House of the Rising Sun population is higher today than it was on D3 by 1. Going to post our house chat group list. We've been talking since at the latest D2 with each other. I know Jdark recommended not revealing info, but at this point either the mafia are in the ring or they already have a very good idea who is.
House of Rising Sun:
Gizzy
MamaWolf
Heffling
BlueCyan
*To be edited in later if permission is given*
On Day 3 (when I had perfect info) we were at six population. Today we are at seven. This change happened today.
House of the Rising Sun population is higher today than it was on D3 by 1. Going to post our house chat group list. We've been talking since at the latest D2 with each other. I know Jdark recommended not revealing info, but at this point either the mafia are in the ring or they already have a very good idea who is.
House of Rising Sun:
Gizzy
MamaWolf
Heffling
BlueCyan
*To be edited in later if permission is given*
On Day 3 (when I had perfect info) we were at six population. Today we are at seven. This change happened today.
... your count's not quite right.
His count is correct for those that have given permission to share this information.
Is it that time? Time for what? For a Gizzy list I just spent hours thinking about and typing? Yes it is!
1. 38thDoe – village feel
due to conversations, no strong read from vote record, could change depending on H3 alignment.
Claimed converted to partisan D2; Turned back into a villager D3
Day 1 – Only vote on ZH. It doesn’t seem like any of the wagons were on mafia. no read.
Day 2 – Last vote on winning CJ, shortly after 2 mafia voted. If H3 turns up mafia this could look bad.
Day 3 – Missed the vote
Day 4 – voted ZH, competing wagons were roman and shalmelo. I talked him out of voting ZH, he then moved vote to discrider
3. Bluecyan – Village
Day 1 – first vote of the day, only vote on Obifett – no read
Day 2 – first vote on H3/Green after wagons on himself and CJ formed. Mafia pushed vote on Blue. – reads village.
Day 3 – pushed vote on mafia – village read
Day 4 – pushed vote on mafia – village read
5. Discrider - Village
Day 1 – First vote on CJ, wagons hadn’t formed – no read
Day 2 – First vote on CJ, moved to Bluecyan, moved to H3/Green – could look good if H3 is mafia
Day 3 – First vote on shalmelo (mafia), moved to premium (mafia) in a good push position, then moved to roman after two other mafia votes. Could be a bad look.
Day 4 – Pushed romanqwerty as steam was building on shalmelo, moved to Jpants shortly thereafter, revealed converting shalmelo to partisan, then tied the vote on shalmelo. Could be read like mafia accussing mafia to look good. My personal feel is village move.
6. Gizzy – Village of course
Day 1 – Lots of suspicious vote movement! Voted to Phyphor, then he revealed game info. Voted for wildcat for no reason. Then moved vote to CJ agreeing that his comments seemed weird.
Day 2 – Voted Bluecyan early, moved vote to CJ jumping competing wagons. Mafia vote movement happened right afterwards. This one could look shady, again depends on H3.
Day 3 – Voted mafia, first vote on wagon. Not really any competing wagons at the time, couple of votes on shalmelo.
Day 4 – steam building on shalmelo, but voted for kime (reason being because at the time discrider was vouching for shalmelo). Could look bad if kime is village.
7. Green H3Knuckles – leaning suspicious
Day 1 – Green had early vote on mamawolf. – no read
Day 2 – missed the vote
Day 3 – voted for Lost Ninja instead of wagons on premium/shalmelo. Could look bad if LostNinja is village. Would be hilarious if lost was mafia.
Day 4 – Pushed ZH instead of shalmelo – bad look (if ZH is village)
8. Heffling – mostly no read
based on votes with exception of day 4, leaning village due to house conversation
Day 1 – Early vote on bluecyan – no read
Day 2 – Early vote on CJ – no read
Day 3 – Early vote on Lost Ninja – no read
Day 4 – Vote on ZH when shalmelo wagon had some steam – bad look (if ZH is village)
11. JPants – no read
based on votes until other alignments are revealed
Day 1 – later vote on CJ, possible competing wagons were jdark, heffling, wildcat, (invictus had no votes at this time), - no read
Day 2 – mid CJ wagon, H3 had no votes on him at the time – no read
Day 3 – pushed LostNinja over premium/shalmelo. Looks bad, unless lost is mafia.
