Long time lurker and reader, just registered because for the first time I've felt like I really could use some advice, and my friends are not the ones to give it.
So - here's the thing - we were at a party last night off campus, and there was this whole salsa dancing thing going on, which was cool, and it was just a really great vibe - everyone was a little wasted, but not hugely, mostly just dancing and having fun. It was a really different atmosphere than a lot of the parties I'm used to. Anyway - I got dancing with this girl, and we got chatting, and frankly she didn't do anything for me. She was pretty short, and kind of funny looking - not exactly ugly, but a face that is really unusual, and you certainly wouldn't say she was pretty. She was a pretty good dancer - not fat, but not really a spinner either - she certainly had a couple of extra pounds, but not really in a bad way, just looked kind of stocky because she was short I think. Anyway, it got late, and she asked whether I'd see her home, and since I was ready to call the night I said I would, just to be a gentleman - I didn't plan on making a move. So we have another beer, and keep talking - she's pretty funny - geeky in the same way I am, then we leave, and her house in just a few blocks away. Anyway, she was showing off some dancing moves, and puts her arms around me, and before you know it we're kissing.
Well, ok, I think, why not? So we go in, and start making out, and before I know it we're in her room and the clothes come off, then something weird happened that I've never experienced before. Her body was kind of what I expected - her boobs are a little too small for her frame, and her legs and waist are a little too big, but, and I don't quite know how to put this - her pussy - well, it was just the most beautiful vagina I have ever seen. I mean, I'm no virgin, and I've had a lot of really hot girls, but this girl's pussy was perfect. I don't go either way on shaving, but the fact that she was shaved gave me a better view, and man, it was amazing. Just beautiful. I must have eaten her out for an hour before I rode that train. And I have to tell you it was as good on the inside as on the outside. Like it was ribbed for my pleasure or something like that.
Well morning arrives, and I roll over, and my estimate on her attractiveness from the previous night was a little optimistic, but we have sex again, and my estimate on her pussy was spot on. The girl is a minx.
So needless to say my mates made hay of the whole situation - I got the whole 'Pelvic Mother Theresa' stuff, but the thing is, I really want to hit that again. So what do I do? She's a fun girl, smart, but I'm really not attracted to her - except in that one way. It's not something that's ever happened to me before - I usually get a 'yes' or 'no' feeling about the whole package, if you know what I mean.
Is this normal? What should I do?