The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.

Looking for some H/A on a malfunctioning Xbox360.

Bosshog78Bosshog78 Registered User regular
edited March 2009 in Help / Advice Forum
So back in November, about 100 hours into a fevored Fallout 3 tryst my 360 started giving me a screen saying "To play this disc put it in an Xbox 360 console."

It was occasional at first but after another hundred or so hours it would take 15 sometimes 30 minutes of turning the 360 on and off to get any game to run. Now it's at the point where it does this everytime and can no longer play Xbox360 games. It will still play dvds, cds, games on the hard drive and I bet regular Xbox games as well, but will only show "Play DVD" then goto that screen anytime I try and load a 360 game.

I've been working on it and it's pretty much down to 2 options.

The first one I don't like so much. The console was purchased August of 2007 so it's a half year out of warrenty. I'd pay $100 and send it in to MS to be fixed. My primary concern with this option is weather on not some type of warrenty would be renewed from the date of repair, I don't want to pay $100 now and have to do it again in a few months with the same/similar problem. I would call MS myself and ask but I want to keep all options open at the moment.

The option I like better is to crack it open, see if I can't fix it myself, maybe clean the lens or tinker with the drive. Then if that fails I'll just go to Best Buy and pick up an Arcade model with the two year warrenty, this would run $230 and make sure I don't have this problem again for a while. As a small start to this option I bought a DVD lens cleaner, ran it several times but it didn't fix it.

A few specfic questions I have-

What's MS policy for consoles they've repaired out of warrenty?

Anyone else had the same issue and found a good solution?

I'm not totally adverse to some forced red-ring shinanigins but wonder if this method is reliable.

What do you fine folks think? Thanks.

Bosshog78 on

Posts

  • Jean Claude Van CalmJean Claude Van Calm 'sup? Awesome Possum.Registered User regular
    edited March 2009
    Mine did this for the longest time with a lot of games that are constantly accessing data from the disc. Out of curiosity, is your box sitting vertical or horizontal? I originally had mine vertical when the problem started and setting it down to the horizontal position helped for a little while. It took maybe 3 months before the problem returned and also started having "Disc is unreadable" errors during gameplay on several games.

    I was going to pay to have it repaired, but my patience paid off just 3 days ago. I bought RE5 and started the 360 up, made it to the opening cinematic and BLAMO! RRoD. Atleast now it's free. My personal suggestion is induced RRoD, stick the 360 inside a tv stand with a DVD or something and finish the poor thing off, it's already borked and more than likely RRoD is a likely end anyways even if you pay to get everything else fixed.

    Jean Claude Van Calm on
    PSN: Grimmsy- Xbox Live: Grimmsy
  • DHS OdiumDHS Odium Registered User regular
    edited March 2009
    Yes, I would hope you get a RRoD for the free fixings. If it is just the DVD drive giving issues, I would personally try the fix-it-yourself route. I believe you can get a replacement drive for the 360 online, probably not too much.

    If you break the thing, sell it for parts, buy an Arcade, slap your old HDD in and use the DRM tool on the Xbox website to transfer licenses. Buying a $200 Arcade will get you a newer chipset, HDMI (don't think yours has it), an extra controller, built-in 256 memory (or mem card), spare cables, and the disc with 5 arcade games and possibly that sega tennis game. That, to me, is worth the extra $100 (you'd have to pay $100 anyways to get it properly fixed, so take it out of the cost). Bonus - many store occasionally have some bundle deal where they throw in an extra game, gift card, or accessory with the purchase of a 360.

    DHS Odium on
    Wii U: DHS-Odium // Live: DHS Odium // PSN: DHSOdium // Steam: dhsykes // 3DS: 0318-6615-5294
  • illigillig Registered User regular
    edited March 2009
    it's a dying DVD drive... you can either pay MS $99 to fix it, or replace it yourself for about $50 in parts... if you go the 2nd route, you'll void the warranty on your xbox though

    my drive recently was dying, and i was going to go the 2nd route, and mod my xbox at the same time... but it just suffered from a RROD (i guess you can consider this "good" luck :D ), so i'm sending it in for RROD repair and hoping i'll get a new unit with a working drive at the same time

    illig on
  • KeyScourgeKeyScourge __BANNED USERS regular
    edited March 2009
    Just torture it till it's gives u the RRoD. Free repair that way, so ur $100 up from what you would be if you sent it to MS for the repair of the original problem

    KeyScourge on
  • Bosshog78Bosshog78 Registered User regular
    edited March 2009
    Thanks for the replies. It's been horizontal the entire time I've had it.

    I'm gonna try one more thing and see if the clearing-the-cache trick will do anything. Despite everything I've read, it seems like this is some kind of firmware issue. If that doesn't work I'm gonna wrap it in a blanket and set it in front of a space heater for a day or so (closely monitered of course). Do I need to have a disk in there to get it to RROD?

    Bosshog78 on
  • KeyScourgeKeyScourge __BANNED USERS regular
    edited March 2009
    I wouldn't think you need a disk to make it RRoD since one of mine once RRoD'd when i had nothing in there and was just browsing the Games Marketplace

    KeyScourge on
Sign In or Register to comment.