As was foretold, we've added advertisements to the forums! If you have questions, or if you encounter any bugs, please visit this thread: https://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/240191/forum-advertisement-faq-and-reports-thread/
We're funding a new Acquisitions Incorporated series on Kickstarter right now! Check it out at https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/pennyarcade/acquisitions-incorporated-the-series-2

[Hearthstone] Beta - Patch changed some things, Freeze Mages still BS

18283858788100

Posts

  • I needed anime to post.I needed anime to post. boom Registered User regular
    jdarksun wrote: »
    jdarksun wrote: »
    Hell I got every deck to 10 in AI before touching Play because Fuuuuuuck Thaaaaat.
    Grinding out 10 against the AI may be super tedious, but it might be less frustrating than trying to play against real people with no cards. But that begs the question, why not give us all the damn cards to start with?
    Earning product increases customer attachment and promotes subsequent interactions with product and future monetization.
    None of those words make any sense in the context of how frustrating and stupid it is to either grind against the AI to unlock cards or punch yourself in the nuts against people to unlock cards.

    And yet you still play....they got you

    liEt3nH.png
  • BlueBlueBlueBlue Registered User regular
    Knight_ wrote: »
    Blehhh lost a game to 3rd mind control on my venture co in arena after fighting to deal with 2 soulpriests as well.

    And that's whatever, but when a dude then says thank you after, it makes me not want to play anymore. i don't think mc is really that great in constructed, but it's infuriating in arena.

    ...my apologies

    CD World Tour status:
    Baidol Voprostein Avraham Thetheroo Taya Zerofill Effef Crimson King Lalabox Mortal Sky ASimPerson Sal Wiet Theidar Tynic Speed Racer Neotoma Goatmon ==>Larlar Munkus Beaver Day of the Bear miscellaneousinsanity Skull Man Delzhand Caulk Bite 6 Somestickguy
  • 38thDoe38thDoe lets never be stupid again wait lets always be stupid foreverRegistered User regular
    I got all my classes to ten with the default cards, didn't seem terrible, but I read that article on the good neutral minions before I started playing.

  • jdarksunjdarksun Struggler VARegistered User regular
    jdarksun wrote: »
    jdarksun wrote: »
    Hell I got every deck to 10 in AI before touching Play because Fuuuuuuck Thaaaaat.
    Grinding out 10 against the AI may be super tedious, but it might be less frustrating than trying to play against real people with no cards. But that begs the question, why not give us all the damn cards to start with?
    Earning product increases customer attachment and promotes subsequent interactions with product and future monetization.
    None of those words make any sense in the context of how frustrating and stupid it is to either grind against the AI to unlock cards or punch yourself in the nuts against people to unlock cards.
    And yet you still play....they got you
    But I've given them no money! Nyaa~~~ ;)

  • I needed anime to post.I needed anime to post. boom Registered User regular
    jdarksun wrote: »
    jdarksun wrote: »
    jdarksun wrote: »
    Hell I got every deck to 10 in AI before touching Play because Fuuuuuuck Thaaaaat.
    Grinding out 10 against the AI may be super tedious, but it might be less frustrating than trying to play against real people with no cards. But that begs the question, why not give us all the damn cards to start with?
    Earning product increases customer attachment and promotes subsequent interactions with product and future monetization.
    None of those words make any sense in the context of how frustrating and stupid it is to either grind against the AI to unlock cards or punch yourself in the nuts against people to unlock cards.
    And yet you still play....they got you
    But I've given them no money! Nyaa~~~ ;)

    you've streamed games and caused others to criticize your games increasing their own connection to the product

    you've become an advertisement!

    liEt3nH.png
  • shrykeshryke Member of the Beast Registered User regular
    This is annoying, I keep getting gold versions of a basic Shaman spell, but I cannot disenchant the gold or the regular version... would this be a bug or intended?

    You can't disenchant basic cards and you get them in a set order as you level the class.

  • KafkaAUKafkaAU Western AustraliaRegistered User regular
    BlueBlue wrote: »
    Knight_ wrote: »
    Blehhh lost a game to 3rd mind control on my venture co in arena after fighting to deal with 2 soulpriests as well.

    And that's whatever, but when a dude then says thank you after, it makes me not want to play anymore. i don't think mc is really that great in constructed, but it's infuriating in arena.

    ...my apologies

    Guy was doing the same to me in constructed playing my shaman deck. I played my earth elemental out, and he says "thank you" then plays out black knight. I play out my fire elemental, cause if I don't I'm going to get crushed anyway, and he also says "thank you" and MCs it.

    Squelched after that (not that the game was much longer).

    steam_sig.png
    Origin: KafkaAU B-Net: Kafka#1778
  • heenatoheenato Alice Leywind Registered User regular
    Man. The druid really IS dumb about suiciding into my 9-7 creature.

