Someone has to be bandwagoned on Day 1. I wonder why no one runs phalla's where there is no vote on Day 1 to give time for something other than grudges and bandwagons to develop.
The problem is that if you have a night which other stuff happens but not the vote you just made every non-special waste a day of being even more uninvolved then normal for a villager. If you have nothing happen that night then nothing is going to "develop" at all and you just pushed day 1 back to day 2.
Really, you all should just vote Rainfall and stop voting for the same people every day 1 and it'd be less of an issue.
You know what? I'm down for a rainfall vote. She is one of the only people to not answer me back with a "no". Almost as if she needed to confer with her evil buddies before answering me?
I know she is probably just not wanting to respond to pms, but its better than the dunadan vote.
Not much to add except that I agree with Spectrum. The bandwagon on Dunadan looks a bit heavy and fast, but I can't really say much against it. I don't know SkyCaptain well enough yet, so while I may eventually switch, I cannot let the first Day 1 after Rolling Green Hills go by without grudging !Powerpuppies.
You know why...
I do, I do know why. . I'm really not convinced by the SkyCaptain wagon, though it's kind of unlikely any wagon could be convincing day one, and at least this one is not totally without reason. I also don't really like heavy bandwagons on day one because then day two is harder.
Someone has to be bandwagoned on Day 1. I wonder why no one runs phalla's where there is no vote on Day 1 to give time for something other than grudges and bandwagons to develop.
The problem is that if you have a night which other stuff happens but not the vote you just made every non-special waste a day of being even more uninvolved then normal for a villager. If you have nothing happen that night then nothing is going to "develop" at all and you just pushed day 1 back to day 2.
Really, you all should just vote Rainfall and stop voting for the same people every day 1 and it'd be less of an issue.
This sounds like something someone evil would say. Vote to "kill" because you're more than likely to hit a villager. I say we all bandwagon DA now.
SkyCaptain on
The RPG Bestiary - Dangerous foes and legendary monsters for D&D 4th Edition
Someone has to be bandwagoned on Day 1. I wonder why no one runs phalla's where there is no vote on Day 1 to give time for something other than grudges and bandwagons to develop.
The problem is that if you have a night which other stuff happens but not the vote you just made every non-special waste a day of being even more uninvolved then normal for a villager. If you have nothing happen that night then nothing is going to "develop" at all and you just pushed day 1 back to day 2.
Really, you all should just vote Rainfall and stop voting for the same people every day 1 and it'd be less of an issue.
This sounds like something someone evil would say. Vote to "kill" because you're more than likely to hit a villager. I say we all bandwagon DA now.
That's a spectacular misrepresentation of what I said.
So, do we have a solid candidate to vote for? I mean, the Dundane vote is pretty obviously a day one style bandwagon, so I'm wondering if there might be any opportunity to make an informed vote.
So, do we have a solid candidate to vote for? I mean, the Dundane vote is pretty obviously a day one style bandwagon, so I'm wondering if there might be any opportunity to make an informed vote.
Provide information for me to make an informed vote and I will.
Nothing much to go on except Spectrum's analysis on page 5 that there might be some baddies in among the original bandwagon on Dunadan, which even though it seems like decent reasoning to me, sparked a pretty quick bandwagon on Skycaptain.
My count may be wrong, but I believe almost all the votes are in at this point, and Skycaptain and Dunadan are tied with 5 votes each, next closest is rainfall with 3.
garroad_ran on
0
Options
Powerpuppiesdrinking coffee in themountain cabinRegistered Userregular
Okie doke, here is a current vote count, this is everyone with votes. Still left to vote is Gumpy.
Looks like my baseless vote for dun still holds the lead, with skycaptain approaching. And for everyone who is calling the dunadan bandwagon fast, isn't this how normally happens day 1. I mean, we have nothing to go on yet, and unfortunately, someone has to get voted out.
Okie doke, here is a current vote count, this is everyone with votes. Still left to vote is Gumpy.
Looks like my baseless vote for dun still holds the lead, with skycaptain approaching. And for everyone who is calling the dunadan bandwagon fast, isn't this how normally happens day 1. I mean, we have nothing to go on yet, and unfortunately, someone has to get voted out.
I'm not that much of a beast. All the credit for the formulas in my sheet go to blarney.
CC made retract buttons one time when we were messing around with awesome stuff to do with spreadsheets. You hit retract and it automatically erases the vote from the vote field and moves it into retraction fields.
We also made the amount of votes' color based on a gradient.
So, do we have a solid candidate to vote for? I mean, the Dundane vote is pretty obviously a day one style bandwagon, so I'm wondering if there might be any opportunity to make an informed vote.
We could always dogpile OrangeSoda and take his key.
