The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
Please vote in the Forum Structure Poll. Polling will close at 2PM EST on January 21, 2025.

Recommend me a new mac!

NatanekoNataneko Registered User regular
edited April 2009 in Help / Advice Forum
Hello! I just came back from the best buy and it looks like I'll probably be getting around 1200$ from them because my computer breaks all the time. I currently have a 13 inch black macbook (with the smallest harddrive ever, 80g)

I use my computer for internetting, schoolpaper making and picture watching (as in I take picture and put them in my computer >.>) so I don't think I need extreme performance. Also, I finish school in about a year, and well, I don't need extreme portability (the main transporting I did in the last year is from my home to my boyfriend's place)

so right now I'm not sure what I should get. the 13 inch new macbook or the 20 inch imac? are there any known issue with any one of them? Are there good reason I should pay more for the next bigger model?

also, if I buy my computer at bestbuy can I still get the applecare? I'd prefer not dealing with bestbuy again if I have to repair my computer.

Nataneko on

Posts

  • KrisKris Registered User regular
    edited April 2009
    Do you have to buy from Best Buy at all? Is it like a store credit deal? Cause if not, I'd recommend going through Apple's online store. You even get a student discount, which I don't think Best Buy does (I could be wrong).

    Kris on
  • EchoEcho ski-bap ba-dapModerator, Administrator admin
    edited April 2009
    Nataneko wrote: »
    also, if I buy my computer at bestbuy can I still get the applecare? I'd prefer not dealing with bestbuy again if I have to repair my computer.

    If it works anything like it does for me here in Sweden: you get 90 days of phone support, and a full year of warranty from Apple. You can buy AppleCare at any time within that year to extend it another two years.

    Echo on
  • NatanekoNataneko Registered User regular
    edited April 2009
    yeah it's store credit sadly, so it has to be from bestbuy (the student discount!:| I don't think bestbuy can get it, I'll check)

    thanks Echo, i'll check if it's the same in Canada (I think it is)

    Nataneko on
  • MonoxideMonoxide Registered User, ClubPA regular
    edited April 2009
    this is entirely about preference. they're almost identical in hardware, so it's more about how you want to use it

    do you want a bigger screen? get the iMac

    do you want to use the mulitouch trackpad? get the macbook

    do you ever intend on moving your computer around, even if it's to the living room or whatever? get the macbook

    need the 320GB hard drive instead of the 160GB? get the iMac

    seriously though all of these except portability are going to be fixable with extra hardware. I'd buy the MacBook simply because if I decide I need a bigger screen, I can go buy one. if I need a bigger hard drive, I can get a terabyte external for ~$100. but if I decide I need portability, I can't exactly turn the iMac into something that's easy to carry around

    Monoxide on
  • BlindZenDriverBlindZenDriver Registered User regular
    edited April 2009
    Consider the Mac Mini!

    It's more flexible than the iMac and you can even hook up two screens to it (once you do you will never understand how one was enough).

    Regardless which Mac you get buy the least amount of memory from Apple. Just like when one buys a PC from Dell or IBM there is a huge mark up on RAM. Just get memory from Crucial or some similar place and you save a lot while still getting brand name memory.

    BlindZenDriver on
    Bones heal, glory is forever.
  • NatanekoNataneko Registered User regular
    edited April 2009
    I didn't think of the mac mini, I'll look more into it. I'm currently leaning more toward the iMac than the macbook, but let's say I'd want to one day upgrade the harddrive, is it still easy to open the lid and just do it (like in the pre-intel era) or is it better anyway to use an external drive should I miss some space?

    Nataneko on
  • Jake!Jake! Registered User regular
    edited April 2009
    Monoxide wrote: »
    seriously though all of these except portability are going to be fixable with extra hardware. I'd buy the MacBook simply because if I decide I need a bigger screen, I can go buy one. if I need a bigger hard drive, I can get a terabyte external for ~$100. but if I decide I need portability, I can't exactly turn the iMac into something that's easy to carry around

    My sentiments exactly. I'm typing this in bed, 300 miles from where I live, on my work computer.

    Jake! on
  • NatanekoNataneko Registered User regular
    edited April 2009
    I went to the apple store yesterday to ask a couple question, and the guy there told me that the mac mini was not a good option for me since I didn't already have a keyboard/display. We talked a bit and now I'm pretty set on the iMac, trying to decide if I should shell out the extra 400$ for the 24" screen. I'd rather keep the cost down as much as I can so I'm not sure if the extra debt would be worth it in the long run.

    Also, I think the iMac updates are pretty recent, so I shouldn't be surprised by a huge price lowering/hardware update right?

    Can't wait for my laptop to be confirmed dead by bestbuy!

    Nataneko on
  • EchoEcho ski-bap ba-dapModerator, Administrator admin
    edited April 2009
    Nataneko wrote: »
    Also, I think the iMac updates are pretty recent, so I shouldn't be surprised by a huge price lowering/hardware update right?

    No, the hardware updates are so frequent that if you keep waiting for the next one you'll never buy one. :P

    Echo on
  • FFFF Once Upon a Time In OaklandRegistered User regular
    edited April 2009
    Nataneko wrote: »
    I didn't think of the mac mini, I'll look more into it. I'm currently leaning more toward the iMac than the macbook, but let's say I'd want to one day upgrade the harddrive, is it still easy to open the lid and just do it (like in the pre-intel era) or is it better anyway to use an external drive should I miss some space?

    Apple will tell you no, however, as long as you're careful, opening up the iMac is stupid easy. Everything on the inside is very easy to get to. HD is an easy replacement, as is the optical drive. Hell, I think there are sites now that show you how to replace your processor (oh so warranty voiding).

    FF on
    Huh...
  • MonoxideMonoxide Registered User, ClubPA regular
    edited April 2009
    FF wrote: »
    Nataneko wrote: »
    I didn't think of the mac mini, I'll look more into it. I'm currently leaning more toward the iMac than the macbook, but let's say I'd want to one day upgrade the harddrive, is it still easy to open the lid and just do it (like in the pre-intel era) or is it better anyway to use an external drive should I miss some space?

    Apple will tell you no, however, as long as you're careful, opening up the iMac is stupid easy. Everything on the inside is very easy to get to. HD is an easy replacement, as is the optical drive. Hell, I think there are sites now that show you how to replace your processor (oh so warranty voiding).

    I believe replacing your HDD is a warranty breaker on iMacs too. or at least, it used to be. check Apple's policies before you do anything.

    hard drives are a user replaceable part (doesn't void your warranty to replace it) on macbooks though.

    Monoxide on
  • FFFF Once Upon a Time In OaklandRegistered User regular
    edited April 2009
    Monoxide wrote: »
    FF wrote: »
    Nataneko wrote: »
    I didn't think of the mac mini, I'll look more into it. I'm currently leaning more toward the iMac than the macbook, but let's say I'd want to one day upgrade the harddrive, is it still easy to open the lid and just do it (like in the pre-intel era) or is it better anyway to use an external drive should I miss some space?

    Apple will tell you no, however, as long as you're careful, opening up the iMac is stupid easy. Everything on the inside is very easy to get to. HD is an easy replacement, as is the optical drive. Hell, I think there are sites now that show you how to replace your processor (oh so warranty voiding).

    I believe replacing your HDD is a warranty breaker on iMacs too. or at least, it used to be. check Apple's policies before you do anything.

    hard drives are a user replaceable part (doesn't void your warranty to replace it) on macbooks though.

    Oh yeah. I forgot to mention that pretty much doing anything on the inside of an iMac might void the warranty (haven't actually read up on what will). Then again, as far as I've ever seen, there are no stickers on the HD or enclosure that would indicate you've opened the machine. And really, with the exception of a failure, there's probably no reason to replace the internal HD anyway considering you can get one CTO with a 1TB drive.

    FF on
    Huh...
  • BladeXBladeX Registered User regular
    edited April 2009
    Nataneko wrote: »
    yeah it's store credit sadly, so it has to be from bestbuy (the student discount!:| I don't think bestbuy can get it, I'll check)

    thanks Echo, i'll check if it's the same in Canada (I think it is)

    It is.

    BladeX on
  • mtsmts Dr. Robot King Registered User regular
    edited April 2009
    so it wil depend on the best buy in regards to student discount. when I bought my macbook i went there and they said that particular store didn't do it. so it kind of implied that others might. just ask

    mts on
    camo_sig.png
  • ascotascot Registered User regular
    edited April 2009
    The 20" iMacs are a super excellent deal these days, especially since the macbook unibodies are ridiculously priced. And the macbook pros even more so.

    Don't even consider the low end aluminium macbook. The only difference between the old-style white and this on is 40gig HD and $300. The low end iMac, which is better than the mid-spec macbook, and is $400 cheaper. They have the same graphics card, but the iMac is a 2.66Ghz and has a 320gig HDD.

    ascot on
  • BladeXBladeX Registered User regular
    edited April 2009
    I love my iMac! It's the 20" 2.66Ghz. I have no issues with Lightroom, Photoshop, games (lolz liek brickbreaker am i rite?), etc on it. Also Best Buy can't do the student discount unless they are allowed to price match the student price (which is worth seeing if they will do). That's a direct from Apple thing either through the Apple Online Store or the Apple Retail Store.

    BladeX on
Sign In or Register to comment.