The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
[Camp Comic] Friday, February 3, 2017 - Steve ‘N Steven #4
This isn't redemption or some kind of happy ending... This is Steve's manipulation at its finest. Treat them like shit and then make them feel good about it.
Steve's showing zero remorse, zero regret for anything that he did, that's the problem. So this is just going to keep happening to Steven, now, and he's going to keep taking it as friendship.
I disagree. Steve is not a manipulator. He's not bright enough for that, to begin with. He's merely a compulsive liar. I think this is the first time he's ever said the word "honestly" and he means it. Yes, it doesn't excuse or make up for previous actions, but it may be a first step to appreciating Steven and perhaps improve his behaviour towards him in the future.
Man some of you guys are really hard on damaged children.
Kid's got issues but he is working through them thanks to his very patient and understanding friend. I'm pretty sure Steven knows Steve is full of crap but he doesn't call him out on it cause he doesn't want to make him feel bad. That will lead to Steve feeling more comfortable to be himself and not put on airs so much.
Other than the arrowhead, Steve wasn't purposefully hurting Steven. He was just oblivious to the fact he was sharing Steven's secret with everyone and with the bridge, I think he genuinely thought it would work.
He's just a compulsive liar trying to cover up for his lack of friends and talents. This is probably the closest Steve has ever got to telling Steven he cherishes their friendship.
So I just finished reading Skadi from start to finish in one sitting, which was kind of epic and amazing.
One thing that strikes me though is that Skadi is a horrible person who is abusive to her best friend in all sorts of ways that would normally get the Vulnerable Persons team in Social Services talking about court orders. However, right through the comments this goes almost entirely uncommented on. Maybe it's the fantasy trapping, or maybe it's because Skadi has this whole femdom bikini barbarian thing going on.
Anyway, seems like we're less forgiving of the abuser this time round. I see your point on these being damaged kids, Lupos, but I'd say that this is still a nasty abusive kid victimising another kid. Sure, the abusive kid is probably like that because he's damaged, and it's probably not his fault he's like that, but still... he is definitely an abuser.
Skadi literally murdered Diseasoid's family and took him as a slave. I don't think there's much to comment on, other than the relationship changed later on. But I don't really read the comments on it for reasons.
As for Steve, I don't think he's an abuser. Besides being a damaged kid, he's not trying to abuse Steven. Obliviousness and overconfidence are not abuse. He's just a lonely kid that's trying to be more than he is to impress people. And he genuinely enjoyed his day with Steven, he's not trying to manipulate him, he just doesn't know how to express it without making grandiose claims about himself.
One thing that strikes me though is that Skadi is a horrible person who is abusive to her best friend in all sorts of ways that would normally get the Vulnerable Persons team in Social Services talking about court orders. However, right through the comments this goes almost entirely uncommented on.
The comic itself comments on this multiple times - Skadi gets chased by angry mobs, gets sentenced to death, gets pursued by revenge-seekers, gets punished for her transgressions by mystical beings, and so on and so forth; Diseasoid complains about his pain and suffering as Skadi's slave, tries to escape multiple times, occasionally tries to kill Skadi but can't go through with it, and sometimes has suicidal thoughts simply so he could escape his miserable life.
The reader comments call out Skadi a lot, too; mind that the original comments have been lost due to Dumm Comic's site malfunctioning, and that there are both a new comment section on Dumm Comics and another on Skadi's own site, which means a lot of comics that seem to have gone without comments simply had their comments lost to the abyss. Even so, there are still plenty of comments about Skadi being an abusive dick.
Yea. I have to agree with the others saying Steve is just an insecure little kid. If he really was a manipulator then he would not simply have Steven as his only friend. Remember when the comic first started both Steve and Steven regularly made up stories always one upping each other. It was though they were always locked in competition with each other over who was better but instead of a physical competition (except for the knife comic) it was all fictional accomplishments. Steven appears to have outgrown it but Steve just desperately holds on. He just doesn't let anyone in.
Fair enough, Xastion. We've not got enough information to make a call, so likely we're each reading things according to our own filters and biases. To me, Steve might be driven by insecurity and immaturity, but then, so are most bullies and abusers. I'm reminded (from work) of battered spouses who insist that their husbands are not bad people or abusive because they're always there for them, and "because he buys me these nice things to say sorry" and so on.