Day 4 – pushed kime wagon instead of shalmelo. Looks bad, unless kime is mafia.
12. JusticeforPluto - Suspicious
Day 1 – Late vote on CJ, jdark/heff/wildcat were tied at 2 (no votes on invlctus at this time) – no read
Day 2 – Late vote on Auralynx, avoiding all wagons. Slight m-vibe.
Day 3 - Missing vote
Day 4 – Early vote on roman, who mafia tried to push on day 3. M-vibe
13. Kime - Suspicious
Day 1 – last vote of the day on Invictus .. looks weird b/c Invictus seemed village then won the vote. But could be whatever b/c day 1 – slight m-vibe
Day 2 – On Bluecyan wagon before H3 had any votes – no read
Day 3 – Missing vote
Day 4 – Pushing ZH instead of shalmelo, vote happened while he had 1 vote on himself so was not one of the wagons at the time – Looks bad, unless ZH is mafia
14. LostNinja – Leaning village
Day 1 – voted jdark, 14th vote of the day, no wagons at the time – no read
Day 2 – Missing vote
Day 3 – 2nd vote on shalmelo (mafia), before disc moved his vote off. Later that day became a wagon himself competing against 2 mafia. Those 2 mafia didn’t vote for him though. – mostly village read
Day 4 – Voted ZH while shalmelo and roman wagons were building steam – could look bad, unless ZH is mafia
15. MamaWolf - Village
Day 1 – Green/H3, to Discrider, back to Green/H3 – no read
Day 2 – Moved from Bluecyan to H3/Green – no read
Day 3 – moved from roman to good push position on premium wagon – village
Day 4 – good early push position on shalmelo wagon – village
16. ObiFett - Suspicious
Day 1 – 18th vote of the day, only vote on roman – no read
Day 2 – Middle of CJ wagon – no read
Day 3 – 11th vote of the day, only vote on jdark. Avoided Lost Ninja/premium/shalmelo wagons – m-vibe
Day 4 – Last votes of the day, late vote on shalmelo, moved off to roman – m-vibe
19. Romanqwerty - Village
Day 1 – wagon steam position on Phyphor, left vote there after wagon dissipated – could be slight m-vibe
Day 2 – earlyish on CJ wagon – no read
Day 3 – 2 mafia tried to vote him out, seemed to be winning the vote – Village
Day 4 – pushed shalmelo vote – Village
21. Wildcat - Village
Day 1 – Early and only vote on J4P, push vote by premium before CJ wagon formed – Village
Day 2 – Voted premium, 13th vote of the day and only vote while there were other wagons – this could read as villager responding to being voted for day 1
Day 3 – Good position on premium – Village
Day 4 – Early vote on shalmelo – village
22. Zombie Hero – Village
(for those meta reasons everyone hates)
Day 1 – Late day vote on wildcat, followed by premium – doesn’t seem like mafia would have a reason to pile together here so this reads village to me.
Day 2 – Pushed bluecyan, premium also pushed bluecyan. ZH’s vote was at a point where the only wagon was CJ. I think normally I might say slight m-vibes but we were talking and voting blue for the same reasons that day.
Day 3 – Right between two mafia on roman when the other wagons were those 2 mafia. Looks bad, but like he said in a funny too bad kind of way.
Day 4 – He pushed kime, shalmelo (mafia) pushed ZH – looking village to me
Switch Animal Crossing Friend Code: SW-5107-9276-1030
Island Name: Felinefine
But also, seeing H3's alignment would help me make stronger opinions on several people. So from an information standpoint, I'd be cool with that vote.
Switch Animal Crossing Friend Code: SW-5107-9276-1030
Island Name: Felinefine
0
Options
MamaWolfThe wolf pack guides all to safetyRegistered Userregular
My analysis while not hours spent on it just gut feelings.
1. 38thDoe – village vibe
3. Bluecyan – village because of communication we've had and been very pro village from day 1.
5. Discrider - though we don't have our usual "You're mafia" tit for tat, I only assume it's because we both realize neither of us are actually mafia.
