El SkidThe frozen white northRegistered Userregular
edited January 2009
I don't think Dusda is a baddy. There's no way he'd draw attention to himself like that if he was evil, since we almost certainly still have a seer around. To me it looks like a surprisingly good attempt to network the vig and the seer.
CrownAxe for trying to get him voted off, that said.
So, what you're trying to say is that you're a normal dude with no confirmation of any abilities or alignment whatsoever, but because you wrote down a list of suspects that means you're a good guy?
If anything it seems that you've passed along all of your suspicions of good guys or bad guys to CJ, who could pass that along to the rest of the daemons to better guide their kills. If they can get a better hold on the suspicions of normal villagers then they can better guide the vote with a little prodding and killing everyone they can "trust".
I don't think you're actually evil, but not because of your amazing little post there was so logically put together, but because the reasoning is so stupid that it can't be evil.
Look at what is happening, Dusda would is basically getting immunity because of his post and if the Vig and Seer do contact him he'll know who to get rid of.
Look at what is happening, Dusda would is basically getting immunity because of his post and if the Vig and Seer do contact him he'll know who to get rid of.
Its exactly what a baddy wants
Yes, that motive makes sense. However, do you realize how much work it would take to forge two days of notes and (at my count) about eight pages of conversation? I have made no attempts to hide the fact that I was fucking duped. I made several stupid judgments. To construct such a story to use as a veil would take an incredible amount of effort. This is my first game of Mafia that has taken place over the web; all of my actions reflect that. My refusal to believe the first round means nothing (games played in person are much more telling, since you can actually see the person you're reading) should be supporting enough on its own.
Me getting killed by the Inquisition would be the most delicious sort of irony.
The effort would be worth the reward though since you wouldn't be the target of anything
And besides how can we know that conversation is valid or not anyways
Also why try so hard if you're not a special of any kind? Espacially since there isn't a real way to validate being a special, which you should know since you just got swendled on the first day
CrownAxe on
0
Options
Dusdais ashamed of this postSLC, UTRegistered Userregular
edited January 2009
Because I care more about being correct than I do about surviving, I guess. Probably why I'm so annoyed with the results of the second night.
We'll have a much better idea of where we're at after tonight, at least. For the time being, I'm going with !It Burns. Something doesn't sit quite right with me, and while my phalla instincts aren't nearly what the rest of the group's (probably) are, instinct counts for something.
We'll have a much better idea of where we're at after tonight, at least. For the time being, I'm going with !It Burns. Something doesn't sit quite right with me, and while my phalla instincts aren't nearly what the rest of the group's (probably) are, instinct counts for something.
Another two hours had passed. Two Daemons lay dead, one of Slaanesh and one of Nurgle. You could only speculate about the identities of any remaining Daemons.
And, a puzzle to all involved, the mysterious yet overly zealous Ork stalking the halls of the Bunker of Phallanon Prime. What was this? And how had they not found him?
None of that mattered, Dusda thought to himself, walking in front of the long line of guardsmen. "It is time for the inquisition to take its next victim..." he said, his storm bolter shining and shimmering in the bunker light. "You!"
He pointed to CrownAxe, who stood tall. "How do we know you're not a Daemon, SIR?"
The hall was silent.
"What... did you say?" Dusda replied slowly.
"I said who says you're not one of them? You may be in the armor of a Grey Knight, bu-"
*SPLAT*
CrownAxe found his brains along the back wall. "Does anyone else have objections to my leadership?"
"I do..."
Dusda turned around, brandishing his Nemesis Force Weapon menacingly, but it was too late. His power armor was already melting as the Flamer of Tzeentch focused its deadly warp-fire at it, seeping into the spaces in his anointed armor. Dusda fell to the ground, a burnt husk, and in seconds, the Flamer was nowhere to be found.
There are 8 of us left, and three kills tonight. If we don't hit either a baddie or the ork I would assume that's game over for the village.
I have a sinking suspicion that we do have a seer out there, but he's managed to consistently seer people who ended up dying.
I'm going to suggest -not- voting for crimsoncoyote or madjazz tonight. Crimsoncoyote didn't post or vote yesterday, and madjazz didn't post or vote on day 1. I'd imagine that neither of them is the ork.
Well, I can tell you that I'm just a plain vanilla guardsman, ready to charge to my death at the hands of any foe. Not that I can do much to prove my innocence. If I die, it will only be in service to the emperor!
Mad Jazz on
0
Options
El SkidThe frozen white northRegistered Userregular
edited January 2009
God dammit, Dusda. As a vigilante with the guardian dead, you're supposed to lay low, not paint a big 'x' on your forehead!
