Personally, I doubt JFP's claim that no scum have died because the puppetry ability appears to have vanished the day an extra kill appeared.
Makes me think Green had that ability and, as it was used on the amulet holder, that it was a mafia ability.
I'd feel safer with the amulet on the called vig/seer.
1) You have both JFP and Austin (our conditional vig) saying that no mafia have died. You doubt both?
2) I agree. The amulet should be passed to Austin
JFP said none of the first 6 are mafia. Austin said none of the first 3. Green was in the second three so JFP could be wrong without Austin being wrong.
I thought Austin's whole thing was "I can kill if no mafia died in the last two days"? And we're on day 3...
His ability is available at night, if no mafia died in the past 2 days. So Night 2, when there were no mafia deaths D1, N1, D2, his ability activated. The only deaths for D1, N1, D2 were Kilnaga, Cyth, and WA criminal. His ability checks at the beginning of the night.
JFP claims his ability checks/fires on Odd Days so at the top of Day 3, there were 6 people dead (same 3 austin checked plus the 3 that died N2) and then he gets his results.
This whole Day/Night thing is messing with me.
OK, whatever, I trust you all :P.
So we have Austin who says no one died in D1, N1, D2, and that he killed... someone, Green? on N2. And he can only shoot again on N....4?
Then we have J4P saying no mafia died in D1, N1, D2, N2.
Is that right?
I'm not clear with @AustinP0027 if he could then fire again N3 assuming STILL no mafia deaths.... or if it has a 2 day recharge as well. That was unclear.
Otherwise yes, your summary looks right.
Unless I'm reading it way wrong, it's a 2day recharge so I won't get a shot again until D4 if no Mafia are dead.
I suggest you clarify this with the host sooner rather than later.
Also, I still feel that JFP needs to get a clarification.
If all abilities happen simultaneously then he shouldn't get a read in anyone who dies at night. So unless there is an order of operations with his power, he should only have gotten a read on the same people that I did to trigger my kill
Um...
Info abilities appear to resolve before kills, but results go out after kills.
Not sure if a power that gives blanket info would then give the game state after kills when the results are sent out, or before kills, when the targeted abilities (like my dream power) resolve.
4. Info/protection phase: other actions that do not involve the possibility of a player dying resolve
5. Killing phase: any night kills (including the Witch Coven’s Murder) resolve
Day phase order of operations
1. Results phase: any results of the night, private or public, are posted
Does this imply that every info ability in the game will generate results prior to a night's kill phase if it activates during night end / day start?
(Is JFP lying)
AuralynxDarkness is a perspectiveWatching the ego workRegistered Userregular
I mean, I dislike that least of everything so far, but it seems like no kill might not be a total disaster tonight as it'll make it easier to sift through the abilities we've revealed.
Interesting that so many people have stayed away from the MP wagon...
Sadly with us needing a majority, and a bunch of people not saying anything yet bandwagons seem to be our only way of getting things done. I'm ok with killing off any of these shifty folks but I don't see how we gain more info on their misdeeds to prove it.
Is saying in thread that I am giving the amulet to Austin good enough?
In order to prevent the "hack" of socially forcing every player to post "I transfer the Amulet to X", any request made to transfer or display the Amulet needs to come to me via PM.
4. Info/protection phase: other actions that do not involve the possibility of a player dying resolve
5. Killing phase: any night kills (including the Witch Coven’s Murder) resolve
Day phase order of operations
1. Results phase: any results of the night, private or public, are posted
Does this imply that every info ability in the game will generate results prior to a night's kill phase if it activates during night end / day start?
(Is JFP lying)
What the quoted section of the rules is saying, is that if a night info action (such as the classic "seer" role) happens to target a person who is also getting killed, the info role will still get a result, rather than getting some sort of blocked or illegal target error.
MP... Might be SK (one seems to be hinted at in the OP under the difficulty section). Claimed power is good cover for a sk role.
Burnage... Don't really get the wagon on him tbh
Gizzy/MrT... Weird speculation post about dreams, other than that idk
Discrider... Leading the conversation, making tons of posts, not feeeling mafia
Do the narrations necessarily reflect what happened in the Day/Night?
Uh, can I get a clarification on your clarification? Not sure what you're asking.
Are the narrations and the actions people took mostly related? If I stab Raiden with a spoon, will that be mentioned in the narration? Important, if a dead body is mentioned which is Raiden's, will the cause of death be reflective of a spoon-like murder?
Do the narrations necessarily reflect what happened in the Day/Night?
Uh, can I get a clarification on your clarification? Not sure what you're asking.
Are the narrations and the actions people took mostly related? If I stab Raiden with a spoon, will that be mentioned in the narration? Important, if a dead body is mentioned which is Raiden's, will the cause of death be reflective of a spoon-like murder?
Does that make sense?
If you kill someone with a spoon-related power, the narration will not necessarily indicate that spoons were involved.
Posts
I suggest you clarify this with the host sooner rather than later.
Um...
Info abilities appear to resolve before kills, but results go out after kills.
Not sure if a power that gives blanket info would then give the game state after kills when the results are sent out, or before kills, when the targeted abilities (like my dream power) resolve.
5. Killing phase: any night kills (including the Witch Coven’s Murder) resolve
Day phase order of operations
1. Results phase: any results of the night, private or public, are posted
Does this imply that every info ability in the game will generate results prior to a night's kill phase if it activates during night end / day start?
(Is JFP lying)
Burnage
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
Not sure if mafia push
Ah screw it.
He's on my Duna.
No point doubting myself now.
Turns out I was wrong. The nights carry over.
So, if none of the night 2 kills plus our vote end up Mafia, I'll have another kill available.
Interesting that so many people have stayed away from the MP wagon...
Pretty sure passing it is a PM to the host and notdone in thread.
Sadly with us needing a majority, and a bunch of people not saying anything yet bandwagons seem to be our only way of getting things done. I'm ok with killing off any of these shifty folks but I don't see how we gain more info on their misdeeds to prove it.
That and the MrT wagon.
Or me.
Uh, can I get a clarification on your clarification? Not sure what you're asking.
In order to prevent the "hack" of socially forcing every player to post "I transfer the Amulet to X", any request made to transfer or display the Amulet needs to come to me via PM.
What the quoted section of the rules is saying, is that if a night info action (such as the classic "seer" role) happens to target a person who is also getting killed, the info role will still get a result, rather than getting some sort of blocked or illegal target error.
I sort of like it better at this point due to the lack of action earlier.
Burnage... Don't really get the wagon on him tbh
Gizzy/MrT... Weird speculation post about dreams, other than that idk
Discrider... Leading the conversation, making tons of posts, not feeeling mafia
3DS: 1289-8447-4695
3DS: 1289-8447-4695
3DS: 1289-8447-4695
3DS: 1289-8447-4695
Are the narrations and the actions people took mostly related? If I stab Raiden with a spoon, will that be mentioned in the narration? Important, if a dead body is mentioned which is Raiden's, will the cause of death be reflective of a spoon-like murder?
Does that make sense?
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
You have 15 seconds :P
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
If you kill someone with a spoon-related power, the narration will not necessarily indicate that spoons were involved.