The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
Just got Scammed with Counterfeit money.. how do I track down this guy?
So here's the story. I sell my Macbook on Craigslist, and I meet in a starbucks, the agreement is all cash. I have his phone number, email, and myspace- plus some other random bits of info and his picture.
Turns out when I checked the cash, 400 of the 800 bucks I was selling it for was fake. I've gone to the police, who are treating it as a theft, and I've just relayed the info to them.
What are my options? Is it legal to reverse search the cell number to get his address to give to the police?
Any knowledge of what they can potentially do? Obviously get the macbook back, but since some of the money was real, I'm inclined to return that. I just don't know what protocol for them would be in this instance.
Yeah they kept the bills. I went to the counter of Starbucks right after he left to check them with their pen. I realize I should've done this while he was there, before I gave him the macbook, but they felt legit.... until I saw all the barcodes were the same on the 20s...
When I was an assistant manager in a retail store we once had a guy try to pass us a $100 that appeared to be an actual $10 bill, with pretty convincing 100s pasted/applied over the 10s in the corners. Of course they didn't bother to change the picture in the center, or the space that said "TEN" so the attempt didn't last long, but I have to wonder how many of them he got away with passing.
Counterfeit iss a federal crime right? That guy may be screwed and going to pound you in the butt jail.
Prosecute all the way. Let the police do their job.
Fred Cheese on
0
GRMikeThe Last Best Hope for HumanityThe God Pod Registered Userregular
edited May 2008
Unless it was a case like Daenris was mentioning I don't think I would have been observant enough to check if the bills were a fraud at the store counter. That was a pretty quick move on your part.
Honestly, I've had the opportunity to see how the police work behind the scenes and while there isn't some magical criminal database, they do spend quite a bit of time compiling usual suspect lists. Counterfeit jack isn't something that some random kid on the street can get and use with no worries. I'd imagine that if you let the cops do their thing it will get sorted out- he might have fenced the Macbook already though...
Yeah, the macbook theft is small potatoes as far as the police are concerned. The counterfeiting is a MUCH bigger deal, which is why you should let them handle it. Anything you could do they'll have the same resources for.
Yeah, the macbook theft is small potatoes as far as the police are concerned. The counterfeiting is a MUCH bigger deal, which is why you should let them handle it. Anything you could do they'll have the same resources for.
Which if they have reason to believe it more then just $400 they'll get the secret service involved who have a lot more lenient rules they have to follow.
Kind of odd that he gave you $400 for real though.
Well... it's possible (though honestly unlikely) that he didn't know it was fake and was just passing on fake bills someone else had paid him with.
Though perhaps a more reasonable theory is that if only half the bills are fake it may take a person longer to realize it. If Double_Faces hadn't checked the bills with a counterfeit pen, but had just stuck them in his wallet he very well may have pulled out several real bills to use before ever trying to pass a counterfeit to someone and realizing he'd been had.
Kind of odd that he gave you $400 for real though.
Nah that's part of the trick. You give someone 8 $100, the top and bottom 2 are real. You flip through them to count, and nothing on the ones that are fully visible look "weird."
I mean, this guy didn't expect to get scammed. That's why he didn't check the money right away -- he thought "hmm, is this real?" after the guy left, which is probably when he counted the money again and noticed something was off with half the money.
But yes, as DeShadow pointed out, if they're reasonably good counterfeits, the fed. gov't will get involved under the assumption that this is not a one-time event.
Yes, that makes sense. Clearly I don't think like a scammer.
I get a ridiculous amount of fake £1 coins at the moment. The only way to notice is that most machines won't take them, and then when you compare them to real ones, they have a slightly different weight. They need to make them harder to make (like our pretty, 2 metal £2 coins). Not seen too many fake notes though, if any (in the UK).
Yes. Weight differently, some are a bit soft and deform.
£1 is still worth $2, so maybe worth the time? I don't know. Our notes are pretty difficult to fake too, lots of watermarks and funny prints and bits of metal stuck in them.
Don't feel too bad about getting fooled. I used to have to get lots of bundles of bills from the bank for a record store I worked at. Once there was a counterfit in a bundle of fives. It was black and white and only copied on one side. I found it when I got back to the store and was rebundling the bills into smaller amounts. I called them up and told them what happened. At first they didn't beleive me because it was so bad. I told him that I couldn't believe that they took it either. When I took it back the next day they had me fill out some kind of form but I never heard anything back.
