Our proboard. I just want to say I am both glad that you chose to kill me instead of the guard. Finishing the game with Tin man, lion, dorothy, todo, and the strawman all alive was pretty awesome. Thanks for running this game, I had a lot of fun. I am really glad the lion's mechanic got a chance to be played out. TT sry you got so unlucky to get seer'd day 1.
Reading through that... man you were hating the whole time. Even after seer died, you tried pulling that "oh, sportz was the ONLY PERSON who knew the seer's ID" bs.|
GG though. Nice Seering TL.
sportzboytjw on
Walkerdog on MTGO
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
Aww man I was gone for all the fun after-game drama. Siiiiigh.
I don't think it matters too much that I was revealed as the Tin Man. Yeah it made people definitely sure they could trust me, but I think after calling my kill and being put to sleep that was pretty obvious. Actually, being outed on day 1 was the best thing that happened. I got in contact with every special, there were no repeats and all were reasonable. It was really just a matter of killing off the munchkins by that point (sorry everyone who died by our vote!).
If it's any consolation though, not killing Law night two didn't really help. He seered whoever died that night (I forget).
I forget anything else. Still mad I missed the fun drama. . . .
Good game lonelyahava!!! Lots of fun, best phalla I've been in yet! And I was actually useful!
Yeah sportz, I had you and Darian lowest on my list of suspects, and I was actually more weary of the people claiming to be dorothy and todo (two mason groups seemed wierd), but decided we would find all the baddies hiding in the munchkins. The reason I called you out like that was to try to make the bad guys think I was unconnected.
After looking at the evil proboard it made a lot of sense how they reasoned pantha and law. But yeah if you remember game 1 of this thread.... all that paranoia and brainstorming, I made the mistake of putting in the thread and made me look evil. It was much better to be able to throw ideas off kime and altuir.
When you edited you post I was so happy, because I knew they would see that as me being special. My work was done as soon as I was able to get with kime after day 1 and prove to him altuir was good (although I didn't realize until later they suspected me and altuir were so ELABORATELY evil, I wished I had been evil trying to pull that off)
The guard to my knowledge was not suspected the whole game. We only lost 2 specials. The game would have been balanced if the queen had been alive, but getting lucky day 1 made it so that we could afford to kill every munchkin looking for baddies.
New thread would be wonderful, yeah. Another game would also be cool too!
Edit: Also, yeah, just to give credit to Orange he did an amazing amount of analysis. And did a great job of subterfuge with MundaneSoul before convincing us to kill him, which was of course a fantastic idea.
sportzboytjwsqueeeeeezzeeeesome more tax breaks outRegistered Userregular
edited October 2008
You guys definently had a chance, but it hurt a lot that TL seered the Witch, and then he made contact with a good guy. Also, I was the only vanilla (in every way) to live. I'm happy about that.
sportzboytjw on
Walkerdog on MTGO
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
You guys definently had a chance, but it hurt a lot that TL seered the Witch, and then he made contact with a good guy. Also, I was the only vanilla (in every way) to live. I'm happy about that.
You got lucky. It was a toss up who to kill on the last day (since we were almost confident bwanie was the baddie). I just happened to not pick you. NEXT TIME. . .
For those keeping track, that's over 7 lbs of candy, including 30 full sized bars. I don't fuck around when it comes to candy - keep that in mind if I offer it up again. :P
Posts
There wasn't much of a chance of you bothering to use it on me, though.
Really? I turned every thing off and took off the password. I made you admin, see what I did wrong.
Do you have the actual general board set to require members and above to see it?
I know the mechanics and balance sucked.
But did the narrations at least partially make up for it?
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
If by epic, you mean ADD, yes :P
Reading through that... man you were hating the whole time. Even after seer died, you tried pulling that "oh, sportz was the ONLY PERSON who knew the seer's ID" bs.|
GG though. Nice Seering TL.
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
you ranned away.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
I don't think it matters too much that I was revealed as the Tin Man. Yeah it made people definitely sure they could trust me, but I think after calling my kill and being put to sleep that was pretty obvious. Actually, being outed on day 1 was the best thing that happened. I got in contact with every special, there were no repeats and all were reasonable. It was really just a matter of killing off the munchkins by that point (sorry everyone who died by our vote!).
If it's any consolation though, not killing Law night two didn't really help. He seered whoever died that night (I forget).
I forget anything else. Still mad I missed the fun drama. . . .
Good game lonelyahava!!! Lots of fun, best phalla I've been in yet! And I was actually useful!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
you had a 1/2 chance to run away.
you ran away.
you're still alive.... i jsut wanted you to run away cause it was funny.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
Also yeah I just realized, they actually targeted him. Yey!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
After looking at the evil proboard it made a lot of sense how they reasoned pantha and law. But yeah if you remember game 1 of this thread.... all that paranoia and brainstorming, I made the mistake of putting in the thread and made me look evil. It was much better to be able to throw ideas off kime and altuir.
When you edited you post I was so happy, because I knew they would see that as me being special. My work was done as soon as I was able to get with kime after day 1 and prove to him altuir was good (although I didn't realize until later they suspected me and altuir were so ELABORATELY evil, I wished I had been evil trying to pull that off)
The guard to my knowledge was not suspected the whole game. We only lost 2 specials. The game would have been balanced if the queen had been alive, but getting lucky day 1 made it so that we could afford to kill every munchkin looking for baddies.
on those paranoid postings and brainstorming.
I'm highly impressed. I can't wait to actually play a game with you... you would be a valuable asset to any team.
just saying.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
Agreed. But not in this thread anymore. Please. Pretty please.
So many threads, so much confusion. I guess it's normal to die a lot in your first few phallas, right?
Right?
PSN : TheDagon
Pretty much every game ever : TheDagon
Edit: Also, yeah, just to give credit to Orange he did an amazing amount of analysis. And did a great job of subterfuge with MundaneSoul before convincing us to kill him, which was of course a fantastic idea.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
this grudge will last forever
Well. . . . it kind of is. . . . as in it's completely my fault.
But you acted oddly! And voted for me!!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
!kime
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
You've had a chance to play solely Newbie, and then a mixed game of Newbie and Vet.
Now, Go dive into a big game.
There will be other Newbie games in the future, I'm sure.
Of course, at that point, you'll all be vets.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
I had a blast. Thanks everyone for playing.
Oh jeez, I'd give you that much of a chance. I mean, at least you didn't all melt day one!!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
You got lucky. It was a toss up who to kill on the last day (since we were almost confident bwanie was the baddie). I just happened to not pick you. NEXT TIME. . .
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile