As was foretold, we've added advertisements to the forums! If you have questions, or if you encounter any bugs, please visit this thread: https://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/240191/forum-advertisement-faq-and-reports-thread/

[Star Wars] Nothing quite as thrilling as galactic politics.

12357100

Posts

  • Donovan PuppyfuckerDonovan Puppyfucker A dagger in the dark is worth a thousand swords in the morningRegistered User regular
    Xeddicus wrote: »
    JoeUser wrote: »
    Minor question about the end:
    Why does Leia hug Rey, who she has never even met and wouldn't know? Is there some significance I'm missing?

    Well, we don't know for sure. But you can take some semi-reasonable guesses:
    At the least they're both force users so could be feeling the others state. Which calls for a hug. Then you get into who Rey really is maybe.
    We know Leia is probably about as Force sensitive as you can get without devoting your life to becoming a Jedi, and I personally suspect that Rey is extremely strong in the Force, like at Yoda levels or higher. They can likely "feel" each other. Plus we don't see every single piece of conversation between Han and Leia, and you know he was probably gibbering on about her - "this crazy shit is happening again, she's just like Luke, what the fuck is up with that?"

    SaraLunaDidgeridooFroThulhu
  • DecomposeyDecomposey Registered User regular
    edited December 2015
    JoeUser wrote: »
    Minor question about the end:
    Why does Leia hug Rey, who she has never even met and wouldn't know? Is there some significance I'm missing?

    Listen to the music that plays when that happens.
    It's the tune called 'Han Solo and the Princess', commonly known as the Han and Leia love song. It plays in the movies, Original Trilogy and New, when Han and Leia have a touching moment. When Leia and Rey hug, they play THAT song. Probably for the last time. I've seen the movie three times, and it chokes me up every time. The looks on their faces are obviously pained and sad, they hug because they are both grieving Han. One the man she loved, the other the father she never had.

    Also, everyone sad that Finn figures aren't selling, maybe that's just where you are. Near me the only figure left on the shelves is the alien X-wing pilot.

    Decomposey on
    Before following any advice, opinions, or thoughts I may have expressed in the above post, be warned: I found Keven Costners "Waterworld" to be a very entertaining film.
    NeoTomaTankHammer
  • KarlKarl Registered User regular
    Can't really blame them to be fair,

  • Al_watAl_wat Registered User regular
    So apparently Episode 8 has a release date of May 2017.

    That is actually a lot sooner than I would have expected. I'm kind of impressed.

  • Donovan PuppyfuckerDonovan Puppyfucker A dagger in the dark is worth a thousand swords in the morningRegistered User regular
    Decomposey wrote: »
    JoeUser wrote: »
    Minor question about the end:
    Why does Leia hug Rey, who she has never even met and wouldn't know? Is there some significance I'm missing?

    Listen to the music that plays when that happens.
    It's the tune called 'Han Solo and the Princess', commonly known as the Han and Leia love song. It plays in the movies, Original Trilogy and New, when Han and Leia have a touching moment. When Leia and Rey hug, they play THAT song. Probably for the last time. I've seen the movie three times, and it chokes me up every time. The looks on their faces are obviously pained and sad, they hug because they are both grieving Han. One the man she loved, the other the father she never had.

    Also, everyone sad that Finn figures aren't selling, maybe that's just where you are. Near me the only figure left on the shelves is the alien X-wing pilot.

    Ello Asty?!? What the fuck?

    TankHammer
  • Iron WeaselIron Weasel Dillon! You son of a bitch!Registered User regular
    Al_wat wrote: »
    So apparently Episode 8 has a release date of May 2017.

    That is actually a lot sooner than I would have expected. I'm kind of impressed.
    I've read that Disney's Master Plan is a Star Wars movie every year for as long as they can get away with it.
    2016 will be Rogue One
    2017 will be Episode 8
    2018 will be another non-episode film
    2019 will be Episode 9
    etc ...

    Currently Playing:
    The Division, Warframe (XB1)
    GT: Tanith 6227
    Al_watFencingsax
  • CenoCeno pizza time Registered User regular
    2019 has the end of the new trilogy and the last part of Infinity War

    All your money are belong to Walt's frozen head

    darleysamTankHammerNechriahMatev
  • ChincymcchillaChincymcchilla Registered User regular
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?

