The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.

High-pitched Noise From Wireless Router...

HallucinogenHallucinogen Registered User regular
So, I have a Linksys WRT54GL and after 3-5 minutes of being turned on the toroid coil begins to vibrate at a pretty high frequency, about 16/17khz. It's really annoying. I'm not sure it's a defect as it has been reported by many people on the Linksys support forums on this and other models from them.

Apparently if I wait until I'm 50 I'll have lost my upper frequency sensitivity enough to not notice it. I don't think I'll wait that long. I might try an exchange but I bet I'll get the same issue with the new one.

So far I've tried putting it in an enclosed space, but I could still hear it/feel it in my ears. Next I tried dropping the power in Tomato but it only reduced the physical sensation/irritation slightly, and the sound actually becomes more audible because the frequency drops.

Has anyone had this issue and found a solution?

[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
Hallucinogen on

Posts

  • SyphonBlueSyphonBlue The studying beaver That beaver sure loves studying!Registered User regular
    edited July 2009
    The solution is not to buy a Linksys. Return it and get a better router.

    Buffalo Wireless G

    SyphonBlue on
    LxX6eco.jpg
    PSN/Steam/NNID: SyphonBlue | BNet: SyphonBlue#1126
  • HallucinogenHallucinogen Registered User regular
    edited July 2009
    Looks like I'll be getting an Asus WL-520gU. It's the next best reviewed router I could find at the store I got the Linksys from.

    Hallucinogen on
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • ZackSchillingZackSchilling Registered User regular
    edited July 2009
    For what it's worth, my WRT54GL doesn't make any noise, and 17 khz tones really bother me too.

    ZackSchilling on
    ghost-robot.jpg
  • HallucinogenHallucinogen Registered User regular
    edited July 2009
    I guess I could've asked the dude at the store to plug one in and see if it made the noise. Oh well. I got the Asus, so I'll see how things work out. My only worry is that it looks cheap as hell and I'm not going to be surprised if it craps out within a year.

    Why doesn't anyone make good consumer level routers that last? It seems rather hit and miss, even if you buy the expensive stuff. I've tried DLink, Linksys, Apple, and now Asus. So far the longest lasting router I ever had was an ethernet-only router from DLink which lasted almost 3 years. Everything since then(which coincidentally have all been wireless) have had something wrong with them out of the box or in less than a year.
    It's so f-ing annoying I'm thinking I'll just make a goddamn router from an old PC with Smoothwall or something. The problem is that I'd want it to be small, at least nano or pico ITX, which wouldn't be cheap, especially if I wanted wireless capabilities.

    Maybe I'll just go mini ITX instead and make a server out of it as well.

    Hallucinogen on
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • exoplasmexoplasm Gainfully Employed Near Blizzard HQRegistered User regular
    edited July 2009
    Why doesn't anyone make good consumer level routers that last? It seems rather hit and miss, even if you buy the expensive stuff. I've tried DLink, Linksys, Apple, and now Asus. So far the longest lasting router I ever had was an ethernet-only router from DLink which lasted almost 3 years. Everything since then(which coincidentally have all been wireless) have had something wrong with them out of the box or in less than a year.

    Cheaper to make it with cheap parts, and as a side effect let it get replaced on a somewhat regular basis for more profit. Big businesses won't put up with this shit, thus their equipment is usually more expensive and not consumer-friendly, but long-lasting.
    It's so f-ing annoying I'm thinking I'll just make a goddamn router from an old PC with Smoothwall or something. The problem is that I'd want it to be small, at least nano or pico ITX, which wouldn't be cheap, especially if I wanted wireless capabilities.

    Maybe I'll just go mini ITX instead and make a server out of it as well.

