All PMs should be out. If I missed anything please PM me.
Also, a reminder because I keep seeing this. YOU CAN ONLY USE GIFTS YOU HAVE RECEIVED, NOT BOUGHT. AND JUST BECAUSE SOMEONE TELLS YOU THAT THEY ARE GIVING YOU THAT GIFT DOES NOT MEAN YOU HAVE IT UNTIL I SAY YOU DO. AND YOU CAN ONLY USE ONE GIFT PER DAY! YOU CAN BUY MULTIPLE GIFTS AT ONCE AND EVEN MULTIPLES OF THE SAME GIFT AND SEND MULTIPLE GIFTS TO AS MANY OR FEW PEOPLE AS YOU PLEASE, BUT YOU CAN'T USE A GIFT YOU BOUGHT. THANK YOU.
+2
Options
lonelyahavaCall me Ahava ~~She/Her~~Move to New ZealandRegistered Userregular
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
Well, looks like Blue wasn't just using snake eyes on kime. If they'd died to mafia I'd know who to vote for next, but it looks like Santa kime got them. Rats!
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
edited November 2017
So we have 9 players left:
Auralynx
Brody
H3Knuckles
JayKaos
lonelyahava
LostNinja
mrpaku
Raiden333
Sir Fabulous
Now, we can safely assume that the three trick or treaters, Lock (boy in devil costume), Shock (girl in witch costume, or child witch?), and Barrel (boy in skeleton costume), are mafia since they're Oogie Boogie's (KetBra's) henchmen. Do we think there were more than four mafia at the start? It's usually about 20% right? so with 25 players that'd 5, but the only other villainous character in the movie is the mad scientist who's brain went missing in the game's prologue.
Unless! Unless the female scientist he makes and gives half his brain to at the end of the film is a character who took his remaining half to have a complete brain? But why would she be affiliated with Oogie (mafia) though?
I asked GG for clarification last night whether flesh masks would obfuscate death announcements and he confirmed that they do not, so we should be able to trust those.
What a ghost town, in both a literal and figurative sense!
Regardless, did anyone know if chamberlain or Virgil was open about being married?
I don't know why they would be, it'd put a huge target on them.
Presumably only the mafia would have wed them, so unless they were worried about the SK there wouldn't have been any harm in it. Might have even been beneficial so we could round up a couple of guards to protect them.
Anyway, Auralynx cause I got nothing. Voting records aren't the most useful this game.
H3, since you usually track voting stuff, is there anyone that hasn't been on the bandwagon consistently? GG said mafia accumulate scares differently, so it may be something like avoiding the bandwagon since that would draw suspicion.
What a ghost town, in both a literal and figurative sense!
Regardless, did anyone know if chamberlain or Virgil was open about being married?
I don't know why they would be, it'd put a huge target on them.
Presumably only the mafia would have wed them, so unless they were worried about the SK there wouldn't have been any harm in it. Might have even been beneficial so we could round up a couple of guards to protect them.
To elaborate on this, wedding two players would serve no benefit for a villager to do unless they knew both were mafia, also if it had been Kime they would have killed them the night after having done it.
+1
Options
lonelyahavaCall me Ahava ~~She/Her~~Move to New ZealandRegistered Userregular
It's saturday here and I'm spending all day stuck inside with a toddler who wants to play outside, but it's raining. and trying to spring clean the house around said toddler.
[color-red] Auralynx[/color]
it's odd to me that there was something of a push on an earlier day, but then it faded into nothing. I sadly don't have the time to go back and look at why.
Bah, not gonna be around closer to vote end so I'll probably miss out on the scares for being on the right bandwagon. We're running low on villagers though, so if folks have scares they should probably be using them on guards instead of seering.
And if blue was after LostNinja that's good enough for me.
Hey Fabulous, while we're getting some vital info out to the village, what was up with that night one self vote
0
Options
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
edited November 2017
Also, @lonelyahava it doesn't look like anyone's voted for Aura at all before today, though I do seem to recall claims of suspicion against them.
