The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.

[Anime] of Fall 2024: Aliens VS Spirits, Remakes VS Isekais

1676870727380

Posts

  • silence1186silence1186 Character shields down! As a wingmanRegistered User regular
    It seems like his editor is not doing his job. I'm not sure which way but given they're 0 for 2 here I'm gonna say it's bad calls regardless

    I never read Instant Bullet, but the ending is also underwhelming, supposedly. Love Agency barely got an ending, since it was axed. The humor was there, but you could tell they were struggling with the premise.

    Aka is also teaming up with the artist from Record of Ragnarok to do a new fantasy series this coming Spring(?) I think. Not sure what to expect.

  • djmitchelladjmitchella Registered User regular
    Latest One Piece, is this the first time we've had a "previously on One Piece" reminder of who someone is?
    ynhjzsdbvq3j.png
    Normally it feels like characters just show up and we're meant to recognise them, no matter how many hundreds of chapters it's been since we last saw them, so it was nice to have a bit of help for once -- I just don't remember this ever happening before.

    No, it happened ALL THE TIME during the Revelry arc. Because people were making their first non-art page appearances in 500 chapters

    Oh, yeah, you're right, when I go back and skim through that, they have literally "a XYZ refresher" for a bunch of people as well as a whole bunch of general "here's a map of the world, in case you forgot" sorts of thing.

    (though that was the arc just before Wano, and Wano went on for long enough it's pushed a bunch of other things out of my 'details I can remember about one piece' list, which is, I must admit, fairly short in the first place)

  • EspantaPajaroEspantaPajaro Registered User regular
    edited November 13
    Just started dandadan since everyone was talking about it , man what a weird but funny first episode .

    10/10 would not give them my banana

    Edit - why is the grandma so hot ?>_>

    EspantaPajaro on
  • rhylithrhylith Death Rabbits HoustonRegistered User regular
    There’s been enough Dandadan talk everywhere I look that I finally watched it and have continued reading.

    I will get into premise spoilers here, but honestly people who haven’t watched and are thinking about it should click.
    I had read the first chapter a while back and dropped it right away because of the alien abduction sexual assault attempt and old lady ghost/penis thief of it all, but hearing that that chapter was kind of an outlier I gave it another shot.

    It’s still very, very juvenile stuff tryin to return Okarun’s magical golden testicles, but the ghosts and aliens stuff is handled well and the characters are fun, plus a lot of the jokes are actually landing and the art is wild. It’s kept me interested.

  • Munkus BeaverMunkus Beaver You don't have to attend every argument you are invited to. Philosophy: Stoicism. Politics: Democratic SocialistRegistered User, ClubPA regular
    Re Zero hits another out of the park
    Love the Subaru speech. Perfect job of building up to it by showing these people go "no dude, we trust you because you get fucking results, you are insane with what you accomplished" and it still feels natural for Subaru to be full of doubts because he remembers all his failures vividly. But these people don't see that, they just see him win almost every encounter frame one. And his speech was actually good, in that it wasn't full of lies and false hope. It clearly laid out the very real situation they were in, then asked them to not surrender to their fears and to lean on each other. And ended with his call to action and saying hey, I've beaten a fuckin Archbishop before I don't give a shit.

    And last shot of the OP as all fuck Reinhardt showing up.

    Humor can be dissected as a frog can, but dies in the process.
  • LarsLars Registered User regular
    Really nice callback in the latest manga chapter of Watamote, though it makes me think the series is probably going to end soon and also won't be continuing into college.

  • AstharielAsthariel The Book Eater Registered User regular
    edited November 13
    Fuck, I have many conflicting opinions about ReZero.

    Character designs are often cringeworthy and it has some obvious trashy tropes, and yet despite it all it is written much smarter, than it could be expected and it remains consistently interesting after first 10 episodes of first season.

    It is a very engaging story, but I still wish the artstyle was not so utterly "anime". I wish I could recommend this series to friends, but I know that they will look at it and ask me what kind of trash am I watching and why.