Don't trust those pens either. I won't say how to do it, but I made a sheet of standard paper "pass" the pen test with about 10 seconds of my time and something that was just lying around in the office. Good catch on the serial numbers.
Secret Service will be involved (did you know that their primary responsibility is investigations of crimes involving counterfeiting? The president protection thing is just a side job) and they will not take the counterfeit lightly.
MurphysParadox on
Murphy's Law: Whatever can go wrong will go wrong.
Murphy's Paradox: The more you plan, the more that can go wrong. The less you plan, the less likely your plan will succeed.
I'm reasonably sure counterfeiting is a federal crime, and I believe they get the Treasury Dept involved.
I don't think you get your 'money' back, its not actually money. Which is why it is theft, I think. If your TV gets stolen, you dont get a new one as a replacement until they catch the guy. Though that would be pretty kickass.
Here in Canada, counterfeiting, depending on scale, will net you 3-5 on a first offense in a minimum security pen.
Don't trust those pens either. I won't say how to do it, but I made a sheet of standard paper "pass" the pen test with about 10 seconds of my time and something that was just lying around in the office. Good catch on the serial numbers.
It's also pretty common for counterfitters to bleach out a small denomination bill and reprint it with a larger denomination.
The best way to check a bill at glance is to hold it up to the light and look for the inlayed thread that says the denomination of the bill. Those threads also glow different colors under uv light.
If you gave the police all of this information, they should have absolutely no problem tracking the guy down. Make sure you save any e-mails between the two of you, and a copy of your craigslist posting. If he's damaged/destroyed your old laptop, you may need to go to court to get your costs paid.
Don't trust those pens either. I won't say how to do it, but I made a sheet of standard paper "pass" the pen test with about 10 seconds of my time and something that was just lying around in the office. Good catch on the serial numbers.
It's also pretty common for counterfitters to bleach out a small denomination bill and reprint it with a larger denomination.
The best way to check a bill at glance is to hold it up to the light and look for the inlayed thread that says the denomination of the bill. Those threads also glow different colors under uv light.
Virtually all newer bills(excepts 1's I think) have magnetic strips and/or watermarks. Both of those are quite hard to reproduce.
Detective has all the info and is going after the guy today. He claimed, "In cases like these, one fake 20 is one thing, but a slew of fake bills is on purpose."
Also, the Starbucks that was home to the transaction found the tape for me, and has it at the ready, showing the guy and I doing the whole thing.
Yeah.. he probably didn't figure they had cameras that weren't looking at the counter.
And the detective is right. Usually fake bills that big indicate he intentionally did it, or is part of a ring.
A couple of years ago my mom got a fake 20$ from the bank, went down the street to pay a bill. They tried to have her arrested. Luckily the bank had it all on video.
Secret Service will be involved (did you know that their primary responsibility is investigations of crimes involving counterfeiting? The president protection thing is just a side job) and they will not take the counterfeit lightly.
This is in fact their primary concern. They are organized under the Department of the Treasury, along with the ATF (just a strange fact), and not Justice, which causes a lot of confusion as you would imagine.
For four hundred bucks the Secret Service won't get THAT involoved.
Your local law enforcemet will forward on the counterfeit bills to them. They'll log and run the bills. If they have known "tells" they will be cataloged. If they don't and have never been seen before they'll be filed away to see if anymore like them pop up.
If he's brought in by your cops...yep, it's a federal crime.
When I was working at a bank we had a guy try to deposit 10 grand in fakes.
1) Any deposit over a certain amount is reported by the banks to the IRS
2) That much fake cash is a big big flag for the Secret Service.
Posts
Indeed. How did you know it was fake?
Maybe it was a $400 bill.
Seriously though, I really doubt the police would let him have the counterfeit bill(s) back to scan them.
Yeah they kept the bills. I went to the counter of Starbucks right after he left to check them with their pen. I realize I should've done this while he was there, before I gave him the macbook, but they felt legit.... until I saw all the barcodes were the same on the 20s...
Owned.
yup
MWO: Adamski
Naw, he doesn't seem that smart, as I know that his phone is with the local phone company and their are records of where he lives attached.
I have to pay for such info of course..
Prosecute all the way. Let the police do their job.
