The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
[Camp Comic] Friday, February 6, 2015 - Seventeen Portrait
That obviously took a lot of artistic talent, but it's creeping me out. It's like Seventeen and The Grinch had a baby. Don't get me wrong, I could not draw that, it's just not my cup of tea. It's just hitting my uncanny valley right on the nose. I wish I could provide more constructive criticism. Honestly, if it was either more realistic or more cartoony, I think it would be better. It's honestly right in the uncanny valley.
Bah! I really like it and don't find it creepy in the slightest. Much less does it tread anywhere near 'uncanny valley' territory, at least for me. It's nothing like a realistic portrait.
The detail and grime do humanize Seventeen and encourage you to imagine her as a real kid, which I guess is sort of creepy, in that Camp Weedonwantcha has such an unrelentingly dark premise. But that tension is why the strip is so compelling in the first place.
I think the reaction might come from the shoulders... They're a little weird, really rolled forward. I've seen some people with shoulders like that, but it's not usual. I like seeing another view of the characters from the artist.
I love it! I've always wondered what the Camp W characters might look like in 'real life.' I think this is great, and the shoulders don't bother me—I actually think her posture is a good representation of her personality. I imagine she's holding her hands clasped in front of her, turning her head to the side a little impishly. I think the creepy factor comes from imagining them as real children, knowing the backstory. Can't wait to see Malachi and Brian.
Hah! Lordy, it took me far too long to get an account just for this comic. I've been following your works for years now, you've been one of my greater inspirations in the field of illustration and comics and the like.
As for our current illustration here, well, quite the split! Some people are unnerved by our seeming hybrid of realistic and cartoon sensibilities! It's sometimes a bit of pitfall, it is - the ole cartoonist's strength is in caricaturing reality, and sometimes it shows up in our stabs at realism, however well crafted it may be!
...it's either that, or the fact they're very good at seeing the crude in people's appeal. I know Katie is good at that! But I can also see why the shoulders seem odd - it's either a movement that makes more sense for people in motion, or one that could've used more rendering...or we need to stare more at shoulders. And here I am at a computer screen instead!
Pardon the lengthy comment Katie, I suppose it's a culmination of finally getting around to talking and because it's something I've studied a few times before. And maybe helpful in some small capacity...nah.
Keep it up, ya make me weeks at college much more bearable with your work!
EDIT - Also, Seventeen is my favorite of the main trio, so it's wonderful to see you capture her wide-eyed, grimy visage in such a way. Whoo!
I think it's adorable. Captures the impish confidence of childhood perfectly.
With regards to the shoulders, it looks like she just leaned back into the 'frame' - you can replicate the pose by leaning back from your keyboard and looking off to your right, as if you were trying to look around a corner or squeeze into a group photo happening behind you.
Please make these portraits available as prints. They're beautiful! And please consider doing a cat portrait too, since there are so many of them they must be considered near-main characters as well.
I am testing a comment as i see the comments here are run by the ones on the actual comic. I cannot seem to comment on any of them. When i type one in and press enter all i get is the sign in box again.
I probably should ask in a newer comic, but what color are Seventeen's eyes?
I've always thought they we're greenish, but they're actually blue here. And some of her siblings have blue eyes.
This actually bothered me for a while, because maybe this is the moment I find out I've been colorblind my entire life, but I need to know. Haha.
Posts
No offence, others seem to find it cute, not creepy.
The detail and grime do humanize Seventeen and encourage you to imagine her as a real kid, which I guess is sort of creepy, in that Camp Weedonwantcha has such an unrelentingly dark premise. But that tension is why the strip is so compelling in the first place.
I can't wait to see more of these!
As for our current illustration here, well, quite the split! Some people are unnerved by our seeming hybrid of realistic and cartoon sensibilities! It's sometimes a bit of pitfall, it is - the ole cartoonist's strength is in caricaturing reality, and sometimes it shows up in our stabs at realism, however well crafted it may be!
...it's either that, or the fact they're very good at seeing the crude in people's appeal. I know Katie is good at that! But I can also see why the shoulders seem odd - it's either a movement that makes more sense for people in motion, or one that could've used more rendering...or we need to stare more at shoulders. And here I am at a computer screen instead!
Pardon the lengthy comment Katie, I suppose it's a culmination of finally getting around to talking and because it's something I've studied a few times before. And maybe helpful in some small capacity...nah.
Keep it up, ya make me weeks at college much more bearable with your work!
EDIT - Also, Seventeen is my favorite of the main trio, so it's wonderful to see you capture her wide-eyed, grimy visage in such a way. Whoo!
No super long break here! Just needed some time to prepare a Kickstarter for the first book.
The comic will be back after this portrait series.
With regards to the shoulders, it looks like she just leaned back into the 'frame' - you can replicate the pose by leaning back from your keyboard and looking off to your right, as if you were trying to look around a corner or squeeze into a group photo happening behind you.
I like this idea
oh wait, yeah, kitty...
It is! Though this Malachi is named after a character from one of my favorite books, Sirens of Titan. :]
Oh wow, I've been pronouncing his name COMPLETELY wrong... "Mala-chee" instead of "Mal-a-kai"...
I've always thought they we're greenish, but they're actually blue here. And some of her siblings have blue eyes.
This actually bothered me for a while, because maybe this is the moment I find out I've been colorblind my entire life, but I need to know. Haha.
Mean parents are all too real.