    Asthariel on
  • EspantaPajaroEspantaPajaro Registered User regular
    Sounds like you need less judgmental friends to be honest.

  • Local H JayLocal H Jay Registered User regular
    edited November 13
    I think anyone who has any overt issues with ReZero's designs probably isn't super down with anime to begin with. ReZero has the standard waifus to hawk merch but outside that it's probably the least offensive popular isekai you could recommend, when the alternatives are the very rapey/incesty SAO and the slave owner Shield Hero

    Local H Jay on
  • JayKaosJayKaos Registered User regular
    The plot is less offensive sure (and "least offensive isekai" is not a real high bar) but if you look at it without that in mind it checks all the very standard tropey character designs (twin maids but one's got boobs, catgirl, immortal ghost in child's body, clown-looking dude for no reason, etc) so I can definitely understand the concern.

    Steam | SW-0844-0908-6004 and my Switch code
  • MadicanMadican No face Registered User regular
    JayKaos wrote: »
    The plot is less offensive sure (and "least offensive isekai" is not a real high bar) but if you look at it without that in mind it checks all the very standard tropey character designs (twin maids but one's got boobs, catgirl, immortal ghost in child's body, clown-looking dude for no reason, etc) so I can definitely understand the concern.

    As someone who bounced off ReZero because my first encounter with it was Subaru making an ass of himself during some kind of princess election, I also got curious about who this Reinhard fellow was to be considered so strong.
    How in the fuck can there be any stakes in the story that can be solved with combat when this guy even exists? "What's your power?" "All of them and also any that I make up."

  • silence1186silence1186 Character shields down! As a wingmanRegistered User regular
    Madican wrote: »
    JayKaos wrote: »
    The plot is less offensive sure (and "least offensive isekai" is not a real high bar) but if you look at it without that in mind it checks all the very standard tropey character designs (twin maids but one's got boobs, catgirl, immortal ghost in child's body, clown-looking dude for no reason, etc) so I can definitely understand the concern.

    As someone who bounced off ReZero because my first encounter with it was Subaru making an ass of himself during some kind of princess election, I also got curious about who this Reinhard fellow was to be considered so strong.
    How in the fuck can there be any stakes in the story that can be solved with combat when this guy even exists? "What's your power?" "All of them and also any that I make up."

    The story explicitly explains how during several arcs. It's pretty clever.

  • rhylithrhylith Death Rabbits HoustonRegistered User regular
    edited November 13
    I admit there’s a chunk of season 1 that’s a rough watch because Subaru keeps making the worst choices and being awful, but they are doing all that to get him on the path to being better.

    Anyways I don’t have crunchyroll right now so I don’t think I can watch the new season.

    rhylith on
  • Moth 13Moth 13 Registered User regular
    I can definitely see Re: Zero getting weird looks. A lot of those characters are extremely Baby.

  • AstharielAsthariel The Book Eater Registered User regular
    edited November 13
    My problem with it is that its extremely "cutesy".

    It can be said that it serves contrasting how "anime" it looks with how utterly brutal it can get, but I dont think that the benefits of it are worth the drawbacks.

    On the other hand, it still is praiseworthy that the series has atually good story and actually well written characters, despite looking like something so completely cliche.

    Asthariel on
  • silence1186silence1186 Character shields down! As a wingmanRegistered User regular
    Re Zero hits another out of the park
    Love the Subaru speech. Perfect job of building up to it by showing these people go "no dude, we trust you because you get fucking results, you are insane with what you accomplished" and it still feels natural for Subaru to be full of doubts because he remembers all his failures vividly. But these people don't see that, they just see him win almost every encounter frame one. And his speech was actually good, in that it wasn't full of lies and false hope. It clearly laid out the very real situation they were in, then asked them to not surrender to their fears and to lean on each other. And ended with his call to action and saying hey, I've beaten a fuckin Archbishop before I don't give a shit.

