So village needs to ignore shit like 'this player is totes mafia because i have inside info', and instead rely on voting and post analyses
Also I think this post is bullshit and that you know it's bullshit. I'm committed to this Phyphor wagon, but if it doesn't turn out, I'm pretty sure I'm voting for you tomorrow.
note that we only have a 11.11% chance of randomly hitting the demon king last, so we are at least wasting one kill out of our limited firepower, most likely.
facetiousa wit so dryit shits sandRegistered Userregular
You make good points, ZH, but we do have to consider whatever leads there are since we've had so few of them.
At the same time though, one wagon does us no good when we're already lacking for useful vote records as it is so I hope it doesn't become a mass vote.
"I am not young enough to know everything." - Oscar Wilde
So village needs to ignore shit like 'this player is totes mafia because i have inside info', and instead rely on voting and post analyses
Also I think this post is bullshit and that you know it's bullshit. I'm committed to this Phyphor wagon, but if it doesn't turn out, I'm pretty sure I'm voting for you tomorrow.
Can't wait.
Now. That post was made basically using my background from the Persona phalla, where we had an invincible mafia do a fake seer call, and the only reasonable defense against such a move was to not follow it(we didn't know of the invinco mafia in that one). Similarly, that call was made super early. If i can avoid making a mistake a second time, I will.
So village needs to ignore shit like 'this player is totes mafia because i have inside info', and instead rely on voting and post analyses
Problem is, the current voting record provides very little information, and all the RPing makes analyzing player behavior a bit tricky as well. As far as I can tell, the Phyphorwagon is right now the only lead we have, and a flimsy one at that. It would be nice if Gandalf elaborated on this a little.
0
facetiousa wit so dryit shits sandRegistered Userregular
I do still find Cayrus suspicious based on that vote yesterday and his general quietness. The timing of the vote struck me as being one where it was cast early enough that it could at least seem not to be a 'hiding in the wagon' vote, yet the way the wind was blowing it was obvious MrT was going to continue receiving votes.
"I am not young enough to know everything." - Oscar Wilde
Other leads of various value:
-Wagon avoiders
-People who didn't play in the recent one or two games, and would have murdered bradicus
-People who commented soon after the game started, as villagers didn't get a role pm and may not have known the game had started
To expound on my Romanian vote:
-Quickly posted after 'some folks are too quiet' post
-Votes on middle early wagon both nights
-Someone aluded to Se++ players having a higher chance of being mafia (because of bradicus), so why not add it here, even though its the flimsiest of the already flimsy reasons
No, I think the speculation about SE++ was that they could have Aqualung's shards deep in them. To my recollection, nobody speculated that they were all demons.
No, I think the speculation about SE++ was that they could have Aqualung's shards deep in them. To my recollection, nobody speculated that they were all demons.
no INANTP (and I) spoke privately, and then he posted publicly, that SE people might have a higher chance of killing bradicus.
the problem with that theory, of course, is that a mafia contains many members and there would not just be SE people in the mafia. So someone would have been around to change targets.
No, I think the speculation about SE++ was that they could have Aqualung's shards deep in them. To my recollection, nobody speculated that they were all demons.
CayrusConsulFriends, Romans, countrymen, lend me your ears!Registered Userregular
Gandalf_the_Crazed seems to be operating a gambit to get us to vote for Phypor for some insidious reason with no real proof. If he dies green then we can turn on Phyphor tomorrow.
No, I think the speculation about SE++ was that they could have Aqualung's shards deep in them. To my recollection, nobody speculated that they were all demons.
no INANTP (and I) spoke privately, and then he posted publicly, that SE people might have a higher chance of killing bradicus.
the problem with that theory, of course, is that a mafia contains many members and there would not just be SE people in the mafia. So someone would have been around to change targets.
it's just a really weird day one choice.
Wait, wait. So you and INANTP were colluding? Stop the presses!
Okay, I stand corrected. Maybe subconsciously I was ignoring INANTP for poo-pooing all of our extremely vital and productive roleplay yesterday.
