This does seem to be a solid plan, these Masons coming forward.
I agree, but the way you've phrased this is suspicious.
mEEksa and LoserForHireX
8-)
People who haven't voted:
Talleyrand
Rawwking Goodguy
Vote tally:
boogedyboo: 1 (lodwilk)
dogbone33: 5 (Suki, LoserForHireX, Ringo, Robos A Go Go, SimpsonsParadox)
Gonmun: 1 (pigeonking)
LoserForHireX: 1 (LemmingHead)
pablo_price: 1 (mEEksa)
Rawwking Goodguy: 1 (dogbone33)
Ringo: 1 (Hippie)
Robos A Go Go: 4 (Kistra, boogedyboo, uean, Timothy Leary Come Check Out This Theory)
SimpsonsParadox: 2 (Gonmun, pablo_price)
Timothy Leary Come Check Out This Theory: 1 (Grobian)
LemmingHead on
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC] hugs!
0
GrobianWhat's on sale?Pliers!Registered Userregular
edited September 2009
Ok, since I'm going out soon and may not be back in time for the narration, I'll have to change my vote from silly reasoning to something with at least a small glimmer of rationalism.
So !Timothy Leary Come Check Out This Theory and !Suki
He voted for the first bandwagon of the game (dogbone) while just repeating the reasons of the first two guys. I know that's not much, but we don't have anything to go by.
I do think Robos plan is at least worth thinking about, so I won't vote him out for proposing it. I also doubt that he is really in danger, so I don't have to bandwagon Dogbone to save him. (uean will probably change his vote away from Robos, Kistra might do the same)
Grobian on
0
Dogbone33I bleed Red and Gold!State of ConfusionRegistered Userregular
edited September 2009
!rawkking
!Robos
I can say that is my first ever almost a grudg vote. I don't wants to die either. I just got my armor nice and shiny.
Dogbone33 on
Play Diablo 3 RoS with me. PSN-Dogbone19
Play Fanduel. One Day Fantasy Leagues use my referral
The first player to reach the tied number of votes "wins" the vote.
Julius Caezure on
0
RingoHe/Hima distinct lack of substanceRegistered Userregular
edited September 2009
Okay, here's the deal with the reveals as I see it (and as I've discussed a bit with the mentor):
3 of us are going to die tonight:
1 to the village
1 to the vig
1 to the mafia
If the narration is going to reveal which faction/power killed whom, then we're pretty golden. We don't usually know this until after night 1 though. Anyway, the Vig should reveal his kill choice after vote close but before narration tonight. That means that tomorrow the guardian can guard the vig and the seer can seer the vig and then reveal himself to the vig because he should know the Vig's spartan name which has been redacted from the OP role posts.
Day three, the seer can start seering anybody who contacts the vig and claims a special role. So that should be the guardian and one of the two masoned brothers (the other one won't need seering as he's already confirmed). If the mafia gets three days of non-special kills that means we have a pretty well setup network by day 4.
He voted for the first bandwagon of the game (dogbone) while just repeating the reasons of the first two guys. I know that's not much, but we don't have anything to go by.
Yeah anyone who starts a bandwagon or jumps on one without any good reasons on the first day is suspicious to me, sooo...!Suki.
Talleyrand on
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
0
RingoHe/Hima distinct lack of substanceRegistered Userregular
I'll change my vote to Suki when/if he's on the brink of taking the lead.
If we both change then he goes to four and we drop to four. Three way tie. Then we just sit back and wait for another person or persons to see the true light.
And we can enjoy our hoagies instead of duelling with them.
Dogbone33 on
Play Diablo 3 RoS with me. PSN-Dogbone19
Play Fanduel. One Day Fantasy Leagues use my referral
Christ, the last two times I've tried to post the forums have gone down. Are the people making the forums go distracted by PAX or something? Perhaps swine flu?
