MamaWolfThe wolf pack guides all to safetyRegistered Userregular
Like I said been going with my gut lately and have been iffy on H3knuckles I don't know...I've been going off of information Blue gave me and my gut. Blue is out, so I guess my suspicions and gut will have to be my reasoning.
"May the moon watch over you and keep you safe through the night, 'till the morning comes and MamaWolf can protect you through the day"
0
MamaWolfThe wolf pack guides all to safetyRegistered Userregular
I am open to hearing counter options and reasoning to defend H3
"May the moon watch over you and keep you safe through the night, 'till the morning comes and MamaWolf can protect you through the day"
MamaWolfThe wolf pack guides all to safetyRegistered Userregular
Also Green/H3's vote record:
Day 1: votes me (not counting day 1 votes cause based off non-sense most of time)
Day 2- didn't vote
Day 3- Votes Lost Ninja (which I don't remember the reasoning for)
Day 4: Votes ZH wagon (to counter Shalmelo wagon)
Day 5- Votes Obi (no big read here just stating)
Me:
I have not voted for a known villager.
Day 1- Green/H3 (again day 1 doesn't really count)
Day 2- Green/H3 (was really quiet and didn't vote)
Day 3- Premium (mafia)
Day 4- Shalmelo (mafia)
Day 5- Kime(mafia)
If I am mafia I voted to kill a lot of my fellow members and am a bad one in my opinion.
"May the moon watch over you and keep you safe through the night, 'till the morning comes and MamaWolf can protect you through the day"
I was toying with moving off H3 yesterday, as he was converted and then a 1982 moved to the Rising Sun without also moving a Partisan.
But if there are two Mafia per house then it's possible he is a 1982 Mafia whilst the other Mafia jumped.
Assuming that this isn't a third party shuffling people between houses.
From blues post it sounds like we started with 6 mafia. 3 in heaven, 2 in 1982, and 1 in rising sun. Then they started switching houses (or using some kind of confuse the numbers ability)
Switch Animal Crossing Friend Code: SW-5107-9276-1030
Island Name: Felinefine
So if we just completely ignore all potential jumping (from what I've seen villagers and partisans can't jump houses) and just go off what Blue said our starting numbers were, and which house people claim:
Heaven: 1 partisan + 4 villagers = 5 members
Rising: 1 partisan + 4 villagers = 5 members
1982: 1 partisan + 5 villagers = 6 members
Current claims plus confirmed dead people:
Heaven: 4 Dead + 2 claim = 6
Rising: 1 Dead + 5 claim = 6
1982: 1 Dead + 6 claim = 7
From that it looks like there's 1 mafia in each list of claims.
Switch Animal Crossing Friend Code: SW-5107-9276-1030
Island Name: Felinefine
As for a vote, I'm not 100% sold on H3K, and have been suspicious of Lost for bit of the game, but looking at the vote records I think Heffling looks slightly worse than LN. Lost at least had a good spot on Shalmelo day 3. I'm not gonna be sad if H3k eats it either though as his vote record is.... not great. But I'm still leaning Heff.
0
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
Day 4 H3Knuckles was on the Zombie Hero train right behind two other mafia members. Day 5 he was one of the only non-Kime voters.
Okay, so Day 4 I had to read through the entire game in one afternoon (it didn't register on me that it was extended through Monday evening until after I'd basically caught up). When I voted, ZH was already in the lead, my gut was wrong about kime, and disc had just flipped to not voting against shalmelo because he'd just propagandized shal. disc had read very village to me those first couple game days, and shal had been trying to figure out the house populations the day before I was catching up, so I figured go with the majority and increase ZH's to reduce the risk of vote shenanigans.
Day 5, I straight followed Gizzy's list of suspicions based on vote analysis and voted the same person they did.
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
Oh, should the winds shift and I look to be surviving the vote tonight, I'd appreciate a cleanse so I'm no longer partisan, thank you. In return, I won't propaganda anyone tonight.
If we think there's one in rising sun, I'm def waaaaay more suspicious of J4P over Heffling. Heffling is a bad vote IMO.
Also it's tempting to go for that potentially 50% chance of hitting mafia if blue is right and voting LostNinja. Though I do agree his Day 3 vote looks good. But sometimes mafia votes for mafia so ehh?
I have a few suspicions for 1982 house, H3 being on that list. But hmmm there's a couple of other folks pinging at me there now, including some shifts in my original list I laid out yesterday. But I don't want to lay it out due to on a vin diagram my suspicions overlapping with who might be the steward.
