wait, no, you made the vote count! that's unsuspicious again, since you're not MrBlarney.
i should have taken a moment to think, and voted for the less lazy option, Grunt's Ghosts and Goblins
What did GG do?
I voted for him to try and get a rise out of him,and that didn't happen.
But that's just terribly disappointing, not suspect.
bah, fine, i'll stop slacking off and actually do some vote analysis.
i picked a name off the early 2-votes-group that didn't get followed up on.
H3K was my first pick, but then i realized H3K did the vote count, which is inherently sort of less-suspicious
when we have no solid evidence of anything.
second vote moved GG up to two votes, nobody else piled on after that, instead it shifted away.
i'm sort of suspicious of Jpants for moving the vote onto H3K, but it was fairly early.
if there was a mafia member in that early cluster of tied votes, which there probably was statistically,
it behooves the mafia to make the breakaway vote a choice between two villagers.
the current most suspicious is LostNinja, who
a: advocated for leaving the vote tied, which with that many targets is madness, and leaves it very vulnerable to manipulation, and also
b: moved the vote onto Brody, a villager.
there is no concrete or good evidence for any of these three to be mafia, but the solidest leads are currently, in order:
LostNinja
Jpants
Grunt's Ghosts
all of these could be villagers with odd luck or bad ideas or whatever.
usually i just "sleep" through the first few days and pretend to not do this
or actually sleep through the first few days and do no analysis, then blast "the eye of the tiger" on day four and vanillager reveal
or be mafia and not do this at all
wait, no, you made the vote count! that's unsuspicious again, since you're not MrBlarney.
i should have taken a moment to think, and voted for the less lazy option, Grunt's Ghosts and Goblins
What did GG do?
I voted for him to try and get a rise out of him,and that didn't happen.
But that's just terribly disappointing, not suspect.
Read like two post above. It was some loose idea that I am racist because Black and Alabama.
wait, no, you made the vote count! that's unsuspicious again, since you're not MrBlarney.
i should have taken a moment to think, and voted for the less lazy option, Grunt's Ghosts and Goblins
What did GG do?
I voted for him to try and get a rise out of him,and that didn't happen.
But that's just terribly disappointing, not suspect.
Read like two post above. It was some loose idea that I am racist because Black and Alabama.
wait, no, you made the vote count! that's unsuspicious again, since you're not MrBlarney.
i should have taken a moment to think, and voted for the less lazy option, Grunt's Ghosts and Goblins
What did GG do?
I voted for him to try and get a rise out of him,and that didn't happen.
But that's just terribly disappointing, not suspect.
bah, fine, i'll stop slacking off and actually do some vote analysis.
i picked a name off the early 2-votes-group that didn't get followed up on.
H3K was my first pick, but then i realized H3K did the vote count, which is inherently sort of less-suspicious
when we have no solid evidence of anything.
second vote moved GG up to two votes, nobody else piled on after that, instead it shifted away.
i'm sort of suspicious of Jpants for moving the vote onto H3K, but it was fairly early.
if there was a mafia member in that early cluster of tied votes, which there probably was statistically,
it behooves the mafia to make the breakaway vote a choice between two villagers.
the current most suspicious is LostNinja, who a: advocated for leaving the vote tied, which with that many targets is madness, and leaves it very vulnerable to manipulation, and also
b: moved the vote onto Brody, a villager.
there is no concrete or good evidence for any of these three to be mafia, but the solidest leads are currently, in order:
LostNinja
Jpants
Grunt's Ghosts
all of these could be villagers with odd luck or bad ideas or whatever.
You do get that "a" was a joke right? That's why it was immediately followed up with "b" (those posts were less than a minute apart). And how is "b" suspicious given your reasoning for "a" being bad?
I think the color you signed up with is basically the "villager" color in this game .
Allright, that makes sense for Brody, but Preda signed up in blue. I erroneously assumed his name was in white, but that's cause I was on my phone at the time. Now that I'm on the desktop, I see his name is colorless (i.e. black on desktop, white on mobile).
I suppose that's to indicate that the color was sapped from him, that is, he was the mafia kill. Nice touch!
Good question.
You voted yesterday apparently, unlike Jpants.
I blame everyone but myself as obviously my sources failed to read the thread thoroughly.