In Steve, I see a manipulator who is working a game of control and negging on Steven, to make him dependent. That he isn't a great manipulator or that he doesn't do it to other people doesn't change the nature of their relationship. That Steve is like this because he's likely immature and lacking in self confidence is the reasons behind the bullying, not the outcome.
To me, the outcome is that Steve puts down Steven to make sure Steven doesn't leave him for someone else, and abuses the power of that relationship to take things from Steven (like the arrowhead). This, and stuff like the bridge, show that its not a true friendship where they care for each other (like say Brian has with Seventeen) but rather a power game.
Though, as I said, SO MUCH of this is subjective interpretation. That you can read this in different ways is a great testament to Katie's storytelling ability.
I think Steven (Or at least part of him) might know that Steve is just lying about his awesome life before camp to compensate for being in camp, and that little opening up to Steven is a sign that he might actually be trying to connect to SOME degree. Rome wasn't built in a day, y'know.
Okay, there it goes. I'm officially shipping it. Before anybody says anything, yeah, I know, all of this is obviously purely platonic- shipping is just really darn fun.
Posts
I concede.
That was worth the build up for a happy Steven.
Steve's showing zero remorse, zero regret for anything that he did, that's the problem. So this is just going to keep happening to Steven, now, and he's going to keep taking it as friendship.
That's a weirdly miserable ending.
I think he's just a braggart like a lot of young kids can be who aren't sure of themselves and want to look cool.
That's because this is a co-dependent abusive relationship. This should make you uncomfortable,
Kid's got issues but he is working through them thanks to his very patient and understanding friend. I'm pretty sure Steven knows Steve is full of crap but he doesn't call him out on it cause he doesn't want to make him feel bad. That will lead to Steve feeling more comfortable to be himself and not put on airs so much.
He's just a compulsive liar trying to cover up for his lack of friends and talents. This is probably the closest Steve has ever got to telling Steven he cherishes their friendship.
One thing that strikes me though is that Skadi is a horrible person who is abusive to her best friend in all sorts of ways that would normally get the Vulnerable Persons team in Social Services talking about court orders. However, right through the comments this goes almost entirely uncommented on. Maybe it's the fantasy trapping, or maybe it's because Skadi has this whole femdom bikini barbarian thing going on.
Anyway, seems like we're less forgiving of the abuser this time round. I see your point on these being damaged kids, Lupos, but I'd say that this is still a nasty abusive kid victimising another kid. Sure, the abusive kid is probably like that because he's damaged, and it's probably not his fault he's like that, but still... he is definitely an abuser.
As for Steve, I don't think he's an abuser. Besides being a damaged kid, he's not trying to abuse Steven. Obliviousness and overconfidence are not abuse. He's just a lonely kid that's trying to be more than he is to impress people. And he genuinely enjoyed his day with Steven, he's not trying to manipulate him, he just doesn't know how to express it without making grandiose claims about himself.
The comic itself comments on this multiple times - Skadi gets chased by angry mobs, gets sentenced to death, gets pursued by revenge-seekers, gets punished for her transgressions by mystical beings, and so on and so forth; Diseasoid complains about his pain and suffering as Skadi's slave, tries to escape multiple times, occasionally tries to kill Skadi but can't go through with it, and sometimes has suicidal thoughts simply so he could escape his miserable life.
The reader comments call out Skadi a lot, too; mind that the original comments have been lost due to Dumm Comic's site malfunctioning, and that there are both a new comment section on Dumm Comics and another on Skadi's own site, which means a lot of comics that seem to have gone without comments simply had their comments lost to the abyss. Even so, there are still plenty of comments about Skadi being an abusive dick.
Damnit XD How'd you make me like him again...
In Steve, I see a manipulator who is working a game of control and negging on Steven, to make him dependent. That he isn't a great manipulator or that he doesn't do it to other people doesn't change the nature of their relationship. That Steve is like this because he's likely immature and lacking in self confidence is the reasons behind the bullying, not the outcome.
To me, the outcome is that Steve puts down Steven to make sure Steven doesn't leave him for someone else, and abuses the power of that relationship to take things from Steven (like the arrowhead). This, and stuff like the bridge, show that its not a true friendship where they care for each other (like say Brian has with Seventeen) but rather a power game.
Though, as I said, SO MUCH of this is subjective interpretation. That you can read this in different ways is a great testament to Katie's storytelling ability.
All hail Adam!