Anyway, there's my chaos mind... voting on LostNinja for now, would vote out H3 over Heffling so might move my vote later.
Switch Animal Crossing Friend Code: SW-5107-9276-1030
Island Name: Felinefine
If we think there's one in rising sun, I'm def waaaaay more suspicious of J4P over Heffling. Heffling is a bad vote IMO.
Also it's tempting to go for that potentially 50% chance of hitting mafia if blue is right and voting LostNinja. Though I do agree his Day 3 vote looks good. But sometimes mafia votes for mafia so ehh?
I have a few suspicions for 1982 house, H3 being on that list. But hmmm there's a couple of other folks pinging at me there now, including some shifts in my original list I laid out yesterday. But I don't want to lay it out due to on a vin diagram my suspicions overlapping with who might be the steward.
Anyway, there's my chaos mind... voting on LostNinja for now, would vote out H3 over Heffling so might move my vote later.
Didn't your previous post imply one in each house?
Also is there a master list of who is in what house that is flying around and i'm the only one who doesn't know it? I'm not really sure how folks are making statements like the bold
I mean I leaked it to shalmelo, so yes, he has claimed.
Gizzy on
Switch Animal Crossing Friend Code: SW-5107-9276-1030
Island Name: Felinefine
0
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
Honestly, LostNinja feels like a better vote to me as well. I'd really like a confirmation from @discrider on whether LostNinja claimed to be from the House That Heaven Built, though:
I mean I leaked it to shalmelo, so yes, he has claimed.
Because that is super suspicious given the population number stuff Blue posted. That house having no non-partisans last night means that unless disc propagandized Lost and never told anyone (but when? before, after, or in-between propagandizing me and shalmelo?) then Lost is able to jump houses.
I guess I could re-read the thread and try to figure out who everyone has claimed, but I don't know all the house words and for my OWN house I've only found 3 others all game so I think instead I'll focus on vote records and suspect posts.
I have a few suspicions for 1982 house, H3 being on that list. But hmmm there's a couple of other folks pinging at me there now, including some shifts in my original list I laid out yesterday.
rofl it sounds like you know more people in my house than I do!
Jdark because heaven knows we always end up trying to vote each other out anyway.
This could be lost "claiming" Heaven Built Day 1....
Yeah, he confirmed the words shortly after, before Phyphor's reveal.
After wondering whether he could trust me or not because I caught the reference in the first place.
And then he followed me onto shalmelo day 3.
He's been solidly villager all game, and I'm absolutely not sold on there being three Mafia on my house to begin with.
Because that is super suspicious given the population number stuff Blue posted. That house having no non-partisans last night means that unless disc propagandized Lost and never told anyone (but when? before, after, or in-between propagandizing me and shalmelo?) then Lost is able to jump houses.
What?
Lost was never a partisan as far as I know and all the partisan movements of the Heaven house are explained through Phyphor, shalmelo and I.
Although I still don't know who turned me into a partisan in the first place.
Honestly, LostNinja feels like a better vote to me as well. I'd really like a confirmation from @discrider on whether LostNinja claimed to be from the House That Heaven Built, though:
I mean I leaked it to shalmelo, so yes, he has claimed.
Because that is super suspicious given the population number stuff Blue posted. That house having no non-partisans last night means that unless disc propagandized Lost and never told anyone (but when? before, after, or in-between propagandizing me and shalmelo?) then Lost is able to jump houses.
Where is the me being partisan coming from? Or me jumping houses? I’ve been Heaven all game (claimed day 1), and never implied being a partisan.
0
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
Because that is super suspicious given the population number stuff Blue posted. That house having no non-partisans last night means that unless disc propagandized Lost and never told anyone (but when? before, after, or in-between propagandizing me and shalmelo?) then Lost is able to jump houses.
What?
Lost was never a partisan as far as I know and all the partisan movements of the Heaven house are explained through Phyphor, shalmelo and I.
Although I still don't know who turned me into a partisan in the first place.
Right, but Blue's numbers showed a night where heaven had no non-partisans. That's my concern, why is the stewards' power that tells them how many NP's a house has saying LostNinja didn't exist for a night? Unless Lost changed house.
Honestly, LostNinja feels like a better vote to me as well. I'd really like a confirmation from @discrider on whether LostNinja claimed to be from the House That Heaven Built, though:
I mean I leaked it to shalmelo, so yes, he has claimed.