    And last shot of the OP as all fuck Reinhardt showing up.

    Incredible episode. No notes.

  • Munkus BeaverMunkus Beaver You don't have to attend every argument you are invited to. Philosophy: Stoicism. Politics: Democratic SocialistRegistered User, ClubPA regular
    rhylith wrote: »
    I admit there’s a chunk of season 1 that’s a rough watch because Subaru keeps making the worst choices and being awful, but they are doing all that to get him on the path to being better.

    Anyways I don’t have crunchyroll right now so I don’t think I can watch the new season.

    The thing about re zero is that the misery has a point. Subaru fails. Constantly. it is the fucking theme of the show! His power only ever works when he absolutely, categorically fails. But he has more growth than literally any other anime character I have seen. He grows as a person each episode each season.

    And honestly, I don’t really like some of the waifu designs either, but they make sense thematically. Why does Roswell make Rem and Rom dress like French maids? Because he is a creepy, awful person.

    As for Subaru’s power being OP…it’s really, really not. He has no control over the save points, and has no idea when they will kick in. And he to, and this is VERY important, actually die each and every time in order to have it kick in.

    And it hurts, a lot, every time. The reason why the shows are wallows in his misery at times early on is to drive that point home. It isn’t just a respawn, he has to slowly bleed out after being disembowled. More than once his mind was utterly shattered by how he had just died and it took a minute (or magic) to have him pull himself back together.

    And the Emilia/Subaru romance doesn’t make a ton of sense to start…but by season 2 it all starts making sense. They are an actual couple who argues and shit, but care about each other.

    I dunno, I am always willing to go the mat for this show because it is extremely clever writing that addresses a lot of the issues with standard isekai trope writing. And like someone said, it actually feels like a world with history that existed independent of Subaru.

    Humor can be dissected as a frog can, but dies in the process.
  • Local H JayLocal H Jay Registered User regular
  • Munkus BeaverMunkus Beaver You don't have to attend every argument you are invited to. Philosophy: Stoicism. Politics: Democratic SocialistRegistered User, ClubPA regular
    I mean, it's not super fanservice is the thing. It's very waifu-ish and very much intended to sell merch and make the series popular and whatnot.

    But it's not like huge tiddys covered by 3 washcloths.

    Humor can be dissected as a frog can, but dies in the process.
  • Local H JayLocal H Jay Registered User regular
    I'm aware in the show they keep fan-service light, that was mostly in response to "rem and ram are dressed as maids because lorewise this guy creepy" which, sure... But there is always that element with anime where it wants to have it's cake (commentary on maid-likers being creeps) while eating fistfuls of cake (exactly 1 million statues of rem in various states of undress or sexy costumes). I understand in the show itself, Rem isn't objectified as hard, but if you Google "rem statue" there will be some NSFW returns. I just tried it and in the first 10 images are Rem in a Bed, Rem laying on top of Ram, Rem in a swimsuit

    Or peep these official brand collabs with um, bikini bride Rem
    https://www.reddit.com/r/NikkeMobile/s/w65uoCpxlP

  • BadablackBadablack Registered User regular
    Isn't this show supposed to take place in like filthy medieval Europe with more dragons, why are people running around in these outfits.

    Why is this man wearing a tracksuit.

    FC: 1435-5383-0883
  • WearingglassesWearingglasses Of the friendly neighborhood variety Registered User regular
    rhylith wrote: »
    There’s been enough Dandadan talk everywhere I look that I finally watched it and have continued reading.

    I will get into premise spoilers here, but honestly people who haven’t watched and are thinking about it should click.
    I had read the first chapter a while back and dropped it right away because of the alien abduction sexual assault attempt and old lady ghost/penis thief of it all, but hearing that that chapter was kind of an outlier I gave it another shot.

    It’s still very, very juvenile stuff tryin to return Okarun’s magical golden testicles, but the ghosts and aliens stuff is handled well and the characters are fun, plus a lot of the jokes are actually landing and the art is wild. It’s kept me interested.
    Thoughts on chapter 17 / what will be episode 7?

