutly nothing since we cant trust you to be telling the truth. Anybody who reveals to you or assumes you are the network head is a damn fool.
I don't think people should necessarily reveal to him yet, nor do I necessarily consider him de facto network head at this point. But there is no good reason at all to vote him out right now either.
Exactly. Especially since the thread was pressuring him to reveal in the first place
OK, I take it back, you are just a ray of sunshine.
0
Options
AssuranIs swinging on the SpiralRegistered Userregular
Six potential deaths a night (if I'm reading the narrative correctly) seems drastic in a 30 person game. Two SKs (Slym, Skullman each came back as black, I assume that's neutral), 2 mafia kills, and a vig, plus the vote.
Dang man, dang. I don't expect this game to last long.
Oh, the default theme, yes. in Olde style, SLyM is black black, while the vote is just the default font color
0
Options
AssuranIs swinging on the SpiralRegistered Userregular
edited March 2012
I'm not really seeing a huge difference in color on my screen, they both look black to me. Coupled with the fact Slym's kill was black and Skull Man is described as being shot to death and his death is in black, it seemed to me that there were two neutral kills.
No inside info, sorry, just inferring from the narrative, as I said.
Awww, ok fine. I guess I get to be network head for realsies this time.
I'm Baidol's mason.
Tell me again the logic of believing you? Ie why would mafia not claim this? Just that if multiple people claimed it, the vigs/mafia hits would go after them?
Yeah basically there's no reason for a villager to make a mason claim if they aren't the mason, so if there's a counter claim, ONE of them has to be evil
guys you gotta be willing to make assumptions that you can't actually 100% prove without reading someone's role pm or getting seer results in phalla, sometimes.
Based on what we know from Day 1 results:
- Alignment is revealed on death (although we got a CD on thralls etc, so they aren't completely reliable)
- Roles are revealed on death (which will help us determine who is actually good/bad, since a thralled special would be especially cruel)
- One mason was killed last night
- The mafia lost one member last night (unless, again, slym was a miller)
- The mafia exchanging one of their members for at best a chance at nabbing a special or two, and at worst a simple villager/mafia exchange, would be really dumb.
We know there is another mason, because it's a listed role. We know that the other mason is alive, because two didn't die last night. We know that it would be foolish for the mafia to claim the mason role in this situation.
Based on all of that, the person who comes forward (mrt), is almost certainly the other mason. And, like I said before, people should wait until later today to contact mrt, just in case.
A quick placeholder vote on stever. I remember something about him yesterday that looked mafiaish although I can't recall what it was and I don't have to time to go back and check right now.
Alright caught up on the day, was confused about all this color business about the skull man kill but I guess that's just a vanilla thing. Also this is the most suspicious I've seen a village regarding someone claiming a mason role. I've never seen more than one person claim an outed role like that but I guess I haven't been playing long enough.
Alright caught up on the day, was confused about all this color business about the skull man kill but I guess that's just a vanilla thing. Also this is the most suspicious I've seen a village regarding someone claiming a mason role. I've never seen more than one person claim an outed role like that but I guess I haven't been playing long enough.
AFAIK, only Bedlam is saying I'm lying, and that's based on the Isaac Phalla. I don't think anyone else really needs convincing. It's kind of funny to me how many people are coming forward to defend me when no one is really objecting...
0
Options
FiggyFighter of the night manChampion of the sunRegistered Userregular
A quick placeholder vote on stever. I remember something about him yesterday that looked mafiaish although I can't recall what it was and I don't have to time to go back and check right now.
Not quite sure where to jump on this just yet. Taya seems sort of suspicious to me, and I can't tell just yet if this is Bedlam being mafia or just Bedlam being Bedlam.
For now I'm going to put a placeholder on obifett, because he sort of nimbly dodged the vote yesterday as everybody suddenly rushed to help romanqwerty fulfill his death wish.
Yeah, I've only ever played with him in the Binding of Isaac game. He was mafia there (in fairness, so was I) and acted much like this, but that really doesn't prove anything. *shrug*
Posts
I think MrT can be trusted assuming no one else comes forward.
And assuming there are no crazy conversion mechanics in this game.
Exactly. Especially since the thread was pressuring him to reveal in the first place
I am just explaining why it's a bad idea...
Dang man, dang. I don't expect this game to last long.
No inside info, sorry, just inferring from the narrative, as I said.
edit= to and two are not the same thing, ;p
oOoO
ObiFett
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1
or is it "mafia"?
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1
mmm
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1
It is me, I am the mason.
Also, hey @Bedlam, how you doing, dogg?
But darling, you know I love chocolate!
Also, he might be sort of suspicious.
I'm sure one of these things is true!
Based on what we know from Day 1 results:
- Alignment is revealed on death (although we got a CD on thralls etc, so they aren't completely reliable)
- Roles are revealed on death (which will help us determine who is actually good/bad, since a thralled special would be especially cruel)
- One mason was killed last night
- The mafia lost one member last night (unless, again, slym was a miller)
- The mafia exchanging one of their members for at best a chance at nabbing a special or two, and at worst a simple villager/mafia exchange, would be really dumb.
We know there is another mason, because it's a listed role. We know that the other mason is alive, because two didn't die last night. We know that it would be foolish for the mafia to claim the mason role in this situation.
Based on all of that, the person who comes forward (mrt), is almost certainly the other mason. And, like I said before, people should wait until later today to contact mrt, just in case.
and yeah guard him tonight.
Don't have much to go on admittedly but playing a hunch
jdarksun
AFAIK, only Bedlam is saying I'm lying, and that's based on the Isaac Phalla. I don't think anyone else really needs convincing. It's kind of funny to me how many people are coming forward to defend me when no one is really objecting...
Don't have time to go back 2 pages?
Taya
jdarksun has been replaced by an infinite void of hatred and terrible.
For now I'm going to put a placeholder on obifett, because he sort of nimbly dodged the vote yesterday as everybody suddenly rushed to help romanqwerty fulfill his death wish.
Grudge until dead, I always say.
E - Oh & this isn't a grudge vote.
I'm carrying on kime's legacy by doing his dirty work.
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1
I see how it is
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1