    I have a podcast about Power Rangers:Teenagers With Attitude | TWA Facebook Group
    Al_watLord_AsmodeusInquisitorMaddocdarleysamToxmasterofmetroidA Dabble Of TheloniusEtchwartsA duck!StiltsPsykomaRomanian My EscutcheonTankHammerFroThulhuTransporterEmporiumMegaMekjgeispookaSpeed RacerMatevKetarMadEddyDarth Waiterdarunia106
  • JavenJaven Registered User regular
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    bsjezzbloodatonement
  • ChincymcchillaChincymcchilla Registered User regular
    Javen wrote: »
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    No, that's needlessly cynical and reductive

    I have a podcast about Power Rangers:Teenagers With Attitude | TWA Facebook Group
    NeoTomamasterofmetroidDonovan PuppyfuckerEtchwartsFencingsaxPsykomaGR_ZombieOlivawPaperLuigi44Lord_AsmodeusEmporiumdarunia106
  • JavenJaven Registered User regular
    Javen wrote: »
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    No, that's needlessly cynical and reductive
    This is literally the first time Rey and Leia meet. Apart from 'the Force' there's not even any explanation that each one knows who the other is. Rey was kidnapped before the resistance came and had never met Poe or Leia or anyone in the Resistance up to that point. They don't even introduce themselves before embracing one another. It's a tiny detail, but it's a super weird tiny detail to add when you think about it, other than 'let's have these two primary characters interact and it's the end of the film so no real time for exposition, so let's just have them be close immediately'.

    bsjezzbloodatonementCurly_BraceClint EastwoodEtiowsaturtleant
  • BlankZoeBlankZoe Registered User regular
    Al_wat wrote: »
    So apparently Episode 8 has a release date of May 2017.

    That is actually a lot sooner than I would have expected. I'm kind of impressed.
    I've read that Disney's Master Plan is a Star Wars movie every year for as long as they can get away with it.
    2016 will be Rogue One
    2017 will be Episode 8
    2018 will be another non-episode film
    2019 will be Episode 9
    etc ...
    2018 is, specifically, the Lord and Miller Han Solo film

    CYpGAPn.png
    darleysamIron Weasel
  • DecomposeyDecomposey Registered User regular
    Javen wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    No, that's needlessly cynical and reductive
    This is literally the first time Rey and Leia meet. Apart from 'the Force' there's not even any explanation that each one knows who the other is. Rey was kidnapped before the resistance came and had never met Poe or Leia or anyone in the Resistance up to that point. They don't even introduce themselves before embracing one another. It's a tiny detail, but it's a super weird tiny detail to add when you think about it, other than 'let's have these two primary characters interact and it's the end of the film so no real time for exposition, so let's just have them be close immediately'.
    They DON'T know each other. But they both know the other is grieving so they hug to share that grief. Chewy is busy taking care of Finn, he's too mentally occupied to be filled with grief, but Rey isn't and Leia isn't, and so they hug to support each other. How is this so hard to grasp?

    Before following any advice, opinions, or thoughts I may have expressed in the above post, be warned: I found Keven Costners "Waterworld" to be a very entertaining film.
    ChincymcchillaDidgeridoomasterofmetroidStiltsFishmanLord_AsmodeusTankHammerCurly_BraceMegaMek
  • JavenJaven Registered User regular
    Decomposey wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    No, that's needlessly cynical and reductive
    This is literally the first time Rey and Leia meet. Apart from 'the Force' there's not even any explanation that each one knows who the other is. Rey was kidnapped before the resistance came and had never met Poe or Leia or anyone in the Resistance up to that point. They don't even introduce themselves before embracing one another. It's a tiny detail, but it's a super weird tiny detail to add when you think about it, other than 'let's have these two primary characters interact and it's the end of the film so no real time for exposition, so let's just have them be close immediately'.
    They DON'T know each other. But they both know the other is grieving so they hug to share that grief. Chewy is busy taking care of Finn, he's too mentally occupied to be filled with grief, but Rey isn't and Leia isn't, and so they hug to support each other. How is this so hard to grasp?
    I grasp it just fine. You can obviously rationalize it, just like you can perfectly rationalize Chewbacca not getting getting a medal in ANH, or how they decided to have Obi-Wan and R2-D2 be pals in the prequels, despite Alec Guinness explicitly saying 'I don't know this droid' in the first film. Doesn't change the fact that it stands out. Oversights happen in films. This definitely feels like one of them.

