Okay, Megafrost. Besides vote counts, re-posting clarifications, commenting with roleplayers, and being helpful and digging up the posts of his fellow mafia...
He never pushed a single vote, but he's voted for TNB, Spool, Sportz, Adventfalls, and am I missing any? Both mafia have voted for TNB.
At the risk of ruining your little RP-fest, here's Megafrost's vote history:
Day 1 - solo vote on Spool32
Day 2 - was in the TrueNeverBorn wagon
Day 3 - solo vote on Zandracon (And thus in his second game of phalla, Megafrost entered into the time-honored tradition of being weirded out by Zand)
A quick look at his post history doesn't give a whole lot of substance. Lots of jokes, some inept (intentionally or not?) attempts at vote counting yesterday. Not sure that there's much to go on here...
New & Reafirmed Suspicions In Order As Of Today (Also looking through the post histories of the people on shalmelo's Dunalist to see who I agree with...):
Tzeentchling
Every time votes start falling on him, other bandwagons start getting stronger in response. He's also been inactive as fuck. I agree with the vote on him.
Stever777
Looked at his post history. He has tons of posts in this phalla. All of them are short. None of them have anything of substance to them at all. It's like he's trying to appear active to avoiding the hiding-in-the-shadows (low post) mafia hunt without putting in any effort to actually be constructive whatsoever. He's also the one that tried to start the vote on Infidel Day 2 - I have not forgotten.
I sill suspect the fuck out of you.
Cythraul
Inactive as fuck (barely ~2 useless posts a day). Helped push the Anialos wagon.
Smoove Operator
His posts have also been useless as hell while being barely above inactive (~2 useless posts a day). There's also a common theme of voting for TrueNeverBorn, the same as the other two mafia.
Lucedes
Roleplaying as a kute Magickarp does not make you helpful. Not active otherwise Also tried to bandwagon TrueNeverBorn (it would be kinda helpful for analysis if this guy was confirmed Green or Red) like our two mafia. Now trying to kill me.
---
Previous Suspicions (That I No Longer Feel As Suspicions About):
Mill
Same Infidel wagon reason as Stever. Same on not being constructive. Using his secret on Day 1 against someone the mafia killed doesn't clear him at all. The mafia could have beeen easily be as clueless to secret use as we (the village) were day 1.
But there's better targets first now. I suspect him less than I did yesterday and all that jazz.
I would actually appriciate a list of those besides me that pushed the Mill wagon on previous days.
---
Don't activly suspect Reg Rysk at the moment and I'd like to hear your thoughts shalmelo. It's true he's been barely active, but he also hasn't been pushing any terible bandwagons and instead seems to be voting every day by his gut. He has voted for Lucedes the most who's also on my suspicon list so that also biases me to suspect him less currently. (Note: This is not me vouching for them.)
I would also like to know the reasons you specet INANTP. I'm not personally feeling it. He made the arguments for trusting Kime when others tried to delay the network. Arguing against people who were supicious against Infidel's wagon. He's posted some somewhat decent game theory reguarding secret use. And as far as I know has been voting on his gut or on Spool's or My suspicon thought. I don't personally see anything that lables him as --> Mafia Here <--- and want to know what I'm missing off hand if anything. (Again: This is not me vouching for them.)
It would hardly be a Dunalist if I gave reasons, now would it? :P
Seriously, though - you've done more analysis here than I have. I'm too lazy to try go through the whole thread and pick apart a player's entire post history without the magic box running. Most of what I'm doing is relying on the work of others (You, spool and bluecyan have all been very helpful in that regard) combined with gut instinct. People will make posts that make me think "that's totally something I would have said if I were mafia" **cough*tzeentchling*cough**, and from that point I'll start looking at them a little more closely and see if I can build a pattern of sketchiness. It's far from an exact science, but I feel like my mafiadar is pretty good, by and large.
@kime Is there a reason we didn't try using any of the other powers last night? Did we mix up again and null one of the two because they were both the same category, or did we just not try to use anything beyond the vig/seer?
Kilnaga on
"The psychedelic mind is a higher dimensional mind, it is not fit for three dimensional space time."
- Terence McKenna
Awwww, KIIIIIIMMMMMEEEEE!!! if I had a vote to retract I would. Not sure where I Went against you/called you into question. However I'm very interested in Smoove Operator so bitter sweet moment here.
TrueNeverborn on
So if you love games and I love games... Why are we not playing... **sees the forum** OOOOHHHH Yeh!
@kime Is there a reason we didn't try using any of the other powers last night? Did we mix up again and null one of the two because they were both the same category, or did we just not try to use anything beyond the vig/seer?
I don't want to overlap powers, so if I am uncertain on categories, then I take priority with vig and seer.
I suppose that smoove operator is who we have decided to remove. Doing detailed analysis is certainly much harder without the old forums, or the magic box, despite whatever sorcery powered it.
It is hard for one to vote so late and not look like simply jumping on the bandwagon. Alas, I have not the time to try and do further research today, perhaps tomorrow I may.
I'll place my !vote on Bluecyan for today. I get the feeling that there's a mafia member among the early posters, and that's where my feelings point for now.
I suppose that smoove operator is who we have decided to remove. Doing detailed analysis is certainly much harder without the old forums, or the magic box, despite whatever sorcery powered it.
It is hard for one to vote so late and not look like simply jumping on the bandwagon. Alas, I have not the time to try and do further research today, perhaps tomorrow I may.
If you haven't done the research or read others opinions who have, then maybe you shouldn't join the bandwagon. Its still fairly close enough right now, that other differences of opinions or new analysis could swing things around. Jumping on the leader because they are the leader seems a poor vote to me.