    If you have the money, this is definitely the way to go. Or you could spend less time and find a Netscreen 5GT on ebay for less than $300. Then you just need a wireless access point and a switch if you have more than 3 computers. Not as cool as building your own, though.

    exoplasm on
    1029386-1.png
    SC2 NA: exoplasm.519 | PA SC2 Mumble Server | My Website | My Stream
  • BarrakkethBarrakketh Registered User regular
    edited July 2009
    SyphonBlue wrote: »
    The solution is not to buy a Linksys. Return it and get a better router.

    Buffalo Wireless G

    I've had that router for about three years and I <3 it.

    Barrakketh on
    Rollers are red, chargers are blue....omae wa mou shindeiru
  • exoplasmexoplasm Gainfully Employed Near Blizzard HQRegistered User regular
    edited July 2009
    Barrakketh wrote: »
    SyphonBlue wrote: »
    The solution is not to buy a Linksys. Return it and get a better router.

    Buffalo Wireless G

    I've had that router for about three years and I <3 it.

    What's funny is Buffalo uses the same parts as Linksys. They are pretty much just an OEM rebrand.

    exoplasm on
    1029386-1.png
    SC2 NA: exoplasm.519 | PA SC2 Mumble Server | My Website | My Stream
  • BarrakkethBarrakketh Registered User regular
    edited July 2009
    exoplasm wrote: »
    Barrakketh wrote: »
    SyphonBlue wrote: »
    The solution is not to buy a Linksys. Return it and get a better router.

    Buffalo Wireless G

    I've had that router for about three years and I <3 it.

    What's funny is Buffalo uses the same parts as Linksys. They are pretty much just an OEM rebrand.

    The stock firmware doesn't completely suck like that on Linksys routers (I run Tomato anyway), and that router has an onboard amplifier. "Same parts" is also something of a misstatement since I doubt the routers are likely to be using identical capacitors, resistors, diodes, etc or even the same board layout. Those are important in circuit design, you know.

    Now if you were to say "some of their routers use the same CPU/wireless platform", that can be accurate since SoHo router manufacturers pick their chipsets from companies like Broadcom and Atheros. Linksys is also known for gimping their routers and otherwise fucking things up, see the WRT54G revisions after the 4th.

    That said, the WRT54GL and the WHR-HP-G54 both use the BCM5352 platform, and the WL-520GU that Hallucinogen bought uses the same BCM5354 platform as the new WRT54Gs (the router we love to avoid).

    Barrakketh on
    Rollers are red, chargers are blue....omae wa mou shindeiru
  • exoplasmexoplasm Gainfully Employed Near Blizzard HQRegistered User regular
    edited July 2009
    They may be different now, but their initial offerings were the WRT54G or GL in a different box.

    exoplasm on
    1029386-1.png
    SC2 NA: exoplasm.519 | PA SC2 Mumble Server | My Website | My Stream
  • HallucinogenHallucinogen Registered User regular
    edited July 2009
    Barrakketh wrote: »
    ...the WL-520GU that Hallucinogen bought uses the same BCM5354 platform as the new WRT54Gs (the router we love to avoid).

    Oh goodie.

    I think I'm going to return it then and either order the Buffalo or build my own. I think building my own is the best option at this point.

    Hallucinogen on
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • BarrakkethBarrakketh Registered User regular
    edited July 2009
    Barrakketh wrote: »
    ...the WL-520GU that Hallucinogen bought uses the same BCM5354 platform as the new WRT54Gs (the router we love to avoid).

    Oh goodie.

    I think I'm going to return it then and either order the Buffalo or build my own. I think building my own is the best option at this point.

    I'd just wait and see if it gives you a problem. If it does, then you can return it.

    Barrakketh on
    Rollers are red, chargers are blue....omae wa mou shindeiru
  • HallucinogenHallucinogen Registered User regular
    edited July 2009
    The place I got it from has a really stupid 7-day return policy. I buy from them because they get lots of hard to find stuff and usually carry only quality products. Though lately they've been disappointing. After that they'll only do an exchange within 30 days for defective product. Which means I likely have the same issue with the new one they give me.

    Hallucinogen on
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
Sign In or Register to comment.