    Mysst
  • BlankZoeBlankZoe Registered User regular
    Grey Ghost wrote: »
    I have now seen Oscar Isaac alongside various other cast members in interviews and I'm pretty sure everyone else in that movie wants to fuck him
    Well, don't you?

    CYpGAPn.png
    FroThulhu
  • DecomposeyDecomposey Registered User regular
    Javen wrote: »
    Decomposey wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    No, that's needlessly cynical and reductive
    This is literally the first time Rey and Leia meet. Apart from 'the Force' there's not even any explanation that each one knows who the other is. Rey was kidnapped before the resistance came and had never met Poe or Leia or anyone in the Resistance up to that point. They don't even introduce themselves before embracing one another. It's a tiny detail, but it's a super weird tiny detail to add when you think about it, other than 'let's have these two primary characters interact and it's the end of the film so no real time for exposition, so let's just have them be close immediately'.
    They DON'T know each other. But they both know the other is grieving so they hug to share that grief. Chewy is busy taking care of Finn, he's too mentally occupied to be filled with grief, but Rey isn't and Leia isn't, and so they hug to support each other. How is this so hard to grasp?
    I grasp it just fine. You can obviously rationalize it, just like you can perfectly rationalize Chewbacca not getting getting a medal in ANH, or how they decided to have Obi-Wan and R2-D2 be pals in the prequels, despite Alec Guinness explicitly saying 'I don't know this droid' in the first film. Doesn't change the fact that it stands out. Oversights happen in films. This definitely feels like one of them.

    Right, so one of the most touching and emotionally charged moments in the film is an oversight. Ok, sure.

    Before following any advice, opinions, or thoughts I may have expressed in the above post, be warned: I found Keven Costners "Waterworld" to be a very entertaining film.
  • Al_watAl_wat Registered User regular
    Blankzilla wrote: »
    Al_wat wrote: »
    So apparently Episode 8 has a release date of May 2017.

    That is actually a lot sooner than I would have expected. I'm kind of impressed.
    I've read that Disney's Master Plan is a Star Wars movie every year for as long as they can get away with it.
    2016 will be Rogue One
    2017 will be Episode 8
    2018 will be another non-episode film
    2019 will be Episode 9
    etc ...
    2018 is, specifically, the Lord and Miller Han Solo film

    not sure how I feel about a han solo film

    I mean, obviously I want it to be good, and based on how episode 7 turned out, I have no reason to doubt it will be.

    I guess it really all comes down to how well whatever actor they choose pulls it off.

  • autono-wally, erotibot300autono-wally, erotibot300 love machine Registered User regular
    Grey Ghost wrote: »
    I have now seen Oscar Isaac alongside various other cast members in interviews and I'm pretty sure everyone else in that movie wants to fuck him

    I'm pretty sure that's real life charisma seeping into the movie..

    kFJhXwE.jpgkFJhXwE.jpg
  • BlankZoeBlankZoe Registered User regular
    Al_wat wrote: »
    Blankzilla wrote: »
    Al_wat wrote: »
    So apparently Episode 8 has a release date of May 2017.

    That is actually a lot sooner than I would have expected. I'm kind of impressed.
    I've read that Disney's Master Plan is a Star Wars movie every year for as long as they can get away with it.
    2016 will be Rogue One
    2017 will be Episode 8
    2018 will be another non-episode film
    2019 will be Episode 9
    etc ...
    2018 is, specifically, the Lord and Miller Han Solo film

    not sure how I feel about a han solo film

    I mean, obviously I want it to be good, and based on how episode 7 turned out, I have no reason to doubt it will be.