  • DoodmannDoodmann Registered User regular
    Badablack wrote: »
    Isn't this show supposed to take place in like filthy medieval Europe with more dragons, why are people running around in these outfits.

    Why is this man wearing a tracksuit.

    The guy in the track suit just got there.

    Whippy wrote: »
    nope nope nope nope abort abort talk about anime
    I like to ART
  • rhylithrhylith Death Rabbits HoustonRegistered User regular
    rhylith wrote: »
    There’s been enough Dandadan talk everywhere I look that I finally watched it and have continued reading.

    I will get into premise spoilers here, but honestly people who haven’t watched and are thinking about it should click.
    I had read the first chapter a while back and dropped it right away because of the alien abduction sexual assault attempt and old lady ghost/penis thief of it all, but hearing that that chapter was kind of an outlier I gave it another shot.

    It’s still very, very juvenile stuff tryin to return Okarun’s magical golden testicles, but the ghosts and aliens stuff is handled well and the characters are fun, plus a lot of the jokes are actually landing and the art is wild. It’s kept me interested.
    Thoughts on chapter 17 / what will be episode 7?

    Good.

  • BahamutZEROBahamutZERO Registered User regular
    It seems like his editor is not doing his job. I'm not sure which way but given they're 0 for 2 here I'm gonna say it's bad calls regardless

    I never read Instant Bullet, but the ending is also underwhelming, supposedly. Love Agency barely got an ending, since it was axed. The humor was there, but you could tell they were struggling with the premise.

    Aka is also teaming up with the artist from Record of Ragnarok to do a new fantasy series this coming Spring(?) I think. Not sure what to expect.

    probably not a satisfying ending, I guess

    BahamutZERO.gif
  • ReynoldsReynolds Gone Fishin'Registered User regular
    I heard they introduced some new characters in season three of Re:Zero, so I'd appreciate it if anyone trying to sell the anime to people saying it's not so bad would post some of the first results you get for Google image searching 'Liliana Masquerade anime' here. Outside of spoilers, please.

    I'll wait.

    uyvfOQy.png
  • MorninglordMorninglord I'm tired of being Batman, so today I'll be Owl.Registered User regular
    Lars wrote: »
    Aw, just found out that You and I Are Polar Opposites is ending in less than two weeks.

    Manga continuing past high school challenge: Impossible

    Manga that actually explores a relationship properly is so rare.

    (PSN: Morninglord) (Steam: Morninglord) (WiiU: Morninglord22) I like to record and toss up a lot of random gaming videos here.
  • MadicanMadican No face Registered User regular
    rhylith wrote: »
    I admit there’s a chunk of season 1 that’s a rough watch because Subaru keeps making the worst choices and being awful, but they are doing all that to get him on the path to being better.

    Anyways I don’t have crunchyroll right now so I don’t think I can watch the new season.

    The thing about re zero is that the misery has a point. Subaru fails. Constantly. it is the fucking theme of the show! His power only ever works when he absolutely, categorically fails. But he has more growth than literally any other anime character I have seen. He grows as a person each episode each season.

    And honestly, I don’t really like some of the waifu designs either, but they make sense thematically. Why does Roswell make Rem and Rom dress like French maids? Because he is a creepy, awful person.

    As for Subaru’s power being OP…it’s really, really not. He has no control over the save points, and has no idea when they will kick in. And he to, and this is VERY important, actually die each and every time in order to have it kick in.

    And it hurts, a lot, every time. The reason why the shows are wallows in his misery at times early on is to drive that point home. It isn’t just a respawn, he has to slowly bleed out after being disembowled. More than once his mind was utterly shattered by how he had just died and it took a minute (or magic) to have him pull himself back together.

    And the Emilia/Subaru romance doesn’t make a ton of sense to start…but by season 2 it all starts making sense. They are an actual couple who argues and shit, but care about each other.

    I dunno, I am always willing to go the mat for this show because it is extremely clever writing that addresses a lot of the issues with standard isekai trope writing. And like someone said, it actually feels like a world with history that existed independent of Subaru.

    I said Reinhard, not Subaru.
    I've seen overpowered characters before, that's nothing new, but this guy literally looks like Calvinball made incarnate, the physical manifestation of a poorly written deviantArt OC who is a Nice Guy, can get any power he wants from god (Od Magna), and also if he fought god he'd win even if he didn't have all his powers. These are all things the author has said about him.

    I literally don't see how someone like this can exist in a story and have it be good short of him never being in the story, ever, or being the final boss and therefore doomed to somehow be defeated.

  • MorninglordMorninglord I'm tired of being Batman, so today I'll be Owl.Registered User regular
    Madican wrote: »
    rhylith wrote: »
    I admit there’s a chunk of season 1 that’s a rough watch because Subaru keeps making the worst choices and being awful, but they are doing all that to get him on the path to being better.

    Anyways I don’t have crunchyroll right now so I don’t think I can watch the new season.

    The thing about re zero is that the misery has a point. Subaru fails. Constantly. it is the fucking theme of the show! His power only ever works when he absolutely, categorically fails. But he has more growth than literally any other anime character I have seen. He grows as a person each episode each season.

    And honestly, I don’t really like some of the waifu designs either, but they make sense thematically. Why does Roswell make Rem and Rom dress like French maids? Because he is a creepy, awful person.

    As for Subaru’s power being OP…it’s really, really not. He has no control over the save points, and has no idea when they will kick in. And he to, and this is VERY important, actually die each and every time in order to have it kick in.

    And it hurts, a lot, every time. The reason why the shows are wallows in his misery at times early on is to drive that point home. It isn’t just a respawn, he has to slowly bleed out after being disembowled. More than once his mind was utterly shattered by how he had just died and it took a minute (or magic) to have him pull himself back together.

    And the Emilia/Subaru romance doesn’t make a ton of sense to start…but by season 2 it all starts making sense. They are an actual couple who argues and shit, but care about each other.

    I dunno, I am always willing to go the mat for this show because it is extremely clever writing that addresses a lot of the issues with standard isekai trope writing. And like someone said, it actually feels like a world with history that existed independent of Subaru.

    I said Reinhard, not Subaru.
    I've seen overpowered characters before, that's nothing new, but this guy literally looks like Calvinball made incarnate, the physical manifestation of a poorly written deviantArt OC who is a Nice Guy, can get any power he wants from god (Od Magna), and also if he fought god he'd win even if he didn't have all his powers. These are all things the author has said about him.

    I literally don't see how someone like this can exist in a story and have it be good short of him never being in the story, ever, or being the final boss and therefore doomed to somehow be defeated.

    Well, it is good, so....

    (PSN: Morninglord) (Steam: Morninglord) (WiiU: Morninglord22) I like to record and toss up a lot of random gaming videos here.
  • King RiptorKing Riptor Registered User regular
    Reinhard is funny because I'm positive Slime is parodying him in the hero guy who's power is he can't lose but it's because he makes people around him stupid

    I have a podcast now. It's about video games and anime!Find it here.
  • MorninglordMorninglord I'm tired of being Batman, so today I'll be Owl.Registered User regular
    edited November 14
    There aren't really any rules about what makes a good story, that stuffs as arbitrary as fashion and changes just as often through time.

    All that really matters is if it manages to engage people. If you keep them engaged you can do whatever you want really they'll buy into it.

    Morninglord on
    (PSN: Morninglord) (Steam: Morninglord) (WiiU: Morninglord22) I like to record and toss up a lot of random gaming videos here.
  • Munkus BeaverMunkus Beaver You don't have to attend every argument you are invited to. Philosophy: Stoicism. Politics: Democratic SocialistRegistered User, ClubPA regular
    Oh.

    Well, Reinhardt is OP. But like, he has been in exactly 1 (one) situation that he was able to instantly solve for subaru, in episode 2, before you are informed how OP he is.

    They lampshade it and use it to critique the OP OC protagonist type. It's especially funny in isekai quartet.

    Everything about reinhardt is excused because of isekai quartet.

    Humor can be dissected as a frog can, but dies in the process.
  • BadablackBadablack Registered User regular
    Liliana Masquerade should probably get put in a tracksuit.

    FC: 1435-5383-0883
  • LarsLars Registered User regular
    That reminds me, the titular spider in So I'm a Spider, So What? is so ludicrously powerful that even by the midpoint of the anime she'd probably destroy most other isekai protagonists...but she's still constantly getting her ass kicked because of how much other powerful crap there is in her world.

    (actual spoiler)
    She even has a skill that says she literally can't die...and is still almost getting killed because there are other characters that can use attacks that circumvent her immortality.

  • TransporterTransporter Registered User regular
    Oh we bitchin bout Re:Zero?

    I actively hated that show before it revealed that it was at least somewhat self aware.
    Now it indulges in it’s bad habits but at least Subaru knows he’s a piece of shit so it’s fine Emilia-Tan is FINE GUYS SHE ACTUALLY LIKES HIM NOW ITS FINE.

  • Bluedude152Bluedude152 Registered User regular
    Madican wrote: »
    rhylith wrote: »
    I admit there’s a chunk of season 1 that’s a rough watch because Subaru keeps making the worst choices and being awful, but they are doing all that to get him on the path to being better.

    Anyways I don’t have crunchyroll right now so I don’t think I can watch the new season.

    The thing about re zero is that the misery has a point. Subaru fails. Constantly. it is the fucking theme of the show! His power only ever works when he absolutely, categorically fails. But he has more growth than literally any other anime character I have seen. He grows as a person each episode each season.

    And honestly, I don’t really like some of the waifu designs either, but they make sense thematically. Why does Roswell make Rem and Rom dress like French maids? Because he is a creepy, awful person.

    As for Subaru’s power being OP…it’s really, really not. He has no control over the save points, and has no idea when they will kick in. And he to, and this is VERY important, actually die each and every time in order to have it kick in.

    And it hurts, a lot, every time. The reason why the shows are wallows in his misery at times early on is to drive that point home. It isn’t just a respawn, he has to slowly bleed out after being disembowled. More than once his mind was utterly shattered by how he had just died and it took a minute (or magic) to have him pull himself back together.

    And the Emilia/Subaru romance doesn’t make a ton of sense to start…but by season 2 it all starts making sense. They are an actual couple who argues and shit, but care about each other.

    I dunno, I am always willing to go the mat for this show because it is extremely clever writing that addresses a lot of the issues with standard isekai trope writing. And like someone said, it actually feels like a world with history that existed independent of Subaru.

    I said Reinhard, not Subaru.
    I've seen overpowered characters before, that's nothing new, but this guy literally looks like Calvinball made incarnate, the physical manifestation of a poorly written deviantArt OC who is a Nice Guy, can get any power he wants from god (Od Magna), and also if he fought god he'd win even if he didn't have all his powers. These are all things the author has said about him.

    I literally don't see how someone like this can exist in a story and have it be good short of him never being in the story, ever, or being the final boss and therefore doomed to somehow be defeated.

    Reinhart
    Has a lot of disadvantages due to his nature. He movement is limited by the goverment. He cannot fight around others because his abilities keep others from accessing any many or spirits when he is around. The first time they try to use him to solve a situation this season he ends up killing everyone by killing the enemy before finding out how her powers work. Hes essentially a tactical nuke that an solve one problem and only if it can be solved by brute force.

    p0a2ody6sqnt.jpg
  • TofystedethTofystedeth Registered User regular
    Doodmann wrote: »
    Badablack wrote: »
    Isn't this show supposed to take place in like filthy medieval Europe with more dragons, why are people running around in these outfits.

    Why is this man wearing a tracksuit.

