I refuse to believe that there are four members of the High Council out there, so one of you is pretty dumb.
But yes, let's all vote me because somebody just made up something about my (supposed) win condition! I mean, it's not like I just pointed out a group of people who would want to lead you astray or anything. It's not like the Domarians haven't already killed two mafia members for you or anything.
Gosh
!Ringo
Glad you can see logic.
!Peccavi
!Ringo
Sorry buddy, i'd rather kill a rumoured evil robot then kill you tonight. maybe tomorrow!
I refuse to believe that there are four members of the High Council out there, so one of you is pretty dumb.
But yes, let's all vote me because somebody just made up something about my (supposed) win condition! I mean, it's not like I just pointed out a group of people who would want to lead you astray or anything. It's not like the Domarians haven't already killed two mafia members for you or anything.
Gosh
!Ringo
Glad you can see logic.
!Peccavi
!Ringo
Sorry buddy, i'd rather kill a rumoured evil robot then kill you tonight. maybe tomorrow!
I'm voting from a boat! Free wifi
Anyways Ringo, I'm neutral considering I can with village and mafia on our mission.
What I did with infidel was at the request of the village.
I'll be refraining from interfering much more though. In part because I'm traveling
I will not be able to respond to pms today, maybe tomorrow night when I take this ferry back
Alegis on
0
Options
RingoHe/Hima distinct lack of substanceRegistered Userregular
Btw, it's weird how Ringo automatically votes for himself whenever someone else does.
Yeah, what's up with this?
It's how I show my contempt for stupid bandwagons.
This isn't the stupidest, because I'm sure some of the people voting for me are High Council and they think they're going to kill a Giant Stompy Robot. Wait, no this is the stupidest because I'm sure some of them are High Council and they just put themselves on the radar of a Giant Stompy Robot.
I'm voting from a boat! Free wifi
Anyways Ringo, I'm neutral considering I can with village and mafia on our mission.
What I did with infidel was at the request of the village.
I'll be refraining from interfering much more though. In part because I'm traveling
I will not be able to respond to pms today, maybe tomorrow night when I take this ferry back
You killed the public seer who gave us a mafia at the request of the village?
Man Alegis, you just like to get thanked no matter what you do, eh? (have fun at the wedding!)
!Wandering Hero - vote to figure out what's going on with my script
I assume it reads wandeRING herO
Yup, the match is not caring about letter ordering and aborting once it finds a shorter name exact match. Should be fixed now, but I can't correct the DB until later tonight
I mean, I haven't voted either yet, I just don't know why you think it's silly. If you knew for certain wandering hero was a mafia, then that'd be awesome. Do you?
I think that the evidence for WH being mafia is kinda flimsy, but on the other hand, I don't think neutral hunting is worth it when there's still probably 3-5 mafia at large
That's really not a good case. I'd rater go on someone who might be neutral but i have been fed good leads that he is hunting Alpha.
Several different networks have suggested it. i know they aren't all the same one because i've had to stop them from killing each other.
Melding on
0
Options
RingoHe/Hima distinct lack of substanceRegistered Userregular
edited June 2011
Just keep pushing that boat Melding.
Here, how about we test it - if the High Council is eliminated and the Domarian faction doesn't leave in victory then you vote me to death.
Everybody wins! Well, not you, having outed yourself in the thread and all. But the village certainly does better by actually hunting mafia and keeping the neutrals firing on each other rather than the village.
Ringo seems to be on a team with Infidel, who helped us find and kill an enemy. So yes, I think voting him out seems silly. He is not an Arcadian, he is not an Exigent. He does not need to die for me to be victorious.
fake edit: Stupid server errors. Imagine this was posted at 4:55
Here, how about we test it - if the High Council is eliminated and the Domarian faction doesn't leave in victory then you vote me to death.
Everybody wins! Well, not you, having outed yourself in the thread and all. But the village certainly does better by actually hunting mafia and keeping the neutrals firing on each other rather than the village.
High Council being eliminated would take a couple of days even with your appart super robot powers. What's the point in doing that when there's still Arcadians and possibly EO around? Neutral hunting isn't in the interest of the village, all it does it buy more time for the bad guys and yet you're doing it anyway.
Wiet on
0
Options
El SkidThe frozen white northRegistered Userregular
I don't have a concrete idea about the neutral factions, but they could also possibly have win conditions that are at odds with the village, like killing either alpha or beta (but not both), as well as another faction.
Right? Which would mean that killing them isn't completely counter productive.
Langly on
0
Options
RingoHe/Hima distinct lack of substanceRegistered Userregular
Here, how about we test it - if the High Council is eliminated and the Domarian faction doesn't leave in victory then you vote me to death.