I like the early on analysis. Feels like it adds more to the conversation rather than us just twiddling our thumbs day 1 and 2 waiting for something to go down.
I also want to drop a vote on JPants if only because I still feel a little guilt in voting someone out early in the first game in such a long time. Last day for that though, I'm not going to feel bad once we hit day 3.
I like the early on analysis. Feels like it adds more to the conversation rather than us just twiddling our thumbs day 1 and 2 waiting for something to go down.
I also want to drop a vote on JPants if only because I still feel a little guilt in voting someone out early in the first game in such a long time. Last day for that though, I'm not going to feel bad once we hit day 3.
She doesn't even vote for who she says is most suspicious though. Suspicious.
I think we've all learned an important lesson about suspicious:
Its fun to say suspicious.
I'm ok with the !JPants vote. Inactivity after such a long period between phallas is definitely suspicious. I usually lay low the first few days when I'm Mafia as well, 'cause you certainly don't want to gimp your group early on by getting voted off randomly because someone decided to latch on to a goofy comment you made on day 1.
Good question.
You voted yesterday apparently, unlike Jpants.
I blame everyone but myself as obviously my sources failed to read the thread thoroughly.
After re-reading the thread, I'm retracting my vote for !JPants[color] and voting !discrider
Way too quick to throw people under the bus and you were wrong twice. I took you at your word regarding inactivity and was wrong to do so. Inattention + sowing confusion gets you the rod!
Discrider's end of the day vote sounds an awful lot like something I'd do/say if I was trying to look innocent.
Also where's our vig? Did he try and attack whoever the guard was guarding? Are there more powers here than meets the eye? I know this was labeled as mostly vanilla compared to other games, but it's also Blarney. Not sure where this falls.
Discrider's end of the day vote sounds an awful lot like something I'd do/say if I was trying to look innocent.
Also where's our vig? Did he try and attack whoever the guard was guarding? Are there more powers here than meets the eye? I know this was labeled as mostly vanilla compared to other games, but it's also Blarney. Not sure where this falls.
It should be borne in mind that discrider (and I believe Lucedes) is from the southern hemisphere.
0
Options
38thDoelets never be stupid againwait lets always be stupid foreverRegistered Userregular
Discrider's end of the day vote sounds an awful lot like something I'd do/say if I was trying to look innocent.
Also where's our vig? Did he try and attack whoever the guard was guarding? Are there more powers here than meets the eye? I know this was labeled as mostly vanilla compared to other games, but it's also Blarney. Not sure where this falls.
It should be borne in mind that discrider (and I believe Lucedes) is from the southern hemisphere.
Good question.
You voted yesterday apparently, unlike Jpants.
I blame everyone but myself as obviously my sources failed to read the thread thoroughly.
I voted for H3Knuckles.
I'll have a vote up later once I look back at how yesterday's votes shook out. It's only day 2 so still not much to go on, though getting the first 3 votes today, and each of them seeming to use the same bad info (that I didn't vote) does feel like there *might* be something there (like bad info on the mafia board). Though probably not unless Romantic Undead is new to phalla. I could see a rookie making the mistake of dog-piling too hard and then switching votes when the rest of the mafia pointed it out to them.
Rereading RU's post it doesn't look like they are a noob so that just leaves "mafia thought i was inactive and they all used that as cover to vote me".
If nothing better jumps out at me i'll probably drop a vote on one of them. Or will try to get a second one of them in the running. Always fun to pit 2 suspects against each other.
Rereading RU's post it doesn't look like they are a noob so that just leaves "mafia thought i was inactive and they all used that as cover to vote me".
If nothing better jumps out at me i'll probably drop a vote on one of them. Or will try to get a second one of them in the running. Always fun to pit 2 suspects against each other.
Rereading RU's post it doesn't look like they are a noob so that just leaves "mafia thought i was inactive and they all used that as cover to vote me".
If nothing better jumps out at me i'll probably drop a vote on one of them. Or will try to get a second one of them in the running. Always fun to pit 2 suspects against each other.
Posts
he's alabamian, he's waiting for the south to rise again!
bah, fine, i'll stop slacking off and actually do some vote analysis.
i picked a name off the early 2-votes-group that didn't get followed up on.
