Mixing up the cabins seems like a good way to minimize the poor planning of some cabins by having those that planned for the future take on their burden.
So how do you propose the randomization? Because we'd basically have to reveal who guarded last night and thereby expose potentially weak cabins. Unless you just want to tell people you should break up into other groups.
I ask because we are quite a ways off of vote close, but I'm going to be out for the evening (JoCo woo!) and would like to get stuff locked up before I head into merciless downtown Seattle during a hurricane (see: mild rain showers).
Sorry if I seem a bit frantic, just trying to put everything into place before I have to go. I don't want to end up the odd man out of any cabin at all.
This is never going to work. We can't even get people to reveal what cabin they were in until the next day.
Also I may not check in after this moment right now (but I also might - hard to predict on weekends), and I'd be willing to bet that my cabin is baddie free.
At the moment I'm thinking that reshuffling isn't advisable at this point. Just logistically it's likely to cause more problems than it solves at 5:30 on a Friday night.
Unless there are undeclared members in their cabins they're in a pretty precarious position.
Note that I don't disagree with the fabulous vote, but there's a decent second.
I'm confused as to how both of those groups managed to be in 2-person cabins when they had like 36 hours to organize.
Alegis is borderline inactive most of the time and in a weird time zone (Belgium), so he is somewhat understandable. But you would think he would have just been left alone to die in the wilderness or something.
I'm confused as to how both of those groups managed to be in 2-person cabins when they had like 36 hours to organize.
Alegis is borderline inactive most of the time and in a weird time zone (Belgium), so he is somewhat understandable. But you would think he would have just been left alone to die in the wilderness or something.
Exactly, which is why I don't think Retaba is mafia. Mafia killed Alegis when they could have just had Retaba not bunk with him. Same with T_A and warban.
MrTLicious on
0
Sir FabulousMalevolent Squid GodRegistered Userregular
So of all people, I think T_A is a bad vote, which makes me slightly concerned about Rend. I don't usually play with him so I don't know what his deal is, but he seems a bit inattentive (i.e. the Sir Fab Flub), which I would imagine is uncharacteristic of someone with a reputation as strong as his.
So of all people, I think T_A is a bad vote, which makes me slightly concerned about Rend. I don't usually play with him so I don't know what his deal is, but he seems a bit inattentive (i.e. the Sir Fab Flub), which I would imagine is uncharacteristic of someone with a reputation as strong as his.
Would you really vig the one person willing to bunk with you?
No. For the exact reason that the village would be talking about it the next day. Not to mention that I'd worry that my 25% chance of being killed by the elements was calculated after I had murderized myself right out of a cabin.
Would you really vig the one person willing to bunk with you?
No. For the exact reason that the village would be talking about it the next day. Not to mention that I'd worry that my 25% chance of being killed by the elements was calculated after I had murderized myself right out of a cabin.
Just wanted to point out, we don't necesarly know that the skinchangers suffer the 25% chance of dying in the elements, though I guess if you chilled out in the woods a few days it would look really really suspicious.
I think we need more info about number of mafia kills.
Warban was definitely murdered. paraphrasing "He Felt something sharp" and he was watching wolves just before he did. Which we saw the skinchangers (in the form Dagon) change slip into the bodies of.
Obifett's is a bit ambiguous since he is just never heard from again, so he could have gotten lost or something.
Alegis went to sleep and never woke up from it. So he could have gotten smothered/neck slit.
Dagon's death is a bit odd. He slips into wolf form and then it mentions and another figure.
Bedlam just has his mutilated corpse.
I would say Alegis and warban seem mafia. Obi seems a bit up in the air.
Would you really vig the one person willing to bunk with you?
No. For the exact reason that the village would be talking about it the next day. Not to mention that I'd worry that my 25% chance of being killed by the elements was calculated after I had murderized myself right out of a cabin.
Just wanted to point out, we don't necesarly know that the skinchangers suffer the 25% chance of dying in the elements, though I guess if you chilled out in the woods a few days it would look really really suspicious.
I know I started the Fab wagon on a throw away joke, but the immediate hop-ons* are suspicious. And since I am leaving soon, throw a vote in for GBarons
* - extra points for arrested development references.
I think we need more info about number of mafia kills.
Warban was definitely murdered. paraphrasing "He Felt something sharp" and he was watching wolves just before he did. Which we saw the skinchangers (in the form Dagon) change slip into the bodies of.
Obifett's is a bit ambiguous since he is just never heard from again, so he could have gotten lost or something.
Alegis went to sleep and never woke up from it. So he could have gotten smothered/neck slit.
Dagon's death is a bit odd. He slips into wolf form and then it mentions and another figure.
Bedlam just has his mutilated corpse.
I would say Alegis and warban seem mafia. Obi seems a bit up in the air.
Warban was undoubtedly killed by Skinchangers.
Bedlam was voted out.
Dagon was murdered by the very person that was supposed to be guarding him.
Alegis could be skinchangers, his own guard (probably not though), or a third faction.
I'm confused as to how both of those groups managed to be in 2-person cabins when they had like 36 hours to organize.
Alegis is borderline inactive most of the time and in a weird time zone (Belgium), so he is somewhat understandable. But you would think he would have just been left alone to die in the wilderness or something.
Exactly, which is why I don't think Retaba is mafia. Mafia killed Alegis when they could have just had Retaba not bunk with him. Same with T_A and warban.
I may just be in "Burnage mode" of thinking we don't know the full mechanics yet. And that if we see something off and strange we should just burn it with fire just to make sure.
I"m going with Rebbatta, I don't' buy the whole he would never murder his bunkmate because it would be too suspicious. Its such an obvious move its the least suspicious thing. Also I would be very surprised if he wasn't picked up by another cabin and she knows it. Also as another note since I'm probably going to get voted off today, I think my cabin is pretty clean. We had a series of disease come through the camp which I am pretty certain is a mafia ability, but they seemed to be target randomly on people, as if they didn't know who was in the guard rotation.
Posts
Sounds suspiciously like communism to me
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1
I ask because we are quite a ways off of vote close, but I'm going to be out for the evening (JoCo woo!) and would like to get stuff locked up before I head into merciless downtown Seattle during a hurricane (see: mild rain showers).
Although, wouldn't that basically be the same strategy that we would use just staying in our groups?
As long as no one blabbed, only the individual cabins know who the guards were/are.
It would certainly put a strain on the soft networking going on behind the scenes.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Your cooperation is appreciated!
Sorry if I seem a bit frantic, just trying to put everything into place before I have to go. I don't want to end up the odd man out of any cabin at all.
Also I may not check in after this moment right now (but I also might - hard to predict on weekends), and I'd be willing to bet that my cabin is baddie free.
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1
In all seriousness though, I think we should stay in our cabins.
I think it's harder for the mafia to hide any shenanigans that way.
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
Unless there are undeclared members in their cabins they're in a pretty precarious position.
Note that I don't disagree with the fabulous vote, but there's a decent second.
If you're in the area come down and find a scalper; we can hi5!
Boy is my face red. In that case, I think anon is a good vote.
Alegis is borderline inactive most of the time and in a weird time zone (Belgium), so he is somewhat understandable. But you would think he would have just been left alone to die in the wilderness or something.
Exactly, which is why I don't think Retaba is mafia. Mafia killed Alegis when they could have just had Retaba not bunk with him. Same with T_A and warban.
Nope. It's in Seattle right? I live in Ontario. If I had a time machine I might make it.
Anyone got one for me?
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
It wouldn't go through, and they would be found out.
I think we need more info about number of mafia kills.
Man if I ever get a reputation for good memory
you need to immediately inform my wife.
No. For the exact reason that the village would be talking about it the next day. Not to mention that I'd worry that my 25% chance of being killed by the elements was calculated after I had murderized myself right out of a cabin.
Just wanted to point out, we don't necesarly know that the skinchangers suffer the 25% chance of dying in the elements, though I guess if you chilled out in the woods a few days it would look really really suspicious.
Warban was definitely murdered. paraphrasing "He Felt something sharp" and he was watching wolves just before he did. Which we saw the skinchangers (in the form Dagon) change slip into the bodies of.
Obifett's is a bit ambiguous since he is just never heard from again, so he could have gotten lost or something.
Alegis went to sleep and never woke up from it. So he could have gotten smothered/neck slit.
Dagon's death is a bit odd. He slips into wolf form and then it mentions and another figure.
Bedlam just has his mutilated corpse.
I would say Alegis and warban seem mafia. Obi seems a bit up in the air.
Right-o. First point still stands, though.
* - extra points for arrested development references.
_____________________________________________
HoTS: Schmutz#1686
Warban was undoubtedly killed by Skinchangers.
Bedlam was voted out.
Dagon was murdered by the very person that was supposed to be guarding him.
Alegis could be skinchangers, his own guard (probably not though), or a third faction.
I have no idea about Obifett.
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
I may just be in "Burnage mode" of thinking we don't know the full mechanics yet. And that if we see something off and strange we should just burn it with fire just to make sure.
Which I'm not sure is the wrong approach.
greenbarons for Langly's stated reasons and to further establish a first place.
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1