@LostNinja Looks like Brody, Sir Fabulous best fit your criteria (each have been off the wagon 3/4 days). Auralynx didn't follow the wagon 2 days, was inactive a 3rd.
Hey Fabulous, while we're getting some vital info out to the village, what was up with that night one self vote
I don't think you've played with me much before, yeah? I think if you asked other players who've had more games with me, they wouldn't be that surprised...
Not sure what I've done suspicious besides apparently being early on a couple bandwagons*. I pretty much always vote early so that was bound to happen this game.
*Well that and the mysterious whispers.
LostNinja on
0
Options
lonelyahavaCall me Ahava ~~She/Her~~Move to New ZealandRegistered Userregular
Oh. Oops.
Taking the toddler to the pool for swimming lessons.
Hey Fabulous, while we're getting some vital info out to the village, what was up with that night one self vote
I don't think you've played with me much before, yeah? I think if you asked other players who've had more games with me, they wouldn't be that surprised...
Or I'm a bomb.
Who knows?
Don't get me wrong, I get having a thing...I do!
But for your thing to be "hey, I'm Joe Q Badass, you should know me by my reputation, and I play by no man's rules" 8-)
That doesn't mean you're *not* suspicious. That just means you have an ongoing *excuse* for being suspicious
Hey Fabulous, while we're getting some vital info out to the village, what was up with that night one self vote
I don't think you've played with me much before, yeah? I think if you asked other players who've had more games with me, they wouldn't be that surprised...
Hey Fabulous, while we're getting some vital info out to the village, what was up with that night one self vote
I don't think you've played with me much before, yeah? I think if you asked other players who've had more games with me, they wouldn't be that surprised...
Or I'm a bomb.
Who knows?
Don't get me wrong, I get having a thing...I do!
But for your thing to be "hey, I'm Joe Q Badass, you should know me by my reputation, and I play by no man's rules" 8-)
That doesn't mean you're *not* suspicious. That just means you have an ongoing *excuse* for being suspicious
So you agree I have an excuse for being suspicious, right?
Looks like it's serving it's purpose then!
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
0
Options
Sir FabulousMalevolent Squid GodRegistered Userregular
Hey Fabulous, while we're getting some vital info out to the village, what was up with that night one self vote
I don't think you've played with me much before, yeah? I think if you asked other players who've had more games with me, they wouldn't be that surprised...
@Sir Fabulous I can second Bluecyan saying doubts about LN in pms
To clarify, that wasn't a seer call correct.
He(?) was vague, whether to avoid exposing self as seer, or because he wasn't sure of results (flesh mask, possibility of miller role), or just hadn't gotten to you yet, I can't say. He only said 'strongly suspicious', whereas he claimed snake eyes for kime's results. It's why I'm not gung-ho about going after you.
Anyway here are my thoughts for after I die green:
I think Mrpaku is village due to being the first to mention the shady whispers thing that I'm guessing is a mafia ability.
Leaning towards Ohava being village as well since she bit and changed her vote last minute last night when Kime was PMing people claiming to be village special.
I think I trust H3 since they are usually more quiet when they mafia (which to be fair I think has only been once)
Posts
Also, a reminder because I keep seeing this. YOU CAN ONLY USE GIFTS YOU HAVE RECEIVED, NOT BOUGHT. AND JUST BECAUSE SOMEONE TELLS YOU THAT THEY ARE GIVING YOU THAT GIFT DOES NOT MEAN YOU HAVE IT UNTIL I SAY YOU DO. AND YOU CAN ONLY USE ONE GIFT PER DAY! YOU CAN BUY MULTIPLE GIFTS AT ONCE AND EVEN MULTIPLES OF THE SAME GIFT AND SEND MULTIPLE GIFTS TO AS MANY OR FEW PEOPLE AS YOU PLEASE, BUT YOU CAN'T USE A GIFT YOU BOUGHT. THANK YOU.
good at it, but a sneaky liar.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZqIoViuHkuA
OOOoOooOoOOoO
Now, we can safely assume that the three trick or treaters, Lock (boy in devil costume), Shock (girl in witch costume, or child witch?), and Barrel (boy in skeleton costume), are mafia since they're Oogie Boogie's (KetBra's) henchmen. Do we think there were more than four mafia at the start? It's usually about 20% right? so with 25 players that'd 5, but the only other villainous character in the movie is the mad scientist who's brain went missing in the game's prologue.