    M A G I K A Z A M
  • JAEFJAEF Unstoppably Bald Registered User regular
    heenato wrote: »
    Man. The druid really IS dumb about suiciding into my 9-7 creature.
    I can do one damage to it, this is totally fucking worth it ~ Druid AI 2013

  • TorgaironTorgairon Registered User regular
    rogue or warrior daily is the worst punishment this game has to offer. warrior is awful in general and I have no idea how people make rogue work in constructed. I am something like 0-5 so far and I want to uninstall so fucking badly.

  • heenatoheenato Alice Leywind Registered User regular
    JAEF wrote: »
    heenato wrote: »
    Man. The druid really IS dumb about suiciding into my 9-7 creature.
    I can do one damage to it, this is totally fucking worth it ~ Druid AI 2013
    My favorite part is that it used an innervate to do it.

    M A G I K A Z A M
  • VorpalVorpal Registered User regular
    Rogue would be much better in constructed if not for the million mages out there.
    One of the problems is that, IMO, the basic sets for both those classes are pretty bad.

    If you make a good neutral minion set and then put in rogue cards like assassinate, deadly poison, assassins blade, backstab, it's not too bad.

    Defias ringleader and eviscerate are both also great, and are commons.

    steam_sig.png
    PSN: Vorpallion Twitch: Vorpallion
  • Knight_Knight_ Dead Dead Dead Registered User regular
    who the fuck gets 3 fucking aldor peacekeepers in a single draft and also draws them all by turn 7. peacekeepered both of my venture cos.

    hooray for 0-3 with this rogue even though i think the deck is good. first loss was to a rogue with 4 assassinates a carine and a sylvanus. eyerollllll.

    aeNqQM9.jpg
    KafkaAU
  • KafkaAUKafkaAU Western AustraliaRegistered User regular
    Same people that get 3 fire elementals and then play them on turns 6, 7 and 8!

    steam_sig.png
    Origin: KafkaAU B-Net: Kafka#1778
    Knight_
  • enlightenedbumenlightenedbum Registered User regular
    Freeze effects generally seem under costed.

    Self-righteousness is incompatible with coalition building.
  • InvictusInvictus Registered User regular
    jdarksun wrote: »
    Hell I got every deck to 10 in AI before touching Play because Fuuuuuuck Thaaaaat.
    Grinding out 10 against the AI may be super tedious, but it might be less frustrating than trying to play against real people with no cards. But that begs the question, why not give us all the damn cards to start with?

    Looking for feedback on my two most recent Shaman losses. The Priest had a perfect start followed by me getting screwed by the RNG, but I manage to drag it out for a while before getting crushed.

    Game #2, vs. a Mage... just couldn't get on the board.

    Starting the VoD linked to in this post, comments below. Comments are made before seeing what happens in the rest of the vod. I'll pause before each of your turns and say what I would do in that spot.

    First game:
    (Spoilered for long)
    you should /definitely/ mulligan far sight in that spot. The problem with your first draw is that you don't have a 2drop, and you desperately need a 2drop, and something to do both of the first two turns would be better. If I'm dealt that hand, the question is whether I mulligan the imp master; I mulligan the rest immediately without thought. I need a 2drop, and a 1drop would be great.

    On your turn 2, I seriously consider coining out the imp master or the acolyte. On review, I decide since he's got a northshire out, the imp master is a bad idea because you're feeding him cards, but you can draw cards with the acolyte because all of his minions are low power. I would have settled on coining out the acolyte.

    I think coining out taz'dingo is a perfectly defensible option on that turn. The problem with it is that he's going to charge your taz'dingo with the northshire, heal it, then kill the taz'dingo with a buffed lightkeeper. You're in a really bad spot; both of his options out scale with time. I seriously consider rockbiter on you, killing the lightkeeper, then putting out a totem. Alternately, I would coin out the acolyte after I rockbiter the lightkeeper. I think that's what I would've done, intending to put out taz'dingo the turn after, so I can carefully control what damages the acolyte.

    Yup, that went the way I thought it would. The lightwell is pretty bad for us, but the spellbreaker is exactly the right thing. I'm pretty sure I would silence the lightwell because that way I can more or less ignore the lightwell for the rest of the game, whereas the cleric still does damage. Either one of them is fine, I think. Ah, but silencing the cleric would also remove PW:S. I think either option is fine, but you have to play the spellbreaker.

    uggggggh. the inner fire play is /awful/ for us, even though it's a pretty bad misplay for them to put it on the cleric and not the lightwell. if he innerfires the light well, the lightwell survives then heals itself next turn. The one upside is that he draws a card this way from the cult master, but I prefer the greater board control from the additional creature.

    The acolyte's a bad play for us now because the cult master kills it for free, then gets healed. I play the imp master and totem.

    Wow, that far sight turned out /amazing/ for us. That was pretty much the best card possible in that spot.