Everybody wins! Well, not you, having outed yourself in the thread and all. But the village certainly does better by actually hunting mafia and keeping the neutrals firing on each other rather than the village.
High Council being eliminated would take a couple of days even with your appart super robot powers. What's the point in doing that when there's still Arcadians and possibly EO around? Neutral hunting isn't in the interest of the village, all it does it buy more time for the bad guys and yet you're doing it anyway.
So your suggestion is to vote me out, and that will help you kill mafia... how, exactly?
I don't think you've thought this through. Or know what neutral hunting is?
If I'm a Stompy Robot telling you to lay off Alegis because he is High Council (and he keeps redirecting your kills at villagers) and I'm going to Stomp him... what does voting me out do except waste the vote?
I don't have a concrete idea about the neutral factions, but they could also possibly have win conditions that are at odds with the village, like killing either alpha or beta (but not both), as well as another faction.
Right? Which would mean that killing them isn't completely counter productive.
There's only one neutral faction in this game that has killed Mafia for the village.
The other neutral faction has repeatedly killed villagers.
If you truly believe Melding's story: "Oh now that you've declared war on the High Council, I'd better tell the village this SUPER SECRET INFORMATION I JUST GOT that says you're out to kill the village!" Then at best he's telling you that I have to kill both the High Council and Alpha Team (notice how convenient it is that it's not Beta Team, what with them already being dead and all). So if that's the truth, what does that mean? It means that after I'm done killing the High Council, then I won't be removed from the game. And you all will know it, and you can then vote me.
What else is likely to happen? "Oh I have all these obvious High Council people in front of me, but I accidentally stepped on villagers again and again. Whoops!"
It's a stupid lie by Melding that doesn't hold up to any scrutiny whatsoever.
I've know this shit for days. we just didn't have anything to work with or motivation to move.
Do you want more? cause i know you know i know this. information isn't hard to come by here ringo. you're just angry i did this.
It's also funny that you "know" that Alegis is responsible for these deaths. Only the person firing knows that.
I'm dying tonight, i got nothing left to hide. let me get some information up up to give you people something to chew on.
Melding on
0
Options
RingoHe/Hima distinct lack of substanceRegistered Userregular
edited June 2011
Same way I knew all attacks Day 1 on Marth were redirected to Infidel, buddy.
But hey, if you can get the village to help you with what you think will complete your win condition instead of letting the village hunt mafia for their own win condition, more power to you. It certainly wouldn't be the first time.
Also, if you wanted to give an outright list of your High Council buddies, that would be swell. Might help tomorrow's survivors not be totally in the dark when trying to find actual mafia.
Infidel's kill order came from my contact in Alpha team. Why would alpha want him dead? he was a seer after all. A seer gunning for them and Exigent Organisation. That is why he gave us gumpy. He needed him dead and what better way then to have him be mobbed.
Likewise High Council was gunning after Beta and Arcadian Order. We've done a really poor job of this i might add. we were gunning for Bale when he died, and we accidentally got 38doe.
Logically, you have an agreement with the Arcadian order. you have no reason to want them dead other then to keep up appearances. That's really the only reason you want high council dead. after days of redirected fire you declare war on the other unsided faction. Also how you knew about Marth.
I want you dead because you're as much a danger to the village as either mafia and the high council. This is why i am going to be dead tonight unless some act of god happens.
If someone has god on speed dial, that would be super.
Clearly this would also imply High Council has been in contact with Exigent Organisation, but our contact died days ago thanks to Infidel, and they have been to scared to reach out again. This is why we had no trouble helping Alpha. If anyone has questions that doesn't finger the rest of the high council members, and alpha team, well dead man walking and talking.
Melding on
0
Options
RingoHe/Hima distinct lack of substanceRegistered Userregular
edited June 2011
So you posit that I'm working with the Arcadian Order... WHEN I KILLED ONE OF THEM LAST NIGHT?
Posts
Glad you can see logic.
!Peccavi
!Ringo
Sorry buddy, i'd rather kill a rumoured evil robot then kill you tonight. maybe tomorrow!
Boy are you going to be surprised
Yeah, what's up with this?
Then we will likely be down one Domarian and one High council. giving the village a better fighting chance, no?
Ringo
I'm voting from a boat! Free wifi
Anyways Ringo, I'm neutral considering I can with village and mafia on our mission.
What I did with infidel was at the request of the village.
I'll be refraining from interfering much more though. In part because I'm traveling
I will not be able to respond to pms today, maybe tomorrow night when I take this ferry back
It's how I show my contempt for stupid bandwagons.
