Quite a few people calling each other out and complaining about them being jumpy... but psolms was the first to complain about someone being jumpy and also throwing down a vote to them as well. His hints about trying to find someone and so requesting PMs from you with secret details seems nefarious in my book.
Of course, this is my first Phalla so I'm probably doing this wrong. I won't mention this fact again though lest it angers the general populace!
Nope, this seems right! Although in my defense, I voted Psolms for being jumpy because I thought it would be funny.
I am changing my vote back to Psolms his searching for someone got resolved pretty fast, and his quickness to jump on SLyM-wagon combined to make me suspicious. Going to bed!
So you start off saying that Kime isn't a good vote target, then you vote for me, even though I voted for Segatai when kime was still winning?
Until we see what color kime dies, I'm not sure this really proves anything? Either way, I suppose I should go Slym self preservation. Though I wouldn't be opposed to swinging onto psolms either, because the later seemed awfully defensive as well
how do I know this? a pretty princess granted me a wish last night (it was one of you, so at least one of you knows im not lying), and i wished to know the identity of the grinch - whom it was my job to convince to publicly renounce his evil ways and learn the true meaning of christmas. this would have meant a conversion to team christmas.
I have given him all day to come forward and renounce his evil ways, but he has refused. therefore, he has chosen to remain against the side of christmas, and must be eliminated.
Except I'm not the grinch. Seriously, he's claiming a mafia -> village conversion. Nothing is more game breaking. Not sure why he's trying to get me killed but there you have it
The Grinch could just as easily be a SK or other neutral. Our win condition is eliminate threats to Christmas and the grinch sounds like a threat. And if you're not the Grinch we can turn on Psolms tomorrow as per the seer test rule.
The Grinch could just as easily be a SK or other neutral. Our win condition is eliminate threats to Christmas and the grinch sounds like a threat. And if you're not the Grinch we can turn on Psolms tomorrow as per the seer test rule.
I would argue that the grinch would fit an anti-santa type theme and 3/4 of the mafia in the last game followed the same type. Furthermore, if I was the grinch and I was neutral why wouldn't I accept the conversion? This only makes sense if I'm not the grinch and psolms is making it up or I am the grinch and I'm mafia. But in the latter case I could never be converted or the game would be broken so that can't be right.
Actually, the more I think about it, the more Phyphor makes sense.
Why wouldn't he accept the conversion rather than be called out and killed, ensuring his demise? It makes more sense that psolms has a "kill another player" objective.
I say we kill psolms first and if he turns up green, we kill Phyphor.
If you think about it, no answer except "no" to this question can give you any information
Heh. Well, yeah. I'd be inclined to believe him if he said yes, but a "clarification denied" would mean that it's possible that messages received in PMs from the host could be false.
Answers to clarifications are...Clarification Denied on other stuff.
0
Options
38thDoelets never be stupid againwait lets always be stupid foreverRegistered Userregular
Sorry I haven't been around today it was a very rough day. Without fully being able to read the thread, it seems like Phyphor was seered? I'll try and catch up tomorrow.
Finally, I'm pretty sure the mafia roleblocked me, unless one of you has a very interesting way of celebrating Christmas.
The Grinch could just as easily be a SK or other neutral. Our win condition is eliminate threats to the Holidays and the grinch sounds like a threat. And if you're not the Grinch we can turn on Psolms tomorrow as per the seer test rule.
I would argue that the grinch would fit an anti-santa type theme and 3/4 of the mafia in the last game followed the same type. Furthermore, if I was the grinch and I was neutral why wouldn't I accept the conversion? This only makes sense if I'm not the grinch and psolms is making it up or I am the grinch and I'm mafia. But in the latter case I could never be converted or the game would be broken so that can't be right.
I agree, a mafia to village or mafia to neutral faction conversion seems to be a very silly thing to include in a normal game. Has it ever happened before? But who knows, it could happen in a custom game like this that wasn't designed or play tested.