    Ugh, mindgames into flametongue is pretty bad. Board position is awful now. I think I go for whatever is necessary to get board position; that means imp master, sunfury to give imp master taunt, then rockbiter kill on the lightwell.

    Comment on your play: toteming in that spot is pretty bad. You don't have board control, and moreover the things that out for him are going to improve whatever else he plays. If we strike now and do whatever we can to grab back board control, we can actually be in a pretty good spot. Toteming is awful for that; two of our four totems are utterly useless right now, and a third is borderline at best.

    You should kill the lightwell, not the flametongue. He's a priest, he only has access to neutral charge minions, you'll be able to kill the flametongue next turn before any other minions he plays can attack. But once we've burned the rockbiter, we actually don't have enough damage to kill the lightwell before it heals itself.

    You draw the lightning bolt and immediately use it on the thing with four health. I think that's a bad move, the dalaran mage is a 1/4, nothing significant, and our opponent's a priest; spell power affects holy nova, holy fire, holy smite, and mind blast. None of those are particular threats right now; even holy nova doesn't actually hurt us too bad. Better to use it to kill a thing that matters, like that 3/3. I run an imp into the divine shield guy, then kill him with lightning bolt. Then I summon the acolyte on the right side of everything, then sunfury between the acolyte and the totem, so that those two things get taunt.

    The other option that turn is to summon the stormwind champion and use the imp and the imp master to kill the dalaran mage, then sac the totem to break the divine shield. On review, I actually like that better; it leaves us with some removal next turn and also has a big meaty dude out he's got to deal with.

    Next turn, I've got the capacity to go for the board clear, so I do it. Here's option 1: Summon stormwind champion, use your silenced totem and spellpower totem to kill the owl, then run both imps into the 4/4 and your sunfury protector into the 3/3. That leaves us them with a clear board, and on our side, a 2/3 imp master, a newly produced 2/2 imp, a 3/1 sunfury protector, and a 6/6 champion of stormwind. It's a pretty good spot for us. Things could go pretty bad if he's got a mind control, but otherwise it's a good spot.

    Option 2 is the flametongue between the sunfury and the silenced totem, and use those two to pop the taunts, then use the imp that moves next to the flametongue to trade for the 3/3. Then we summon the acolyte of pain and a totem. That leaves us with a 1/2 imp master, 1/1 new imp, 3/1 old imp, 0/3 flametongue, 2/2 spellpower totem with taunt, and the new totem and the acolyte off to the side. This one is very vulnerable to holy nova, though not mind control. Between the two, I pick vulnerability to holy nova and the second option; even if he novas, it will get us another card from the acolyte and we should expect to bring out the champion next turn.

    Ugh. You misplaced the flametongue and it meant you both traded badly and didn't clear his board.

    Next turn, you draw the novice engineer and immediately play it. I get that you're hoping for the instawin on bloodlust, but you can't play the stormwind champion until something dies because you're maxed on minions now. Play the stormwind champion first, kill the silverback with the acolyte (free card!) and an imp, then summon the engineer. Then kill his 3/3 argus with your now 3/4 sunfury. You've got 6 damage worth of minions left after that, you can kill the 6/6, but I'd just lunge for the face. He's likely to trade his 6/6 for your 6/6, and I'd prefer to have 3 smaller minions instead of one big one because of bloodlust.

    You have /got/ to use your acolyte to attack 1 power things. You want your acolyte to take as many small hits as possible, so whenever there's a 1-power thing out there, hit it with your acolyte.

    MC on the champion to be expected. SW:P on the acolyte suuuuucks. Totem first, see what we get. We're hoping for taunt, but probably wont' change things. I'd fire elemental on the champion, then kill it with a rockbiter'd silenced totem. Need to get some use out of that totem, and something's got to die. We'd like to keep as many things around as possible for when bloodlust comes.

    If you kill the stormwind first, the frostwolf will become a 6/6.

    Next turn: kill champ with fire elemental, go for the face with everything else.

    Holy nova: game ender unless you draw another fire elemental. Everything afterward is inconsequential.

    First game is all I have time for now.

    Generalísimo de Fuerzas Armadas de la República Argentina
  • VorpalVorpal Registered User regular
    Knight_ wrote: »
    who the fuck gets 3 fucking aldor peacekeepers in a single draft and also draws them all by turn 7. peacekeepered both of my venture cos.

    hooray for 0-3 with this rogue even though i think the deck is good. first loss was to a rogue with 4 assassinates a carine and a sylvanus. eyerollllll.

    Sometimes you just get rolled by people who flat out had vastly better draft options. Unless they fix that, I don't really see people paying $$ for arena much. If it's just virtual gold your spending, well, it can be irritating, but you haven't lost anything rela.