So village needs to ignore shit like 'this player is totes mafia because i have inside info', and instead rely on voting and post analyses
Problem is, the current voting record provides very little information, and all the RPing makes analyzing player behavior a bit tricky as well. As far as I can tell, the Phyphorwagon is right now the only lead we have, and a flimsy one at that. It would be nice if Gandalf elaborated on this a little.
A man has told you all he knows. You have further questions?
So village needs to ignore shit like 'this player is totes mafia because i have inside info', and instead rely on voting and post analyses
Problem is, the current voting record provides very little information, and all the RPing makes analyzing player behavior a bit tricky as well. As far as I can tell, the Phyphorwagon is right now the only lead we have, and a flimsy one at that. It would be nice if Gandalf elaborated on this a little.
A man has told you all he knows. You have further questions?
Austin sighed with a shrug and stepped forward to address the congress. "Ehem... You should knowing that Gandalf isn't exactly trustworthy. He's claimed to play no part in this play. Also that he has the ability to make deals for some sort of employer. What he means by that is that in exchange for a pact neutering you against him he will grant you a favor. You can no longer vote for him nor can you use any of your gifts against him. It's a Faustian bargain. I'm not sure about you guys, but that sounds like the kind of power a demon would have.
"This isn't exactly damning testimony, but I have confirmed it with another. Either way, unless we have some sort of confirmation that Gandalf is neutral in this theatre I'm not sure we can trust him."
Okay... its too hard to get this info across through RP
Gandalf has claimed neutral with the ability to grant favors
In exchange for those favors, you cannot vote and/or use powers against him
I have confirmed those are the conditions of his deals with another player who also made the deal
Gamewise, that's an interesting neutral; Flavorwise, it sounds like a demon deal
I'm not saying we vote him out or whatever, but maybe he's not a trustworthy source
I'm not sure how to test his alignment though without wasting resources
No, I think the speculation about SE++ was that they could have Aqualung's shards deep in them. To my recollection, nobody speculated that they were all demons.
no INANTP (and I) spoke privately, and then he posted publicly, that SE people might have a higher chance of killing bradicus.
the problem with that theory, of course, is that a mafia contains many members and there would not just be SE people in the mafia. So someone would have been around to change targets.
it's just a really weird day one choice.
For what it's worth, this combined with his defensiveness after accruing a single vote was my rationale behind voting for Zonugal yesterday.
So village needs to ignore shit like 'this player is totes mafia because i have inside info', and instead rely on voting and post analyses
Problem is, the current voting record provides very little information, and all the RPing makes analyzing player behavior a bit tricky as well. As far as I can tell, the Phyphorwagon is right now the only lead we have, and a flimsy one at that. It would be nice if Gandalf elaborated on this a little.
A man has told you all he knows. You have further questions?
Are you a demon?
look at his sweat and struggle. Some myth says demons cannot lie, but I disagree with this. I have no experience, but if our current situation is any idication, they can and will.
So village needs to ignore shit like 'this player is totes mafia because i have inside info', and instead rely on voting and post analyses
Problem is, the current voting record provides very little information, and all the RPing makes analyzing player behavior a bit tricky as well. As far as I can tell, the Phyphorwagon is right now the only lead we have, and a flimsy one at that. It would be nice if Gandalf elaborated on this a little.
A man has told you all he knows. You have further questions?
Are you a demon?
He is very persistent in claiming that he is a man. Mayhap he doth protest too much?
So village needs to ignore shit like 'this player is totes mafia because i have inside info', and instead rely on voting and post analyses
Problem is, the current voting record provides very little information, and all the RPing makes analyzing player behavior a bit tricky as well. As far as I can tell, the Phyphorwagon is right now the only lead we have, and a flimsy one at that. It would be nice if Gandalf elaborated on this a little.
A man has told you all he knows. You have further questions?
Are you a demon?
A man is not a demon. The politician may as well think of him as one, though -- he does have a mighty roar.