This isn't the stupidest, because I'm sure some of the people voting for me are High Council and they think they're going to kill a Giant Stompy Robot. Wait, no this is the stupidest because I'm sure some of them are High Council and they just put themselves on the radar of a Giant Stompy Robot.
You killed the public seer who gave us a mafia at the request of the village?
Man Alegis, you just like to get thanked no matter what you do, eh? (have fun at the wedding!)
herp derp I haven't even read the last few pages
You're helping a neutral faction antagonize the village, pretty much
I assume it reads wandeRING herO
Yup, the match is not caring about letter ordering and aborting once it finds a shorter name exact match. Should be fixed now, but I can't correct the DB until later tonight
Wandering Hero is the other highest vote-getter?
Wandering Hero
I mean, I haven't voted either yet, I just don't know why you think it's silly. If you knew for certain wandering hero was a mafia, then that'd be awesome. Do you?
That's really not a good case. I'd rater go on someone who might be neutral but i have been fed good leads that he is hunting Alpha.
Several different networks have suggested it. i know they aren't all the same one because i've had to stop them from killing each other.
Here, how about we test it - if the High Council is eliminated and the Domarian faction doesn't leave in victory then you vote me to death.
Everybody wins! Well, not you, having outed yourself in the thread and all. But the village certainly does better by actually hunting mafia and keeping the neutrals firing on each other rather than the village.
posting from a kindle is hard
fake edit: Stupid server errors. Imagine this was posted at 4:55
I figure you have an alliance with the Arcadian order.
only reason why i can see you going after HC.
Good job trying to pin high council membership on me though. It'd be nice to be a part of something other then loose networks.
Loose networks are exactly what phalla is all about
High Council being eliminated would take a couple of days even with your appart super robot powers. What's the point in doing that when there's still Arcadians and possibly EO around? Neutral hunting isn't in the interest of the village, all it does it buy more time for the bad guys and yet you're doing it anyway.
Fixed that for you! :P
yeah, but to be a team player, isn't that what america is about? That or having sex with at least one B list celebrity.
Right? Which would mean that killing them isn't completely counter productive.
So your suggestion is to vote me out, and that will help you kill mafia... how, exactly?
I don't think you've thought this through. Or know what neutral hunting is?
If I'm a Stompy Robot telling you to lay off Alegis because he is High Council (and he keeps redirecting your kills at villagers) and I'm going to Stomp him... what does voting me out do except waste the vote?
There's only one neutral faction in this game that has killed Mafia for the village.
The other neutral faction has repeatedly killed villagers.
If you truly believe Melding's story: "Oh now that you've declared war on the High Council, I'd better tell the village this SUPER SECRET INFORMATION I JUST GOT that says you're out to kill the village!" Then at best he's telling you that I have to kill both the High Council and Alpha Team (notice how convenient it is that it's not Beta Team, what with them already being dead and all). So if that's the truth, what does that mean? It means that after I'm done killing the High Council, then I won't be removed from the game. And you all will know it, and you can then vote me.
What else is likely to happen? "Oh I have all these obvious High Council people in front of me, but I accidentally stepped on villagers again and again. Whoops!"
It's a stupid lie by Melding that doesn't hold up to any scrutiny whatsoever.
Do you want more? cause i know you know i know this. information isn't hard to come by here ringo. you're just angry i did this.
It's also funny that you "know" that Alegis is responsible for these deaths. Only the person firing knows that.
I'm dying tonight, i got nothing left to hide. let me get some information up up to give you people something to chew on.
But hey, if you can get the village to help you with what you think will complete your win condition instead of letting the village hunt mafia for their own win condition, more power to you. It certainly wouldn't be the first time.
Also, if you wanted to give an outright list of your High Council buddies, that would be swell. Might help tomorrow's survivors not be totally in the dark when trying to find actual mafia.
Likewise High Council was gunning after Beta and Arcadian Order. We've done a really poor job of this i might add. we were gunning for Bale when he died, and we accidentally got 38doe.
Logically, you have an agreement with the Arcadian order. you have no reason to want them dead other then to keep up appearances. That's really the only reason you want high council dead. after days of redirected fire you declare war on the other unsided faction. Also how you knew about Marth.
I want you dead because you're as much a danger to the village as either mafia and the high council. This is why i am going to be dead tonight unless some act of god happens.
If someone has god on speed dial, that would be super.
Clearly this would also imply High Council has been in contact with Exigent Organisation, but our contact died days ago thanks to Infidel, and they have been to scared to reach out again. This is why we had no trouble helping Alpha. If anyone has questions that doesn't finger the rest of the high council members, and alpha team, well dead man walking and talking.