The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
Hello, I am an avid trade reader, but mostly I am into the non-superheroish stuff (Clowes, Tomine)...Anyway, does anyone have any good suggestions for something a female reader might enjoy. Books along the lines of Blankets by Craig Thompson.
It's tough finding people talking about these types of things. I just needed a little direction.
I know that she enjoyed Ghost World a little bit. I think something more love story oriented would be great.
Vampire Loves by France's Joann Sfar, the Scott Pilgrim series by Bryan Lee O'Malley, and Blue Monday and Scooter Girl by Chynna Clugston Major are the few romance-oriented books that come to mind for me.
Strangers in Paradise might be a good choice. Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane might appeal to her as well. Pretty much a highschool teen girl drama that just happens to have Spider-Man characters in it. There's no focus on heroing or villain of the week stuff. I actually enjoy it, but rarely admit it due to the whole 'the book is for girls' stigma. It's actually a really good book though. I think she'd probably like Runaways or, if she's a Buffy fan, Whedon's Season 8 Buffy comic.
Also, manga is an excellent source for female oriented works. Tsubasa Resevoir Chronicles, School Rumble (highschool comedy / love story), Fruits Basket, Inu Yasha and so on are all popular manga that have either a neutral orientation or are written towards females in general. There's actually dozens and dozens of choices from manga that you would be hardpressed to find for conventional comics.
In my experience, Y the Last Man, Sandman, and Fables all tend to be pretty popular with women for some reason. I'd also recommend Hopeless Savages for something upbeat and fun, and the complete works of Jason for some of that dry, Clowes-y humor with a dash of dysfunctional relationships and misery.
JacobkoshGamble a stamp.I can show you how to be a real man!Moderatormod
edited November 2007
Strangers in Paradise, Y, and Blue Monday were really good suggestions. To them I'd add Box Office Poison (available in a single handy tpb!), Breakfast After Noon (ditto!) and a couple volumes of Artbabe.
What's Micheal is about, uh, cats. They, uh, do cat things? It's super hard to describe, but I know my wife loves it, and if your girlfriend is into cats, then she would probably like it. Anybody who likes cats seems to like 'What's Micheal.'
Aria is another great manga for girls (and anybody, really). ADV put out three volumes and then cancelled it, but Tokyopop has picked it up, along with its prequel series Aqua. Basically it's about a bunch of girls who live on Mars and do whimsical things in a gorgeous fantasy world.
Sexy Voice and Robo is a really amazing-looking art-manga about a girl detective who is also a 'date-line' operator. It's kind of like Veronica Mars, but not really at all.
In non-manga works, Hope Larson's Salamander Dream and Grey Horses are both stellar comics, dealing with growing up and love and distance and all those wonderful things. You can read Salamander Dream in its entirety here, if you want, although Adhouse books put out a really nice book version.
And Lost At Sea, the comic that Bryan Lee O'Malley did before Scott Pilgrim, is a great bit of introspective, angsty teen drama. It's about four kids just out of high school who are on a road trip from California to Ontario, and the self-discoveries they make along the way.
I'd say Ultimate Spider-Man would also be a pretty good bet. Lots of innocent fun with teen drama and colorful super villains. Girls like colors, you see.
Did everyone only read the thread title? Planetary, From Hell, and The Filth are hardly romantic.
it says 'for the female', not 'for a rom-com zombie' (romcomzom?)
i generally assume that girls (people in general, really) don't dislike comics because they're too testeosterrific, but because they think they're all poorly written junk. thus, i would rather give someone something well written and interesting (like from hell, though i wouldn't give anyone my copy of from hell as the damn thing cost like thirty-five bucks and i already spilled enough water on it thank you very much) over giving them something i assume they're gender-encoded to like.
Did everyone only read the thread title? Planetary, From Hell, and The Filth are hardly romantic.
it says 'for the female', not 'for a rom-com zombie' (romcomzom?)
i generally assume that girls (people in general, really) don't dislike comics because they're too testeosterrific, but because they think they're all poorly written junk. thus, i would rather give someone something well written and interesting (like from hell, though i wouldn't give anyone my copy of from hell as the damn thing cost like thirty-five bucks and i already spilled enough water on it thank you very much) over giving them something i assume they're gender-encoded to like.
That's a fair approach in general, but I don't see why we shouldn't trust the OP when he says that romance comics may in fact be appropriate for the girl in question, even if the same cannot be said for all girls.
Transmetropolitan. If she's even vaguely liberal, she'll dig it. She'll also dig it if she thinks words like "whorehopper" are hilarious.
Personally, I think it's the same exact thing as "recommend for the non-comic-reader". My lady-friend has liked a lot of indy humor comic stuff, Transmet, Scott Pilgrim, and V for Vendetta.
The major difference here is that to a person un-versed in comics, "super-people" is a genre. I happen to dig Invincible in a different way than I do Spider-Man, but from the outside they both look like person-with-great-power-story-time.
Any interests she has, see if you can find stuff that suits them. Anything that moved you and didn't involve Batman's parents dying? That's good too. "The Walking Dead" is a romantic gift for a female person who enjoys zombies a ton.
