The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
Please vote in the Forum Structure Poll. Polling will close at 2PM EST on January 21, 2025.
GV Comicking Tournament Redux? Come Share Your Ideas
Last year's GV comic tournament was pretty awesome, at least until it fizzled out and ended without any resolution. As you may recall, the participants chose a character as their champion, and were then pitted against one another in themed comic duels. The winner of each bout was determined by vote. This was a pretty simple and reasonable way of conducting the tournament, assuming that everyone turned in their pages on time. This is probably why the tournament was never completed. :P
That said, I propose we revive the tournament, or something like it, that will give us an excuse to create some comics. Instead of a tournament, we could have a "relay", wherein each creator team is responsible for a part of the story and setting up things for the next team. We could use licensed characters, but I personally think just making up some new ones would probably be a better idea. Either way, if anyone is interested, or you have some ideas about how we could conduct this project, reply in this thread. Hopefully we can get rolling towards the end of the week.
NogsCrap, crap, mega crap.Crap, crap, mega crap.Registered Userregular
edited November 2008
you say "we" but who is going to be the sole person to tally the votes, moderate the thread, and oversee the direction of the tournament. I think that's why it fizzled out, on top of no one turning in their work on time. It takes a lot of time and dedication for the person running the whole thing.
Honestly, I think it'd go so much easier if we did away with the tournament aspect. But if it came down to it, I'd be fine keeping up with the votes and minding the deadlines.
I can't say I didn't have fun with it last time, but it's definitely a huge time commitment. The last few months probably haven't been kind to my already pitiful drawing skills, either.
Iroh on
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
0
Garlic Breadi'm a bitch i'm a bitch i'm a bitch i'm aRegistered User, Disagreeableregular
edited November 2008
How is your idea any different than your Comic Creators Thread?
I'm not sure about my own participation, but one thing I'd suggest is making it so people don't sign up by posting their intent to participate in the first round, but rather by posting the entry to the first round itself. This will ensure that everyone who plays is capable of completing at least one entry before succumbing to real world obligations or simple creative despair.
Also, any format that allows an entrant to simply disappear from the face of the Earth without the tournament itself being all that adversely affected is what we ought to shoot for. Given that, I'm not sure about the relay idea, as one person neglecting to participate would delay things by days and two people disappearing, especially if it's two in a row, would outright kill the thing.
My own suggestion would be to have the organizer issue a challenge at the start of each round in the vein of, "Your hero needs to do so and so, and how you do it is up to you," and then leave the contestants to compete indirectly by completing the task in the most inventive manner they can rather than directly or in tandem with one another, where the unexpected departure of an entrant affects the performance of the others.
How is your idea any different than your Comic Creators Thread?
People might actually participate in this one? Especially if we use licensed characters.
If it's a tournament, maybe
But you said "We can just do without the tournament thing and people can just write/draw comics maybe with licensed characters but I'd rather it was our own stuff"
I'm thinking a bi-monthly themed challenge. There should be a minimum page count, something low like 3 or 4 pages. There'll be no restrictions on characters used. Judging can be either through a poll or by everyone rating every comic submitted and averaging the ratings. The theme for each round will be randomly selected from a pool of themes that anyone in the thread can add to.
i'm pretty sure he was joking in the first place, mask. Edit: oh or maybe he wasn't? I don't know anymore.
Also 3 or 4 pages? Of like, a comic? Even cut down to twice a month that seems like a lot for two dudes to work on for a forum thing. I mean it's not that hard to write up a little essay or short story thing where batman beats the red tornado with his dirty laundry and here's why. Making an actual comic where that happens is difficult, especially when you're working with someone else.
And then it's he didn't finish god damn it or you never sent in the written part I'm flying blind here I can't work in these conditions i will be in my trailer.
i'm pretty sure he was joking in the first place, mask. Edit: oh or maybe he wasn't? I don't know anymore.
Also 3 or 4 pages? Of like, a comic? Even cut down to twice a month that seems like a lot for two dudes to work on for a forum thing. I mean it's not that hard to write up a little essay or short story thing where batman beats the red tornado with his dirty laundry and here's why. Making an actual comic where that happens is difficult, especially when you're working with someone else.
And then it's he didn't finish god damn it or you never sent in the written part I'm flying blind here I can't work in these conditions i will be in my trailer.
Come one, 3 pages is easy. Six panel grid means you'd be drawing, at the most, 18 panels. I think you should be able to manage that in 14 days. Judicious use of splash pages makes it even easier.
i'm pretty sure he was joking in the first place, mask. Edit: oh or maybe he wasn't? I don't know anymore.
