As was foretold, we've added advertisements to the forums! If you have questions, or if you encounter any bugs, please visit this thread: https://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/240191/forum-advertisement-faq-and-reports-thread/
Options
Netbook, Laptop, Ultrabook[?] buying reccomendations
Kadoken
Giving Ends to my Friends and it Feels StupendousRegistered User regular
Giving Ends to my Friends and it Feels StupendousRegistered User regular
As I have "completed" my gaming desktop (by completed, I mean I have met my personal requisites for a title), and most of the games I buy are from sales, besides a few which I'd pay full price to have at or near launch date (Company of Heroes 2, Guild Wars 2). I'm setting my sights on something which I've been wanting for a while.
A portable computer. Now I've been looking at some netbooks, because they are on the small side, portable, and would be great for long car rides, downtime on vacations, and airplanes. I do play games, but really, I'm not expecting Crysis quality preformande. A good benchmark, however, would be something like Max Payne 2, Jedi Academy, or maybe Psychonauts. I've got a couple of older games in their cases and on Steam, Jagged Alliance, Command and Conquer and such.
What I need suggestions for is something optimal for it's price range, which I feel that I'd have trouble deciphering. I'd like to pay below $600, something that has a decent amount of hard drive space (over 150gb HDD) decent battery, RAM, and a mobile videocard that can play most to everything made before 2003. Also a decent CPU.
I like the lightness and smallness of netbooks compared to other computers, but I'm open to suggestion for a anything. Does anyone have any advice of a specific computer or brand to buy from?
suggestions.
A portable computer. Now I've been looking at some netbooks, because they are on the small side, portable, and would be great for long car rides, downtime on vacations, and airplanes. I do play games, but really, I'm not expecting Crysis quality preformande. A good benchmark, however, would be something like Max Payne 2, Jedi Academy, or maybe Psychonauts. I've got a couple of older games in their cases and on Steam, Jagged Alliance, Command and Conquer and such.
What I need suggestions for is something optimal for it's price range, which I feel that I'd have trouble deciphering. I'd like to pay below $600, something that has a decent amount of hard drive space (over 150gb HDD) decent battery, RAM, and a mobile videocard that can play most to everything made before 2003. Also a decent CPU.
I like the lightness and smallness of netbooks compared to other computers, but I'm open to suggestion for a anything. Does anyone have any advice of a specific computer or brand to buy from?
suggestions.
Kadoken on
0
Posts
don't?
If i'm not at the desktop or at the couch with the consoles, the only other thing I ever play is my iPhone.
I never ever game on the go. If I'm not home, I'm socializing or traveling around or doing things that are cooler than pc gaming. The iPhone covers those "damn shoe shopping" or "this line at the bank never moves" moments.
Of course, you're not me. But some sort of iOS or android ultra portable device might be a lot more gameable on the go than a notebook or other kind of computer.
Netbooks are much, much better toys for Linux, IMO. It only ever became usable to me after putting Xubuntu on it (Ubuntu yielded similar performance to W7SE). And while it may not be true for you, I have a real hard time typing on netbook keyboards.
For the games you describe, I'd consider this: Find a used aluminum Macbook or Macbook Pro and throw a copy of Windows 7 on it. What you're after in this case is the 9400m integrated graphics (or the 320m, if you can find one for a good price). They are integrated graphics, but they'll still handle the games you're after fairly well. Certainly better than any netbook. Alternatively, you could try to find a 2008 or older Macbook Pro, which will have dedicated graphics. They're quality computers, they're very portable, but still very usable (full-size keyboard, amazing trackpad). A quick pass through my local Kijiji indicates you should be able to get one within your budget. (Edit: Here's an example: http://calgary.kijiji.ca/c-buy-and-sell-computers-Apple-MacBook-Notebook-13-Aluminum-Unibody-Casing-W0QQAdIdZ381679796)
Of course, you can look beyond Macs. Just, in your case, finding a used ultraportable with good integrated graphics or older dedicated graphics would likely serve you much, much better than a new netbook for the same price. Netbooks are indeed small, but they have surprisingly poor battery life... don't expect to be playing games for an entire 8 hour car ride or something. You might get 2 hours out of it if you're lucky.