Since a bandwagon change of this nature would be kinda suspicious for mafia to start, I support the !Suki bandwagon. The whole tied votes between Robos and Dogbone would have been bad, because if one of them was mafia they would have been able to subtly tip the scales.
I support the vig reveal plan as well. Masons should not reveal if we're going with this (they can contact the vig and vote for each other).
We don't know that the vig will be online right before the day ends, though.
Also, the mafia might be allowed to change their target at the last second. The close of voting doesn't necessarily mean that the night's other targets aren't locked in as well.
Dogbone is correct. All votes and orders must be received prior to vote close in order for them to count.
Julius Caezure on
0
RingoHe/Hima distinct lack of substanceRegistered Userregular
edited September 2009
If the vig gets dead at any point, then one of the masons can reveal themselves and asked to be guarded/seered. If two people claimed to be one of the Masons, well then one of the mafia has just revealed themselves, and I'd gladly exchange a 1 for 1 there.
The key is that the other mason stays hidden so that the first one can share all the PMs with that other person in case the guard fails to act and the revealed mason gets killed. The hidden mason can then reveal himself to the village by knowing the contents of those PMs and hopefully be successfully guarded from then on.
RingoHe/Hima distinct lack of substanceRegistered Userregular
edited September 2009
And now I just realized that if everything I've just said has made sense to everyone, I'm gonna get killed by the mafia day one for appearing to be knowledgeable. Bummer.
Then again, any of us could die by the mafia. Except mafia.
If the vig doesn't announce his kill tonight, a mason should definitely reveal. There seem to be a lot of ways to construct a village network in this game, so we should make sure to get on it quickly.
Ok, since I'm going out soon and may not be back in time for the narration, I'll have to change my vote from silly reasoning to something with at least a small glimmer of rationalism.
So !Timothy Leary Come Check Out This Theory and !Suki
He voted for the first bandwagon of the game (dogbone) while just repeating the reasons of the first two guys. I know that's not much, but we don't have anything to go by.
I do think Robos plan is at least worth thinking about, so I won't vote him out for proposing it. I also doubt that he is really in danger, so I don't have to bandwagon Dogbone to save him. (uean will probably change his vote away from Robos, Kistra might do the same)
Grobian Hmmm... so your saying that because I chose a bandwagon which had some other votes on it and repeating others reasoning, you are going to vote for me for no other reason than that? How is your reasoning any different from my own?
Considering how little information we have to work with so far, I'd prefer to not make a target of myself for no reason. You know, like what happened to dogbone.
Daypigeon on
0
TL DRNot at all confident in his reflexive opinions of thingsRegistered Userregular
Ok, since I'm going out soon and may not be back in time for the narration, I'll have to change my vote from silly reasoning to something with at least a small glimmer of rationalism.
So !Timothy Leary Come Check Out This Theory and !Suki
He voted for the first bandwagon of the game (dogbone) while just repeating the reasons of the first two guys. I know that's not much, but we don't have anything to go by.
I do think Robos plan is at least worth thinking about, so I won't vote him out for proposing it. I also doubt that he is really in danger, so I don't have to bandwagon Dogbone to save him. (uean will probably change his vote away from Robos, Kistra might do the same)
Grobian Hmmm... so your saying that because I chose a bandwagon which had some other votes on it and repeating others reasoning, you are going to vote for me for no other reason than that? How is your reasoning any different from my own?
Grobian started the bandwagon on you. You jumped onto the bandwagon on Dogbone. Jumping onto a bandwagon without your own reason makes you suspicious, as there aren't any leaders in this game (yet).
this is phalla, trust no one
edit: I know that, Tim, but I was just pointing it out. Also your post had no substance.
I'll probably change my vote from pablo_price at some point, I'm just trying to figure who is the most likely to be the mafia between dogbone, gogo and suki.
mEEksa on
0
RingoHe/Hima distinct lack of substanceRegistered Userregular
edited September 2009
I am perfectly willing to let my love for The Beatles Rockband lead me to kill both dogbone today and Hippie tomorrow (barring any significant evidence from day one). On day one irrational bandwagons are pretty much the norm.
I'm kind of sad it no longer looks like a three way hoagie fight. I was curious what metric would be used for judging a hoagie fight. Stale bread would definitely make a better weapon but a worse hoagie. Crunchy vegetables give bonuses maybe?
Kistra on
Animal Crossing: City Folk Lissa in Filmore 3179-9580-0076
I'm kind of sad it no longer looks like a three way hoagie fight. I was curious what metric would be used for judging a hoagie fight. Stale bread would definitely make a better weapon but a worse hoagie. Crunchy vegetables give bonuses maybe?
Persians ONLY use stale bread for their sandwiches. How are your jaws going to be strong enough to bite the persian soldier in front of you when your arms have been severed otherwise?
LemmingHead wrote:
pigeonking has made 2 posts so far: his signup and his vote, as have lodwilk, Tim Leary, and boogedyboo. Quite a few quiet players, indeed.
we're watching you guys
Just got back from work, currently reading through the previous posts.
I think that we should make Gogo, Dogbone, and Suki have the three ways buttsechs. Whichever of them is reluctant is obviously a Persian.
Or perhaps we can offer them all little boys...
LoserForHireX on
"The only way to get rid of a temptation is to give into it." - Oscar Wilde
"We believe in the people and their 'wisdom' as if there was some special secret entrance to knowledge that barred to anyone who had ever learned anything." - Friedrich Nietzsche
Posts
I agree, but the way you've phrased this is suspicious.
mEEksa and LoserForHireX
8-)
People who haven't voted:
Talleyrand
Rawwking Goodguy
Vote tally:
boogedyboo: 1 (lodwilk)
dogbone33: 5 (Suki, LoserForHireX, Ringo, Robos A Go Go, SimpsonsParadox)
Gonmun: 1 (pigeonking)
LoserForHireX: 1 (LemmingHead)
pablo_price: 1 (mEEksa)
Rawwking Goodguy: 1 (dogbone33)
Ringo: 1 (Hippie)
Robos A Go Go: 4 (Kistra, boogedyboo, uean, Timothy Leary Come Check Out This Theory)
SimpsonsParadox: 2 (Gonmun, pablo_price)
Timothy Leary Come Check Out This Theory: 1 (Grobian)
So !Timothy Leary Come Check Out This Theory and !Suki
He voted for the first bandwagon of the game (dogbone) while just repeating the reasons of the first two guys. I know that's not much, but we don't have anything to go by.
I do think Robos plan is at least worth thinking about, so I won't vote him out for proposing it. I also doubt that he is really in danger, so I don't have to bandwagon Dogbone to save him. (uean will probably change his vote away from Robos, Kistra might do the same)
!Robos
I can say that is my first ever almost a grudg vote. I don't wants to die either. I just got my armor nice and shiny.
Play Fanduel. One Day Fantasy Leagues use my referral
Be my friend on Magic Online! Dogbone19 is me.
THERE CAN BE ONLY ONE!
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
Since I'm the challenged I choose the weapons.
I choose a hoagie battle.
Play Fanduel. One Day Fantasy Leagues use my referral
Be my friend on Magic Online! Dogbone19 is me.
Not... the hoagie battle!
We're all doomed.
On that note, what happens in the event of a tie?
The first player to reach the tied number of votes "wins" the vote.
3 of us are going to die tonight:
1 to the village
1 to the vig
1 to the mafia
If the narration is going to reveal which faction/power killed whom, then we're pretty golden. We don't usually know this until after night 1 though. Anyway, the Vig should reveal his kill choice after vote close but before narration tonight. That means that tomorrow the guardian can guard the vig and the seer can seer the vig and then reveal himself to the vig because he should know the Vig's spartan name which has been redacted from the OP role posts.