Austin sighed with a shrug and stepped forward to address the congress. "Ehem... You should knowing that Gandalf isn't exactly trustworthy. He's claimed to play no part in this play. Also that he has the ability to make deals for some sort of employer. What he means by that is that in exchange for a pact neutering you against him he will grant you a favor. You can no longer vote for him nor can you use any of your gifts against him. It's a Faustian bargain. I'm not sure about you guys, but that sounds like the kind of power a demon would have.
"This isn't exactly damning testimony, but I have confirmed it with another. Either way, unless we have some sort of confirmation that Gandalf is neutral in this theatre I'm not sure we can trust him."
Okay... its too hard to get this info across through RP
Gandalf has claimed neutral with the ability to grant favors
In exchange for those favors, you cannot vote and/or use powers against him
I have confirmed those are the conditions of his deals with another player who also made the deal
Gamewise, that's an interesting neutral; Flavorwise, it sounds like a demon deal
I'm not saying we vote him out or whatever, but maybe he's not a trustworthy source
I'm not sure how to test his alignment though without wasting resources
The suited-up one would do well to check a man's life story in the fabled OP.
Kodassa Moore – Before joining the Omerta, Kodassa was a small-time conman. He would play a small con here, a long con there, enough to get by and live comfortably. Eventually, his talents landed him in deep trouble with one of the Omerta families. Instead of breaking his arms, however, they offered him a job as a port salesman. Kodassa now uses his charm to negotiate the best deals, and sneak important cargo in and out of Underlund.
"Yes and I was supposed to have a set of magic perfumes but I don't. Why did you got to keep your powers?
"I'm just putting information out there for the village. They'll have to make the decision for themselves."
Well, I'm just a simple politician. I'm no necro-librarian or agavemancer. I don't know whether a man can also be a demon. Apparently a man can also be a vessel for Mister Antiqueroadshow's seed, so why not also a vessel for pure evil?
Then again, a man can be a vessel for pure evil without being a demon, can't he...
Sometimes I have ideas for things.
0
facetiousa wit so dryit shits sandRegistered Userregular
Yeah I mean just because my character is in love with hoping to land a job as the Acquantaince's sex slave manservant doesn't mean I want to work with him.
"I am not young enough to know everything." - Oscar Wilde
THESE ROLES ARE ENTIRELY FLAVOR FOR OPTIONAL ROLEPLAY AND FOR FLUFF IN THE NARRATION. FLUFF IN THE NARRATION IS ALSO JUST THAT: ME MAKING THE GAME MORE INTERESTING FOR YOU. DON'T TRY TO INFER THINGS BY WHO PARTICIPATES IN WHAT ACTION OF THE NARRATION OR WHAT THEIR JOB ON THE SHIP IS.
+1
blahmcblahYou pick your side and you stick - you don't cut and run when things get ugly.Registered Userregular
THESE ROLES ARE ENTIRELY FLAVOR FOR OPTIONAL ROLEPLAY AND FOR FLUFF IN THE NARRATION. FLUFF IN THE NARRATION IS ALSO JUST THAT: ME MAKING THE GAME MORE INTERESTING FOR YOU. DON'T TRY TO INFER THINGS BY WHO PARTICIPATES IN WHAT ACTION OF THE NARRATION OR WHAT THEIR JOB ON THE SHIP IS.
A man had forgotten about this.
Coincidence has reigned supreme in a man's life and abilities, then.
in gandalf's defense, role fluff is mechanically meaningless basically until it is not meaningless anymore. Here is obifett's role
17. James Raddison – A former Underlund knight, was once a well respected swordsman until the treasure he was guarding was stolen while he was seduced by an auburn-haired accomplice. Now a beggar, his possessions are the robes on his back and the silver sword he once used to fight enemies of the country.
and he was a vig. Basically the roles serve in such a way that munkus can "turn on" an ability on them if the RNG selects them and have it fit with their fluff. So you can't look at anyone and discern if they are actually a special or have powers, but if they DO have a special role, it will fit with their fluff.
+1
facetiousa wit so dryit shits sandRegistered Userregular
Posts
Also I think this post is bullshit and that you know it's bullshit. I'm committed to this Phyphor wagon, but if it doesn't turn out, I'm pretty sure I'm voting for you tomorrow.
