As was foretold, we've added advertisements to the forums! If you have questions, or if you encounter any bugs, please visit this thread: https://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/240191/forum-advertisement-faq-and-reports-thread/

VOTING THREAD: FIGHTS 3C AND 3D

Son of BeyonderSon of Beyonder From BeyondBeyondRegistered User regular
edited November 2006 in Graphic Violence
This is the comprehensive voting thread for Matches C and D

You are to vote for the order you predict the competitors will finish in. Points will be given to each competitor based upon your placement. Alongside each selection you make, give a reason. All votes that are posted without an explanation of why you chose that person will not be counted. The explanation does not have to be long, or detailed. For example, you could write 1 – Dr. Strange: he is pretty much powerful as fuck.

Each first place vote is worth four points. Each second place vote is worth two points. A third place vote is worth one point. And a last place vote costs that competitor one point. I will be watching the votes against very carefully.

Please use only the name given in the official tournament thread. I don’t care if you want to call Green Arrow by his first name elsewhere, I need you to refer to him by the name given here, to make voting go faster. I won’t disqualify your votes for this, but please show me the courtesy. I will, however, disqualify your votes for the following reasons:

*Putting the matches out of order – There are only two matches here. It shouldn’t be difficult
*Not fully filling out a match – If you only vote for two people in a match, I won’t count your votes. Make a decision.
*Voting with an alt, or voting twice (Note: accidental double posts are exempt from this rule as long as you edit the votes out of any duplicate)
*Posting any discussion before voting is closed. If you made changes to your votes, PM me.

THIS IS NOT A DISCUSSION THREAD. I need this thread to be votes only, to make it easier to tally votes. Discussion of the battles is to remain in their respective threads, and discussion of these rules can take place in the Tournament Central thread.

All votes that are placed AFTER I close the voting will NOT be counted.

All posts should be in this format:

1: NAME (EXPLANATION)
2: NAME (EXPLANATION)
3: NAME (EXPLANATION)
4: NAME (EXPLANATION)

Any alts that are discovered voting in this competition will be barred from voting in the future, and their votes will be eliminated. Any posts that do not follow the format above will be ignored. Any person that chooses to post anything other than their vote in this thread will have their votes discounted in this thread.

VOTING WILL CLOSE AT NOON CENTRAL TIME TOMORROW

5u13zxvb47g3.jpg
Son of Beyonder on
«1

Posts

  • saint2esaint2e Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight 3C:

    1) Thor (Just too powerful for the rest)
    2) Hulk (I think he can take out Namor and J'onn, which will make me unpopular with Jordyn and the other MM lovers, but I'm okay with that)
    3) Martian Manhunter (I do like MM, but I think Hulk/Thor can take him)
    4) Namor (I think he's a dick, and the lack of water in this battleground will cripple him)

    Fight 3D:

    1) Wonder Woman (Amazonian princess. She rocks)
    2) Shade (As much as I like Rogue, I think Shade will prevail over her)
    3) Rogue (Just can't touch Shade, and I don't think Wonder Woman would let her get close enough)
    4) Captain America (Outclassed, simply put)

    saint2e on
    banner_160x60_01.gif
  • ZeroCowZeroCow Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    C:
    Thor: He's a fucking god.
    Hulk: Hulk is the strongest there is
    MM: Extremely close fight for 2nd
    Namor: He's tough, but not tough enough

    D:
    Shade: I think he wins just because he can avoid direct confrontation
    WW: She'll just one punch Rogue
    Rogue: Unique powers would help, but she's outclassed
    Captain America: Speaking of outclassed.....just not "super" enough for this fight.

    ZeroCow on
    PSN ID - Buckeye_Bert
    Magic Online - Bertro
  • Spectre-xSpectre-x Rating: AWESOME YESRegistered User regular
    edited November 2006
    C:

    1- Martian Manhunter: Powerful, experienced, and easily the most versatile. Fire is a weakness, but he can manage with it, and nobody knows about it other than him.
    2- Thor: Verily he shall smite yon other opponents. Except Martian Manhunter.
    3- Hulk: Hulk is third-strongest there is.
    4- Namor: Namor is just outclassed here, and there's no real water around.

    D:

    1-Shade: Extremely powerful, experienced and terrifying. Pretty much untouchable as well.
    2- Wonder Woman: Too powerful for the others.
    3- Captain America: ALL THOSE WHO CHOOSE TO OPPOSE HIS MIGHTY SHIELD MUST YIELD! Except Shade and Wondy.
    4- Rogue: Yes, very nice, you can do something that the others can all block or avoid in some way.