    I guess it really all comes down to how well whatever actor they choose pulls it off.
    Lord and Miller have directed 4 films and 4 of them are absolutely fantastic and hilarious and full of great casting

    I am very confident in it

    CYpGAPn.png
    Al_wat
  • Mr. GMr. G Registered User regular
    More importantly than them making 4 movies

    Every one of those movies they've made has been a horrible idea that turns out excellent, much like how an Adventures of Young Han Solo movie is A Bad Idea

    6F32U1X.png
    BlankZoedarleysamEtchwarts
  • InquisitorInquisitor Registered User regular
    Han Solo is probably near the bottom of the list of things I want the film to focus on, he's already a very well eatablished, fleshed out character.

    But it will probably be a pretty darn entertaining film regardless.

    Ceno
  • KarlKarl Registered User regular
    I would love a Kyle Katarn film.

    He doesn't even pick up a lightsaber until the 2nd or 3rd film.

    el_vicioTheBlackWindOlivawNothingLord_AsmodeusMatevdarunia106
  • BlankZoeBlankZoe Registered User regular
    I just realized Han Solo might feature young Lando

    Who might (should) be played by Michael B. Jordan

    CYpGAPn.png
    OlivawFroThulhuTransporterCurly_BraceJimothydarunia106
  • InquisitorInquisitor Registered User regular
    Blankzilla wrote: »
    I just realized Han Solo might feature young Lando

    Who might (should) be played by Michael B. Jordan

    Okay you may have gotten me back on board with the film being about han solo.

    BlankZoeOlivawFroThulhu
  • Mr. GMr. G Registered User regular
    edited December 2015
    Karl wrote: »
    I would love a Kyle Katarn film.

    He doesn't even pick up a lightsaber until the 2nd or 3rd film.

    Now that I actually know the full history of Kyle Katarn (I had only ever played Jedi Outcast)

    Making him into a jedi is duuuuuuuuuumb

    Great for gameplay, awful for narrative

    The idea of this merc who's done work for the Empire and the Rebellion, has no particular allegiance, and is constantly using his knowledge of both sides against the other is fantastic

    And he should just be a dude

    Just like how making Han Solo a jedi would be dumb as hell

    Mr. G on
    6F32U1X.png
    Etchwarts
  • Al_watAl_wat Registered User regular
    I want a movie based on that ice cream vendor from Bespin in ESB who was a secret alliance spy


    I learned today that yes... this is an actual thing....

    TankHammer
  • ChincymcchillaChincymcchilla Registered User regular
    edited December 2015
    Chincymcchilla was warned for this.
    Javen wrote: »
    Decomposey wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    No, that's needlessly cynical and reductive
    This is literally the first time Rey and Leia meet. Apart from 'the Force' there's not even any explanation that each one knows who the other is. Rey was kidnapped before the resistance came and had never met Poe or Leia or anyone in the Resistance up to that point. They don't even introduce themselves before embracing one another. It's a tiny detail, but it's a super weird tiny detail to add when you think about it, other than 'let's have these two primary characters interact and it's the end of the film so no real time for exposition, so let's just have them be close immediately'.
    They DON'T know each other. But they both know the other is grieving so they hug to share that grief. Chewy is busy taking care of Finn, he's too mentally occupied to be filled with grief, but Rey isn't and Leia isn't, and so they hug to support each other. How is this so hard to grasp?
    I grasp it just fine. You can obviously rationalize it, just like you can perfectly rationalize Chewbacca not getting getting a medal in ANH, or how they decided to have Obi-Wan and R2-D2 be pals in the prequels, despite Alec Guinness explicitly saying 'I don't know this droid' in the first film. Doesn't change the fact that it stands out. Oversights happen in films. This definitely feels like one of them.

    Nah

    You're just for some reason ignoring rational reasoning for why Leia would do what basically any decent human would

    That's your prerogative but acting like an emotional moment is a mistake because you either don't understand emotions or are intentionally ignoring how human beings act to one another does sort of make you seem like a robbit

    A duck! on
    I have a podcast about Power Rangers:Teenagers With Attitude | TWA Facebook Group
    BlankZoeDecomposeyMaddocmasterofmetroidaudaxDonovan PuppyfuckerPsykomaEmporium
  • KarlKarl Registered User regular
    Mr. G wrote: »
    Karl wrote: »
    I would love a Kyle Katarn film.

