So... kime tried to convert a SK day one, and then a mafia day 2? Nice aim!
I have a gift!
Edit: And oh yeah, roman, your cover kind of fizzled the last couple days. Good effort though :P. I just still thought you'd be too worried about the mafia, 'cause I still thought they were the dominant power. Nor did I think there were two of you in a faction. But next time
Ummm...usually someone has to survive from that faction to win. I suppose that if you think about it that way, both Cake and Pie fulfilled their secondary conditions. :P
Well, CapFalcon was alive. He wouldn't have survived today, but he was alive with all his victory conditions fulfilled. Either way, though, I lose
He would have died tomorrow, and Day 5 would have been really dumb, so I decided to let the carnage end today. I thought my post was pretty clear about what was going on. Poor Lemonbar, all alone in the corner.
but our win condition didn't mention killing or outnumbering the SKs.
First time running a Phalla guys, so let me know what I did wrong, besides all the busdrivers.
From my perspective, we (SKs) should of gotten cover roles, rather than one of us a guard, the other a vig, it should of alternated who did what each night, to make us not pretty much screwed as soon as the vig died.
From a game perspective, i think you tried too hard to give everyone something to do (which is important). Perhaps you could have given some people even/odd day abilities rather than have a mess of too many specials.
That's good, I like even/odd day powers. I mainly did that because I hate being a vanillager.
I had a hard time deciding how to give you guys cover roles in a faction game, and it was only today that I figured it out. Next time for sure...
You should of just told us of a pie/cake that wasn't in the game...Thats the only reason i made this junk up because if i'd picked something already in the game, i'd be insta-exposed.
So, your post absolutely reeks of you being mafia and you'll eat the vote tonight.
Nothing could be more pleasing for me (the mafia part, you dieing is irrelevant), as you see, i'm in a pretty shitty scenario, which i'm going to bitch the host out for come post game, still trying to make the best of it.
I'm a gingerbread man, and a vengeful one at that. I fit into no categories and am pissed at the cookies for excluding me (go figure).
I know that there are two serial killer cookies and i need to survive to see them die and then leave the game victorious. Why one of their kills looked like it was done by ice-cream i dunno.
The catch: I don't have a kill, only a nightly seer for cookie crumbs. So like, i guess i have to make friends and hope they'll kill them for me.
At the moment i know Rawkking Goodguy is not a cookie, but that's about it.
Anyway, at the moment i'm not looking for anything other than to not die from you guys.
Should one of your teammates want to get in touch with me after your death, the password Cookie Monster will suffice.
Cheers.
Bad news for you: your mafiadar is broken. I have no known teammates since, as I said, cake started out unmasoned.
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFF-
God damn it daniant and this bullshit role.
errr...sorry about that, good luck anyway, i'd take my vote off you but in the chance that you are mafia i dont wanna be an easy wagon target. Also, it wouldn't really matter anyway, you're going to eat the vote anyway i'd start planning for that now, and have some fun with it or try and mason your team etc.
Yeah, we'll see what I can manage. I figure even if the vote doesn't get me the mafia will, since I'm a seer.
First time running a Phalla guys, so let me know what I did wrong, besides all the busdrivers.
The busdrivers were fine, but I busdrove myself with Lucedes day 1 as well! If the kills got split into two by busdrivers, shouldn't the seers have been split as well? :P
I think you took the right approach in giving the mafia and serial killer abilities, with their sizes and with *everybody* having an ability it was practically a necessity.
Only other thing is whether the mafia/SKs got cover roles. Duny's rhubarb pie was pretty good if he made that up, unfortunately for him I was already in contact with kime :P
First time running a Phalla guys, so let me know what I did wrong, besides all the busdrivers.
The busdrivers were fine, but I busdrove myself with Lucedes day 1 as well! If the kills got split into two by busdrivers, shouldn't the seers have been split as well? :P
I think you took the right approach in giving the mafia and serial killer abilities, with their sizes and with *everybody* having an ability it was practically a necessity.
Only other thing is whether the mafia/SKs got cover roles. Duny's rhubarb pie was pretty good if he made that up, unfortunately for him I was already in contact with kime :P
Right, but I busdrove as well. That's why it got split.