My only real straight-up romance recommendation is Scott Pilgrim. It's a nice, light, really funny story that is basically a soap opera and it is awesomely fun.
She might like the Emma Frost mini, if she can get over the frankly retarded covers by Greg Horn (although I think the TPBs used different, better, covers).
She might like the Emma Frost mini, if she can get over the frankly retarded covers by Greg Horn (although I think the TPBs used different, better, covers).
No shut up no one should ever read that horrid thing
She might like the Emma Frost mini, if she can get over the frankly retarded covers by Greg Horn (although I think the TPBs used different, better, covers).
No shut up no one should ever read that horrid thing
no one
not even hitler
Yeah? Okay. I never read it, but remember hearing that it's not too bad for the ones with girl parts.
Posts
Also, manga is an excellent source for female oriented works. Tsubasa Resevoir Chronicles, School Rumble (highschool comedy / love story), Fruits Basket, Inu Yasha and so on are all popular manga that have either a neutral orientation or are written towards females in general. There's actually dozens and dozens of choices from manga that you would be hardpressed to find for conventional comics.
Edit: Oh damn, I was beaten to it. Check out this list for some more ideas.
Tumblr Twitter
You don't want to give her ideas!
Yes I do!
What's Micheal is about, uh, cats. They, uh, do cat things? It's super hard to describe, but I know my wife loves it, and if your girlfriend is into cats, then she would probably like it. Anybody who likes cats seems to like 'What's Micheal.'
Aria is another great manga for girls (and anybody, really). ADV put out three volumes and then cancelled it, but Tokyopop has picked it up, along with its prequel series Aqua. Basically it's about a bunch of girls who live on Mars and do whimsical things in a gorgeous fantasy world.
Sexy Voice and Robo is a really amazing-looking art-manga about a girl detective who is also a 'date-line' operator. It's kind of like Veronica Mars, but not really at all.
In non-manga works, Hope Larson's Salamander Dream and Grey Horses are both stellar comics, dealing with growing up and love and distance and all those wonderful things. You can read Salamander Dream in its entirety here, if you want, although Adhouse books put out a really nice book version.
And Lost At Sea, the comic that Bryan Lee O'Malley did before Scott Pilgrim, is a great bit of introspective, angsty teen drama. It's about four kids just out of high school who are on a road trip from California to Ontario, and the self-discoveries they make along the way.
JordynNolz.com <- All my blogs (Shepard, Wasted, J'onn, DCAU) are here now!
Why wouldn't a girl just like any old comic that a dude would like? Buy her From Hell and The Filth.
3DS: 1607-3034-6970
JordynNolz.com <- All my blogs (Shepard, Wasted, J'onn, DCAU) are here now!
Best wedding ever.
What did the groomsmen get?
Oh, and I'd recommend the "Death" books - "High Cost of Living" and "The Time of Your Life."
Except for my little brother, he got a sword.
JordynNolz.com <- All my blogs (Shepard, Wasted, J'onn, DCAU) are here now!
Not such a hot idea
Planetary *see above*
It's not a "girl" comic but I don't give a damn and cannot recommend it enough.
This man speaks truth
(for those keeping trck - yes, I intend to recommend this to everyone and everything)
it says 'for the female', not 'for a rom-com zombie' (romcomzom?)
i generally assume that girls (people in general, really) don't dislike comics because they're too testeosterrific, but because they think they're all poorly written junk. thus, i would rather give someone something well written and interesting (like from hell, though i wouldn't give anyone my copy of from hell as the damn thing cost like thirty-five bucks and i already spilled enough water on it thank you very much) over giving them something i assume they're gender-encoded to like.
That's a fair approach in general, but I don't see why we shouldn't trust the OP when he says that romance comics may in fact be appropriate for the girl in question, even if the same cannot be said for all girls.
There's a bit of an unrequited love subplot in there too.
Personally, I think it's the same exact thing as "recommend for the non-comic-reader". My lady-friend has liked a lot of indy humor comic stuff, Transmet, Scott Pilgrim, and V for Vendetta.
The major difference here is that to a person un-versed in comics, "super-people" is a genre. I happen to dig Invincible in a different way than I do Spider-Man, but from the outside they both look like person-with-great-power-story-time.
Any interests she has, see if you can find stuff that suits them. Anything that moved you and didn't involve Batman's parents dying? That's good too. "The Walking Dead" is a romantic gift for a female person who enjoys zombies a ton.
My only real straight-up romance recommendation is Scott Pilgrim. It's a nice, light, really funny story that is basically a soap opera and it is awesomely fun.
Pride of Baghdad
JordynNolz.com <- All my blogs (Shepard, Wasted, J'onn, DCAU) are here now!
3DS: 1607-3034-6970
Kevin Smith can't write a comic without:
1. mentioning one or more female character "PMS-ing"
2. rape
3. heroine
No shut up no one should ever read that horrid thing
no one
not even hitler
3DS: 1607-3034-6970