    He doesn't even pick up a lightsaber until the 2nd or 3rd film.

    Now that I actually know the full history of Kyle Katarn (I had only ever played Jedi Outcast)

    Making him into a jedi is duuuuuuuuuumb

    Great for gameplay, awful for narrative

    The idea of this merc who's done work for the Empire and the Rebellion, has no particular allegiance, and is constantly using his knowledge of both sides against the other is fantastic

    And he should just be a dude

    Just like how making Han Solo a jedi would be dumb as hell

    Final scene of the final Kyle Katarn film is him starting on the path to be a Jedi.

    But we never see that actually happen.

  • Dex DynamoDex Dynamo Registered User regular
    edited December 2015
    Al_wat wrote: »
    I want a movie based on that ice cream vendor from Bespin in ESB who was a secret alliance spy


    I learned today that yes... this is an actual thing....

    the one thing i've learned from reading the backs of toy boxes

    is that every on-screen extra in the star wars trilogy is either a spy, double agent, mercenary, soldier, or bounty hunter

    that guy carrying those boxes? yeah, those boxes were full of explosives that he was smuggling for the rebellion!

    Dex Dynamo on
    BlankZoeAl_wat
  • darleysamdarleysam On my way to UKRegistered User regular
    Mr. G wrote: »
    More importantly than them making 4 movies

    Every one of those movies they've made has been a horrible idea that turns out excellent, much like how an Adventures of Young Han Solo movie is A Bad Idea

    Yeah, this. It's not just that they've made great films, they've made films that I had absolutely zero interest in into great films. That's a special kind of alchemy.

    forumsig.png
  • JavenJaven Registered User regular
    edited December 2015
    Decomposey wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Decomposey wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    No, that's needlessly cynical and reductive
    This is literally the first time Rey and Leia meet. Apart from 'the Force' there's not even any explanation that each one knows who the other is. Rey was kidnapped before the resistance came and had never met Poe or Leia or anyone in the Resistance up to that point. They don't even introduce themselves before embracing one another. It's a tiny detail, but it's a super weird tiny detail to add when you think about it, other than 'let's have these two primary characters interact and it's the end of the film so no real time for exposition, so let's just have them be close immediately'.
    They DON'T know each other. But they both know the other is grieving so they hug to share that grief. Chewy is busy taking care of Finn, he's too mentally occupied to be filled with grief, but Rey isn't and Leia isn't, and so they hug to support each other. How is this so hard to grasp?
    I grasp it just fine. You can obviously rationalize it, just like you can perfectly rationalize Chewbacca not getting getting a medal in ANH, or how they decided to have Obi-Wan and R2-D2 be pals in the prequels, despite Alec Guinness explicitly saying 'I don't know this droid' in the first film. Doesn't change the fact that it stands out. Oversights happen in films. This definitely feels like one of them.

    Right, so one of the most touching and emotionally charged moments in the film is an oversight. Ok, sure.
    My issue isn't that the scene itself is an oversight, because it's not, it's with the characters who took part in said scene and the roles they play. Rey obviously cares more about Finn than she did Han, and Chewbacca definitely cares more about Han than Finn, so it's strange that the decision was made to essentially swap their positions that would have made the most sense; with Chewie and Leia sharing the moment of mourning for Han, and Rey ensuring that her first and best friend survives. And given the lack of history between Rey and Leia, the decision to do so seems to have been made because of Rey's position as primary protagonist

    Javen on
    Tox
  • JoeUserJoeUser Forum Santa Registered User regular
    Javen wrote: »
    Decomposey wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    No, that's needlessly cynical and reductive
    This is literally the first time Rey and Leia meet. Apart from 'the Force' there's not even any explanation that each one knows who the other is. Rey was kidnapped before the resistance came and had never met Poe or Leia or anyone in the Resistance up to that point. They don't even introduce themselves before embracing one another. It's a tiny detail, but it's a super weird tiny detail to add when you think about it, other than 'let's have these two primary characters interact and it's the end of the film so no real time for exposition, so let's just have them be close immediately'.
    They DON'T know each other. But they both know the other is grieving so they hug to share that grief. Chewy is busy taking care of Finn, he's too mentally occupied to be filled with grief, but Rey isn't and Leia isn't, and so they hug to support each other. How is this so hard to grasp?
    I grasp it just fine. You can obviously rationalize it, just like you can perfectly rationalize Chewbacca not getting getting a medal in ANH, or how they decided to have Obi-Wan and R2-D2 be pals in the prequels, despite Alec Guinness explicitly saying 'I don't know this droid' in the first film. Doesn't change the fact that it stands out. Oversights happen in films. This definitely feels like one of them.