First time running a Phalla guys, so let me know what I did wrong, besides all the busdrivers.
From my perspective, we (SKs) should of gotten cover roles, rather than one of us a guard, the other a vig, it should of alternated who did what each night, to make us not pretty much screwed as soon as the vig died.
From a game perspective, i think you tried too hard to give everyone something to do (which is important). Perhaps you could have given some people even/odd day abilities rather than have a mess of too many specials.
That's good, I like even/odd day powers. I mainly did that because I hate being a vanillager.
I had a hard time deciding how to give you guys cover roles in a faction game, and it was only today that I figured it out. Next time for sure...
You should of just told us of a pie/cake that wasn't in the game...Thats the only reason i made this junk up because if i'd picked something already in the game, i'd be insta-exposed.
So, your post absolutely reeks of you being mafia and you'll eat the vote tonight.
Nothing could be more pleasing for me (the mafia part, you dieing is irrelevant), as you see, i'm in a pretty shitty scenario, which i'm going to bitch the host out for come post game, still trying to make the best of it.
I'm a gingerbread man, and a vengeful one at that. I fit into no categories and am pissed at the cookies for excluding me (go figure).
I know that there are two serial killer cookies and i need to survive to see them die and then leave the game victorious. Why one of their kills looked like it was done by ice-cream i dunno.
The catch: I don't have a kill, only a nightly seer for cookie crumbs. So like, i guess i have to make friends and hope they'll kill them for me.
At the moment i know Rawkking Goodguy is not a cookie, but that's about it.
Anyway, at the moment i'm not looking for anything other than to not die from you guys.
Should one of your teammates want to get in touch with me after your death, the password Cookie Monster will suffice.
Cheers.
Bad news for you: your mafiadar is broken. I have no known teammates since, as I said, cake started out unmasoned.
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFF-
God damn it daniant and this bullshit role.
errr...sorry about that, good luck anyway, i'd take my vote off you but in the chance that you are mafia i dont wanna be an easy wagon target. Also, it wouldn't really matter anyway, you're going to eat the vote anyway i'd start planning for that now, and have some fun with it or try and mason your team etc.
Yeah, we'll see what I can manage. I figure even if the vote doesn't get me the mafia will, since I'm a seer.
Name: Cheescake
Faction: Mafia
Role: Vig
Primary Victory Condition: Kill or outnumber Cake and Pie!
Posing as Cake or Pie, you really don’t fit in either category. But you are delicious. Each day, you may choose one player to kill. In addition, the mafia has one group vig daily. You are masoned with Brownie (Ebfan) and Lemon Bar (Capfalcon).
Kill Romanqwerty
what happened to my kill?
There must have been a guard or a roleblock. :P
Can we get some cover roles?
Ask and ye shall receive. Angel Food Cake, Rhubarb Pie, Custard Pie, Carrot Cake are not taken.
Only other thing is whether the mafia/SKs got cover roles. Duny's rhubarb pie was pretty good if he made that up, unfortunately for him I was already in contact with kime :P
everything about the busdriver actions was true.....
I was just hoping that the pie player who was a busdriver got killed already......
I should have gone with the roleblock but the busdriver was just a more convincing story.
I think the biggest component of why the village lost was inactive guards, personally. Take a look at the spreadsheet.
This has really helped me learn how to play in a faction game. It was so obvious to me the clues people were giving day 1 about what faction they belonged too (and who wasn't doing that). I loved running this game guys, thanks for playing!
Was there anything else I could've done to convince you all that he was lying, or was I pretty much screwed regardless?
there are ways......
you probably still would have died though.
Yeah, there's really no set strategy for getting out of that. When you get called out as someone saying you were seered as mafia, it's hard to stay alive.
Was there anything else I could've done to convince you all that he was lying, or was I pretty much screwed regardless?
there are ways......
you probably still would have died though.
