Anyways, lets talk results. A few things stand out:
1. How many different villagers were being bandwagoned on day 1. The only people who received more than 2 votes that we don't KNOW are villagers are Fiaryn and Mill. Megafrost being the third vote on Fiaryn makes it unlikely that he's mafia. For various reasons, I think it's unlikely that Mill is as well. The mafia knows this and my guess is that most of them did throwaways on day 1.
2. How quickly the mafia jumped on the megafrost wagon after jdark's vote. They realized immediately that mega had been seered and wanted to get the best records they could. Not one of our confirmed mafia even questioned jdark's qualifications or the vote.
So a real quick look at who made a day 1 throwaway and a day 2 vote for Megafrost:
Mikey CTS
Shalmelo
INANTP
Cayrus
Gizzy
I'm not sure that the combination of a throwaway day 1 vote then sheeping to a network call day 2 is all that damning, but even if it is, why did you leave Tehspectre and Zombie Hero off your list? They both did the same thing, and you're usually more thorough than that.
Anyways, lets talk results. A few things stand out:
1. How many different villagers were being bandwagoned on day 1. The only people who received more than 2 votes that we don't KNOW are villagers are Fiaryn and Mill. Megafrost being the third vote on Fiaryn makes it unlikely that he's mafia. For various reasons, I think it's unlikely that Mill is as well. The mafia knows this and my guess is that most of them did throwaways on day 1.
2. How quickly the mafia jumped on the megafrost wagon after jdark's vote. They realized immediately that mega had been seered and wanted to get the best records they could. Not one of our confirmed mafia even questioned jdark's qualifications or the vote.
So a real quick look at who made a day 1 throwaway and a day 2 vote for Megafrost:
Mikey CTS
Shalmelo
INANTP
Cayrus
Gizzy
I'm not sure that the combination of a throwaway day 1 vote then sheeping to a network call day 2 is all that damning, but even if it is, why did you leave Tehspectre and Zombie Hero off your list? They both did the same thing, and you're usually more thorough than that.
I'm not saying it's 100%, but of the mafia we know, half fall into exactly that category. So it's a place to start.
TehSpectre voted for T_A on day 1, so I didn't mark him down as a throwaway. ZH had a vote with other people who changed on day 1. I couldn't remember if his vote was while others were on the wagon or not, so I kept him off the list as well. I'd happily listen to reasoning on either of them though.
Anyways, lets talk results. A few things stand out:
1. How many different villagers were being bandwagoned on day 1. The only people who received more than 2 votes that we don't KNOW are villagers are Fiaryn and Mill. Megafrost being the third vote on Fiaryn makes it unlikely that he's mafia. For various reasons, I think it's unlikely that Mill is as well. The mafia knows this and my guess is that most of them did throwaways on day 1.
2. How quickly the mafia jumped on the megafrost wagon after jdark's vote. They realized immediately that mega had been seered and wanted to get the best records they could. Not one of our confirmed mafia even questioned jdark's qualifications or the vote.
So a real quick look at who made a day 1 throwaway and a day 2 vote for Megafrost:
Mikey CTS
Shalmelo
INANTP
Cayrus
Gizzy
I'm not sure that the combination of a throwaway day 1 vote then sheeping to a network call day 2 is all that damning, but even if it is, why did you leave Tehspectre and Zombie Hero off your list? They both did the same thing, and you're usually more thorough than that.
I'm not saying it's 100%, but of the mafia we know, half fall into exactly that category. So it's a place to start.
TehSpectre voted for T_A on day 1, so I didn't mark him down as a throwaway. ZH had a vote with other people who changed on day 1. I couldn't remember if his vote was while others were on the wagon or not, so I kept him off the list as well. I'd happily listen to reasoning on either of them though.
Oops, you're right about spec - I was looking at the vote counts before I had coffee and confused a vote FOR him on day 1 for a vote BY him. My bad.
Rainfall voted for Megafrost before the call that he was mafia.
So I theorize that you are either:
1) A mafia putting a throwaway vote on another mafia to look good when he turns up dead.
2) A special with prior knowledge of megas identity
3) unlucky
I'm going to go with Talented Phalla Player with prior history of targeting mafia via post and voting analysis, or TPPWPHoTMVPaVA, for short.
If you want to go for someone who drops out all the time/get's killed by me/is a lying, backstabbing son of a bitch then Maximus is another candidate.
I think I barely remember doug_grammar.
Also, apologies for posting so little up till now. I have a transatlantic flight tomorrow to get back to school and have been preparing for that. I should be able to make my voting and posting requirements for the rest of this game, but will alert the hosts if I am unable to.
Also, apologies for posting so little up till now. I have a transatlantic flight tomorrow to get back to school and have been preparing for that. I should be able to make my voting and posting requirements for the rest of this game, but will alert the hosts if I am unable to.
Day 1 position + too busy to play = suspiciousssss Thetheroo
Switch Animal Crossing Friend Code: SW-5107-9276-1030
Island Name: Felinefine
People need to be careful about using OL's Day 1 count. It's wrong in at least the following way: it says 7 people voted for Assuran but lists 6 names.
Generalísimo de Fuerzas Armadas de la República Argentina
hm? it hasn't been fixed in your post, quoting OL, at the top of pg 25. It hasn't been fixed in Saber's post on that same page. Gizzy appears to be quoting your post in their post just above this, and it hasn't been fixed there.
EDIT: What I really mean is: what post ought I use for voting infO?
Invictus on
Generalísimo de Fuerzas Armadas de la República Argentina
Also, apologies for posting so little up till now. I have a transatlantic flight tomorrow to get back to school and have been preparing for that. I should be able to make my voting and posting requirements for the rest of this game, but will alert the hosts if I am unable to.
