With the assumption that the mafia's copy of jdark's ability works the same way:
1.) It mean Kime is probably village. There's no way the mafia would change a vote to convict if they didn't know how other people were voting on one of their own.
2.) We REALLY need to get the action log in place. BlueCyan had a good start a few pages back. I'd look for someone who doesn't have claims for Day 1, 2 or 5 as our briber and someone without day 2 and 3 as our civil claim blocker.
3.) MrT is still mafia. Look at how helpful he's trying to be now that he's gotten called out.
4.) It is likely that there are 5 minor village specials (Current claims: Jdark-bribery; Moridin-appelate; kime-???; Preda-???, Brody-Civil Action block)
Aren't there two mafia groups?
Also, Preda and I share the same ability. So we think they are evil, then?
It might help if the people that were affected by kime/Preda's power come forward. Kime should have three Preda should have four if they are telling the truth about how often they used abilities.
Also, Preda and I share the same ability. So we think they are evil, then?
For Appelate and Bribe we have one each in the village and the mafia have shown the ability to duplicate those. Hence if you and Preda claim the same power one of you is likely to be mafia.
And for red vote I guess Kime because I feel like there had to have been a mafia in the Day 1 officers and I think everyone else is accounted for (assuming MamaWolf is not part of ZHs mafia).
And for red vote I guess Kime because I feel like there had to have been a mafia in the Day 1 officers and I think everyone else is accounted for (assuming MamaWolf is not part of ZHs mafia).
As a reminder, jpants, the mafia tried to kill kime with a bribe on day 2.
And for red vote I guess Kime because I feel like there had to have been a mafia in the Day 1 officers and I think everyone else is accounted for (assuming MamaWolf is not part of ZHs mafia).
As a reminder, jpants, the mafia tried to kill kime with a bribe on day 2.
That's not ringing a bell but I'm pretty frazzled from last minute packing and trailer prep. Was that one where jdark didn't reveal his vote so they couldn't be sure he was safe?
Preda based on the toss up between Kime and them. Kime seems to be playing more similar to the Nightmare Before Christmas Phalla but every game I have played with Preda and they've been Village, inactivus got them well before now.
Bluecyan, if you want to add to your action list, I was civil cases:
2-01 FOIA on discrider
3-01 FOIA on ZH
4-01 FOIA on Mamawolf
Thanks, I'll try and get the list updated after work today (may be too late to support much for today so if someone else wants to pick it up and update it please do)
I'm sort of baffled why Preda came forward to me if they are mafia. Why help confirm kime's claim?
He may not have realized kimes exact power? He may not have realized the village has the same specials as the mafia? He needed to claim something since we were collecting actions?
And for red vote I guess Kime because I feel like there had to have been a mafia in the Day 1 officers and I think everyone else is accounted for (assuming MamaWolf is not part of ZHs mafia).
As a reminder, jpants, the mafia tried to kill kime with a bribe on day 2.
That's not ringing a bell but I'm pretty frazzled from last minute packing and trailer prep. Was that one where jdark didn't reveal his vote so they couldn't be sure he was safe?
No, this was day 2, when no one revealed their vote until the end, but kime was charged and revealed that he was a special to try and not die.
Ok, I should be up to speed, so let's start with my claim. I'm action seer.
That were my action the various days:
Day 1 I targeted JFP, that as a good inactivus didn't do anything. I did go to bed and didn't get back to check at vote close. My bad...
Day 2 I targeted kime, and I've seen him using a special power on Jdark. That paired on kime saying that he would confim himself with his target made me come out with jdark, that I considered probably village, and giving him all this info.
On his suggestion, day 3 I targeted mamawolf, that, surprise surprise, that night used a special ability on jdark. Wander what it might be... That day I come out to kime too, that claimed my same ability.
On day 4 I targeted Green and he used a special ability on Jaysonfour. That died. So he's probably mafia and probably to convict as soon as possible.
That said, semi-mandatory read on all survivors:
1. kime - Judge - claimed my same power, but he knew of me (the reverse is true too) and didn't do anything about it. Probably villlage.
4. MrTLicious - low post count, little information in it, suspicious
6. JPants - really loud especially in the first part of the week, his many ideas didn't get many followers. His vocality make me lean village.
8. lonelyahava - replaced an inactive player and her contribution consisted mostly in question on the game mechanics, way to appear active without being so. Suspicious.
9. Bluecyan - did a useful claimed action count. I've done vote counts as village and as mafia both (when I had time to do that). Undecided.
10. LostNinja - Judge - I don't have a good reed on him, good claims, but also bad ones. Undecided.
12. 38thDoe - District Attorney - I begin having doubts on him, because his long service as DA din't give us any mafia.