    Spectre-x on
  • CharmyCharmy Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Match C:

    1) Thor: The mighty God of Thunder. Can do a lot of damage.
    2) The Hulk: So very strong, and actually a capable fighter and strategist in this form. He's got a lot going for him.
    3) Martian Manhunter: Powerful though he might be, I think he's going to suffer from the fact that the other three contestants in the match know each other. They'll want to bump him off early just to be safe.
    4) Namor: The lack of water is rather unfortunate for him.

    Match D:

    1) Wonder Woman: Superstrong, and raised to be a master of fighting and tactics? Yeah, she's got this one in the bag.
    2) The Shade: He's a classy chap. Also difficult to hit and quite powerful to boot.
    3) Captain America: Can't do much against Shade or Wonder Woman, but he's smart enough to take Rogue.
    4) Rogue: The first two can beat her with their powers alone, and Cap would have no problem out-fighting her.

    Charmy on
    I have a twitter.
  • inthegrayinthegray Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    C:

    1 Hulk: Hulk is the strongest there is.
    2 Thor: Hammer time
    3 Martian Manhunter: The above two are too much
    4 Namor: Outclassed by the above three

    D:

    1 Wonder Woman: Experience and a powerhouse
    2 Rogue: Hard choice on this one, but I don't see the bottom two taking her
    3 Captain America: Shield to Shade's face
    4 Shade: Shield in his face

    inthegray on
  • Kshah777Kshah777 Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    3C:

    1. Martian Manhunter: Powerful and versatile array of powers>weakness to fire.
    2. Thor: If necessary, can beat down the Hulk. Otherwise will go toe to toe with MM and probably get a very very close second.
    3. Hulk: Hulk may be strongest there is, but Hulk tired of fighting. HULK JUST WANT TO BE LEFT ALONE!
    4. Namor: Goes out in a short blaze of glory. "IMPERIUS--" *punch'd*

    3D:
    1.Shade: Sneaky, classy, awesome powers.
    2. Wonder Woman: Lassoes Captain America for super patriotic happy fun time.
    3. Cap: Tactics aren't going to get him through, but he will put on a damn good showing.
    4. Rogue: Not powerful enough to take on everyone here.

    Kshah777 on
    "He ate a moose and he ate a whale, he even ate a mountain... of shrimp..."
    ~"The Ballad of Morgan Brown"
  • FencingsaxFencingsax It is difficult to get a man to understand, when his salary depends upon his not understanding GNU Terry PratchettRegistered User regular
    edited November 2006
    C:
    1. Martian Manhunter: These homps can do anything he can't get out of.
    2. Thor Hammer + flight = Wack-a Namor
    3 Hulk: Usually strongest one.
    4. Namor Totally outclassed. Fish out of water

    D:
    1 Wonder Woman: Experience + Stamina+ she's really strong
    2. Shade: Noone really has ay counter to him, until WW smashes one of thoise pretty bracelets in his face
    3. Captain America Experience+Shield+ No Technical powers= Rogue's going down
    4 Rogue Can't really hack it this match. Plus, She was a bitch to Emma, which is good, but a bitch to the rest of the team as well, which is bad.

    Fencingsax on
  • MonkeydryeMonkeydrye Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    C
    1. Martian Manhunter: Versitility and power. Just has too many tricks he can pull.
    2. Thor: VERY close second.
    3. Hulk: Strong, but mostly a one trick pony. He can hit hard...so can MM and Thor.
    4. Namor: Just outclassed

    D
    1. Wonderwoman: Again, power AND versitiliy. Easily the fastest one here by orders of magnitude.
    2. Shade: Experience. Smart enough to deal with Rogue and Cap.
    3. Captain America: Despite his human limits, his skill and experience keep him from going down fast. Again, smart enough to deal with Rogue.
    4. Rogue: Fair ammount of raw power, but not much else. Yes, she could drian her foes...but none of these guys is stupid enough to give her a chance.

    Monkeydrye on
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • SlagmireSlagmire Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C
    1 - Hulk: Compared as a force of nature, nothing in this bracket should be able to beat him.
    2 - Martian Manhunter: Just got that feeling that he can take the silver with all the abilities he has.
    3 - Thor: Thor's solid, but I just think he's got less of a chance here.
    4 - Namor: Out of the pool now, little guppy.

    Fight D
    1 - Shade: His abilities completely mess with everyone else in this bracket, not to mention he can just avoid conflict for as long as he'd like.
    2 - Wonder Woman: Super strength will be the advantage between her and the Captain.
    3 - Captain America: Sorry boss... at least you'll be able to take out Rogue.
    4 - Rogue: It feels odd giving her last place here, but I just don't think she compares to anybody else here.