    I too have been in the sadface club of aldor peacekeepered venture mercs. I was so begging to top deck a silence :p

    steam_sig.png
    PSN: Vorpallion Twitch: Vorpallion
  • MazzyxMazzyx Comedy Gold Registered User regular
    Vorpal wrote: »
    Knight_ wrote: »
    who the fuck gets 3 fucking aldor peacekeepers in a single draft and also draws them all by turn 7. peacekeepered both of my venture cos.

    hooray for 0-3 with this rogue even though i think the deck is good. first loss was to a rogue with 4 assassinates a carine and a sylvanus. eyerollllll.

    Sometimes you just get rolled by people who flat out had vastly better draft options. Unless they fix that, I don't really see people paying $$ for arena much. If it's just virtual gold your spending, well, it can be irritating, but you haven't lost anything rela.

    I too have been in the sadface club of aldor peacekeepered venture mercs. I was so begging to top deck a silence :p

    Silence doesn't fix it because it changes the attack value to 1 not reduces it to 1.

    u7stthr17eud.png
  • I needed anime to post.I needed anime to post. boom Registered User regular
    Silence would remove the mana increase of Venture Co though

    liEt3nH.png
  • BlueBlueBlueBlue Registered User regular
    I thought that silence did fix it

    CD World Tour status:
    Baidol Voprostein Avraham Thetheroo Taya Zerofill Effef Crimson King Lalabox Mortal Sky ASimPerson Sal Wiet Theidar Tynic Speed Racer Neotoma Goatmon ==>Larlar Munkus Beaver Day of the Bear miscellaneousinsanity Skull Man Delzhand Caulk Bite 6 Somestickguy
  • MazzyxMazzyx Comedy Gold Registered User regular
    BlueBlue wrote: »
    I thought that silence did fix it

    There are two different things change and like increase or reduce. Aldo doesn't green things so it isn't silenceable. It is basically altering the cards text or so I remember. Someone might want to test this.

    u7stthr17eud.png
  • InvictusInvictus Registered User regular
    Mazzyx wrote: »
    BlueBlue wrote: »
    I thought that silence did fix it

    There are two different things change and like increase or reduce. Aldo doesn't green things so it isn't silenceable. It is basically altering the cards text or so I remember. Someone might want to test this.

    I am confident silence does not change back something hit by aldor peacekeeper. Same thing for health and equality.

    Generalísimo de Fuerzas Armadas de la República Argentina
    Mazzyx
  • enlightenedbumenlightenedbum Registered User regular
    edited December 2013
    Vorpal wrote: »
    Knight_ wrote: »
    who the fuck gets 3 fucking aldor peacekeepers in a single draft and also draws them all by turn 7. peacekeepered both of my venture cos.

    hooray for 0-3 with this rogue even though i think the deck is good. first loss was to a rogue with 4 assassinates a carine and a sylvanus. eyerollllll.

    Sometimes you just get rolled by people who flat out had vastly better draft options. Unless they fix that, I don't really see people paying $$ for arena much. If it's just virtual gold your spending, well, it can be irritating, but you haven't lost anything rela.

    I too have been in the sadface club of aldor peacekeepered venture mercs. I was so begging to top deck a silence :p

    I think Wizards' experience says this is wrong. Running into say, the doubling hydra or Jace in M14 is not a fun experience. And yet you keep doing them.

    Granted, running the doubling hydra is good times.

    enlightenedbum on
    Self-righteousness is incompatible with coalition building.
  • KafkaAUKafkaAU Western AustraliaRegistered User regular
    Silence removes all text from a card. Pretty sure it removes a peacekeepering.

    steam_sig.png
    Origin: KafkaAU B-Net: Kafka#1778
  • BillmaanBillmaan Registered User regular
    KafkaAU wrote: »
    Silence removes all text from a card. Pretty sure it removes a peacekeepering.
    I'm also pretty sure I've silenced off a peacekeeper debuff before.

  • BlueBlueBlueBlue Registered User regular
    Invictus wrote: »
    Mazzyx wrote: »
    BlueBlue wrote: »
    I thought that silence did fix it

    There are two different things change and like increase or reduce. Aldo doesn't green things so it isn't silenceable. It is basically altering the cards text or so I remember. Someone might want to test this.

    I am confident silence does not change back something hit by aldor peacekeeper. Same thing for health and equality.

    how confident are you

    CD World Tour status:
    Baidol Voprostein Avraham Thetheroo Taya Zerofill Effef Crimson King Lalabox Mortal Sky ASimPerson Sal Wiet Theidar Tynic Speed Racer Neotoma Goatmon ==>Larlar Munkus Beaver Day of the Bear miscellaneousinsanity Skull Man Delzhand Caulk Bite 6 Somestickguy
  • FrosteeyFrosteey Elaise 1521-2945-8940Registered User regular
    Silence 100% cancels out peacekeeper/humility.