Because that is super suspicious given the population number stuff Blue posted. That house having no non-partisans last night means that unless disc propagandized Lost and never told anyone (but when? before, after, or in-between propagandizing me and shalmelo?) then Lost is able to jump houses.
Where is the me being partisan coming from? Or me jumping houses? I’ve been Heaven all game (claimed day 1), and never implied being a partisan.
I was leaving you a possible out that you'd been converted with no one knowing. Otherwise there's a big problem since Heaven Built supposedly had 0 non-partisans for a day.
I don't know where the day 5 Heaven stats even come from.
I pretty certain it's the wardens that have the house lists, and we lost ours day 2.
Anyway, it looks like we're running with "Mafia
pick their house N1" and in that circumstance, I can see a lot of them joining Phyphor's house because he had announced prior to vote close.
... But he had said only Aura contacted him.
So.
That also doesn't make sense.
Posts
If not I think he needs to.
Day 1: votes me (not counting day 1 votes cause based off non-sense most of time)
Day 2- didn't vote
Day 3- Votes Lost Ninja (which I don't remember the reasoning for)
Day 4: Votes ZH wagon (to counter Shalmelo wagon)
Day 5- Votes Obi (no big read here just stating)
Me:
I have not voted for a known villager.
Day 1- Green/H3 (again day 1 doesn't really count)
Day 2- Green/H3 (was really quiet and didn't vote)
Day 3- Premium (mafia)
Day 4- Shalmelo (mafia)
Day 5- Kime(mafia)
If I am mafia I voted to kill a lot of my fellow members and am a bad one in my opinion.
But if there are two Mafia per house then it's possible he is a 1982 Mafia whilst the other Mafia jumped.
Assuming that this isn't a third party shuffling people between houses.
Island Name: Felinefine
2 Jdarksun – shalmelo (7), Lostninja (14)
2 Heffling – cj iwakura (9), Phyphor (23)
2 Wildcat – Gizzy (19), Zombie Hero (24), premium (25)
2 Invictus – Auralynx (30), kime (31)
1 Obifett – Bluecyan (1)
1 Shalmelo – jdarksun (2)
1 JusticeforPluto – Wildcat (3)
1 Green/H3 Knuckles – mamawolf (4), mamawolf (17)
1 Bluecyan – Heffling (6)
1 Phyphor – Gizzy (13), Invictus (15), romanqwerty (16)
1 Romanqwerty – ObiFett (18)
1 Zombie Hero – 38thDoe (22)
1 Mamawolf – Green/H3 (5), discrider (8)
0 Kime – romanqwerty (11), JPants (20)
0 Discrider – mamawolf (12)
0 Gizzy – Auralynx (21)
Day 2
4 Bluecyan – Gizzy (3), Mamawolf (5), Zombie Hero (6), Kime (8), premium (17), Discrider (19), CJ iwakura(20)
4 Green/H3 Knuckles – Bluecyan (12), Mamawolf (13), Discrider (22), jdarksun (23)
1 Auralynx – Jpants (7), Justice for Pluto (21)
1 premium – Wildcat (14)
Missing votes: H3/Green, LostNinja
Day 3
4 Lost Ninja – Heffling (2), JPants (9), Green/H3 (10), romanqwerty (15)
4 Premium – Gizzy (7), Bluecyan (8), mamawolf (12), wildcat (14), discrider (17)
2 Shalmelo – Discrider (3), Lost Ninja (6), jdarksun (13)
1 Jdarksun – Obifett (11)
0 Green/H3 – Lost Ninja (1)
0 Kime – romanqwerty (4)
Missing votes: 38thDoe, JusticeforPluto, kime
Day 4
5 Zombie Hero – Lostninja (10), Heffling (11), 38thDoe (12), shalmelo (13), kime (16), H3Knuckles (19)
3 kime – Gizzy (7), Zombie Hero (17), JPants (18)
2 Romanqwerty – JusticeforPluto (3), discrider (6), kime (8), Obifett (23)
1 Discrider - 38thdoe (14)
0 Jpants – discrider (9)
0 JusticeforPluto - Zombie Hero (15)
0 Lost Ninja – romanqwerty (1)
Day 5
2 JusticeforPluto – Heffling (7), wildcat (12), kime (15)
2 Obifett – Gizzy (5), H3Knuckles (8)
1 Zombie Hero – LostNinja (2)
1 LostNinja – JusticeforPluto (3)
0 H3Knuckles – Discrider (1)
Island Name: Felinefine
Heaven: 1 partisan + 4 villagers = 5 members
Rising: 1 partisan + 4 villagers = 5 members
1982: 1 partisan + 5 villagers = 6 members
Current claims plus confirmed dead people:
Heaven: 4 Dead + 2 claim = 6
Rising: 1 Dead + 5 claim = 6
1982: 1 Dead + 6 claim = 7
From that it looks like there's 1 mafia in each list of claims.