    Slagmire on
  • ScooterScooter Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:

    1. Martian Manhunter: Too many abilities at too high a level.
    2. Thor: Also a lot of good abilities.
    3. Hulk: Strongest there is, but screwed if he leaves the ground.
    4. Namor: No contest.


    Fight D:

    1. Wonder Woman: Obvious choice.
    2. Rogue: I think she stands a good chance of draining enough juice.
    3. Shade: I still don't know exactly what he does, but I'm sure he's good at it.
    4. Captain America: Shield to the face! Oh wait, that didn't hurt at all!

    Scooter on
  • Munkus BeaverMunkus Beaver You don't have to attend every argument you are invited to. Philosophy: Stoicism. Politics: Democratic SocialistRegistered User, ClubPA regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:

    1. Thor: Hammer time! Might team up with Hulk, but he's a powerhouse anyway.
    2. Hulk: Hulk. Strongest. There. Is.
    3. Martian Manhunter: A flammable forest, people who can kick his ass, and hulk strongest there is. Sorry, but Jordyn's lover boy has got to go.
    4. Namor: He's like a fish out of water! And the fact that he's a dick won't endure himself to the others.

    Fight D

    1. Cap: Shield to the back of the head for Rogue! Shield to the back of the head for Shade!
    2. Rogue: Drains WW, knocks her out
    3. WW: See above
    4. Shade: See Cap.

    Munkus Beaver on
    Humor can be dissected as a frog can, but dies in the process.
  • lwt1973lwt1973 King of Thieves SyndicationRegistered User regular
    edited November 2006
    C
    1. Thor: Lightning and Hammer
    2. Hulk: Strength and Regeneration.
    3. Martian Manhunter: Telepathy and Intangility.
    4. Namor: Nothing on the top three.

    D
    1. Shade: Darkness will defeat the others.
    2. Wonder Woman: Strength and Speed but not over Shade.
    3. Captain America: He's great but not enough to defeat the top two.
    4. Rogue: Power draining is good but Cap has the experience.

    lwt1973 on
    "He's sulking in his tent like Achilles! It's the Iliad?...from Homer?! READ A BOOK!!" -Handy
  • Canada_jezusCanada_jezus Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:
    1.Thor: He's a god, he can go toe to toe with regular ungimped hulk
    2.Hulk:I'd give him first place but its gladiator hulk
    3.Namor: very powerful too, but i'm giving it to hulk and thor
    4.Martian manhunter: even without the fire thing, he'd get beat up by the rest



    Fight D:
    1.Shade: Has the biggest range of abilties, can choose when to engage the competition. And when he does, they're all fucked
    2.Wonderwoman: I'd give her first place, but she's got an awful lot of exposed skin
    3.Rogue:I think its more likely rogue gets taken out by cap or shade, or one hit from ww, than its likely she absorbs her powers.
    4.Captain america: he could take out rogue, but eh i'm giving third place to her cause she can fly.

    Canada_jezus on
  • Conditional_AxeConditional_Axe Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:

    1. Hulk - PUNY LIGHTNING MAN TICKLE HULK WITH SILLY HAMMER! HULK SMASH WHINY FISH MAN! NAKED GREEN MAN HULK FRIEND! BEST FRIEND SINCE RICK JONES!

    2. Thor - He's a god, guys. J'Onn's awesome, but he's no god. Granted, Hulk's not a god, but Hulk is strongest there is.

    3. Martian Manhunter - He's good. He might be able to hold his own against Thor or Hulk, but could he win? I say no.

    4. Namor - Imperius Rex and all that, but this round is full of people who can very easily make Namor shut his bitch mouth.

    Fight D:

    1. Captain America - Rogue and Shade are no contest against him. And Diana's really strong, but Cap is the most tenacious guy ever, and he'll keep coming at her until he can't move. He's not stupid, either. He's going to be able to use the terrain and the environment to his advantage.

    2. Wonder Woman - Even without her superrad sword, there's not much stopping her.

    3. Rogue - With her current powers, she's not a huge factor here.

    4. Shade - May as well sit home and drink some absinthe. Fancy darkness worked well for him in his first match, but it's not so impressive at this point.

    Conditional_Axe on
  • FierceDeity666FierceDeity666 Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    C:
    1st: Hulk: HULK THROW FLAMING FOREST
    2nd: Martian Manhunter: Just about every power in the book makjes for broken powaa
    3rd: Thor: If the Hammer had some more magic related to smashing shit and not indestructability, Thor'd be higher.
    LAME MAN: Namor: FISH OUTTA WATER FISH OUTTA WATER

    D:
    1st: Shade: LIVING DARKNESS EATS EVERYONE. NO ARGUMENTS.
    2nd: Wonder Woman: The toughest one here physically. Will last long enough against the darkness to be 2nd.
    3rd: Captain America: He's as strong as a normal human can get.
    LAME MAN: Rouge: She'll try her power steal thing on the darkness and her head will explode.

    FierceDeity666 on
  • werehippywerehippy Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:

    1) Hulk - He might legitimately be able to take Thor, but Thor won't even try when Hulk tells him what the Marvel heroes did to him. Thor bows out at the end to give Hulk first.
    2) Thor- He's a god, and Hulk is his friend.
    3) Namor - Normally dead last here, but he's Hulk's friend, and Hulk is Thor's friend. He succumbs to vast injuries immediately after MM is put down.
    4) Martian Manhunter - Tough break. A God, and unstoppable force, and Imperius Rex who all happen to be friends.

    Fight D:

    1) Shade - A bit too powerful to be slowed down by anyone here.
    2) Rogue - Power drain, power drain, fire to the face. Would be first but Shade outclasses her.
    3) Wonder Woman - Hell of a fighter, just can't win here.
    4) Captain America - He's a tough old bird, but Rogue doesn't care enough to help him, and everyone else just wants to put down the crazy guy with the shield before moving on to the real threats.

    werehippy on
  • GABBO GABBO GABBOGABBO GABBO GABBO Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    C:
    1. Hulk
    2. Hulk
    3. Hulk
    4. Hulk
    The madder hulk gets, the stronger hulk gets.
    KNEEL BEFORE THE GREEN SCAR

    GABBO GABBO GABBO on
  • robosagogorobosagogo Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    C:

    1) Namor: He's been fighting for 80 odd years against the very first super-folk like the original Human Torch straight to modern annoyances like Richards. He's also led numerous attacks on the surface world with an army who can't breathe on land. His tactical brilliance has to be near Captain America levels, and his mastery of his powers is surely second to none.

    2) Hulk: Oh yeah, Martian Manhunter thinks it's just another fight with a brute that'll end with mind overtaking body just as it has always happened in the DC Universe. Then Hulk bites off Jonn's head, and then eats the rest of him. Sure that doesn't kill him, but there's no escape from Hulk's gamma re-inforced Bowels.

    3) Martian Manhunter: At the very least, he takes out Thor who, for the record, is still kind of a dunce despite all his immortality.

    4) Thor: He's used to being the strongest person in a fight and, frankly, all the people in this fight are at his level and prone to ingenuity or unpredictable ferocity that he just isn't capable of. Couple that with the fact that his magic hammer is only indestructible and no more empowered than your average feminist with a shotgun.

    D:

    1) Shade: Immortality grants him extraordinary resilience second to Wonder Woman while his tangible and intangible shadows grant him protection from literally any of the attacks that these people can launch at him. Furthermore, shadow beats will eat them all.

    2) Wonder Woman: The shield would bounce off her head and she'd slice Rogue in half before letting her drain her of too much of her abilities.

    3) Captain America: He's aces, even against super-humans, but he falters against the invulnerable because there's usually nothing he can do to stop them. That's the case here.

    4) Rogue: Too bad she has the flame powers. She goes after Cap and is outdone by his acrobatics or she goes after WW's exposed skin and is destroyed in the process. I doubt she could even find Shade.

    robosagogo on
  • MarathonMarathon Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:
    1) Thor - God of Thunder, wins due to his range of abilities.
    2) Hulk - The longer the fight goes on the stronger he becomes, loses points due to him not being able to fly. Familiar with Thor and Namor, each a possible ally.
    3) Martian Manhunter - If Supes and Marvel can team up to dominate their match I see no reason why Thor and Hulk can't do the exact same thing. Thor dominates him in the air and Hulk helps dish out the punishment on land.
    4) Namor - No water around, tough luck duder.

    Fight D:
    1) Shade - Most versitile and wide range of powers.
    2) Wonder Woman - Trained all her life to be a fighter. Basically Superman with ovaries.
    3) Captain America - Peak human potential is sadly not enough to keep you in this fight in the late rounds.
    4) Rogue - Without her Mrs. Marvel powers she just does not have the power to hang in against fighters as skilled as these.