    Also works on Equality, which, I don't even know, that's how it works.

  • KafkaAUKafkaAU Western AustraliaRegistered User regular
    edited December 2013
    Silence removes equality, which restores the minion to original maximum health, however it's at 1 health, so it's now at 1 health of max.

    KafkaAU on
    steam_sig.png
    Origin: KafkaAU B-Net: Kafka#1778
  • Gnome-InterruptusGnome-Interruptus Registered User regular
    shryke wrote: »
    This is annoying, I keep getting gold versions of a basic Shaman spell, but I cannot disenchant the gold or the regular version... would this be a bug or intended?

    You can't disenchant basic cards and you get them in a set order as you level the class.

    Yes, I'm only half talking about the cards you get as you level to 10, I'm saying, once you have 2 of [insert card] that cannot be disenchanted, why would the game give you even more of [exact same card] that also cannot be disenchanted.

    It seems incredibly pointless, and as a newbie, also incredibly frustrating to get 100% useless cards that I cannot do anything with, because I already have 2 of that exact same card, and I cannot equip the same card more than 2x in a deck.

    steam_sig.png
    MWO: Adamski
  • FrosteeyFrosteey Elaise 1521-2945-8940Registered User regular
    KafkaAU wrote: »
    Silence removes equality, which restores the minion to original maximum health, however it's at 1 health, so it's now at 1 health of max.

    It restores health too. If there's a 5/5hp, you Equality it to 1/1hp, silence brings it back to 5/5hp.

    They should just remove Paladin really.

  • hippofanthippofant ティンク Registered User regular
    It seems incredibly pointless, and as a newbie, also incredibly frustrating to get 100% useless cards that I cannot do anything with, because I already have 2 of that exact same card, and I cannot equip the same card more than 2x in a deck.

    Authentic World of Warcraft experience!

  • InvictusInvictus Registered User regular
    shryke wrote: »
    This is annoying, I keep getting gold versions of a basic Shaman spell, but I cannot disenchant the gold or the regular version... would this be a bug or intended?

    You can't disenchant basic cards and you get them in a set order as you level the class.

    Yes, I'm only half talking about the cards you get as you level to 10, I'm saying, once you have 2 of [insert card] that cannot be disenchanted, why would the game give you even more of [exact same card] that also cannot be disenchanted.

    It seems incredibly pointless, and as a newbie, also incredibly frustrating to get 100% useless cards that I cannot do anything with, because I already have 2 of that exact same card, and I cannot equip the same card more than 2x in a deck.

    But these are prettier!

    Generalísimo de Fuerzas Armadas de la República Argentina
    38thDoe
  • KafkaAUKafkaAU Western AustraliaRegistered User regular
    Frosteey wrote: »
    KafkaAU wrote: »
    Silence removes equality, which restores the minion to original maximum health, however it's at 1 health, so it's now at 1 health of max.

    It restores health too. If there's a 5/5hp, you Equality it to 1/1hp, silence brings it back to 5/5hp.

    They should just remove Paladin really.

    Ahh this is their wierd damage mechanic at play. Since when you equality something it takes it to 1 health with 0 damage, when you remove the text you get restored back to normal health at 0 damage. The way I remembered their wording works for all instances except for equality I guess!

    steam_sig.png
    Origin: KafkaAU B-Net: Kafka#1778
  • VorpalVorpal Registered User regular
    You want to silence your venture co even if it doesn't remove peacekeepering because it's not a threat at 1 attack and will not be removed, which means you can't play any additional minions and you have no threat on the board :(

    steam_sig.png
    PSN: Vorpallion Twitch: Vorpallion
  • sanstodosanstodo Registered User regular
    If other people's emotes bug you, just squelch them at the start if every game. Focus on your own play, not on their possible lack of courtesy.

  • Wooden SpoonWooden Spoon Great for SaucesRegistered User regular
    Just opened my first freebie pack from Arena.

    Hungry Crab, Pyromancer, Argent Squire...Onyxia. I'll take it.

    FFXIV:Iadrich Loffel
    Wooden Spoon on Steam
    3DS: 1005-8709-0277
    jdarksunSeGaTaiMolybdenumArithon32
  • DraevenDraeven Registered User regular
    currently running an interesting shaman arena deck, currently 2-1
    0 Ancestrial healing
    1 earth shock
    1 lightning bolt x3
    1 dust devil x2
    2 storm forged axe
    2 Ancestral spirit
    2 mana addict
    2 nat pagle
    3 hex
    3 lava burst
    3 mana tide totem x2
    3 tauren warrior x2
    3 unbound elemental
    3 Wolf rider
    4 dark Iron dwarf
    4 spell breaker x2
    4 wind speaker
    5 Earth elemental
    5 Gadgatzan auctioneer
    5 Gurubashi Berserker
    6 Fire Elemental
    7 storm wind champion
    Its kind of all over the place, but with the mana tide totems out i dont have a problem with card shortages and with my silence minions can handle most of the crappy text heavy beasts they throw at me.