I mean, I know from years of experience that you can do more shit with a full laptop, theoretically. But in the end, for stuff like airports and air plane rides and a little gaming at the supermarket and quick email checks at a starbucks, a tablet is a billion times more useable. Also, extra batteries are kinda clunky, and you have to shut everything down to swap it.
Oh, and playing anything mouse based or FPS on a netbook fucking sucks, and it's even worse on a plane. turn based strategy games are your best bet.
Of course, this is my experience. I used to think just like you before having all this crap. Maybe you'll feel different, I don't know.
What? I have a phone to check on Email and do small things like waiting in a line. Gaming at the supermarket? Why would I take something out like a notebook/laptop or some shit at a supermarket. I wouldn't bring a laptop to the DMV. Waiting for an airplane, long car rides, downtime at hotels, downtime at relative's and far off friends houses, that's where I'd use it for. I would use it for doing more shit without some frustrations of a tablet. You can't do much with a tablet. At least you don't have some convenient things that I like. You can't put the library of older PC games that I have in cases, on GOG and on Steam in a tablet.
Your incredulous attitude of me wanting to buy a laptop or notebook is irritating the fuck out of me, I'm sorry. Also, you end your posts with a variation of "You're not me"
like these
The turned based game comment? I have games like Fallout 1 and JA. I'm not taking this shit out at work (Maybe school for note taking). The socializing or "Doing much cooler shit than PC gaming" is annoyingly presumptuous. No, I'm not you.
I didn't make this thread to get talked out of this, I just wanted a reccomendation of a portable PC that's at my price range which I would like to use while away at a stationary place like a hotel or a relatives house, at downtime. Perhaps while on the road. I don't see Fallout or JA being frustrating while in a car or a plane or some shit.
Edit: the thread title doesn't mean I would only buy a netbook exclusively. In fact, it says Netbook, Laptop, and Ultrabook (Whatever those are).
It's not a ultrabook, but this is a pretty good deal.
Check it. 6 GB RAM, 500 GB HDD? Core I5? Average sized form factor? $600.
Here's your video card benchmarks. Definitely won't be winning any awards but it'll play the pre-2003 things you asked for pretty damn well.
Also, Lenovo. Very good brand.
But a VERY powerful machine will have less battery life, so striking some sort of balance is a good idea.
TB games are better for airplanes, airports and long bus/car/train rides, because you can play them on the trackpad. Stuff like Max Payne 2 and even fast RTSs are better when you're at a room with a table or whatever.
What about screensize? is 10.1 enough for you, or do you prefer 11 or 12 inches?
I guess a top netbook is your best bet.
This looks like a decent contender.
I think the OP may want something either not within his desired form factor or price range. The specs? You can get a decently specced pc for that price. The light, portable form factor? Too easy. Both of them together for $600? Difficult.
I'd say the OP may want to be a little more flexible on either the form factor or the price, and really evaluate exactly what he needs it for. If he imagines portability, he's either gonna have to pony up a couple hundred more or be stuck with a damn-near-awful Atom series processor. If he was performance, he's gonna have to maybe deal with a little clunkier/heavier computer.
I think you'll need to figure out if your gaming requirements can be served using Intel's IGP. The only ultra book with discrete graphics is the acer ultra m3 and I can't find it anywhere. If an HD3000 can handle your gaming then an ultrabook might work for you though You'll have to spend at least $700 to play ball. They're a lot better than netbooks. Ultrabooks usually have non-upgradable ram and non-user serviceable battery.
Since you said you'd be willing to keep another battery on you I think you want a traditional laptop w/discrete graphics if you need to keep it south of $600.
Well, netbooks don't, though.