    Marathon on
  • NinjaSquirrelNinjaSquirrel Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight c
    1. Martian Manhunter - Strong as anyone here. Can fuck up peoples minds. Can turn intangible. Can turn invisible. This guy has the power set to win the entire tournament. Hulk won't be able to do anything to him with the intangible and flying. Thor will struggle against him. Namor can't do much more than the Hulk. He wins this round easily.
    2. Thor - Is a god, but unfortunately can't take out MM since he can just go intangible and fuck up his mind. And even should the two throw down hand to hand MM would be able to take him as he's as strong and faster
    3. Namor - At least he's in the match. Can fly to hit the other guys while Hulk is left on the ground with nothing to do. Strength enough to at least make his punches felt.
    4. Hulk - Not the strongest there is. Not mobile enough to get to the other competitors. Cannot even hit MM and thor and Namor will notice him coming and be able to dodge the jump.

    Fight D
    1. Shade - Control of darkness and being really fucking hard to hit get him through this round quite easily.
    2. Wonder Woman - Super strength, speed and the awesome lasso giver her easy placement above the other two competitors, unfortunately Shade should still be able to handle her/evade her long enough to wear her down and squeak out first.
    3. Rogue - Not strong enough to take out the first two but at least she has real powers unlike....
    4. Captain America - Love ya guy but you got shit on these people. What are you even doing here? You know you don't stand a chance against them. No actual powers and unfortunately "shield to head" won't work so well against the first two competitors.

    NinjaSquirrel on
  • deadonthestreetdeadonthestreet Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight 3C:

    1) Thor (The hammer will crush any opposition)
    2) Namor (Imperius Rex)
    3) Hulk (Really is the strongest, I don't care what you think)
    4) Martian Manhunter (Fire. Fire. Fire.)

    Fight 3D:

    1) Rogue (Stealin' powers, kickin' ass)
    2) Shade (Preeeety much unbeatable. You know unless he somehow loses his powers. Or has them stolen.)
    3) Wonder Woman (Every punch she lands on Rogue will only make her stronger)
    4) Captain America (Shield to the---oh god it burns!)

    deadonthestreet on
  • Adaemus1sfAdaemus1sf Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:
    1. Martian Manhunter- No one else in the match can touch him, literally.
    2. Thor- Too strong, too versatile.
    3. Namor- Can put up a fight and, being able to fly, can reach the top contestants at least long enough to get his ass kicked.
    4. Hulk- Stuck on the ground, stuck dealing with people way too versatile for him.
    Fight D:
    1. Wonder Woman- Lassos Shade (I'm thinking her lasso can contain even nonphysical stuff, right?), punches everyone else.
    2. Shade- Amuses himself talking about old times with Cap while WW deals with Rogue.
    3. Captain America- Not a priority to remove, so WW deals with him later.
    4. Rogue- Flying and throwing fireballs? WW takes her out immediately, one quick punch to knock her out so she can't use the powers she just absorbed.

    Adaemus1sf on
  • JordynJordyn Really, Commander? Probing Uranus. Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C
    1. Martian Manhunter- There are a million fuck ways for him to win this. He can turn invisible and intangible while the others fuck each other and he can his arm through all of them, he can mind fuck them with his telepathy, and no one in this match knows or has a way to find out about his fire weakness so godfuckingdammit, J'onn fucking wins.
    2. Thor- J'onn might wait to mind fuck the lightning guy last.
    3. Namor- And he might let Namor hang around a bit because J'onn is a nice guy.
    4. Hulk- Because fuck the Hulk, he does not win this. J'onn can fuck him up so hard.

    Jordyn on
    thumbsupguy-1.jpg
    JordynNolz.com <- All my blogs (Shepard, Wasted, J'onn, DCAU) are here now!
  • Caveman PawsCaveman Paws Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C
    1.Thor- I'm pretty sure a -god- can do well in this fight. He'll beat the other three so easily it won't be considered murder, just three very late abortions.
    2.Hulk- Hitting him only makes him angry. You wouldn't like him when he's angry.
    3.Martian Manhunter- Lots of neat tricks and a very strange outfit which will give him the edge over homophobic combatants.
    4.Namor- Waiter! Bring me a jug of water ASAP! Oh no too late!

    Fight D
    1.Rogue- all she has to do is touch -anyone- else in this fight and her chances of winning skyrocket.
    2.Wonder Woman- If she's brave enough to engage in mortal combat wearing -that- outfit you know she's badass.
    3.Shade- He controls the darkness! Sadly I don't know exactly what that means other than he can make everything really dark.
    4.Captain America- peak human physical blah blah blah, tactics yadda yadda, shield that acts like a frickin boomerang... fuck that.