6. Gizzy – Village because of her analysis
7. Green H3Knuckles – obviously voted day 1 because spouse originally, but seriously too quiet even when trying to communicate. Mafia vibes
8. Heffling – village vibes
11. JPants – mixed views
12. JusticeforPluto - Mixed views because of quietness as well.
13. Kime - mafia cause Kime and I attempted to reach out through message and litterally got back "just letting you know I saw this" and nothing else. Though this could be cause Kime forgot about it and just never got back.
14. LostNinja – Village vibes though I'm not 100% on that
15. MamaWolf - Village cause well I said so
16. ObiFett - mafia vibes
19. Romanqwerty - mixed feels
21. Wildcat - Village
22. Zombie Hero – Village maybe...I'm not 100% on this either
My vote Kime cause I don't want to judge H3 based off of Green if he was possibly just being quiet cause of not feeling well. But H3 is high on my list.
"May the moon watch over you and keep you safe through the night, 'till the morning comes and MamaWolf can protect you through the day"
0
Options
ObiFettUse the ForceAs You WishRegistered Userregular
Here's where I'm at in this game:
I left a clue about my house on like Day 1. No one reached out. Jdark said its bad to tell anyone your house. So I've not reached out to anyone since.
Yesterday, I was on board with Shalmelo being voted out (hence my vote post saying I was putting a vote in stone). Then I swapped out to keep the tie to force other people to make a choice.
Fwiw, looking at my activity objectively, I too would think I'm mafia. But not sure what else I should be doing this game.
House of the Rising Sun population is higher today than it was on D3 by 1. Going to post our house chat group list. We've been talking since at the latest D2 with each other. I know Jdark recommended not revealing info, but at this point either the mafia are in the ring or they already have a very good idea who is.
House of Rising Sun:
Gizzy
MamaWolf
Heffling
BlueCyan
*To be edited in later if permission is given*
On Day 3 (when I had perfect info) we were at six population. Today we are at seven. This change happened today.
... your count's not quite right.
His count is correct for those that have given permission to share this information.
So are you saying there's one more confirmed person who hasn't given authority for their name to be revealed?
House of the Rising Sun population is higher today than it was on D3 by 1. Going to post our house chat group list. We've been talking since at the latest D2 with each other. I know Jdark recommended not revealing info, but at this point either the mafia are in the ring or they already have a very good idea who is.
House of Rising Sun:
Gizzy
MamaWolf
Heffling
BlueCyan
*To be edited in later if permission is given*
On Day 3 (when I had perfect info) we were at six population. Today we are at seven. This change happened today.
... your count's not quite right.
His count is correct for those that have given permission to share this information.
So are you saying there's one more confirmed person who hasn't given authority for their name to be revealed?
In our group chat? No, there's just one who hasn't given permission. Our 6th member is a mystery person who is not part of the chat / hasn't revealed or reported in.
Switch Animal Crossing Friend Code: SW-5107-9276-1030
Island Name: Felinefine
House of the Rising Sun population is higher today than it was on D3 by 1. Going to post our house chat group list. We've been talking since at the latest D2 with each other. I know Jdark recommended not revealing info, but at this point either the mafia are in the ring or they already have a very good idea who is.
House of Rising Sun:
Gizzy
MamaWolf
Heffling
BlueCyan
*To be edited in later if permission is given*
On Day 3 (when I had perfect info) we were at six population. Today we are at seven. This change happened today.
... your count's not quite right.
His count is correct for those that have given permission to share this information.
So are you saying there's one more confirmed person who hasn't given authority for their name to be revealed?
In our group chat? No, there's just one who hasn't given permission. Our 6th member is a mystery person who is not part of the chat / hasn't revealed or reported in.
Aah, now I understand - thanks.
0
Options
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
Who said a little while back that you shouldn't reveal your house?
I'm starting to think more and more that the village should publicly reveal what houses they are since it is almost certain that the mafia has that info anyway.
Who said a little while back that you shouldn't reveal your house?
I'm starting to think more and more that the village should publicly reveal what houses they are since it is almost certain that the mafia has that info anyway.