14. Preda - investigator
16. Gizzy - Judge - her story make sense. it's compatible with what we believe to know on the mafia powers. It's either the thruth or a really good ruse. I lean on Thruth
17. chamberlain - two chances here. I can't decide which. He's either village, than yesterday conviction change is a ruse to make us consume one of our conviction tonight or he's mafia, and than yestersay move was desperation. In the second case I suspect we hit another mafia yesterday...
21. kuhlmeye - many suspected him at the start of the game, less now. I still lean more mafia than not.
24. Wildcat - really little to read. suspicious.
I accept suggestion on today target.
0
38thDoelets never be stupid againwait lets always be stupid foreverRegistered Userregular
And for red vote I guess Kime because I feel like there had to have been a mafia in the Day 1 officers and I think everyone else is accounted for (assuming MamaWolf is not part of ZHs mafia).
As a reminder, jpants, the mafia tried to kill kime with a bribe on day 2.
That's not ringing a bell but I'm pretty frazzled from last minute packing and trailer prep. Was that one where jdark didn't reveal his vote so they couldn't be sure he was safe?
No, this was day 2, when no one revealed their vote until the end, but kime was charged and revealed that he was a special to try and not die.
While true we did not formally reveal how we would be voting .. in the DA chat I think we kinda informally did reveal we'd be voting to acquit. We discussed Kime revealing as a special, and told Lostninja he should withdraw his Kime submission.
Switch Animal Crossing Friend Code: SW-5107-9276-1030
Island Name: Felinefine
And for red vote I guess Kime because I feel like there had to have been a mafia in the Day 1 officers and I think everyone else is accounted for (assuming MamaWolf is not part of ZHs mafia).
As a reminder, jpants, the mafia tried to kill kime with a bribe on day 2.
That's not ringing a bell but I'm pretty frazzled from last minute packing and trailer prep. Was that one where jdark didn't reveal his vote so they couldn't be sure he was safe?
No, this was day 2, when no one revealed their vote until the end, but kime was charged and revealed that he was a special to try and not die.
While true we did not formally reveal how we would be voting .. in the DA chat I think we kinda informally did reveal we'd be voting to acquit. We discussed Kime revealing as a special, and told Lostninja he should withdraw his Kime submission.
Will confirm this. I messed up the close time and started doing some stuff IRL and did not get it changed in time.
And for red vote I guess Kime because I feel like there had to have been a mafia in the Day 1 officers and I think everyone else is accounted for (assuming MamaWolf is not part of ZHs mafia).
As a reminder, jpants, the mafia tried to kill kime with a bribe on day 2.
That's not ringing a bell but I'm pretty frazzled from last minute packing and trailer prep. Was that one where jdark didn't reveal his vote so they couldn't be sure he was safe?
No, this was day 2, when no one revealed their vote until the end, but kime was charged and revealed that he was a special to try and not die.
While true we did not formally reveal how we would be voting .. in the DA chat I think we kinda informally did reveal we'd be voting to acquit. We discussed Kime revealing as a special, and told Lostninja he should withdraw his Kime submission.
So that would’ve been Jdark, LostNinja, Gizzy, 38thDoe and Mamawolf.
It’s not out of the realm of possibility that none of those people were mafia. Or at least, not associated it’s the larger mafia. They may not have known that’s how you were leaning.
1. kime - seems a little less flamboyant than I remember... I'm wondering why.
4. MrTLicious - mafia-level suspicious and on the down-low.
6. JPants - probably village? I don't really have much of an opinion yet.
8. lonelyahava - mafia. Is being her usual delightful self but not contributing anything of substance. Plus replacements are 50/50 to be mafia ohoho
9. Bluecyan - doing enough to be a helpful mafioso.
10. LostNinja - can't tell what they're at yet.
12. 38thDoe - I backed 38D to the hilt at the beginning but I'm beginning to lean towards them either being a desperately unlucky villager or a rather cunning mafioso.
14. Preda - is it just my impression, or has Preda only really begun to start talking now?
16. Gizzy - probably a villager, 70/30.
17. chamberlain - I don't think the mafia are desperate enough (yet?) to so blantantly save one of their own. I call SHENANIGANS
Posts
Kime I have played with, and is being much quieter Than I'm used to.
Kime has survived a mafia bribe and didn't vote to eliminate Gizzy last night.
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
Aren't there two mafia groups?
Also, Preda and I share the same ability. So we think they are evil, then?
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Kime, 38th
Preda due to the duplicate claimed powers and Chamberlain being convicted tonight.
For Appelate and Bribe we have one each in the village and the mafia have shown the ability to duplicate those. Hence if you and Preda claim the same power one of you is likely to be mafia.