Also 3 or 4 pages? Of like, a comic? Even cut down to twice a month that seems like a lot for two dudes to work on for a forum thing. I mean it's not that hard to write up a little essay or short story thing where batman beats the red tornado with his dirty laundry and here's why. Making an actual comic where that happens is difficult, especially when you're working with someone else.
And then it's he didn't finish god damn it or you never sent in the written part I'm flying blind here I can't work in these conditions i will be in my trailer.
Come one, 3 pages is easy. Six panel grid means you'd be drawing, at the most, 18 panels. I think you should be able to manage that in 14 days. Judicious use of splash pages makes it even easier.
i'm pretty sure he was joking in the first place, mask. Edit: oh or maybe he wasn't? I don't know anymore.
Also 3 or 4 pages? Of like, a comic? Even cut down to twice a month that seems like a lot for two dudes to work on for a forum thing. I mean it's not that hard to write up a little essay or short story thing where batman beats the red tornado with his dirty laundry and here's why. Making an actual comic where that happens is difficult, especially when you're working with someone else.
And then it's he didn't finish god damn it or you never sent in the written part I'm flying blind here I can't work in these conditions i will be in my trailer.
Come one, 3 pages is easy. Six panel grid means you'd be drawing, at the most, 18 panels. I think you should be able to manage that in 14 days. Judicious use of splash pages makes it even easier.
I'm imagining a MadLibs sort of setup, where we have a list of villains, a list of heroes, a list of MacGuffins, a and list of scenarios, then randomly combine them to complete a plot synopsis for each challenge.
When I was a little kid, I always pretended I was the hero,' Skip said.
'Fuck yeah, me too. What little kid ever pretended to be part of the lynch-mob?'
Posts
PARKER, YOU'RE FIRED! <-- My comic book podcast! Satan look here!
Also, any format that allows an entrant to simply disappear from the face of the Earth without the tournament itself being all that adversely affected is what we ought to shoot for. Given that, I'm not sure about the relay idea, as one person neglecting to participate would delay things by days and two people disappearing, especially if it's two in a row, would outright kill the thing.
My own suggestion would be to have the organizer issue a challenge at the start of each round in the vein of, "Your hero needs to do so and so, and how you do it is up to you," and then leave the contestants to compete indirectly by completing the task in the most inventive manner they can rather than directly or in tandem with one another, where the unexpected departure of an entrant affects the performance of the others.
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
People might actually participate in this one? Especially if we use licensed characters.
Plus, I inevitably participate in these things, churn out a bunch of crap really quickly, and then hate how it turns out.
Tumblr Twitter
If it's a tournament, maybe
But you said "We can just do without the tournament thing and people can just write/draw comics maybe with licensed characters but I'd rather it was our own stuff"
which is uh
your comic creators thread
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
He said a good character.
Then Carnage would try to come in to use the john and Sentry would rip him in half.
In fact, an entire issue where Sentry just goes around ripping people in half might be kinda funny.
Also 3 or 4 pages? Of like, a comic? Even cut down to twice a month that seems like a lot for two dudes to work on for a forum thing. I mean it's not that hard to write up a little essay or short story thing where batman beats the red tornado with his dirty laundry and here's why. Making an actual comic where that happens is difficult, especially when you're working with someone else.
And then it's he didn't finish god damn it or you never sent in the written part I'm flying blind here I can't work in these conditions i will be in my trailer.
Come one, 3 pages is easy. Six panel grid means you'd be drawing, at the most, 18 panels. I think you should be able to manage that in 14 days. Judicious use of splash pages makes it even easier.
can the three pages include a two-page splash?
PARKER, YOU'RE FIRED! <-- My comic book podcast! Satan look here!
isn't that how Marvel Zombies started?
Sure, it's your comic.
Yeah, zombie Sentry started it off. I'd just like to see what madcap hijinks he gets up to when he's not biting superheroes and eating people.
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
Heroes
Villains
MacGuffins
Goals\Motivations
The MadLib synopsis will be something in this vein: "Spider-Man is trying to obtain the Elder Wand to stop Lex Luthor from disappearing Australia.
Spider-Man
Batman
Superman
Wolverine
Deadpool (maybe as a villain, depends)
The Punisher
She Hulk
Thor
Villains
The Joker
Stilt Man
Rhino
Lex Luthor
Scarecrow
Omega Red
Dr Octopus
I'm basically just listing characters I would want to write.
Villain: The Spot
MacGuffin: King Solomon's Frogs
Goals/Motivations: Change all the faces on Mount Rushmore.
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
Here's the comic: