The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.

Getting a new harddrive?

DigitoDigito Registered User regular
edited December 2006 in Help / Advice Forum
Ok I'm preeeetty sure I asked this question once some number of months ago, back when I thought my harddrive was about to die a painful agonizing death, but... my HD managed to hang on and we never got around to actually getting ahold of a harddrive.

But now with the Christmas Season in full blast, it seems I'll be able to get myself a brand new harddrive for Christmas, the only catch being that it's probably going to have to be under a hundred dollars. Not that I really mind, I've spotted a handful of 320 gigabyte drives for that price.

However, I recall almost none of the advice I got last time I asked this question as I never got a chance to put any of it to use, so I guess I'm kinda stuck with two questions at once here. The first question...


Now I know there are different kinds of harddrives, (IDE, SATA, so on so forth) but I can't remember for the life of me what these mean, or which my computer is able to take. I also know nothing about installing a harddrive, so even if I popped it open right now, I'd have no idea what I'm looking for as far as if a harddrive will fit or not, or if my computer is capable of having two drives installed at the same time.

Second, I'm entirely open to reccomendations for a hundred dollar harddrive, or less than a hundred dollars. I'm pretty sure that this ISN'T alot of money to work with, but I'm not about to pass this chance up, especially as I'm pretty sure this time that my harddrive is definately on the way out. (and 120 gigs feels so small these days...)

Third, I just thought of this, but my computer came prebuilt with a copy of XP already installed, and as such I don't own a spare copy. Will the restore discs be able to put XP onto the new harddrive, or am I about to be forced onto Linux or something here?

(to clarify I'm talking about internal drives here, I highly doubt an external would be fast enough to serve as a main harddrive unless I missed something here.)

Digito on

Posts

  • robaalrobaal Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    I think almost all PCs support at least 2 PATA devices, though this also includes optical drives but only the newest motherboards are reduced to 2 PATA drives, so if your PC wasn't built in the last 6 months or so you should be safe with one.

    Anyway, get a drive with a 5 year warranty (all seagate drives and "RE" series WDs). AFAIK Hitachi drives aren't great, but all other major brands are OK (Maxtor drives might be a bit loud though).

    I think Seagate (or maybe Maxtor?) has some free software on their site that lets you copy your system partition to the new hard drive. For some reason this works and you can then use the new drive for booting - your whole system should be intact (just swap the connections on them to boot from the new one, or change the boot order in the BIOS).


    You wouldn't want an external hard drive as your system drive, but they aren't bad for storage. Their transfer rate is capped by the interface at ~33MB/s while I think the new drives can get up to ~70MB/s.
    edit: You can buy just an external enclosure into which you can put whatever desktop hard drive you like (assuming the enclosure internal interface is the same) including your old drive.

    robaal on
    "Love is a snowmobile racing across the tundra when suddenly it flips over, pinning you underneath.
    At night, the ice weasels come."

  • blincolnblincoln Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    You'll really need to find out if your system supports SATA or not. The connectors are easy to distinguish from IDE, just Google some pictures.

    SATA is a better interface, so use that if you can.

    There are plenty of good drives for < $100. I just got a 250GB SATA drive at New Egg for $75, and it has a 16MB cache. Which brings me to the guidelines for what you're looking for. Obviously size is a major factor. The speed of the drive (5400 rpm, 7200 rpm, etc) is another, and so is the size of the cache. I personally wouldn't buy anything with less than an 8MB cache, and the one I just got has 16. In both cases, higher is better. Faster revolution speed gives you faster access times. More cache memory means the drive can use that more often instead of reading directly from the disk.

    Brand is kind of subjective. I've been going with Western Digital recently, because I've had good experiences with them. I used to like Seagate, but haven't trusted them since they bought Maxtor, because I **HATE** Maxtor and have gotten nothing but crap drives from them.

    blincoln on
    Legacy of Kain: The Lost Worlds
    http://www.thelostworlds.net/
  • MengerSpongeMengerSponge Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    It would be really helpful to know what kind of motherboard you have. You say it came pre-built, do you have anything that says the mobo's model number, what connections it can take, etc.?

    $100 isn't a whole lot to work with, but for a hard drive, it's not bad. Just browsing newegg, I see a 320GB Seagate, 250GB Western Digital, etc. for under $100, so you should be fine. My basic advice would be this:

    -Get SATA if your motherboard will take it. Let us know the mobo's model number, computer model, or something, and someone can tell you what it can take.
    -Make sure you get a 3.5" (internal drive for desktops), not a 2.5" (which are for laptops, and generally more expensive.)
    -7200RPM is pretty much the standard for speed. They make drives going up to 10,000RPM (and maybe faster), but those are going to be expensive, loud, and run really hot. 7200 is what you want.

    Beyond that, there's not too much to know. People will suggest different companies that are awesome/suck, but I've found that all the major manufacturers (Western Digital and Seagate especially) are pretty good. Also, installation is really easy. I mean, really easy. You need a screw driver, and you have to plug in two cables; that's it.

    I have no idea how transferring Windows to the new drive will work. Legally, I'm pretty sure you can do it, as you own that license, and you'd still be using it only on one machine. Technically, with the protection Microsoft uses, I don't know how the process will go. I haven't used Windows in quite some time, and I've never restored from those restore discs that manufacturers give you, so who knows.

    MengerSponge on
  • DigitoDigito Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    Alright, all very useful information that I'm sure is going to come in EXTREMELY useful.

    On the subject of what kind of motherboard I have, how would I go about finding this out from the computer itself? I admit that's one part of my comp I have absolutely no knowledge about, as I've never had to mess around with it.


    If it helps, I'd gauge the systems age at about half a decade or so... it's an older comp by now. <_<; Give or take a year or maybe two.

    Digito on
  • robaalrobaal Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    You don't need to know what motherboard you have, just open the case up and see if there are any SATA connectors:
    GA-81PE1000MK-SATA-Port-O.jpg

    The motherboard pictures at newegg are labeled now, so you can check them out also

    They aren't always orange.

    robaal on
    "Love is a snowmobile racing across the tundra when suddenly it flips over, pinning you underneath.
    At night, the ice weasels come."

  • MengerSpongeMengerSponge Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    If the system is 4-5 years old, I doubt it'll have SATA connectors. Check on it, but you're probably looking at IDE.

    MengerSponge on
  • BoredomBoredom Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    Um, sorry to hijack this thread, but I have a really really quick HDD buying related question. I want to buy and HDD but I have a laptop, and can't add an internal one obviously; so, what's that thing called that allows you to use an internal HDD as an external one?

    Its name completely escapes me as I've never bought one.

    Boredom on
  • CorvusCorvus . VancouverRegistered User regular
    edited December 2006
    Boredom wrote:
    Um, sorry to hijack this thread, but I have a really really quick HDD buying related question. I want to buy and HDD but I have a laptop, and can't add an internal one obviously; so, what's that thing called that allows you to use an internal HDD as an external one?

    Its name completely escapes me as I've never bought one.

    A Drive enclosure.

    Or you can just buy an external hard drive. Theres lots on the market.

    Corvus on
    :so_raven:
  • robaalrobaal Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    Corvus wrote:
    Boredom wrote:
    Um, sorry to hijack this thread, but I have a really really quick HDD buying related question. I want to buy and HDD but I have a laptop, and can't add an internal one obviously; so, what's that thing called that allows you to use an internal HDD as an external one?

    Its name completely escapes me as I've never bought one.

    A Drive enclosure.

    Or you can just buy an external hard drive. Theres lots on the market.

    Yeah, strangely enough there are decent looking ones that aren't more expensive then a internal drive + enclosure (example)

    robaal on
    "Love is a snowmobile racing across the tundra when suddenly it flips over, pinning you underneath.
    At night, the ice weasels come."

  • DigitoDigito Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    I wouldn't mind taking the motherboard-number route partly as the case to my computer is a bit of a pain to open and close... this machine doesn't see much downtime, and I'm antsy about popping it open while the thing is still on.


    EDIT: That, and it'd be nice to know just what Motherboard I have in general


    EDIT 2: And what are my odds of being able to hook up both HD's at once so I can just haul everything off of the first drive, and onto the new drive, and then from there actually sort out what I want to keep and get rid of? (I know, moving over a hundred gigabytes of stuff will probably take awhile, but... my stuff is a little unorganized, and it'll take longer to sort through it and figure out what I want to keep and what I want to get rid of than I have before I get the new harddrive.)

    Digito on
  • robaalrobaal Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    Try using Everest Home Edition to identify the motherboard; you should then go to the manufacturer's site and check the features there or in the downloadable manual.

    You shouldn't have any trouble using both drives at once.

    robaal on
    "Love is a snowmobile racing across the tundra when suddenly it flips over, pinning you underneath.
    At night, the ice weasels come."

  • DigitoDigito Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    Cuuuute... Everest only tells me "Motherboard Name: Unknown", so I still don't know what my motherboard is.

    Looks like I'll be doing this the old fashion way and cracking this case open to take a look, while I'm digging around in there, does anybody know how I can check to see if I can install two harddrives at once? (I don't know if that's standard or not...)

    Digito on
  • MengerSpongeMengerSponge Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    Digito wrote:
    Cuuuute... Everest only tells me "Motherboard Name: Unknown", so I still don't know what my motherboard is.

    Looks like I'll be doing this the old fashion way and cracking this case open to take a look, while I'm digging around in there, does anybody know how I can check to see if I can install two harddrives at once? (I don't know if that's standard or not...)

    I've never seen a computer on which you can't install two at once (as long as there's a physical space inside the case to attach both.) Generally you can just use an IDE cable that has space for attaching two drives. The only thing is, with two drives on one cable, you have to play around with jumper settings (the little pins next to the power and IDE connections, that say things like master, slave, etc.) Those always confuse me, so someone else may have to give you some pointers, but there's no reason you shouldn't be able to do this.

    MengerSponge on
  • DigitoDigito Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    In that case, I'm certainly open for pointers in advance as to how I should go about doing this. What I want to do is to install the second harddrive in addition to the one I have now, but to make the new one the main harddrive, and the old one more of a secondary drive.

    Digito on
  • DigitoDigito Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    I hate to bump, but I just wanted a little feedback on this one drive I found, that I'm wondering if it's one of those "too good to be true" cases.


    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822148139


    I dunno... it's got 320 gigs of space, 7200 RPM, 16MB cache, and it's an IDE to boot. (Which is a good thing, because upon looking, my computer doesn't do SATA.)

    And all for under a hundred dollars? It seems like the perfect drive, but is there anything here I should be wary of? Something that someone more knowledgable about harddrives could warn me of?

    Digito on
  • DaedalusDaedalus Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    Digito wrote:
    I hate to bump, but I just wanted a little feedback on this one drive I found, that I'm wondering if it's one of those "too good to be true" cases.


    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822148139


    I dunno... it's got 320 gigs of space, 7200 RPM, 16MB cache, and it's an IDE to boot. (Which is a good thing, because upon looking, my computer doesn't do SATA.)

    And all for under a hundred dollars? It seems like the perfect drive, but is there anything here I should be wary of? Something that someone more knowledgable about harddrives could warn me of?

    $100 or so is about the standard price for a 320GB hard drive nowadays.

    If you're buying it from the Internet, that is. Best Buy and CompUSA will typically charge like twice as much.

    Anyway. An IDE connection will support up to two devices per connection. Most motherboards have two connections (total of four devices), and the optical drives are usually kept on a separate line from the hard drives. Some of the newer motherboards only have one IDE port, as IDE is slowly being phased out. If your current hard drive is connected to your motherboard with a gigantic ribbon cable, it's IDE.

    SATA is newer and faster, and it uses smaller cables that don't impede airflow nearly as much. If you have SATA ports on your motherboard, get a SATA drive. If not, settle for IDE, I guess.

    Daedalus on
  • robaalrobaal Registered User regular
    edited December 2006
    Yeah, that's pretty normal. For a while newegg had them rebated at $85 or so.

    If you want to transfer data from the old drive to the new one you'll first have to install the new one as a secondary. It would be easiest to set it up on a separate cable as master or cable select, or hook it up to the same cable the old one uses and set it as slave.

    You might need to go into the BIOS (hit DEL at POST) and make the motherboard find the new drive - set Primary Master and Primary Slave to Auto which will make the system recognize both PATA devices on the Primary channel at every POST.

    I think you'll have to format/partition the drive before you do anything with it. Under XP go to Control Panel -> Administrative Tools -> Computer Management -> Disk Managment. Initialize the drive - I think you do this my right-clicking the drive icon. Partition the drive - the option should be in the context menu of the drive icon or the "unpartitioned space" next to it. Format the drive and assign a drive letter.

    Now you can use Seagate DiskWizard or Maxtor MaxBlast to copy the whole old drive to the new one. I think you'll be able to do it even if you aren't using drives from these companies, though I'm not sure.
    Additionally, Seagate owns Maxtor now, so I would expect them both to work on Maxtor and Seagate drives even if they are limited.

    After that's done just swap the jumpers on the drives if they use the same cable (ie. new drive - master, old drive - slave) or swap their physical connections if they use separate cables.

    robaal on
    "Love is a snowmobile racing across the tundra when suddenly it flips over, pinning you underneath.
    At night, the ice weasels come."

Sign In or Register to comment.