If they are able to use the same sort of game style and concept for two separate games, and yet give us 120 unique challenges in each, with a majority of the challenges doing something pretty creative...why in the world would you assume they've reached the end of the line?
It's like saying, well, now that we've made songs featuring every good-sounding chord at least once, now that we've used every key on the piano, it's all downhill from here!
I didn't read your post or click your links, but no, he hasn't. I think Galaxy is done now, two games was enough and there's no need to keep revisiting that idea. They should definitely hold off on the next proper 3D Mario until next gen, and I'd like to see something a little more adventure-ish next time. Revisit Mushroom Kingdom and other countries or whatever, SMB3-style. No more magical paintings or floating islands, but some actual real scenery. I don't want it to be a full open world game or anything, but a sense of actually playing in a real world would be a nice change of pace. I think Nintendo can come up with enough new ideas to keep it fresh, and all of the 3D Marios so far have just been disparate levels attached together by a hub world, so this would be a pretty big change.
I didn't read your post or click your links, but no, he hasn't. I think Galaxy is done now, two games was enough and there's no need to keep revisiting that idea. They should definitely hold off on the next proper 3D Mario until next gen, and I'd like to see something a little more adventure-ish next time. Revisit Mushroom Kingdom and other countries or whatever, SMB3-style. No more magical paintings or floating islands, but some actual real scenery. I don't want it to be a full open world game or anything, but a sense of actually playing in a real world would be a nice change of pace. I think Nintendo can come up with enough new ideas to keep it fresh, and all of the 3D Marios so far have just been disparate levels attached together by a hub world, so this would be a pretty big change.
Merging the 3D games with the Mario and Luigi RPGs would be amazing.
I think it's a bit silly to say "well, this is the best mario game ever, and I can't think of any new ways to improve it, so surely nintendo can't either." I mean, before galaxy came out did anyone envision improving Mario in this direction? I don't think anyone can predict what will emerge from Nintendo next, but there is a good chance we will see this kind of post again saying how mario has peaked and nobody can beat the new iteration's gameplay.
Posts
Super Mario Supercluster.
Beat that.
Also I don't think so. Nintendo are fantastic at taking an existing product and making it into something fantastic and new.
Get dumped into a pit and then miss your penguin suit because somebody can't let go of the goddamn sprint button.
Invent new swearwords.
TADA INNOVATION!
It's like saying, well, now that we've made songs featuring every good-sounding chord at least once, now that we've used every key on the piano, it's all downhill from here!
edit: in fact it's all you've posted!
Merging the 3D games with the Mario and Luigi RPGs would be amazing.
It's been posted across several boards.