SkyCaptain on
The RPG Bestiary - Dangerous foes and legendary monsters for D&D 4th Edition
So, do we have a solid candidate to vote for? I mean, the Dundane vote is pretty obviously a day one style bandwagon, so I'm wondering if there might be any opportunity to make an informed vote.
We could always dogpile OrangeSoda and take his key.
O_o
I said I was looking for a key, not that I have one. What the hell info do YOU have?
Oh yeah, I don't suggest taking any bandwagon personally. I do have to note if you continually, consecutively get voted out or killed day 1 it can be tough not to.
Nevermind that voting for Kime on day 1 is exactly the same as saying "I'm going to make a vote to lay low but a vote that everybody will just find funny instead of trying to pay attention to what I'm doing." Perfect bad guy cover.
Oh yeah, I don't suggest taking any bandwagon personally. I do have to note if you continually, consecutively get voted out or killed day 1 it can be tough not to.
Nevermind that voting for Kime on day 1 is exactly the same as saying "I'm going to make a vote to lay low but a vote that everybody will just find funny instead of trying to pay attention to what I'm doing." Perfect bad guy cover.
Posts
Really, you all should just vote Rainfall and stop voting for the same people every day 1 and it'd be less of an issue.
voting for dunadan seems to be too easy and suspicious right now as Spec mentioned. for now placing my vote for !SkyCaptain
I do, I do know why.
That's a spectacular misrepresentation of what I said.
Provide information for me to make an informed vote and I will.
My count may be wrong, but I believe almost all the votes are in at this point, and Skycaptain and Dunadan are tied with 5 votes each, next closest is rainfall with 3.
Looks like my baseless vote for dun still holds the lead, with skycaptain approaching. And for everyone who is calling the dunadan bandwagon fast, isn't this how normally happens day 1. I mean, we have nothing to go on yet, and unfortunately, someone has to get voted out.
Spreadsheet (Current)
SkyCaptain 4
Rainfall 3
kuhlmeye 2
SpectralSpork 2
Orange Soda 2
Powerpuppies 2
Darian 1
Eipnoom 1
kime 1
...like voting for kime "Has been killed day 1 like 17 times in the last 20" on day 1 for no reason.
Vote Rainfall for a better tomorrow in phalla land.
There are 5 votes for Skycaptain on your spreadsheet.
Skycaptain - Timmer, thetheroo, Spectrum, nodgarb, eipnoom
Dunadan019 - SkyCaptain, SpectralSpork, dunedainjedi, kuhlmeye, Darian
And that is why I use data validation so it is impossible to misspell anyone's name for Countif's
CC made retract buttons one time when we were messing around with awesome stuff to do with spreadsheets. You hit retract and it automatically erases the vote from the vote field and moves it into retraction fields.
We also made the amount of votes' color based on a gradient.
Good times :P
Spectrum when I said you could find something I didn't mean you actually should. That results in thinking on day one.
O_o
I said I was looking for a key, not that I have one. What the hell info do YOU have?
I'd probably go insane.
When asking people if they had a key a couple people asked me if I was either of those.
Also, !DevoutlyApathetic seems pretty evil.
It's starting to hurt my head.....
*yawn*
You really should have learned by now that when you think I'm evil, I'm not.
*face palm* If that was it I feel bad for missing that :P
Glad that I'm not the only one.
If I weren't busy trying to vote for rainfall for voting for kime on day 1 I would totally try and get you bandwagoned.
Pah, most of them deserve it.
Oh yeah, I don't suggest taking any bandwagon personally. I do have to note if you continually, consecutively get voted out or killed day 1 it can be tough not to.
Nevermind that voting for Kime on day 1 is exactly the same as saying "I'm going to make a vote to lay low but a vote that everybody will just find funny instead of trying to pay attention to what I'm doing." Perfect bad guy cover.
SkyCaptain = 5 [Eipnoom, Nodgarb, Spectrum, Thetheroo, Timmer]
Dunadan019 = 4 [dunedainjedi, kuhlmeye, SkyCaptain, SpectralSpork]
Rainfall = 3 [DevoutlyApathetic, kime, Orange Soda]
kuhlmeye = 2 [Dunadan019, Ebfan]
Powerpuppies = 2 [Cleonicus, Julius Caezure]
SpectralSpork = 2 [Erich Zahn, Fatal3RR0R]
Darian = 1 [Powerpuppies]
DevoutlyApathetic = 1 [B:L]
Eipnoom = 1 [oldmanken]
kime = 1 [Rainfall]
Orange Soda = 1 [garroad_ran]
Still to vote:
Darian
Gumpy
How does that impact Cleonicus's vote? Does Wildcat need to cast a vote or does Cleonicus's vote for Powerpuppies stand until retracted or replaced?
Cleonicus' vote has been nullified by his departure.
Heres my sheet.