    The guy in the track suit just got there.

    Well, got there like 18 months ago by now. He really should get a different outfit. That isn't his butler outfit.

    steam_sig.png
  • Munkus BeaverMunkus Beaver You don't have to attend every argument you are invited to. Philosophy: Stoicism. Politics: Democratic SocialistRegistered User, ClubPA regular
    Madican wrote: »
    rhylith wrote: »
    I admit there’s a chunk of season 1 that’s a rough watch because Subaru keeps making the worst choices and being awful, but they are doing all that to get him on the path to being better.

    Anyways I don’t have crunchyroll right now so I don’t think I can watch the new season.

    The thing about re zero is that the misery has a point. Subaru fails. Constantly. it is the fucking theme of the show! His power only ever works when he absolutely, categorically fails. But he has more growth than literally any other anime character I have seen. He grows as a person each episode each season.

    And honestly, I don’t really like some of the waifu designs either, but they make sense thematically. Why does Roswell make Rem and Rom dress like French maids? Because he is a creepy, awful person.

    As for Subaru’s power being OP…it’s really, really not. He has no control over the save points, and has no idea when they will kick in. And he to, and this is VERY important, actually die each and every time in order to have it kick in.

    And it hurts, a lot, every time. The reason why the shows are wallows in his misery at times early on is to drive that point home. It isn’t just a respawn, he has to slowly bleed out after being disembowled. More than once his mind was utterly shattered by how he had just died and it took a minute (or magic) to have him pull himself back together.

    And the Emilia/Subaru romance doesn’t make a ton of sense to start…but by season 2 it all starts making sense. They are an actual couple who argues and shit, but care about each other.

    I dunno, I am always willing to go the mat for this show because it is extremely clever writing that addresses a lot of the issues with standard isekai trope writing. And like someone said, it actually feels like a world with history that existed independent of Subaru.

    I said Reinhard, not Subaru.
    I've seen overpowered characters before, that's nothing new, but this guy literally looks like Calvinball made incarnate, the physical manifestation of a poorly written deviantArt OC who is a Nice Guy, can get any power he wants from god (Od Magna), and also if he fought god he'd win even if he didn't have all his powers. These are all things the author has said about him.

    I literally don't see how someone like this can exist in a story and have it be good short of him never being in the story, ever, or being the final boss and therefore doomed to somehow be defeated.

    Reinhart
    Has a lot of disadvantages due to his nature. He movement is limited by the goverment. He cannot fight around others because his abilities keep others from accessing any many or spirits when he is around. The first time they try to use him to solve a situation this season he ends up killing everyone by killing the enemy before finding out how her powers work. Hes essentially a tactical nuke that an solve one problem and only if it can be solved by brute force.

    Yeah, this is the important thing to remember.
    If he is around, literally nobody else in Subaru's party can use any magic. Reinhardt is also not exactly clever which leads to issues like the one describes where he OHKOs his opponent and that kills literally everyone he was trying to save.

    The political limitations are also huge. He cannot do anything against his father, who is a drunkard and holds all the power in his family. He supports one of the rivals for the throne, so while his interests usually align with Subaru this is the first time since the early episodes that he's even been present for any of Subaru's shit. The last time we really saw him before this season was S1 when Subaru was making an ass out of himself.

    In essence, he cannot lose a fight. So he doesn't always succeed in his goals, if his goals require strategy or diplomacy.

    Humor can be dissected as a frog can, but dies in the process.
  • CormacCormac Registered User regular
    Lars wrote: »
    Aw, just found out that You and I Are Polar Opposites is ending in less than two weeks.

    Manga continuing past high school challenge: Impossible

    Manga that actually explores a relationship properly is so rare.

    It also does a great job with the inner monologue of teenagers figuring out who they are, their issues with self-confidence/doubt, social awkwardness, etc.

    Steam: Gridlynk | PSN: Gridlynk | FFXIV: Jarvellis Mika
Sign In or Register to comment.