    Nah

    You're just for some reason ignoring rational reasoning for why Leia would do what basically any decent human would

    That's your prerogative but acting like an emotional moment is a mistake because you either don't understand emotions or are intentionally ignoring how human beings act to one another does sort of make you seem like a robbit

    I'm just wondering if it's supposed to be something else, like
    Rey is actually another Solo kid

    OmnipotentBagel
  • MuzzmuzzMuzzmuzz Registered User regular
    Wait.... the Stormtrooper
    Who got force persuaded by Rey to release her was played by Daniel Craig? Is this true?

    Tox
  • DecomposeyDecomposey Registered User regular
    Muzzmuzz wrote: »
    Wait.... the Stormtrooper
    Who got force persuaded by Rey to release her was played by Daniel Craig? Is this true?

    Yup.

    Before following any advice, opinions, or thoughts I may have expressed in the above post, be warned: I found Keven Costners "Waterworld" to be a very entertaining film.
    BlankZoeAl_watTofystedethJoolanderToxRomanian My EscutcheonTankHammerTransporterLord_AsmodeusMatevdarunia106
  • Al_watAl_wat Registered User regular
    Muzzmuzz wrote: »
    Wait.... the Stormtrooper
    Who got force persuaded by Rey to release her was played by Daniel Craig? Is this true?

    apparently yes, this is true.

    also apparently the name of the stormtrooper was
    JB-007

    NeoTomael_viciobloodatonementDonovan PuppyfuckerdarleysamStiltsJoolanderMoth 13FencingsaxRainfallToxSixshotStrikerRomanian My EscutcheonOlivawTransporterLord_AsmodeusCurly_BraceMegaMekJimothyCimmeriiMatevMadEddysarukunDarth WaiterMr Fuzzbuttdarunia106
  • ChincymcchillaChincymcchilla Registered User regular
    Javen wrote: »
    Decomposey wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Decomposey wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    No, that's needlessly cynical and reductive
    This is literally the first time Rey and Leia meet. Apart from 'the Force' there's not even any explanation that each one knows who the other is. Rey was kidnapped before the resistance came and had never met Poe or Leia or anyone in the Resistance up to that point. They don't even introduce themselves before embracing one another. It's a tiny detail, but it's a super weird tiny detail to add when you think about it, other than 'let's have these two primary characters interact and it's the end of the film so no real time for exposition, so let's just have them be close immediately'.
    They DON'T know each other. But they both know the other is grieving so they hug to share that grief. Chewy is busy taking care of Finn, he's too mentally occupied to be filled with grief, but Rey isn't and Leia isn't, and so they hug to support each other. How is this so hard to grasp?
    I grasp it just fine. You can obviously rationalize it, just like you can perfectly rationalize Chewbacca not getting getting a medal in ANH, or how they decided to have Obi-Wan and R2-D2 be pals in the prequels, despite Alec Guinness explicitly saying 'I don't know this droid' in the first film. Doesn't change the fact that it stands out. Oversights happen in films. This definitely feels like one of them.