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
At the same time though, one wagon does us no good when we're already lacking for useful vote records as it is so I hope it doesn't become a mass vote.
Steam: Chagrin LoL: Bonhomie
Can't wait.
Now. That post was made basically using my background from the Persona phalla, where we had an invincible mafia do a fake seer call, and the only reasonable defense against such a move was to not follow it(we didn't know of the invinco mafia in that one). Similarly, that call was made super early. If i can avoid making a mistake a second time, I will.
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Problem is, the current voting record provides very little information, and all the RPing makes analyzing player behavior a bit tricky as well. As far as I can tell, the Phyphorwagon is right now the only lead we have, and a flimsy one at that. It would be nice if Gandalf elaborated on this a little.
Steam: Chagrin LoL: Bonhomie
-Wagon avoiders
-People who didn't play in the recent one or two games, and would have murdered bradicus
-People who commented soon after the game started, as villagers didn't get a role pm and may not have known the game had started
etc.
Edit: in response to bliss
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Island Name: Felinefine
-Quickly posted after 'some folks are too quiet' post
-Votes on middle early wagon both nights
-Someone aluded to Se++ players having a higher chance of being mafia (because of bradicus), so why not add it here, even though its the flimsiest of the already flimsy reasons
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
no INANTP (and I) spoke privately, and then he posted publicly, that SE people might have a higher chance of killing bradicus.
the problem with that theory, of course, is that a mafia contains many members and there would not just be SE people in the mafia. So someone would have been around to change targets.
it's just a really weird day one choice.
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Surely you'd be all about that.
Steam: Chagrin LoL: Bonhomie
Henri Emmanuel Gratien St Pierre in Where No Man Has Gone Before
Lord Augustus Cumberbatch in Eclipse Phase
Wait, wait. So you and INANTP were colluding? Stop the presses!
Okay, I stand corrected. Maybe subconsciously I was ignoring INANTP for poo-pooing all of our extremely vital and productive roleplay yesterday.
A man has told you all he knows. You have further questions?
Are you a demon?
"This isn't exactly damning testimony, but I have confirmed it with another. Either way, unless we have some sort of confirmation that Gandalf is neutral in this theatre I'm not sure we can trust him."
Gandalf has claimed neutral with the ability to grant favors
In exchange for those favors, you cannot vote and/or use powers against him
I have confirmed those are the conditions of his deals with another player who also made the deal
Gamewise, that's an interesting neutral; Flavorwise, it sounds like a demon deal
I'm not saying we vote him out or whatever, but maybe he's not a trustworthy source
I'm not sure how to test his alignment though without wasting resources
For what it's worth, this combined with his defensiveness after accruing a single vote was my rationale behind voting for Zonugal yesterday.
look at his sweat and struggle. Some myth says demons cannot lie, but I disagree with this. I have no experience, but if our current situation is any idication, they can and will.
that being said !Gandalf_the_Crazed
He is very persistent in claiming that he is a man. Mayhap he doth protest too much?
A man is not a demon. The politician may as well think of him as one, though -- he does have a mighty roar.
The suited-up one would do well to check a man's life story in the fabled OP.
this was a good joke
"Yes and I was supposed to have a set of magic perfumes but I don't. Why did you got to keep your powers?
"I'm just putting information out there for the village. They'll have to make the decision for themselves."
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Then again, a man can be a vessel for pure evil without being a demon, can't he...
Steam: Chagrin LoL: Bonhomie
This is perhaps the case? A man is not sure. Coincidence, however, can be an amusing mistress.
because otherwise, yeah role fluff is mechanically meaningless.
A man had forgotten about this.
Coincidence has reigned supreme in a man's life and abilities, then.
and he was a vig. Basically the roles serve in such a way that munkus can "turn on" an ability on them if the RNG selects them and have it fit with their fluff. So you can't look at anyone and discern if they are actually a special or have powers, but if they DO have a special role, it will fit with their fluff.
I know I am.
Acquantaince/Collin OTP
Steam: Chagrin LoL: Bonhomie