Day 1 position + too busy to play = suspiciousssss Thetheroo
Yeah, I really have only myself to blame for that. Hopefully if I survive till Friday I can participate a whole lot more. Flying through 5 timezones with 3 layovers on the way is not going to be a fun trip.
hm? it hasn't been fixed in your post, quoting OL, at the top of pg 25. It hasn't been fixed in Saber's post on that same page. Gizzy appears to be quoting your post in their post just above this, and it hasn't been fixed there.
EDIT: What I really mean is: what post ought I use for voting infO?
ah you are correct. I was counting T_A for some reason. My mistake.
Also, apologies for posting so little up till now. I have a transatlantic flight tomorrow to get back to school and have been preparing for that. I should be able to make my voting and posting requirements for the rest of this game, but will alert the hosts if I am unable to.
Day 1 position + too busy to play = suspiciousssss Thetheroo
Yeah, I really have only myself to blame for that. Hopefully if I survive till Friday I can participate a whole lot more. Flying through 5 timezones with 3 layovers on the way is not going to be a fun trip.
Have fun , roo.
at least you won't have the same experience I did and have an airline that played this
Why is there always at least one terrible rom-com on every airline that plays a movie during the flight? I think it's like some bizarre law.
it's not even a rom-com, it's a movie designed to make you hate the human race for 129 minutes and leave that feeling lingering for at least 15 minutes.
Why is there always at least one terrible rom-com on every airline that plays a movie during the flight? I think it's like some bizarre law.
it's not even a rom-com, it's a movie designed to make you hate the human race for 129 minutes and leave that feeling lingering for at least 15 minutes.
most flights i'm on tend to have movie selections you can pick
I AM CASTING A VOTE FOR THORGOT, BUT MY RAGE HAS NOT BEEN LOCKED ON TARGET YET. IF A BETTER, MORE DESERVING TARGET APPEARS, ONE BETTER SUITED FOR THE SHEER POWER OF MY WRATHFUL ANGER, I WILL SHIFT IT.
Posts
Yeah, I'll do it later today after I'm back from PT. Slacker bum is slacker. For the moment, ZH's list of the living is accurate, I'm fairly sure.
I'm not sure that the combination of a throwaway day 1 vote then sheeping to a network call day 2 is all that damning, but even if it is, why did you leave Tehspectre and Zombie Hero off your list? They both did the same thing, and you're usually more thorough than that.
No. No.
I'm not saying it's 100%, but of the mafia we know, half fall into exactly that category. So it's a place to start.
TehSpectre voted for T_A on day 1, so I didn't mark him down as a throwaway. ZH had a vote with other people who changed on day 1. I couldn't remember if his vote was while others were on the wagon or not, so I kept him off the list as well. I'd happily listen to reasoning on either of them though.
Thorgot (1) - Zombie Hero
Xenogears of Bore (1) - Locus
Rainfall (1) - Bedlam
Delmain (1) - Hucklebuck
Mill (1) - Thorgot
Smasher(1) - SaberOverEasy
Fiaryn(1) - Premium
Anialios(1) - B:L
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Oops, you're right about spec - I was looking at the vote counts before I had coffee and confused a vote FOR him on day 1 for a vote BY him. My bad.
( sorry Lozenge, I was p sure you were a rival spreadsheeter!
I guess this is a good time to make it clear that, while I am putting up vote counts right now, it has nothing to do with my role.
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Seems like it had a bunch of mafia in it. And if there are many more then the mafia participants might actually out number the village participants.
Lets find out Saberovereasy
Maybe Cythraul is doug_grammar.
Oh my god, that guy
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
This is how we know you're new.
I think I barely remember doug_grammar.
Also, apologies for posting so little up till now. I have a transatlantic flight tomorrow to get back to school and have been preparing for that. I should be able to make my voting and posting requirements for the rest of this game, but will alert the hosts if I am unable to.
Shit, I've been playing for 3+ years and that name doesn't ring a bell for me.
thorgot's vote counts towards him.
I mean
Hey there phalla people
Steam
Day 1 position + too busy to play = suspiciousssss
Thetheroo
Island Name: Felinefine
and there are reserves..so
Obi threw a vote on him
Let's see what it meant
Spoit (1) - Anialos
Thorgot (1) - Zombie Hero
Xenogears of Bore (1) - Locus
Delmain (1) - Hucklebuck
M.D. (1) - Thorgot
Smasher(1) - SaberOverEasy
Anialios(1) - B:L
Thetheroo (1) - Gizzy
SaberOverEasy (1) - Bedlam
TehSpectre (1) - Smasher
Rainfall (0) - Bedlam
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
hm? it hasn't been fixed in your post, quoting OL, at the top of pg 25. It hasn't been fixed in Saber's post on that same page. Gizzy appears to be quoting your post in their post just above this, and it hasn't been fixed there.
EDIT: What I really mean is: what post ought I use for voting infO?
i'm paying close attention to what you folks are doing too, so dont think cause i just jumped in I dunno what to do!
Steam
Yeah, I really have only myself to blame for that. Hopefully if I survive till Friday I can participate a whole lot more. Flying through 5 timezones with 3 layovers on the way is not going to be a fun trip.
ah you are correct. I was counting T_A for some reason. My mistake.
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Have fun , roo.
at least you won't have the same experience I did and have an airline that played this
it's not even a rom-com, it's a movie designed to make you hate the human race for 129 minutes and leave that feeling lingering for at least 15 minutes.
Although come to think of it, I find it sort of interesting that Cythraul didn't merit a replacement when he withdrew, but Mill did.
most flights i'm on tend to have movie selections you can pick
anyhow back to figuring things out
Steam
M.D.[/color what's new?
I can has cheezburger, yes?
Steam