    Caveman Paws on
  • RoyseRoyse Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C
    1. Thor - Hulk is strongest there is, but Mjolnir is most deadly there is.
    2. Hulk - Strongest there is.
    3. Martian Manhunter - Just not as good a fighter as Thor, not good enough to hurt Hulk.
    4. Namor - Feeling a little parched in this one.

    Fight D
    1. Captain America - More experienced than WW.
    2. Wonder Woman - Fights Cap one-on-one, loses.
    3. Rogue - Attempts to steal WW's powers, fails.
    4. Shade - Cap's first target.

    Royse on
  • -SPI--SPI- Osaka, JapanRegistered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C
    1. Thor- God
    2. MM- Ridiculous DC overpowering
    3. Hulk- Why the fuck is hulk third? This Make hulk angry! GRAHHHH!
    4. Namor- Yeah, no. Outclassed.

    Fight D
    1. Wonder Woman- Ridiculous DC overpowering (wait, I sense a pattern...)
    2. Shade- OMG HAX!
    3. Captain America- Awesome, just beaten by stupidly high powers.
    4. Rogue- SHIELD TO THE MOTHER FUCKING FACE BITCH! (that feels better)

    -SPI- on
  • spidahspidah Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C
    1. Thor: Pretty sure he can hammer these guys into oblivion
    2. Hulk: Hulk Smash, blah blah blah
    3. Martian Manhunter: While he's got a bunch of nifty tricks and he's tactically superior to most people here, I still think he goes down.
    4. Namor: He's freaking strong, but I don't think he can hang here without water. If he had his H20, I think this might have ended a little different.

    Fight D
    1. Shade: I think he'd shadow everyone into oblivion
    2. Rouge: I think she'd be able to grab onto Wondy long enough to destroy the others, but I'm probably the only one who thinks so.
    3. Wonder Woman: Should be able to last longer than Cap
    4. Captain America: I don't see Cap being able to beat these people.

    spidah on
  • RonnieWooWoo!RonnieWooWoo! Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C

    1. Thor - He's a flying, lightning-spewing God with an enchanted hammer of assbeating. The only one who could compete with him is the MM (see below)

    2. Hulk - He outclasses Namor in pretty much every aspect (strength, speed, durability, etc), but lack of flight or a reliable ranged attack keeps him from passing Thor.

    3. Namor - He's good, but nothing special. Lack of water on the battlefield is a death sentence. He pretty much gets a free bump to 3rd though. It's nice to have powerful friends.

    4. Martian Manhunter - Is he more powerful than every other fighter in ths match? Yes. Is he more powerful than all three of them at once? No. "Avengers Assemble" and MM makes an early exit.

    Fight D

    1. Shade - Matched up against three competitors who are primarily brawlers, I can't see anybody being able to touch this guy.

    2. Rogue - I refuse to believe that Wonder Woman would be able to knock her completely out without Rogue being able to get a hand on some exposed skin somewhere. When's the last time a comic book fight ended with a one-shot, anyway? Rogue takes a beating, but eventually gets the powerdrain in and beats WW.

    3. Wonder Woman - Overall stronger than Rogue, but as a brawler, way too vulnerable to Rogue's mutant power. She has to get close enough to hit her opponents, and that means Rogue can touch her.

    4. Captain America - Just kind of out of his league here. His main strengths are tactics and leadership, but this fight sees him without anyone to lead, and without the raw power to execute any plan he might formulate. His lack of mobility REALLY hurts him in this one too.

    RonnieWooWoo! on
    Woo!
  • laughterkillsmelaughterkillsme Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C
    1 - Hulk: Since I can't give both Thor and the Hulk first, I'll give it to the hulk in this one.
    2 - Thor: Extremely powerful, probably fight the Hulk for days before it was decided. Lightning and heavily flamable environment is what owns J'onn.
    3 - Namor: loligags for real.
    4 - Martian Manhunter: I'd give him third, but I need to help offset the heavily biased J'onn fanboy vote here.

    Fight D
    1 - Shade: Whether by avoidance or direct confrontation, I think he'd win this one.
    2 - Wonder Woman: Only her strength beats the smarter Captain America.
    3 - Captain America: Rogue doesn't have the experience to touch caps face, he'd knock her stupid way before she could get the chance.
    4 - Rogue: Outclassed.

    laughterkillsme on
    freealonesig.jpg
  • MunchMunch Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C
    1) Martian Manhunter. He's been an active superhero since what? Like the thirties? And before that he was a police officer on his home planet. He knows how to fight, and he's got the muscle for it.
    2) Thor. He's tough, wields a deadly weapon, and fights like a berserker.
    3) Hulk. Strong as he is, in his current gladiator form his strength is, to the best of my knowledge, more limited. And while he can jump pretty high, everyone else has flight on their side, which can't be underestimated.
    4) Namor. Tough as hell, but with this competition he's outclassed. If he'd been paired up with Captain America he might have made it further.