So Phyphor tonight, psolm tomorrow if Phyphor is green.
Posts
Nope, this seems right! Although in my defense, I voted Psolms for being jumpy because I thought it would be funny.
Mmmmm....toasty.
I steal all of your first-born children...Even the women...Also everyone dies, i guess...
Confusion will be my epitaph
Until we see what color kime dies, I'm not sure this really proves anything? Either way, I suppose I should go Slym self preservation. Though I wouldn't be opposed to swinging onto psolms either, because the later seemed awfully defensive as well
Phyphor is the Grinch who stole Christmas.
how do I know this? a pretty princess granted me a wish last night (it was one of you, so at least one of you knows im not lying), and i wished to know the identity of the grinch - whom it was my job to convince to publicly renounce his evil ways and learn the true meaning of christmas. this would have meant a conversion to team christmas.
I have given him all day to come forward and renounce his evil ways, but he has refused. therefore, he has chosen to remain against the side of christmas, and must be eliminated.
Phyphor
Phyphor for now.
But Im too busy hoping Phyphor's heart grows three sizes too large.
how dare you.
That's actually much more likely
Phyphor
I would argue that the grinch would fit an anti-santa type theme and 3/4 of the mafia in the last game followed the same type. Furthermore, if I was the grinch and I was neutral why wouldn't I accept the conversion? This only makes sense if I'm not the grinch and psolms is making it up or I am the grinch and I'm mafia. But in the latter case I could never be converted or the game would be broken so that can't be right.
are there conversions in this game?
Zithra Melitch in Star Wars: An Empire's End
Jellica in In the Shadow of Zeus
Bring in Test Subject #0001 "Phyphor".
Zithra Melitch in Star Wars: An Empire's End
Jellica in In the Shadow of Zeus
Why wouldn't he accept the conversion rather than be called out and killed, ensuring his demise? It makes more sense that psolms has a "kill another player" objective.
I say we kill psolms first and if he turns up green, we kill Phyphor.
roman told me i had been granted a wish, i wished through him, he told me phyphor's grinchitude.
but i know what i know, and i have been told that he will be converted. he does not believe that he will be. thats what it comes down to.
Clarification Denied.
Can the mafia be converted?
Edit: that was supposed to be in response to psolm's comment, I didn't see roman's response.
Are messages from the host reliable?
If you think about it, no answer except "no" to this question can give you any information
Heh. Well, yeah. I'd be inclined to believe him if he said yes, but a "clarification denied" would mean that it's possible that messages received in PMs from the host could be false.
Answers to clarifications are...Clarification Denied on other stuff.
Finally, I'm pretty sure the mafia roleblocked me, unless one of you has a very interesting way of celebrating Christmas.
I agree, a mafia to village or mafia to neutral faction conversion seems to be a very silly thing to include in a normal game. Has it ever happened before? But who knows, it could happen in a custom game like this that wasn't designed or play tested.
So Phyphor tonight, psolm tomorrow if Phyphor is green.
Henri Emmanuel Gratien St Pierre in Where No Man Has Gone Before
Lord Augustus Cumberbatch in Eclipse Phase
Every Who down in Whoville liked Christmas a lot
But the Grinch who lived just North of Whoville did not!
The Grinch hated Christmas! The whole Christmas season!
Now, please don't ask why. No one quite knows the reason.
Twas a crab named psolms who got a wish one night
"Who is the Grinch? I must show him the light!"
"Say the words and join us" the crab said
Let me win or I out you and you'll be dead!
Learning the true meaning of Christmas by force
A truer Grinch a Grinch couldn't ask for, of course
But ultimatiums are unpleasant though
As Christmas is doomed, his offer I forgo
It's too early, not on day two
I shall not join the whos
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCAn_sf9f_A
while i am disappointed by your rejection
i could not be more pleased by the form which it took
edit: did not want that to be botp