Honestly, I've had the opportunity to see how the police work behind the scenes and while there isn't some magical criminal database, they do spend quite a bit of time compiling usual suspect lists. Counterfeit jack isn't something that some random kid on the street can get and use with no worries. I'd imagine that if you let the cops do their thing it will get sorted out- he might have fenced the Macbook already though...
blog facebook steam twitter
Which if they have reason to believe it more then just $400 they'll get the secret service involved who have a lot more lenient rules they have to follow.
Well... it's possible (though honestly unlikely) that he didn't know it was fake and was just passing on fake bills someone else had paid him with.
Though perhaps a more reasonable theory is that if only half the bills are fake it may take a person longer to realize it. If Double_Faces hadn't checked the bills with a counterfeit pen, but had just stuck them in his wallet he very well may have pulled out several real bills to use before ever trying to pass a counterfeit to someone and realizing he'd been had.
Not really its a common to mix real bills with the fake ones. lowers your chance of getting caught.
Nah that's part of the trick. You give someone 8 $100, the top and bottom 2 are real. You flip through them to count, and nothing on the ones that are fully visible look "weird."
I mean, this guy didn't expect to get scammed. That's why he didn't check the money right away -- he thought "hmm, is this real?" after the guy left, which is probably when he counted the money again and noticed something was off with half the money.
But yes, as DeShadow pointed out, if they're reasonably good counterfeits, the fed. gov't will get involved under the assumption that this is not a one-time event.
I get a ridiculous amount of fake £1 coins at the moment. The only way to notice is that most machines won't take them, and then when you compare them to real ones, they have a slightly different weight. They need to make them harder to make (like our pretty, 2 metal £2 coins). Not seen too many fake notes though, if any (in the UK).
wtf?
Yes. Weight differently, some are a bit soft and deform.
£1 is still worth $2, so maybe worth the time? I don't know. Our notes are pretty difficult to fake too, lots of watermarks and funny prints and bits of metal stuck in them.
Not directly the only thing he can do is hope to get the laptop back, which pawn shops would be forced to do, or sue the person for the money back.
Don't trust those pens either. I won't say how to do it, but I made a sheet of standard paper "pass" the pen test with about 10 seconds of my time and something that was just lying around in the office. Good catch on the serial numbers.
Unlikely. He can go after the guy in court if he gets caught.
Murphy's Paradox: The more you plan, the more that can go wrong. The less you plan, the less likely your plan will succeed.
I don't think you get your 'money' back, its not actually money. Which is why it is theft, I think. If your TV gets stolen, you dont get a new one as a replacement until they catch the guy. Though that would be pretty kickass.
Here in Canada, counterfeiting, depending on scale, will net you 3-5 on a first offense in a minimum security pen.
It's also pretty common for counterfitters to bleach out a small denomination bill and reprint it with a larger denomination.
The best way to check a bill at glance is to hold it up to the light and look for the inlayed thread that says the denomination of the bill. Those threads also glow different colors under uv light.
I say yes on this one! Did some quick research and below is a link to their field offices. Give a call to the closest one to see if they can help.
http://www.secretservice.gov/field_offices.shtml
The fact the guy is so traceable means he should be busted soon. But who knows, he may have been scammed too.
Virtually all newer bills(excepts 1's I think) have magnetic strips and/or watermarks. Both of those are quite hard to reproduce.
Detective has all the info and is going after the guy today. He claimed, "In cases like these, one fake 20 is one thing, but a slew of fake bills is on purpose."
Also, the Starbucks that was home to the transaction found the tape for me, and has it at the ready, showing the guy and I doing the whole thing.
I know the word is "teh old", but this guy=pwned.
And the detective is right. Usually fake bills that big indicate he intentionally did it, or is part of a ring.
A couple of years ago my mom got a fake 20$ from the bank, went down the street to pay a bill. They tried to have her arrested. Luckily the bank had it all on video.
(She transferred her account the next day)
This is in fact their primary concern. They are organized under the Department of the Treasury, along with the ATF (just a strange fact), and not Justice, which causes a lot of confusion as you would imagine.
Your local law enforcemet will forward on the counterfeit bills to them. They'll log and run the bills. If they have known "tells" they will be cataloged. If they don't and have never been seen before they'll be filed away to see if anymore like them pop up.
If he's brought in by your cops...yep, it's a federal crime.
When I was working at a bank we had a guy try to deposit 10 grand in fakes.
1) Any deposit over a certain amount is reported by the banks to the IRS
2) That much fake cash is a big big flag for the Secret Service.
He was picked up a week later.