H3K was my first pick, but then i realized H3K did the vote count, which is inherently sort of less-suspicious
when we have no solid evidence of anything.
second vote moved GG up to two votes, nobody else piled on after that, instead it shifted away.
i'm sort of suspicious of Jpants for moving the vote onto H3K, but it was fairly early.
if there was a mafia member in that early cluster of tied votes, which there probably was statistically,
it behooves the mafia to make the breakaway vote a choice between two villagers.
the current most suspicious is LostNinja, who
a: advocated for leaving the vote tied, which with that many targets is madness, and leaves it very vulnerable to manipulation, and also
b: moved the vote onto Brody, a villager.
there is no concrete or good evidence for any of these three to be mafia, but the solidest leads are currently, in order:
LostNinja
Jpants
Grunt's Ghosts
all of these could be villagers with odd luck or bad ideas or whatever.
or actually sleep through the first few days and do no analysis, then blast "the eye of the tiger" on day four and vanillager reveal
or be mafia and not do this at all
but it's been so long!
Was Brody a special of some kind?
Preda was white, which would indicate colorless-ness, but narration seems to suggest that he was a villager.
Read like two post above. It was some loose idea that I am racist because Black and Alabama.
Different birbs though
You do get that "a" was a joke right? That's why it was immediately followed up with "b" (those posts were less than a minute apart). And how is "b" suspicious given your reasoning for "a" being bad?
I'm going to throw up Jpants for inactivity. If only to wake him up.
Allright, that makes sense for Brody, but Preda signed up in blue. I erroneously assumed his name was in white, but that's cause I was on my phone at the time. Now that I'm on the desktop, I see his name is colorless (i.e. black on desktop, white on mobile).
I suppose that's to indicate that the color was sapped from him, that is, he was the mafia kill. Nice touch!
You voted yesterday apparently, unlike Jpants.
I blame everyone but myself as obviously my sources failed to read the thread thoroughly.
I think its possible that there are less kills/no SK because this is a smaller than normal game.
I also want to drop a vote on JPants if only because I still feel a little guilt in voting someone out early in the first game in such a long time. Last day for that though, I'm not going to feel bad once we hit day 3.
She doesn't even vote for who she says is most suspicious though. Suspicious.
I think we've all learned an important lesson about suspicious:
Its fun to say suspicious.
Jpants voted for knuckles
Way too quick to throw people under the bus and you were wrong twice. I took you at your word regarding inactivity and was wrong to do so. Inattention + sowing confusion gets you the rod!
@38thDoe Thankyou for introducing me to this crack by running prinny themed games
Island Name: Felinefine
I'm also from Alabama (though not currently living there)
corvidae!
Island Name: Felinefine
Also where's our vig? Did he try and attack whoever the guard was guarding? Are there more powers here than meets the eye? I know this was labeled as mostly vanilla compared to other games, but it's also Blarney. Not sure where this falls.
Confusion will be my epitaph
What part?
It should be borne in mind that discrider (and I believe Lucedes) is from the southern hemisphere.
Glad I could help. I try to only run games on media that I'd recommend. Which game are you playing?
Anniston and Birmingham
Island Name: Felinefine
Disgea 5 - using Nintendo switch
Island Name: Felinefine
So I should trust him less?
Confusion will be my epitaph
Thanks for the tag! I did totally forget Phalla was back after voting yesterday.
I voted for H3Knuckles.
I'll have a vote up later once I look back at how yesterday's votes shook out. It's only day 2 so still not much to go on, though getting the first 3 votes today, and each of them seeming to use the same bad info (that I didn't vote) does feel like there *might* be something there (like bad info on the mafia board). Though probably not unless Romantic Undead is new to phalla. I could see a rookie making the mistake of dog-piling too hard and then switching votes when the rest of the mafia pointed it out to them.
If nothing better jumps out at me i'll probably drop a vote on one of them. Or will try to get a second one of them in the running. Always fun to pit 2 suspects against each other.
Montgomery and Troy. Everyone I talk to in this forum that is from Alabama is from your neck of the woods.
Island Name: Felinefine
Romantic Undead is definitely not new to phalla.
I have just been... away...
I honestly don't know the answer to this. This person is a complete unknown to me. I have NO PRIOR DATA TO BASE ASSUMPTIONS OFF OF!