MrT Gizzy kime
MrT 38th[/b]
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
MrT Gizzy kime
MrT 38th
2-01 FOIA on discrider
3-01 FOIA on ZH
4-01 FOIA on Mamawolf
38thDoe Gizzy JPants
JPants 38th
And for red vote I guess Kime because I feel like there had to have been a mafia in the Day 1 officers and I think everyone else is accounted for (assuming MamaWolf is not part of ZHs mafia).
As a reminder, jpants, the mafia tried to kill kime with a bribe on day 2.
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
Thanks, I'll try and get the list updated after work today (may be too late to support much for today so if someone else wants to pick it up and update it please do)
He may not have realized kimes exact power? He may not have realized the village has the same specials as the mafia? He needed to claim something since we were collecting actions?
No, this was day 2, when no one revealed their vote until the end, but kime was charged and revealed that he was a special to try and not die.
Island Name: Felinefine
That were my action the various days:
Day 1 I targeted JFP, that as a good inactivus didn't do anything. I did go to bed and didn't get back to check at vote close. My bad...
Day 2 I targeted kime, and I've seen him using a special power on Jdark. That paired on kime saying that he would confim himself with his target made me come out with jdark, that I considered probably village, and giving him all this info.
On his suggestion, day 3 I targeted mamawolf, that, surprise surprise, that night used a special ability on jdark. Wander what it might be... That day I come out to kime too, that claimed my same ability.
On day 4 I targeted Green and he used a special ability on Jaysonfour. That died. So he's probably mafia and probably to convict as soon as possible.
That said, semi-mandatory read on all survivors:
1. kime - Judge - claimed my same power, but he knew of me (the reverse is true too) and didn't do anything about it. Probably villlage.
4. MrTLicious - low post count, little information in it, suspicious
6. JPants - really loud especially in the first part of the week, his many ideas didn't get many followers. His vocality make me lean village.
8. lonelyahava - replaced an inactive player and her contribution consisted mostly in question on the game mechanics, way to appear active without being so. Suspicious.
9. Bluecyan - did a useful claimed action count. I've done vote counts as village and as mafia both (when I had time to do that). Undecided.
10. LostNinja - Judge - I don't have a good reed on him, good claims, but also bad ones. Undecided.
12. 38thDoe - District Attorney - I begin having doubts on him, because his long service as DA din't give us any mafia.
14. Preda - investigator
16. Gizzy - Judge - her story make sense. it's compatible with what we believe to know on the mafia powers. It's either the thruth or a really good ruse. I lean on Thruth
17. chamberlain - two chances here. I can't decide which. He's either village, than yesterday conviction change is a ruse to make us consume one of our conviction tonight or he's mafia, and than yestersay move was desperation. In the second case I suspect we hit another mafia yesterday...
21. kuhlmeye - many suspected him at the start of the game, less now. I still lean more mafia than not.
24. Wildcat - really little to read. suspicious.
I accept suggestion on today target.
Don’t forget to get an order in.
While true we did not formally reveal how we would be voting .. in the DA chat I think we kinda informally did reveal we'd be voting to acquit. We discussed Kime revealing as a special, and told Lostninja he should withdraw his Kime submission.
Island Name: Felinefine
Will confirm this. I messed up the close time and started doing some stuff IRL and did not get it changed in time.
So that would’ve been Jdark, LostNinja, Gizzy, 38thDoe and Mamawolf.
It’s not out of the realm of possibility that none of those people were mafia. Or at least, not associated it’s the larger mafia. They may not have known that’s how you were leaning.
Jpants, 38thdoe
Island Name: Felinefine
Jpants, 38thdoe
Island Name: Felinefine
Island Name: Felinefine
Island Name: Felinefine
Island Name: Felinefine
According to Jdark, it's a once per game ability.
Island Name: Felinefine
1. kime - seems a little less flamboyant than I remember... I'm wondering why.
4. MrTLicious - mafia-level suspicious and on the down-low.
6. JPants - probably village? I don't really have much of an opinion yet.
8. lonelyahava - mafia. Is being her usual delightful self but not contributing anything of substance. Plus replacements are 50/50 to be mafia ohoho
9. Bluecyan - doing enough to be a helpful mafioso.
10. LostNinja - can't tell what they're at yet.
12. 38thDoe - I backed 38D to the hilt at the beginning but I'm beginning to lean towards them either being a desperately unlucky villager or a rather cunning mafioso.
14. Preda - is it just my impression, or has Preda only really begun to start talking now?
16. Gizzy - probably a villager, 70/30.
17. chamberlain - I don't think the mafia are desperate enough (yet?) to so blantantly save one of their own. I call SHENANIGANS
22. kuhlmeye - tickles my mafiadar somewhat.
24. Wildcat - confirmed mafioso, surely?