    Right, so one of the most touching and emotionally charged moments in the film is an oversight. Ok, sure.
    My issue isn't that the scene itself is an oversight, because it's not, it's with the characters who took part in said scene and the roles they play. Rey obviously cares more about Finn than she did Han, and Chewbacca definitely cares more about Han than Finn, so it's strange that the decision was made to essentially swap their positions that would have made the most sense; with Chewie and Leia sharing the moment of mourning for Han, and Rey ensuring that her first and best friend survives. And given the lack of history between Rey and Leia, the decision to do so seems to have been made because of Rey's position as primary protagonist
    Chewie immediately goes for alone time, and Rey knows finn is alive and goes and checks on her after the hug

    People can perform more than one similar action

    Chewie probably also got a hug

    And Rey and Leia both loved Han, they are sharing a moment of grief

    this is super weird dude, this is like

    a basic human emotional action

    I have a podcast about Power Rangers:Teenagers With Attitude | TWA Facebook Group
    Andy JoeDonovan Puppyfucker
  • MaddocMaddoc I'm Bobbin Threadbare, are you my mother? Registered User regular
    Javen wrote: »
    Decomposey wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Decomposey wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Javen wrote: »
    Leia and rey
    Leia knows rey was with han and she cared for Han

    She knows Han died

    I dunno I thought it was self explanatory?
    Yeah but so was Chewie and Leia didn't even look at him.

    It's because Rey is the jedi now and thus cemented her role as primary protagonist. That's the first and last the reason.

    No, that's needlessly cynical and reductive
    This is literally the first time Rey and Leia meet. Apart from 'the Force' there's not even any explanation that each one knows who the other is. Rey was kidnapped before the resistance came and had never met Poe or Leia or anyone in the Resistance up to that point. They don't even introduce themselves before embracing one another. It's a tiny detail, but it's a super weird tiny detail to add when you think about it, other than 'let's have these two primary characters interact and it's the end of the film so no real time for exposition, so let's just have them be close immediately'.
    They DON'T know each other. But they both know the other is grieving so they hug to share that grief. Chewy is busy taking care of Finn, he's too mentally occupied to be filled with grief, but Rey isn't and Leia isn't, and so they hug to support each other. How is this so hard to grasp?
    I grasp it just fine. You can obviously rationalize it, just like you can perfectly rationalize Chewbacca not getting getting a medal in ANH, or how they decided to have Obi-Wan and R2-D2 be pals in the prequels, despite Alec Guinness explicitly saying 'I don't know this droid' in the first film. Doesn't change the fact that it stands out. Oversights happen in films. This definitely feels like one of them.

    Right, so one of the most touching and emotionally charged moments in the film is an oversight. Ok, sure.
    My issue isn't that the scene itself is an oversight, because it's not, it's with the characters who took part in said scene and the roles they play. Rey obviously cares more about Finn than she did Han, and Chewbacca definitely cares more about Han than Finn, so it's strange that the decision was made to essentially swap their positions that would have made the most sense; with Chewie and Leia sharing the moment of mourning for Han, and Rey ensuring that her first and best friend survives. And given the lack of history between Rey and Leia, the decision to do so seems to have been made because of Rey's position as primary protagonist
    I think you missed the part where they were pretty clearly putting Han in the position of a father figure for Rey during the short time they were together

    Like, Han even talks up Rey to Leia when they're together

    97H9G7S.png PSN - Masked Unit | FFXIV - Laitarne Gilgamesh
    Donovan PuppyfuckerRainfallTankHammerMegaMekdarunia106
  • OmnipotentBagelOmnipotentBagel floof Registered User regular
    Yeah Han and Rey's interactions were very father-daughter in tone. The whole thing with him giving her that blaster felt like a father bringing his kid along to work for the first time.

    cdci44qazyo3.gif

    Donovan PuppyfuckerdarleysamRainfallTankHammerLord_Asmodeus
  • MaddocMaddoc I'm Bobbin Threadbare, are you my mother? Registered User regular
    Between this and the political situation of the galaxy, we should retitle this to "The [Star Wars] thread where everything not explicitly stated is an oversight" or something

    97H9G7S.png PSN - Masked Unit | FFXIV - Laitarne Gilgamesh
    The_InfidelAndy JoeDonovan PuppyfuckerLord_AsmodeusEmporiumMegaMek
  • Al_watAl_wat Registered User regular
    Al_wat wrote: »
    Muzzmuzz wrote: »
    Wait.... the Stormtrooper
    Who got force persuaded by Rey to release her was played by Daniel Craig? Is this true?

    apparently yes, this is true.

    also apparently the name of the stormtrooper was
    JB-007

    I just checked IMDB. It confirms this information.

    Also many bothans died....?

This discussion has been closed.