Day three, the seer can start seering anybody who contacts the vig and claims a special role. So that should be the guardian and one of the two masoned brothers (the other one won't need seering as he's already confirmed). If the mafia gets three days of non-special kills that means we have a pretty well setup network by day 4.
one correction though: the mafia gets 2 kills a night. (it's in their role PM in the OP)
Yeah anyone who starts a bandwagon or jumps on one without any good reasons on the first day is suspicious to me, sooo...!Suki.
Oh, whoops. I didn't see that. Well, more chances for everything to go wrong and we lose our specials early! Hooray?
I guess that's why the Vets like to look at voting history so much.
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
If we both change then he goes to four and we drop to four. Three way tie. Then we just sit back and wait for another person or persons to see the true light.
And we can enjoy our hoagies instead of duelling with them.
Play Fanduel. One Day Fantasy Leagues use my referral
Be my friend on Magic Online! Dogbone19 is me.
Suki it is!
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
!Suki
Now we all have a good direction.
Play Fanduel. One Day Fantasy Leagues use my referral
Be my friend on Magic Online! Dogbone19 is me.
Since a bandwagon change of this nature would be kinda suspicious for mafia to start, I support the !Suki bandwagon. The whole tied votes between Robos and Dogbone would have been bad, because if one of them was mafia they would have been able to subtly tip the scales.
I support the vig reveal plan as well. Masons should not reveal if we're going with this (they can contact the vig and vote for each other).
Also, the mafia might be allowed to change their target at the last second. The close of voting doesn't necessarily mean that the night's other targets aren't locked in as well.
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
Play Fanduel. One Day Fantasy Leagues use my referral
Be my friend on Magic Online! Dogbone19 is me.
The key is that the other mason stays hidden so that the first one can share all the PMs with that other person in case the guard fails to act and the revealed mason gets killed. The hidden mason can then reveal himself to the village by knowing the contents of those PMs and hopefully be successfully guarded from then on.
Then again, any of us could die by the mafia. Except mafia.
If the vig doesn't announce his kill tonight, a mason should definitely reveal. There seem to be a lot of ways to construct a village network in this game, so we should make sure to get on it quickly.
pigeonking has made 2 posts so far: his signup and his vote, as have lodwilk, Tim Leary, and boogedyboo. Quite a few quiet players, indeed.
we're watching you guys
Grobian Hmmm... so your saying that because I chose a bandwagon which had some other votes on it and repeating others reasoning, you are going to vote for me for no other reason than that? How is your reasoning any different from my own?
I was a reserve :P
Grobian started the bandwagon on you. You jumped onto the bandwagon on Dogbone. Jumping onto a bandwagon without your own reason makes you suspicious, as there aren't any leaders in this game (yet).
this is phalla, trust no one
edit: I know that, Tim, but I was just pointing it out. Also your post had no substance.
And out of the top three contenders i'm going to say.... Suki
Fingers crossed for taking out a mafia day 1.
I'm kind of sad it no longer looks like a three way hoagie fight. I was curious what metric would be used for judging a hoagie fight. Stale bread would definitely make a better weapon but a worse hoagie. Crunchy vegetables give bonuses maybe?
Persians ONLY use stale bread for their sandwiches. How are your jaws going to be strong enough to bite the persian soldier in front of you when your arms have been severed otherwise?
I picked up Batman Arkham Aslyum last night. So I've been a tad busy punching crazy people in the face and throwing them off of railings.
They tried to bury us. They didn't know that we were seeds. 2018 Midterms. Get your shit together.
Punching crazy people, huh? Sounds entertaining.
Also, don't forget to turn on invisible mode.
Just got back from work, currently reading through the previous posts.
and we're all out of nails!
Or perhaps we can offer them all little boys...
"We believe in the people and their 'wisdom' as if there was some special secret entrance to knowledge that barred to anyone who had ever learned anything." - Friedrich Nietzsche