    Fight D
    1) Wonder Woman. She's Superman with breasts.
    2) Shade. He's basically just tougher than the other competition.
    3) Captain America. He's got nobody to lead here, and his shield throws won't do much to WW or Shade, if they're ready for them.
    4) Rogue. Shield to the face knocks her out. Never should have advanced past the last round.

    Munch on
  • Mai-KeroMai-Kero Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:
    1)HULK STRONGEST THERE IS
    2)Namor ALSO PRETTY STRONG. And fast. He's water-superman. But he knows how to fight better. And IMPERIUS REX.
    3) Thor: God of thunder. Lightning starts fires and
    4)MM goes down.

    Fight D
    1) Rogue. PEW PEW PEW FLYING AROUND BLOWING SHIT UP!
    2) Shade. He's basically the best person ever.
    3) Captain America. Best fighter ever, and since wonder woman won't be trying to decapitate him instantly, he'd be able to hold his own.
    4) Wonder Woman. Honestly I'd like to tie her, rogue, and cap for #2, but I can't do that. She'll probably win anyway since she's wonder woman.

    Mai-Kero on
  • bAm-BaMbAm-BaM Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:
    1. Martian Manhunter - A billion powers and no fireslingers.
    2. Thor - Thunder God. Has many rock ballads attributed to his name. Big fucking hammer. Pew pew. You get the idea.
    3. Hulk - If the other two didn't fly, or it was one on one, I'd probably give it to the Hulk.
    4. Namor - Without water, he's fairly screwed.

    Fight D:
    1. Shade - A lot of options, all end in dead capes.
    2. Wonder Woman - HERA. Basically a Superman that trades some power for technique.
    3. Rogue - Her blasts really only work against...
    4. Captain America - I'm still bamboozled on how he made it this far.

    bAm-BaM on
    marvelcrotchsig.jpg
  • SentrySentry Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:

    1. Martian Manhunter- He's too versatile, too good at what he does, and he's freaking psychic to boot. He can make Hulk think he's hugging a basketfull of kittens... you can be mad if you have a basket full of kittens.
    2. Thor- He's a god. Not a particularly strong god... and I don't really understand why god would even need a hammer... but, he has that too.
    3. Namor- He's underwater superman... nuff said.
    4. Hulk just doesn't have the versatility for this fight. HULK MOST ONE-DIMENSIONAL THERE IS...

    Fight D:
    1. Wonder Woman- Honestly... there isn't a single fighter here who can take her out. I don't care what the Shade enthusiasts say...
    2. Shade- Okay, I care enough about what they say to make him second. He seems pretty dang powerful.
    3. Rogue- Ha... if this were Ms. Marvel Rogue, she could have stood a chance... but her skin to skin contact is neither instantanious nor completely debilitating...
    4. Captain America- You can't kill an idea... but you can escort one out of the tournament...

    Sentry on
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    wrote:
    When I was a little kid, I always pretended I was the hero,' Skip said.
    'Fuck yeah, me too. What little kid ever pretended to be part of the lynch-mob?'
  • Bad KarmaBad Karma Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Munch wrote:
    Fight C
    1) Martian Manhunter. He's been an active superhero since what? Like the thirties? And before that he was a police officer on his home planet. He knows how to fight, and he's got the muscle for it.
    2) Thor. He's tough, wields a deadly weapon, and fights like a berserker.
    3) Hulk. Strong as he is, in his current gladiator form his strength is, to the best of my knowledge, more limited. And while he can jump pretty high, everyone else has flight on their side, which can't be underestimated.
    4) Namor. Tough as hell, but with this competition he's outclassed. If he'd been paired up with Captain America he might have made it further.

    Fight D
    1) Wonder Woman. She's Superman with breasts.
    2) Shade. He's basically just tougher than the other competition.
    3) Captain America. He's got nobody to lead here, and his shield throws won't do much to WW or Shade, if they're ready for them.
    4) Rogue. Shield to the face knocks her out. Never should have advanced past the last round.

    Lazy again..Thanks Munch!

    Bad Karma on
    Xbox Live: Ornery Rooster
    PSN: OrneryRooster
  • ReatheranReatheran Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C
    1:Martian Manhunter (Tough, experianced, a telepath, intangible, and just generally more capible than the others here.)
    2: Thor (He's a god, people.)
    3: Namor (Fast and capible, but outclassed.)
    4: Hulk (Can he fly? No? Then he's fucked.)

    Fight D
    1: Shade (Really fucking powerful.)
    2: Wonder Woman (Fast and really difficult to hurt.)
    3: Captain America (Lack of actual powers knocks him to third.)
    4: Rogue (Yeah, she's not beating these guys.)

    Reatheran on
  • TheidarTheidar Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C:
    1. Martian Manhunter-versatile and powerful, no one in this group is aware of his weakness.
    2. Thor-like everyone says he is a god, and he may be immune to mind conrol, but not arm through chest
    3. Hulk-strong and durable
    4. Namor-no water this time.

    Fight D:
    1. Shade-crazy powerful
    2. Wonder woman-fast, resilient, strong and well trained
    3. Rogue-not beating the top 2
    4: Captain America-his tactics and skill have brought him far but this should be his last fight on Battleworld

    Theidar on
    Gamertag: Theidar
    Wii Friend Code: 0072 4984 2399 2126
    PSN ID : Theidar
    Facebook
    Behold the annhilation of the extraterrestrial and the rise of the machines.
    Hail Satan!
    WISHLIST
  • DJ EebsDJ Eebs Moderator, Administrator admin
    edited November 2006
    Fight C

    1. Thor: Because he's still my pick to win it all
    2. Martian Manhunter: Yes, he can beat Hulk.
    3. Hulk: But Hulk can probably beat Namor
    4. Namor: I know he does well out of water, but I don't think it's going to matter with these three.

    Fight D

    1. Wonder Woman: I still don't think anyone in this fight can touch her
    2. Rogue: Fire vs. darkness vs. shut up it's not like this vote matters
    3. Shade: I thought some physical violence could take him down. Surely Diana's more than capable.
    4. Captain America: Shouldn't have advanced last round. Probably not even the first. And can it with the hurr hurr tactics bullshit

    DJ Eebs on
  • wwtMaskwwtMask Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Fight C
    1. Hulk - Hulk smash, bitches.
    2. Thor - He and Hulk fight to a standstill. Anyone who is nearby gets destroyed.
    3. Martian Manhunter - Between Thor and Hulk, this Superman copy gets his shit handled.
    4. Namor - His experience is negated by lack of water and power level. Gives MM a good fight before he goes down though.

    Fight D
    1. Rogue - She takes the kid gloves off and wrecks shit. Power stealing ftw.
    2. Wonder Woman - She and Cap have a good, long tussle, so she doesn't quite have the gas to handle Rogue.
    3. Captain America - Meets his match vs. Diana, but puts on a good show.
    4. Shade - Underestimates Rogue and gets her loving caress. Getting beaten by your own powers must really suck.

    wwtMask on
    When he dies, I hope they write "Worst Affirmative Action Hire, EVER" on his grave. His corpse should be trolled.
    Twitter - @liberaltruths | Google+ - http://gplus.to/wwtMask | Occupy Tallahassee
  • ServoServo Registered User, ClubPA regular
    edited November 2006
    fight c

    1- hulk- i don't care, there's a reason they had to shoot him into space rather than some other solution and it's because he's fucking unstoppable

    2- thor- i hate the way he talks

    3- namor- mean, but outclassed

    4- martian manhunter- too nice a guy


    fight d

    1- wonder woman- cccccccccccrrrrrazy combat skills + superstrength etc

    2- shade- diabolically excellent

    3- rogue- mmmmmmmeh

    4- cap- cccccccccrazy combat skills - superstrength etc

    Servo on
    newsigs.jpg
  • DarkPrimusDarkPrimus Registered User regular
    edited November 2006
    Servo wrote:
    fight c

    1- hulk- i don't care, there's a reason they had to shoot him into space rather than some other solution and it's because he's fucking unstoppable

    2- thor- i hate the way he talks

    3- martian manhunter- he nice, but not that nice

    4- namor- no water




    fight d

    1- wonder woman- cccccccccccrrrrrazy combat skills + superstrength etc

    2- shade- diabolically excellent

    3- rogue- mmmmmmmeh

    4- cap- cccccccccrazy combat skills - superstrength etc

    Flipped MM and Namor, but other than that... yeah.

    DarkPrimus on
    usnTyq4.jpg
    Gamertag: PrimusD | Rock Band DLC | GW:OttW - arrcd | WLD - Thortar
Sign In or Register to comment.