I'll put my money where my mouth is. I'm 1982.
jdarksun (village) was concerned that it only aided mafia and partisans, so it wasn't in vanillagers interests to communicate their house. But that was early game when there was a lot less information about. At this point the consensus is that ne'er-do-wells can piece enough together that it doesn't really matter anymore.
He also said this -after- becoming the 7th Heaven Built house member by telling me while I was counting in thread.
So, he may have been wondering who would agree with him.
Your vote history is bad and none of the 3 village coordinated house groups vouch for you as working with them (to the best of my knowledge). Claim a house and explain the lack of contact and I might move my vote to one of the other people who also fail those two criteria.
Your vote history is bad and none of the 3 village coordinated house groups vouch for you as working with them (to the best of my knowledge). Claim a house and explain the lack of contact and I might move my vote to one of the other people who also fail those two criteria.
House That Heaven Built, and I was solo watching my three year old since Wednesday for the long weekend
Yeah I thought jfp’s and obi’s votes looked a little worse, hence going a different direction today. But now you claiming heaven house has me O.o
8 member party house eh?
That's actually agrees with what I have seen. SUPER weird for kime to claim Heaven at this point, other two houses would have been a safer call. Ironically this is about the only thing that gives me pause. But if my other option is Obi then kime has a better chance of turning up red.
Posts
... your count's not quite right.
2 Jdarksun – shalmelo (7), Lostninja (14)
2 Heffling – cj iwakura (9), Phyphor (23)
2 Wildcat – Gizzy (19), Zombie Hero (24), premium (25)
2 Invictus – Auralynx (30), kime (31)
1 Obifett – Bluecyan (1)
1 Shalmelo – jdarksun (2)
1 JusticeforPluto – Wildcat (3)
1 Green/H3 Knuckles – mamawolf (4), mamawolf (17)
1 Bluecyan – Heffling (6)
1 Phyphor – Gizzy (13), Invictus (15), romanqwerty (16)
1 Romanqwerty – ObiFett (18)
1 Zombie Hero – 38thDoe (22)
1 Mamawolf – Green/H3 (5), discrider (8)
0 Kime – romanqwerty (11), JPants (20)
0 Discrider – mamawolf (12)
0 Gizzy – Auralynx (21)
Day 2
4 Bluecyan – Gizzy (3), Mamawolf (5), Zombie Hero (6), Kime (8), premium (17), Discrider (19), CJ iwakura(20)
4 Green/H3 Knuckles – Bluecyan (12), Mamawolf (13), Discrider (22), jdarksun (23)
1 Auralynx – Jpants (7), Justice for Pluto (21)
1 premium – Wildcat (14)
Missing votes: H3/Green, LostNinja
Day 3
4 Lost Ninja – Heffling (2), JPants (9), Green/H3 (10), romanqwerty (15)
4 Premium – Gizzy (7), Bluecyan (8), mamawolf (12), wildcat (14), discrider (17)
2 Shalmelo – Discrider (3), Lost Ninja (6), jdarksun (13)
1 Jdarksun – Obifett (11)
0 Green/H3 – Lost Ninja (1)
0 Kime – romanqwerty (4)
Missing votes: 38thDoe, JusticeforPluto, kime
Day 4
5 Zombie Hero – Lostninja (10), Heffling (11), 38thDoe (12), shalmelo (13), kime (16), H3Knuckles (19)
3 kime – Gizzy (7), Zombie Hero (17), JPants (18)
2 Romanqwerty – JusticeforPluto (3), discrider (6), kime (8), Obifett (23)
1 Discrider - 38thdoe (14)
0 Jpants – discrider (9)
0 JusticeforPluto - Zombie Hero (15)
0 Lost Ninja – romanqwerty (1)
Island Name: Felinefine
His count is correct for those that have given permission to share this information.
** another small correction, realized I didn't have H3/Green's vote counted on Day 1
Island Name: Felinefine
LostNinja for now.
1. 38thDoe – village feel
Claimed converted to partisan D2; Turned back into a villager D3
Day 1 – Only vote on ZH. It doesn’t seem like any of the wagons were on mafia. no read.
Day 2 – Last vote on winning CJ, shortly after 2 mafia voted. If H3 turns up mafia this could look bad.
Day 3 – Missed the vote
Day 4 – voted ZH, competing wagons were roman and shalmelo. I talked him out of voting ZH, he then moved vote to discrider
3. Bluecyan – Village
Day 2 – first vote on H3/Green after wagons on himself and CJ formed. Mafia pushed vote on Blue. – reads village.
Day 3 – pushed vote on mafia – village read
Day 4 – pushed vote on mafia – village read
5. Discrider - Village
Day 2 – First vote on CJ, moved to Bluecyan, moved to H3/Green – could look good if H3 is mafia
Day 3 – First vote on shalmelo (mafia), moved to premium (mafia) in a good push position, then moved to roman after two other mafia votes. Could be a bad look.
Day 4 – Pushed romanqwerty as steam was building on shalmelo, moved to Jpants shortly thereafter, revealed converting shalmelo to partisan, then tied the vote on shalmelo. Could be read like mafia accussing mafia to look good. My personal feel is village move.
6. Gizzy – Village of course
Day 2 – Voted Bluecyan early, moved vote to CJ jumping competing wagons. Mafia vote movement happened right afterwards. This one could look shady, again depends on H3.
Day 3 – Voted mafia, first vote on wagon. Not really any competing wagons at the time, couple of votes on shalmelo.
Day 4 – steam building on shalmelo, but voted for kime (reason being because at the time discrider was vouching for shalmelo). Could look bad if kime is village.
7. Green H3Knuckles – leaning suspicious
Day 2 – missed the vote
Day 3 – voted for Lost Ninja instead of wagons on premium/shalmelo. Could look bad if LostNinja is village. Would be hilarious if lost was mafia.
Day 4 – Pushed ZH instead of shalmelo – bad look (if ZH is village)
8. Heffling – mostly no read
Day 1 – Early vote on bluecyan – no read
Day 2 – Early vote on CJ – no read
Day 3 – Early vote on Lost Ninja – no read
Day 4 – Vote on ZH when shalmelo wagon had some steam – bad look (if ZH is village)
11. JPants – no read
Day 1 – later vote on CJ, possible competing wagons were jdark, heffling, wildcat, (invictus had no votes at this time), - no read
Day 2 – mid CJ wagon, H3 had no votes on him at the time – no read
Day 3 – pushed LostNinja over premium/shalmelo. Looks bad, unless lost is mafia.
Day 4 – pushed kime wagon instead of shalmelo. Looks bad, unless kime is mafia.
12. JusticeforPluto - Suspicious
Day 2 – Late vote on Auralynx, avoiding all wagons. Slight m-vibe.
Day 3 - Missing vote
Day 4 – Early vote on roman, who mafia tried to push on day 3. M-vibe
13. Kime - Suspicious
Day 2 – On Bluecyan wagon before H3 had any votes – no read
Day 3 – Missing vote
Day 4 – Pushing ZH instead of shalmelo, vote happened while he had 1 vote on himself so was not one of the wagons at the time – Looks bad, unless ZH is mafia
14. LostNinja – Leaning village
Day 2 – Missing vote
Day 3 – 2nd vote on shalmelo (mafia), before disc moved his vote off. Later that day became a wagon himself competing against 2 mafia. Those 2 mafia didn’t vote for him though. – mostly village read
Day 4 – Voted ZH while shalmelo and roman wagons were building steam – could look bad, unless ZH is mafia
15. MamaWolf - Village
Day 2 – Moved from Bluecyan to H3/Green – no read
Day 3 – moved from roman to good push position on premium wagon – village
Day 4 – good early push position on shalmelo wagon – village
16. ObiFett - Suspicious
Day 2 – Middle of CJ wagon – no read
Day 3 – 11th vote of the day, only vote on jdark. Avoided Lost Ninja/premium/shalmelo wagons – m-vibe
Day 4 – Last votes of the day, late vote on shalmelo, moved off to roman – m-vibe
19. Romanqwerty - Village
Day 2 – earlyish on CJ wagon – no read
Day 3 – 2 mafia tried to vote him out, seemed to be winning the vote – Village
Day 4 – pushed shalmelo vote – Village
21. Wildcat - Village
Day 2 – Voted premium, 13th vote of the day and only vote while there were other wagons – this could read as villager responding to being voted for day 1
Day 3 – Good position on premium – Village
Day 4 – Early vote on shalmelo – village
22. Zombie Hero – Village
Day 1 – Late day vote on wildcat, followed by premium – doesn’t seem like mafia would have a reason to pile together here so this reads village to me.
Day 2 – Pushed bluecyan, premium also pushed bluecyan. ZH’s vote was at a point where the only wagon was CJ. I think normally I might say slight m-vibes but we were talking and voting blue for the same reasons that day.
Day 3 – Right between two mafia on roman when the other wagons were those 2 mafia. Looks bad, but like he said in a funny too bad kind of way.
Day 4 – He pushed kime, shalmelo (mafia) pushed ZH – looking village to me
Island Name: Felinefine
Island Name: Felinefine
Island Name: Felinefine
1. 38thDoe – village vibe
3. Bluecyan – village because of communication we've had and been very pro village from day 1.
5. Discrider - though we don't have our usual "You're mafia" tit for tat, I only assume it's because we both realize neither of us are actually mafia.
6. Gizzy – Village because of her analysis
7. Green H3Knuckles – obviously voted day 1 because spouse originally, but seriously too quiet even when trying to communicate. Mafia vibes
8. Heffling – village vibes
11. JPants – mixed views
12. JusticeforPluto - Mixed views because of quietness as well.
13. Kime - mafia cause Kime and I attempted to reach out through message and litterally got back "just letting you know I saw this" and nothing else. Though this could be cause Kime forgot about it and just never got back.
14. LostNinja – Village vibes though I'm not 100% on that
15. MamaWolf - Village cause well I said so
16. ObiFett - mafia vibes
19. Romanqwerty - mixed feels
21. Wildcat - Village
22. Zombie Hero – Village maybe...I'm not 100% on this either
My vote Kime cause I don't want to judge H3 based off of Green if he was possibly just being quiet cause of not feeling well. But H3 is high on my list.
I left a clue about my house on like Day 1. No one reached out. Jdark said its bad to tell anyone your house. So I've not reached out to anyone since.
Yesterday, I was on board with Shalmelo being voted out (hence my vote post saying I was putting a vote in stone). Then I swapped out to keep the tie to force other people to make a choice.
Fwiw, looking at my activity objectively, I too would think I'm mafia. But not sure what else I should be doing this game.
Island Name: Felinefine
So are you saying there's one more confirmed person who hasn't given authority for their name to be revealed?
In our group chat? No, there's just one who hasn't given permission. Our 6th member is a mystery person who is not part of the chat / hasn't revealed or reported in.
Island Name: Felinefine
Aah, now I understand - thanks.
I would not be cool with that vote.
ObiFett
Kime is the top of my suspicious list.
Because there should be a 1982 Mafia, and they likely jumped ship.
But I don't have much info on who's claimed what to figure out who hasn't claimed and might now have joined the house of Sun.
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
I'm starting to think more and more that the village should publicly reveal what houses they are since it is almost certain that the mafia has that info anyway.
I'll put my money where my mouth is. I'm 1982.
eh, gotta do something to create an interesting voting trail and discussion.
jdarksun (village) was concerned that it only aided mafia and partisans, so it wasn't in vanillagers interests to communicate their house. But that was early game when there was a lot less information about. At this point the consensus is that ne'er-do-wells can piece enough together that it doesn't really matter anymore.
So, he may have been wondering who would agree with him.
I feel like the reasoning is..... lacking? Which is pretty bad on day 5 lol
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Your vote history is bad and none of the 3 village coordinated house groups vouch for you as working with them (to the best of my knowledge). Claim a house and explain the lack of contact and I might move my vote to one of the other people who also fail those two criteria.
Weak mafia argument is weak, old buddy...
House That Heaven Built, and I was solo watching my three year old since Wednesday for the long weekend
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
8 member party house eh?
Island Name: Felinefine
Don't blame me!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Oh, but we will.
Having said that, !JusticeforPluto.
That's actually agrees with what I have seen. SUPER weird for kime to claim Heaven at this point, other two houses would have been a safer call. Ironically this is about the only thing that gives me pause. But if my other option is Obi then kime has a better chance of turning up red.