    Morskitter wrote "Spikes, choppas, tentacles, magic? Can't hold a candle to Sergeant Pimp here."

  • jdarksunjdarksun Struggler VARegistered User regular
    Invictus wrote: »
    jdarksun wrote: »
    Hell I got every deck to 10 in AI before touching Play because Fuuuuuuck Thaaaaat.
    Grinding out 10 against the AI may be super tedious, but it might be less frustrating than trying to play against real people with no cards. But that begs the question, why not give us all the damn cards to start with?

    Looking for feedback on my two most recent Shaman losses. The Priest had a perfect start followed by me getting screwed by the RNG, but I manage to drag it out for a while before getting crushed.

    Game #2, vs. a Mage... just couldn't get on the board.

    Starting the VoD linked to in this post, comments below. Comments are made before seeing what happens in the rest of the vod. I'll pause before each of your turns and say what I would do in that spot.

    First game:
    (Spoilered for long)
    you should /definitely/ mulligan far sight in that spot. The problem with your first draw is that you don't have a 2drop, and you desperately need a 2drop, and something to do both of the first two turns would be better. If I'm dealt that hand, the question is whether I mulligan the imp master; I mulligan the rest immediately without thought. I need a 2drop, and a 1drop would be great.

    On your turn 2, I seriously consider coining out the imp master or the acolyte. On review, I decide since he's got a northshire out, the imp master is a bad idea because you're feeding him cards, but you can draw cards with the acolyte because all of his minions are low power. I would have settled on coining out the acolyte.

    I think coining out taz'dingo is a perfectly defensible option on that turn. The problem with it is that he's going to charge your taz'dingo with the northshire, heal it, then kill the taz'dingo with a buffed lightkeeper. You're in a really bad spot; both of his options out scale with time. I seriously consider rockbiter on you, killing the lightkeeper, then putting out a totem. Alternately, I would coin out the acolyte after I rockbiter the lightkeeper. I think that's what I would've done, intending to put out taz'dingo the turn after, so I can carefully control what damages the acolyte.

    Yup, that went the way I thought it would. The lightwell is pretty bad for us, but the spellbreaker is exactly the right thing. I'm pretty sure I would silence the lightwell because that way I can more or less ignore the lightwell for the rest of the game, whereas the cleric still does damage. Either one of them is fine, I think. Ah, but silencing the cleric would also remove PW:S. I think either option is fine, but you have to play the spellbreaker.

    uggggggh. the inner fire play is /awful/ for us, even though it's a pretty bad misplay for them to put it on the cleric and not the lightwell. if he innerfires the light well, the lightwell survives then heals itself next turn. The one upside is that he draws a card this way from the cult master, but I prefer the greater board control from the additional creature.

    The acolyte's a bad play for us now because the cult master kills it for free, then gets healed. I play the imp master and totem.

    Wow, that far sight turned out /amazing/ for us. That was pretty much the best card possible in that spot.

    Ugh, mindgames into flametongue is pretty bad. Board position is awful now. I think I go for whatever is necessary to get board position; that means imp master, sunfury to give imp master taunt, then rockbiter kill on the lightwell.

    Comment on your play: toteming in that spot is pretty bad. You don't have board control, and moreover the things that out for him are going to improve whatever else he plays. If we strike now and do whatever we can to grab back board control, we can actually be in a pretty good spot. Toteming is awful for that; two of our four totems are utterly useless right now, and a third is borderline at best.

    You should kill the lightwell, not the flametongue. He's a priest, he only has access to neutral charge minions, you'll be able to kill the flametongue next turn before any other minions he plays can attack. But once we've burned the rockbiter, we actually don't have enough damage to kill the lightwell before it heals itself.

    You draw the lightning bolt and immediately use it on the thing with four health. I think that's a bad move, the dalaran mage is a 1/4, nothing significant, and our opponent's a priest; spell power affects holy nova, holy fire, holy smite, and mind blast. None of those are particular threats right now; even holy nova doesn't actually hurt us too bad. Better to use it to kill a thing that matters, like that 3/3. I run an imp into the divine shield guy, then kill him with lightning bolt. Then I summon the acolyte on the right side of everything, then sunfury between the acolyte and the totem, so that those two things get taunt.

    The other option that turn is to summon the stormwind champion and use the imp and the imp master to kill the dalaran mage, then sac the totem to break the divine shield. On review, I actually like that better; it leaves us with some removal next turn and also has a big meaty dude out he's got to deal with.