Unless! Unless the female scientist he makes and gives half his brain to at the end of the film is a character who took his remaining half to have a complete brain? But why would she be affiliated with Oogie (mafia) though?
I asked GG for clarification last night whether flesh masks would obfuscate death announcements and he confirmed that they do not, so we should be able to trust those.
Edit: although listening to the song you posted, the lyrics fit better.
Regardless, did anyone know if chamberlain or Virgil was open about being married?
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
I don't know why they would be, it'd put a huge target on them.
Presumably only the mafia would have wed them, so unless they were worried about the SK there wouldn't have been any harm in it. Might have even been beneficial so we could round up a couple of guards to protect them.
Anyway, Auralynx cause I got nothing. Voting records aren't the most useful this game.
H3, since you usually track voting stuff, is there anyone that hasn't been on the bandwagon consistently? GG said mafia accumulate scares differently, so it may be something like avoiding the bandwagon since that would draw suspicion.
To elaborate on this, wedding two players would serve no benefit for a villager to do unless they knew both were mafia, also if it had been Kime they would have killed them the night after having done it.
[color-red] Auralynx[/color]
it's odd to me that there was something of a push on an earlier day, but then it faded into nothing. I sadly don't have the time to go back and look at why.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
He felt confident about voting !LostNinja this evening, and so do i
And if blue was after LostNinja that's good enough for me.
Hi! Sorry I'm so late getting on, will check the vote records and be back in just a smidge, LN.
Do you have anything to substantiate your claims?
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
@LostNinja Looks like Brody, Sir Fabulous best fit your criteria (each have been off the wagon 3/4 days). Auralynx didn't follow the wagon 2 days, was inactive a 3rd.
No joke, when blue pm'ed me about kime; my response was
I don't think you've played with me much before, yeah? I think if you asked other players who've had more games with me, they wouldn't be that surprised...
Or I'm a bomb.
Who knows?
This is very helpful.
I assume Sally was the Seer? It fits pretty well...
LostNinja
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
*Well that and the mysterious whispers.
Taking the toddler to the pool for swimming lessons.
Won't be back till after close.
lostninja
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
I'd be surprised if multiple people hadn't. If they had on different nights that would prove me village.
Don't get me wrong, I get having a thing...I do!
But for your thing to be "hey, I'm Joe Q Badass, you should know me by my reputation, and I play by no man's rules" 8-)
That doesn't mean you're *not* suspicious. That just means you have an ongoing *excuse* for being suspicious
To clarify, that wasn't a seer call correct.
But it wasn't a seer call
So you agree I have an excuse for being suspicious, right?
Looks like it's serving it's purpose then!
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
No, not officially, but it means (if Sally was in fact the Seer) that you hadn't been Seered clear yet.
And sometimes Seers try to drop hints about suspicious folks without making an official call if they're scared.
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
He(?) was vague, whether to avoid exposing self as seer, or because he wasn't sure of results (flesh mask, possibility of miller role), or just hadn't gotten to you yet, I can't say. He only said 'strongly suspicious', whereas he claimed snake eyes for kime's results. It's why I'm not gung-ho about going after you.
I think Mrpaku is village due to being the first to mention the shady whispers thing that I'm guessing is a mafia ability.
Leaning towards Ohava being village as well since she bit and changed her vote last minute last night when Kime was PMing people claiming to be village special.
I think I trust H3 since they are usually more quiet when they mafia (which to be fair I think has only been once)
I HAVE GAZED UPON HIS NOT-FACE, AND IT WAS *GLORIOUS*
I HAVE WALKED WITH JACK AMONGST THE BRIAR AND BONES*
Not if they wed someone else that they will kill tonight.