Island Name: Felinefine
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Well done Hosts! I know what I'm listening to for the rest of the day!
So are you saying LostNinja claimed Heaven Built? Because that doesn't fit Bluecyan's numbers.
What's that saying about the third on a wagon?
Okay, so Day 4 I had to read through the entire game in one afternoon (it didn't register on me that it was extended through Monday evening until after I'd basically caught up). When I voted, ZH was already in the lead, my gut was wrong about kime, and disc had just flipped to not voting against shalmelo because he'd just propagandized shal. disc had read very village to me those first couple game days, and shal had been trying to figure out the house populations the day before I was catching up, so I figured go with the majority and increase ZH's to reduce the risk of vote shenanigans.
Day 5, I straight followed Gizzy's list of suspicions based on vote analysis and voted the same person they did.
I don't know what else to say, people.
Also it's tempting to go for that potentially 50% chance of hitting mafia if blue is right and voting LostNinja. Though I do agree his Day 3 vote looks good. But sometimes mafia votes for mafia so ehh?
I have a few suspicions for 1982 house, H3 being on that list. But hmmm there's a couple of other folks pinging at me there now, including some shifts in my original list I laid out yesterday. But I don't want to lay it out due to on a vin diagram my suspicions overlapping with who might be the steward.
Anyway, there's my chaos mind... voting on LostNinja for now, would vote out H3 over Heffling so might move my vote later.
Island Name: Felinefine
Didn't your previous post imply one in each house?
Also is there a master list of who is in what house that is flying around and i'm the only one who doesn't know it? I'm not really sure how folks are making statements like the bold
And in response to roman asking if lostninja claimed a house -
Island Name: Felinefine
Because that is super suspicious given the population number stuff Blue posted. That house having no non-partisans last night means that unless disc propagandized Lost and never told anyone (but when? before, after, or in-between propagandizing me and shalmelo?) then Lost is able to jump houses.
rofl it sounds like you know more people in my house than I do!
This could be lost "claiming" Heaven Built Day 1....
Reading back thru the thread and this back and forth Day 2 made me chuckle
Going with Heffling for seemingly always being a late vote on the winning wagon after its made clear which one that is.
Yeah, he confirmed the words shortly after, before Phyphor's reveal.
After wondering whether he could trust me or not because I caught the reference in the first place.
And then he followed me onto shalmelo day 3.
He's been solidly villager all game, and I'm absolutely not sold on there being three Mafia on my house to begin with.
Sometimes they are mafia and sometimes they are village just like every other place on a wagon?
What?
Lost was never a partisan as far as I know and all the partisan movements of the Heaven house are explained through Phyphor, shalmelo and I.
Although I still don't know who turned me into a partisan in the first place.
Man, that's crazy talk.
Where is the me being partisan coming from? Or me jumping houses? I’ve been Heaven all game (claimed day 1), and never implied being a partisan.
Right, but Blue's numbers showed a night where heaven had no non-partisans. That's my concern, why is the stewards' power that tells them how many NP's a house has saying LostNinja didn't exist for a night? Unless Lost changed house.
I was leaving you a possible out that you'd been converted with no one knowing. Otherwise there's a big problem since Heaven Built supposedly had 0 non-partisans for a day.
I pretty certain it's the wardens that have the house lists, and we lost ours day 2.
Anyway, it looks like we're running with "Mafia
pick their house N1" and in that circumstance, I can see a lot of them joining Phyphor's house because he had announced prior to vote close.
... But he had said only Aura contacted him.
So.
That also doesn't make sense.
6 H3Knuckles – mamawolf (2), discrider (3), justiceforPluto (4), Heffling (5), Zombie Hero (13), 38thdoe (14)
3 Heffling – Zombie Hero (6), Jpants (7), H3Knuckles (8), LostNinja (11), Obifett (12)
3 LostNinja – romanqwerty (1), Gizzy (9), H3Knuckles (10)
Not voted: wildcat
Island Name: Felinefine