    Next turn, I've got the capacity to go for the board clear, so I do it. Here's option 1: Summon stormwind champion, use your silenced totem and spellpower totem to kill the owl, then run both imps into the 4/4 and your sunfury protector into the 3/3. That leaves us them with a clear board, and on our side, a 2/3 imp master, a newly produced 2/2 imp, a 3/1 sunfury protector, and a 6/6 champion of stormwind. It's a pretty good spot for us. Things could go pretty bad if he's got a mind control, but otherwise it's a good spot.

    Option 2 is the flametongue between the sunfury and the silenced totem, and use those two to pop the taunts, then use the imp that moves next to the flametongue to trade for the 3/3. Then we summon the acolyte of pain and a totem. That leaves us with a 1/2 imp master, 1/1 new imp, 3/1 old imp, 0/3 flametongue, 2/2 spellpower totem with taunt, and the new totem and the acolyte off to the side. This one is very vulnerable to holy nova, though not mind control. Between the two, I pick vulnerability to holy nova and the second option; even if he novas, it will get us another card from the acolyte and we should expect to bring out the champion next turn.

    Ugh. You misplaced the flametongue and it meant you both traded badly and didn't clear his board.

    Next turn, you draw the novice engineer and immediately play it. I get that you're hoping for the instawin on bloodlust, but you can't play the stormwind champion until something dies because you're maxed on minions now. Play the stormwind champion first, kill the silverback with the acolyte (free card!) and an imp, then summon the engineer. Then kill his 3/3 argus with your now 3/4 sunfury. You've got 6 damage worth of minions left after that, you can kill the 6/6, but I'd just lunge for the face. He's likely to trade his 6/6 for your 6/6, and I'd prefer to have 3 smaller minions instead of one big one because of bloodlust.

    You have /got/ to use your acolyte to attack 1 power things. You want your acolyte to take as many small hits as possible, so whenever there's a 1-power thing out there, hit it with your acolyte.

    MC on the champion to be expected. SW:P on the acolyte suuuuucks. Totem first, see what we get. We're hoping for taunt, but probably wont' change things. I'd fire elemental on the champion, then kill it with a rockbiter'd silenced totem. Need to get some use out of that totem, and something's got to die. We'd like to keep as many things around as possible for when bloodlust comes.

    If you kill the stormwind first, the frostwolf will become a 6/6.

    Next turn: kill champ with fire elemental, go for the face with everything else.

    Holy nova: game ender unless you draw another fire elemental. Everything afterward is inconsequential.

    First game is all I have time for now.
    Why are you super into killing the Lightwell? It seems pretty innocuous.

  • enlightenedbumenlightenedbum Registered User regular
    jdarksun wrote: »
    Invictus wrote: »
    jdarksun wrote: »
    Hell I got every deck to 10 in AI before touching Play because Fuuuuuuck Thaaaaat.
    Grinding out 10 against the AI may be super tedious, but it might be less frustrating than trying to play against real people with no cards. But that begs the question, why not give us all the damn cards to start with?

    Looking for feedback on my two most recent Shaman losses. The Priest had a perfect start followed by me getting screwed by the RNG, but I manage to drag it out for a while before getting crushed.

    Game #2, vs. a Mage... just couldn't get on the board.

    Starting the VoD linked to in this post, comments below. Comments are made before seeing what happens in the rest of the vod. I'll pause before each of your turns and say what I would do in that spot.

    First game:
    (Spoilered for long)
    you should /definitely/ mulligan far sight in that spot. The problem with your first draw is that you don't have a 2drop, and you desperately need a 2drop, and something to do both of the first two turns would be better. If I'm dealt that hand, the question is whether I mulligan the imp master; I mulligan the rest immediately without thought. I need a 2drop, and a 1drop would be great.

    On your turn 2, I seriously consider coining out the imp master or the acolyte. On review, I decide since he's got a northshire out, the imp master is a bad idea because you're feeding him cards, but you can draw cards with the acolyte because all of his minions are low power. I would have settled on coining out the acolyte.

    I think coining out taz'dingo is a perfectly defensible option on that turn. The problem with it is that he's going to charge your taz'dingo with the northshire, heal it, then kill the taz'dingo with a buffed lightkeeper. You're in a really bad spot; both of his options out scale with time. I seriously consider rockbiter on you, killing the lightkeeper, then putting out a totem. Alternately, I would coin out the acolyte after I rockbiter the lightkeeper. I think that's what I would've done, intending to put out taz'dingo the turn after, so I can carefully control what damages the acolyte.

    Yup, that went the way I thought it would. The lightwell is pretty bad for us, but the spellbreaker is exactly the right thing. I'm pretty sure I would silence the lightwell because that way I can more or less ignore the lightwell for the rest of the game, whereas the cleric still does damage. Either one of them is fine, I think. Ah, but silencing the cleric would also remove PW:S. I think either option is fine, but you have to play the spellbreaker.

    uggggggh. the inner fire play is /awful/ for us, even though it's a pretty bad misplay for them to put it on the cleric and not the lightwell. if he innerfires the light well, the lightwell survives then heals itself next turn. The one upside is that he draws a card this way from the cult master, but I prefer the greater board control from the additional creature.

    The acolyte's a bad play for us now because the cult master kills it for free, then gets healed. I play the imp master and totem.

    Wow, that far sight turned out /amazing/ for us. That was pretty much the best card possible in that spot.

    Ugh, mindgames into flametongue is pretty bad. Board position is awful now. I think I go for whatever is necessary to get board position; that means imp master, sunfury to give imp master taunt, then rockbiter kill on the lightwell.

    Comment on your play: toteming in that spot is pretty bad. You don't have board control, and moreover the things that out for him are going to improve whatever else he plays. If we strike now and do whatever we can to grab back board control, we can actually be in a pretty good spot. Toteming is awful for that; two of our four totems are utterly useless right now, and a third is borderline at best.

    You should kill the lightwell, not the flametongue. He's a priest, he only has access to neutral charge minions, you'll be able to kill the flametongue next turn before any other minions he plays can attack. But once we've burned the rockbiter, we actually don't have enough damage to kill the lightwell before it heals itself.

    You draw the lightning bolt and immediately use it on the thing with four health. I think that's a bad move, the dalaran mage is a 1/4, nothing significant, and our opponent's a priest; spell power affects holy nova, holy fire, holy smite, and mind blast. None of those are particular threats right now; even holy nova doesn't actually hurt us too bad. Better to use it to kill a thing that matters, like that 3/3. I run an imp into the divine shield guy, then kill him with lightning bolt. Then I summon the acolyte on the right side of everything, then sunfury between the acolyte and the totem, so that those two things get taunt.

    The other option that turn is to summon the stormwind champion and use the imp and the imp master to kill the dalaran mage, then sac the totem to break the divine shield. On review, I actually like that better; it leaves us with some removal next turn and also has a big meaty dude out he's got to deal with.

    Next turn, I've got the capacity to go for the board clear, so I do it. Here's option 1: Summon stormwind champion, use your silenced totem and spellpower totem to kill the owl, then run both imps into the 4/4 and your sunfury protector into the 3/3. That leaves us them with a clear board, and on our side, a 2/3 imp master, a newly produced 2/2 imp, a 3/1 sunfury protector, and a 6/6 champion of stormwind. It's a pretty good spot for us. Things could go pretty bad if he's got a mind control, but otherwise it's a good spot.

    Option 2 is the flametongue between the sunfury and the silenced totem, and use those two to pop the taunts, then use the imp that moves next to the flametongue to trade for the 3/3. Then we summon the acolyte of pain and a totem. That leaves us with a 1/2 imp master, 1/1 new imp, 3/1 old imp, 0/3 flametongue, 2/2 spellpower totem with taunt, and the new totem and the acolyte off to the side. This one is very vulnerable to holy nova, though not mind control. Between the two, I pick vulnerability to holy nova and the second option; even if he novas, it will get us another card from the acolyte and we should expect to bring out the champion next turn.

    Ugh. You misplaced the flametongue and it meant you both traded badly and didn't clear his board.

    Next turn, you draw the novice engineer and immediately play it. I get that you're hoping for the instawin on bloodlust, but you can't play the stormwind champion until something dies because you're maxed on minions now. Play the stormwind champion first, kill the silverback with the acolyte (free card!) and an imp, then summon the engineer. Then kill his 3/3 argus with your now 3/4 sunfury. You've got 6 damage worth of minions left after that, you can kill the 6/6, but I'd just lunge for the face. He's likely to trade his 6/6 for your 6/6, and I'd prefer to have 3 smaller minions instead of one big one because of bloodlust.

    You have /got/ to use your acolyte to attack 1 power things. You want your acolyte to take as many small hits as possible, so whenever there's a 1-power thing out there, hit it with your acolyte.

    MC on the champion to be expected. SW:P on the acolyte suuuuucks. Totem first, see what we get. We're hoping for taunt, but probably wont' change things. I'd fire elemental on the champion, then kill it with a rockbiter'd silenced totem. Need to get some use out of that totem, and something's got to die. We'd like to keep as many things around as possible for when bloodlust comes.

    If you kill the stormwind first, the frostwolf will become a 6/6.

    Next turn: kill champ with fire elemental, go for the face with everything else.

    Holy nova: game ender unless you draw another fire elemental. Everything afterward is inconsequential.

    First game is all I have time for now.
    Why are you super into killing the Lightwell? It seems pretty innocuous.

    I dunno if he's thinking of it, but there's a lot of stupid obnoxious combos that killed me involving making that thing 10/10 on turn 3.

    Self-righteousness is incompatible with coalition building.
    SeGaTaiElbasunu
This discussion has been closed.