Posts
No one in there right mind would put that much work into this
Plus of this knowledge is just begging to be a Daemon of Tzeentch
Bugger!
OOOooooOOOOoooOOOO
CrownAxe for trying to get him voted off, that said.
If anything it seems that you've passed along all of your suspicions of good guys or bad guys to CJ, who could pass that along to the rest of the daemons to better guide their kills. If they can get a better hold on the suspicions of normal villagers then they can better guide the vote with a little prodding and killing everyone they can "trust".
I don't think you're actually evil, but not because of your amazing little post there was so logically put together, but because the reasoning is so stupid that it can't be evil.
Critical Failures - Havenhold Campaign • August St. Cloud (Human Ranger)
Critical Failures - Havenhold Campaign • August St. Cloud (Human Ranger)
Wouldnt be the first time I've seen someone taken out for no other reason then they are talking a lot
Critical Failures - Havenhold Campaign • August St. Cloud (Human Ranger)
Its exactly what a baddy wants
Yes, that motive makes sense. However, do you realize how much work it would take to forge two days of notes and (at my count) about eight pages of conversation? I have made no attempts to hide the fact that I was fucking duped. I made several stupid judgments. To construct such a story to use as a veil would take an incredible amount of effort. This is my first game of Mafia that has taken place over the web; all of my actions reflect that. My refusal to believe the first round means nothing (games played in person are much more telling, since you can actually see the person you're reading) should be supporting enough on its own.
Me getting killed by the Inquisition would be the most delicious sort of irony.
And besides how can we know that conversation is valid or not anyways
Also why try so hard if you're not a special of any kind? Espacially since there isn't a real way to validate being a special, which you should know since you just got swendled on the first day
This is the internet. Validity is just as real here as Big Foot
I'd think our seer would try to verify his claim. (Still assuming we have a seer)
I reveal that im nothing but a guardsman
You have no reason to vote me off for i have not been tainted by chaos
No one knows who anyone is for sure, all you can do is point fingures at people that act the most suspicious
Dasda fits that description
I'm sorry but what
No u!
!Mad Jazz
Another two hours had passed. Two Daemons lay dead, one of Slaanesh and one of Nurgle. You could only speculate about the identities of any remaining Daemons.
And, a puzzle to all involved, the mysterious yet overly zealous Ork stalking the halls of the Bunker of Phallanon Prime. What was this? And how had they not found him?
None of that mattered, Dusda thought to himself, walking in front of the long line of guardsmen. "It is time for the inquisition to take its next victim..." he said, his storm bolter shining and shimmering in the bunker light. "You!"
He pointed to CrownAxe, who stood tall. "How do we know you're not a Daemon, SIR?"
The hall was silent.
"What... did you say?" Dusda replied slowly.
"I said who says you're not one of them? You may be in the armor of a Grey Knight, bu-"
*SPLAT*
CrownAxe found his brains along the back wall. "Does anyone else have objections to my leadership?"
"I do..."
Dusda turned around, brandishing his Nemesis Force Weapon menacingly, but it was too late. His power armor was already melting as the Flamer of Tzeentch focused its deadly warp-fire at it, seeping into the spaces in his anointed armor. Dusda fell to the ground, a burnt husk, and in seconds, the Flamer was nowhere to be found.
And then, it happened.
"WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA-
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA-
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA-
AAAAGH!!!!!!!"
This time, TheLawinator found himself victim to the choppa-wielding ninja Ork.
And again, he was gone before anyone even realized what had happened.
RESULTS
Dusda - Grey Knight (Vigilante) - Killed by Flamer of Tzeentch
TheLawinator - Veteran Guardsman (Mason) - Killed by ork
Gumpy - Guardsman - Killed by Grey Knight
CrownAxe - Guardsman - Failed the Inquisition
/slump
Big time
There goes the Vigilante.
We are sucking this shit up... Is it even possible for us to win now?
Critical Failures - Havenhold Campaign • August St. Cloud (Human Ranger)
FIGHT ON BROTHERS!
There are 8 of us left, and three kills tonight. If we don't hit either a baddie or the ork I would assume that's game over for the village.
I have a sinking suspicion that we do have a seer out there, but he's managed to consistently seer people who ended up dying.
I'm going to suggest -not- voting for crimsoncoyote or madjazz tonight. Crimsoncoyote didn't post or vote yesterday, and madjazz didn't post or vote on day 1. I'd imagine that neither of them is the ork.
As for who to actually vote for, beats me.
Zee pain, eet ees excruciating.