Yeah, there's really no set strategy for getting out of that. When you get called out as someone saying you were seered as mafia, it's hard to stay alive.
however, every action has it's consequence. people are now less likely to believe Farangu in the next games.
well i killed the wedding cake, and yes I was the cake vig
Void Slayer on
He's a shy overambitious dog-catcher on the wrong side of the law. She's an orphaned psychic mercenary with the power to bend men's minds. They fight crime!
if you want, you can think about a SK as a standalone mafia anyway so making it a mason pair is fine especially for bigger games, I did it in ghostbusters so it isn't exactly new.
with the mafia being undersized and the SK being oversized, it pretty much was a wash.
Dunadan019 on
0
FaranguI am a beardy manWith a beardy planRegistered Userregular
edited September 2010
Yea, for a 22 player game, masoned SK's(essentially a second mafia) AND a village idiot kinda made it hard for the village to get anything done, I think.
Posts
I have a gift!
Edit: And oh yeah, roman, your cover kind of fizzled the last couple days. Good effort though :P. I just still thought you'd be too worried about the mafia, 'cause I still thought they were the dominant power. Nor did I think there were two of you in a faction. But next time
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
but our win condition didn't mention killing or outnumbering the SKs.
You should of just told us of a pie/cake that wasn't in the game...Thats the only reason i made this junk up because if i'd picked something already in the game, i'd be insta-exposed.
The busdrivers were fine, but I busdrove myself with Lucedes day 1 as well! If the kills got split into two by busdrivers, shouldn't the seers have been split as well? :P
I think you took the right approach in giving the mafia and serial killer abilities, with their sizes and with *everybody* having an ability it was practically a necessity.
Only other thing is whether the mafia/SKs got cover roles. Duny's rhubarb pie was pretty good if he made that up, unfortunately for him I was already in contact with kime :P
Twitch Stream
Right, but I busdrove as well. That's why it got split.
Twitch Stream
Mafia and SKs tie! Kinda!
Zithra Melitch in Star Wars: An Empire's End
Jellica in In the Shadow of Zeus
Gingerbread is pretty creative though.
Zithra Melitch in Star Wars: An Empire's End
Jellica in In the Shadow of Zeus
woot!
the best kind of correct!
I was wondering how the hell you got that list...
Oh, and Mafia Proboard, Confections of Chaos!
Twitch Stream
huge component of why we lost
Zithra Melitch in Star Wars: An Empire's End
Jellica in In the Shadow of Zeus
I claim moral victory!
everything about the busdriver actions was true.....
I was just hoping that the pie player who was a busdriver got killed already......
I should have gone with the roleblock but the busdriver was just a more convincing story.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I think the biggest component of why the village lost was inactive guards, personally. Take a look at the spreadsheet.
This has really helped me learn how to play in a faction game. It was so obvious to me the clues people were giving day 1 about what faction they belonged too (and who wasn't doing that). I loved running this game guys, thanks for playing!
Zithra Melitch in Star Wars: An Empire's End
Jellica in In the Shadow of Zeus
Yeah; village idiots don't have the village's interests at heart, though. He was doing fine playing to his own win condition.
killing almost all the vigs and seers on day 1 and 2 was pretty good....
Oh I'm not saying it was the only component
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
there are ways......
you probably still would have died though.
Yeah, there's really no set strategy for getting out of that. When you get called out as someone saying you were seered as mafia, it's hard to stay alive.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
we only killed 6 people all game long, alot of it was just luck in this case.
I can see us having lost pretty quickly.
however, every action has it's consequence. people are now less likely to believe Farangu in the next games.
he would be a VI stuck as a network head.
Turns out I accidentally picked what would have been a critical part of the network.
Whoops!
Chicago Megagame group
Watch me struggle to learn streaming! Point and laugh!
Isn't that a contradiction in terms?
Well, grudged I suppose.
Edit: Which was already discussed in the sign-up thread, woops.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
with the mafia being undersized and the SK being oversized, it pretty much was a wash.
Chicago Megagame group
Watch me struggle to learn streaming! Point and laugh!
And I just love Village Idiots for some reason.
Zithra Melitch in Star Wars: An Empire's End
Jellica in In the Shadow of Zeus
Well on Tuesday, I straight up forgot. :P
Last night, I remember typing up the PM, but I guess I forgot to send it.
P.S. Sorry for not trusting you kime...