I'll place my !vote on Bluecyan for today. I get the feeling that there's a mafia member among the early posters, and that's where my feelings point for now.
My dear old boy, I did not imply that I had not read the opinions of those who had done the research. I have read and thought and cast my vote. I was only lamenting the fact that I am sure I could have come up with another possible target had I more time to do intricate research.
0
Erin The RedThe Name's Erin! Woman, Podcaster, Dungeon Master, IT nerd, Parent, Trans. AMABaton Rouge, LARegistered Userregular
It seems that people are more willing to stand by their votes today. Looking at this spreadsheet of Blarney's, there's been mvch less vote retracting.
Posts
anyhow i'll have to think a bit more on who i want to vote and why later cause im studying
Steam
He never pushed a single vote, but he's voted for TNB, Spool, Sportz, Adventfalls, and am I missing any? Both mafia have voted for TNB.
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //
Yeah, I don't think TrueNeverBorn is mafia.
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //
Didn't want to give away that you were the mastermind and make you a bigger target
Mmmmm....toasty.
Everyone knows I'm directing everything.
Just like always
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
New & Reafirmed Suspicions In Order As Of Today (Also looking through the post histories of the people on shalmelo's Dunalist to see who I agree with...):
Tzeentchling
Every time votes start falling on him, other bandwagons start getting stronger in response. He's also been inactive as fuck. I agree with the vote on him.
Stever777
Looked at his post history. He has tons of posts in this phalla. All of them are short. None of them have anything of substance to them at all. It's like he's trying to appear active to avoiding the hiding-in-the-shadows (low post) mafia hunt without putting in any effort to actually be constructive whatsoever. He's also the one that tried to start the vote on Infidel Day 2 - I have not forgotten.
I sill suspect the fuck out of you.
Cythraul
Inactive as fuck (barely ~2 useless posts a day). Helped push the Anialos wagon.
Smoove Operator
His posts have also been useless as hell while being barely above inactive (~2 useless posts a day). There's also a common theme of voting for TrueNeverBorn, the same as the other two mafia.
Lucedes
Roleplaying as a kute Magickarp does not make you helpful. Not active otherwise Also tried to bandwagon TrueNeverBorn (it would be kinda helpful for analysis if this guy was confirmed Green or Red) like our two mafia. Now trying to kill me.
---
Previous Suspicions (That I No Longer Feel As Suspicions About):
Mill
Same Infidel wagon reason as Stever. Same on not being constructive. Using his secret on Day 1 against someone the mafia killed doesn't clear him at all. The mafia could have beeen easily be as clueless to secret use as we (the village) were day 1.
But there's better targets first now. I suspect him less than I did yesterday and all that jazz.
I would actually appriciate a list of those besides me that pushed the Mill wagon on previous days.
---
Don't activly suspect Reg Rysk at the moment and I'd like to hear your thoughts shalmelo. It's true he's been barely active, but he also hasn't been pushing any terible bandwagons and instead seems to be voting every day by his gut. He has voted for Lucedes the most who's also on my suspicon list so that also biases me to suspect him less currently. (Note: This is not me vouching for them.)
I would also like to know the reasons you specet INANTP. I'm not personally feeling it. He made the arguments for trusting Kime when others tried to delay the network. Arguing against people who were supicious against Infidel's wagon. He's posted some somewhat decent game theory reguarding secret use. And as far as I know has been voting on his gut or on Spool's or My suspicon thought. I don't personally see anything that lables him as --> Mafia Here <--- and want to know what I'm missing off hand if anything. (Again: This is not me vouching for them.)
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //
!Tzeentchling
That's with a ! for extra old-school phalla vote smackdown.
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //
Well, I never.
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1
That stuff is delicious
Confusion will be my epitaph
Refresh that browser, sir
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Not that I want to defend this guy, especially since he has a vote against me, but that's pretty much how he always is.
3DS: 1289-8447-4695
Whoops.
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //
It would hardly be a Dunalist if I gave reasons, now would it? :P
Seriously, though - you've done more analysis here than I have. I'm too lazy to try go through the whole thread and pick apart a player's entire post history without the magic box running. Most of what I'm doing is relying on the work of others (You, spool and bluecyan have all been very helpful in that regard) combined with gut instinct. People will make posts that make me think "that's totally something I would have said if I were mafia" **cough*tzeentchling*cough**, and from that point I'll start looking at them a little more closely and see if I can build a pattern of sketchiness. It's far from an exact science, but I feel like my mafiadar is pretty good, by and large.
Click on "Posts" on the left bar.
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //
Edit. Spelling
3DS: 1289-8447-4695
Thanks?
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1
- Terence McKenna
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //
Current Spreadsheet (up to post 1413)
Smoove Operator leads at 7 votes, with premium and tzeentchling following at 4 votes each. 7 players remaining who have not yet made a vote.
- Terence McKenna
Your list is broken, I'm not on it.
been too busy with other things today to really do much here i'm sorry
Steam
I don't want to overlap powers, so if I am uncertain on categories, then I take priority with vig and seer.
Also keeps the mafia guessing! :P
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Oh, alegis, how could you?
Mmmmm....toasty.
It is hard for one to vote so late and not look like simply jumping on the bandwagon. Alas, I have not the time to try and do further research today, perhaps tomorrow I may.
3DS: 1289-8447-4695
If you haven't done the research or read others opinions who have, then maybe you shouldn't join the bandwagon. Its still fairly close enough right now, that other differences of opinions or new analysis could swing things around. Jumping on the leader because they are the leader seems a poor vote to me.
Just as long as its not any part of Shakira.
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //